Rayner's stealth taxes would crush growth
Among the ideas Ms Rayner is pushing on the Chancellor are a freeze on thresholds for the 45 per cent income tax rate, measures to raise yet more in inheritance taxes, increasing the bank levy, and yet another clampdown on stamp duty that will, in effect, amount to another increase.
Chancellor Rachel Reeves may be boxed in by her promise not to raise any of the main taxes, but with the economy stagnating, and with the wealthy exiting the country in escalating numbers, she will have to raise money from somewhere.
There are two problems with Ms Rayner's little list. The point of Labour's pledge not to raise the main rates of tax was not to impose dozens of stealth levies instead. It was a promise to deliver faster growth and higher spending without taking more money out of people's pockets.
Next, and more importantly, the stealth taxes Ms Rayner proposes will do maximum damage to the productive base of the economy. For example, if the government scraps the inheritance tax exemption for companies listed on the Aim market it may raise a little extra cash. But Aim was designed to help growing businesses raise money for investment; the exemption encouraged investors to take a chance on backing smaller businesses. If we starve them of cash, they won't be able to invest or grow.
Freezing the thresholds for the 45 per cent rate of income tax will over time capture more and more middle earners in a bracket that was originally designed for the genuinely wealthy. It will take us back to the punitive rates of the 1970s, deter people from working, and drive wealth overseas.
Each and every raid the Deputy Prime Minister proposes damages entrepreneurs, savers, or strivers. Ms Rayner will find a ready audience on the backbenchers and among Labour Party members for her old-fashioned tax-and-spend agenda. The Chancellor hasn't given in to her yet.
Unless the Government can find a way of controlling spending, or boosting growth, then it will inevitably try to find new sources of revenue. Ms Rayner's nightmare list may be a terrible warning of what lies ahead.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
26 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Over 13,000 Admiral staff to receive free share awards worth up to £1,800
More than 13,000 staff at Admiral will each receive free share awards worth up to £1,800 under the firm's employee share schemes amid bumper half-year results. For the firm's broader base of shareholders, the company announced it would pay an interim dividend of 115 per share, up 62 per cent from last year. Admiral shares jumped 5 per cent to 3,534p on Thursday, having risen by over a quarter in the past 12 months. The insurance group raked in a pre-tax profit of £559million from its motor insurance arm in the six months to the end of June, against £359million at the same point a year ago. The FTSE 100 firm flagged 'higher insurance revenue and a notably improved insurance service margin' across its motor protection arm. It said car insurance prices had been falling for the past 18 months in response to softer inflation. Admiral recorded a near 5 per cent rise in the number of vehicles it insured across Britain in the period. Claims inflation across the motoring insurance arm is hovering at around five per cent, indicating prices may be close to finding a bottom. Across the business, Admiral reported a 69 per cent rise in pre-tax profit from continuing operations to £521million, while earnings per share surged 72 per cent to 132.5p. Total group turnover remained flat compared to the previous year, while insurance revenue increased by 18 per cent. In its home insurance arm, profits rose more than 100 per cent from £11.3million to £25.2million. The firm's pet and travel insurance arm saw its losses narrow. The business maintained its annual forecasts. Chief executive Milena Mondini de Focatiis, said: 'We have delivered another excellent first half with strong execution across all strategic objectives.' She added: 'I'm confident in our fundamentals and adaptability which mean that we are well-placed for further success, delivering even more value for our shareholders and our growing customer base.' The group flagged the Financial Conduct Authority's multi-business probe into UK motor insurance total loss claims valuations. Admiral said: 'The expected incremental claims cost of this action to Admiral (excluding statutory interest) is approximately £50million (around half of which has been accounted for in H1 2025, the remainder in the previous financial year).' It added: 'Admiral expects to begin contacting impacted customers during H2 2025, and whilst noting uncertainty remains, does not expect the final cost of the action to vary materially from that noted above.' Russ Mould, investment director at AJ Bell, said: 'FTSE 100 insurer Admiral is humming along quite nicely, supported by a strong showing in its motor insurance business. 'In a competitive market, Admiral remains in the fast lane. The strength of its brand allows it to remain disciplined on price while still attracting new business. Admiral's smart pricing tools have also helped to support underwriting profitability over time.' He added: 'The company is being rewarded for treating customers relatively well, at least in relation to its rivals, including during the pandemic. This is driving customer loyalty. 'Admiral recently swerved a potential hazard as the FCA decided to take no regulatory action on premium finance – effectively the cost borne by consumers if they opt to pay their insurance premiums in monthly instalments rather than in one lump sum.'
The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
Report finds top 2% of households have 18% of wealth in Scotland
The wealthiest households in Scotland have on average £1.7 million in total wealth, while in comparison the least wealthy had just £7,600, a new report has revealed. With the figures showing the wealthiest 2% of households have almost a fifth (18%) of wealth in Scotland, campaigners said the data highlighted 'the vast scale of unfairness in Scotland today'. The report looked at wealth in Scotland – which includes the physical wealth of households' belongings, as well as savings and investment, property and pension wealth. Scottish Government"> The latest data, for the period 2018 to 2020, showed median household wealth in Scotland stood at £214,000 – with this down from £242,700 in 2016 to 2018 and £250,700 in 2014 to 2016. The report, which was published by the Scottish Government, noted: 'A typical household in the wealthiest 10% of households had £1.7 million in total wealth, whereas a typical household in the least wealthy 10% of households had £7,600.' It added: 'The least wealthy households rarely own property or have any private pension savings. Their wealth is mainly made up of the value of their possessions such as cars, furniture and clothing.' The report also noted that wealth can 'vary a lot by age', saying that 'younger households are less likely to have much or even any pension or property wealth, and most of their wealth is made up of the value of their belongings (physical wealth)'. It added: 'In general, people start building up wealth once they start receiving a salary, buy some goods, maybe save some money, and pay into a private pension scheme such as a workplace pension. 'Many buy a home, and through paying off their mortgage they build property wealth.' Meanwhile when people retire, the report said that 'pension wealth gets drawn upon and used up, while some people also downsize their homes and reduce their property wealth'. However campaigners at Tax Justice Scotland – which wants Holyrood's powers to be used to deliver greater equality – insisted changes are needed to 'share wealth more fairly'. Speaking on behalf of the group Scottish Trades Union Congress, general secretary Roz Foyer said: 'These figures show the vast scale of unfairness in Scotland today. 'Whilst those at the top accumulate more wealth, more than one in five children grow up in poverty and our public services are starved of the investment they urgently need. This cannot go on.' Ms Foyer demanded: 'We need urgent tax reform to help share wealth more fairly and to distribute resources right across the country. 'Over time, public finance pressures mean that most of us may need to pay a bit more, but this data makes clear this must start with those at the very top. 'In Scotland, that means parties must set out clear plans to scrap Council Tax and replace it with a fairer, modern property tax. 'At the UK level, we also need common sense wealth taxes that ensure the richest pay their fair share.' She insisted: 'It's time for our political leaders to step up with serious tax plans to help close this growing wealth gap and to invest in creating a fairer, more prosperous future for all of us.'
BBC News
28 minutes ago
- BBC News
Burnham 'watching Salford situation closely'
Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham has said he is "watching closely" at the situation at Salford Red beleaguered Super League club have had a season to forget, plagued with financial problems despite a takeover going through on the eve of the wage payments and an upcoming winding-up petition, previously served over £500,000 owed to His Majesty's Revenue and Customs (HMRC), has overshadowed a dismal campaign which has included a mass player exodus and just two wins from 21 league games."I've been watching the situation very closely indeed. [Head coach] Paul Rowley is someone I know very well," Burnham told BBC Radio Manchester."I know how difficult it's been for him and all of the staff there at Salford. I can say I'm watching it closely."The question is, what can be done to change things? Obviously a consortium came in promising to clear the debts and put significant investment in. But that clearly hasn't happened." Financial problems already plagued the club before a consortium, led by businessman Dario Berta, bought Salford on the eve of the season, with the Red Devils asking for an advance on 2025's funding late last the takeover, however, Salford have continued to struggle financially, while the club's attempt to purchase their Salford Community Stadium home was rejected by the council, who pulled out of negotiations in this week the Red Devils' owners, who have not spoken to the media since their arrival, said that they remained "fully committed", pledged that the club would not close, and said that bridge funding would be "available and settled" by the end of formerly a president of the Rugby Football League as well as previously being honorary chairman of Leigh Leopards, said that he is prepared to work alongside Salford city mayor Paul Dennett to support the club if necessary."All I can say is that Paul and I will do every single thing we can to protect one of the most historic names, not just in rugby league but in sport as a whole," Burnham added."Our commitment is there. Obviously we can't just conjure up the funding, but from both of us, we massively recognise the role of rugby league in Salford and Greater Manchester and we can't let a proud name like this be left to rot."We will do everything we can and pull out all of the stops to support Salford as they go forward from here."
