‘Nobody knew things were going to get so bad': Catholic RUC officer's defaced headstone at centre of Troubles exhibition
Donegal
-born
RUC
officer that was vandalised within weeks is now the centrepiece of an exhibition recalling the Troubles.
The deep gashes left by the angle grinder used to deface John Doherty's marble headstone took time to inflict, but those who stole it from his grave at Castlefin St Mary's Church in Co Donegal in 2023 had plenty of that.
The damaged headstone, along with a memorial quilt commemorating some of the Troubles' dead, formed part of an exhibition at the
Church of Ireland
's Synod in Naas, Co Kildare, which finished on Saturday.
The headstone was erected on October 28th, 2023 to mark the 50th anniversary of the killing by the
IRA
of Mr Doherty, a Catholic Royal Ulster Constabulary officer, as he came home to visit his mother at their home near Lifford.
READ MORE
Within days of being erected, it was stolen under cover of darkness. A month later, similarly in darkness, it reappeared with the inscription defaced, with the harp and shamrock symbol of the RUC bearing cut marks.
On the back, a text had been carefully chiselled: 'Remember All The Victims of RUC Collusive Behaviour and loyalist Paramilitaries. RUC/PSNI Sectarian Police – Enforcing British Rule in Ireland. Not Welcome'.
The final line of the text on the back of the stone, which had been unveiled just weeks before in front of senior Garda and PSNI officers, had been filled in with the colours of the Irish Tricolour, with 'Up The 'Ra' written in green, white and orange.
The defaced memorial stone to Donegal-born RUC officer John Doherty, who was killed by the IRA in October 1973 as he visited his elderly mother
'There's a casual cruelty about that that, isn't there? It's dark. Death is always supposed to be sacrosanct in Ireland,' says the exhibition's organiser, Kenny Donaldson, director of the South East Fermanagh Foundation (SEFF).
Mr Doherty had joined the Metropolitan Police in London a few years before the Troubles erupted, but transferred to the RUC in late 1969 to be closer to his five brothers, six sisters and parents at their Ardnasool home.
His brother Terry, who served for more than 25 years in the Irish Army, said: 'Nobody knew when he decided to come back that things were going to get so bad.'
He told of how the family's home came under surveillance for nearly 18 months before his brother was killed, and his girlfriend wounded, as he turned his car on the narrow laneway on a Sunday evening. His mother rushed out to find him.
The reverse face of the defaced memorial stone to Donegal-born RUC officer John Doherty
A man with no obvious reason to be in Ardnasool had travelled the quiet country road so often in the months beforehand that he was given a nickname – the name of a country music singer – by Mr Doherty's siblings.
'John was a target for the IRA, but he loved getting home to see our mother. We always feared for him, but you always hope that trouble won't come to your door,' Terry said.
His Catholic background had condemned him: 'By killing him, the IRA frightened a lot of other Catholics from joining the RUC, or frightened those who were already in it to quit,' Terry added.
Nobody has been held responsible for the desecration. 'The guards did their best, but there was no CCTV and these spineless individuals operated in darkness, as they always do,' Terry said.
The headstone and the memorial quilt were exhibited by the SEFF, which helps people on both sides of the Border who are suffering due to traumatic experiences caused by terrorism.
John Doherty, the Donegal-born RUC officer killed by the IRA outside his mother's home in October 1973
The quilt, the eighth completed so far, honours, among others, the Quinn children killed by a loyalist paramilitary firebomb in 1998, along with Ross and Ann Hearst, a father and daughter who served in the RUC and were killed by the IRA three years apart.
The quilts are brought by SEFF before schools and groups to tell the stories of those who were lost and who were left behind, including places where people 'may have perceived that we would have had difficulty, but that wasn't the reality', said Mr Donaldson.
Last year, the organisation went to Latton GAA club in Co Monaghan, the home club of the late Fine Gael senator Billy Fox, who was murdered by the IRA in March 1974 when some of its members raided his girlfriend's house in Tircooney.
[
50 years on: Murder of Senator Billy Fox is remembered by his then girlfriend
Opens in new window
]
One of the earliest exhibitions took place in St Mary's College in west Belfast a decade ago, where some of those who visited 'struggled' when faced with emblems of Orange Lodges, GAA clubs, the RUC and the Irish Army on one quilt.
Mr Donaldson recalled one young woman's initially negative reaction. 'I said nothing and let her continue to look. Then, she worked it out. She said to me, 'It's because they're all innocent, isn't it?'.'
The quilts never knowingly commemorate anyone involved in the IRA, or other republican groups, or loyalist paramilitaries.
'And they won't be,' Mr Donaldson added. 'Those individuals signed up to a code which enabled them and empowered them to go out and to murder their neighbours. That's the difference. There's human choice.'
The checks are, he said, 'easier to make in some cases than others'.
'Sometimes there is a challenge to doing so, but we have built an organisation on the basis of its safe space that it offers to victims and survivors.
'If we overnight were to introduce a perpetrator into that, it totally changes the dynamic of everything. Do I have, on a human level, sympathy for everyone killed? Absolutely, yes, I do,' he went on.
'These were young men or young women who were misguided, who were ideologically used by others. Often, they were the cannon fodder who went out and did what they did. But they are not innocents and cannot be classified as such.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
4 hours ago
- The Journal
New IRA had planned earlier attack on PSNI detective John Caldwell, court told
THE PSNI UNCOVERED what they believe was a failed attempt to murder detective John Caldwell in the weeks before he was seriously wounded in a gun attack by dissident republicans, a court has heard. The details were revealed as two men appeared at Dungannon Magistrates' Court on charges linked to the attempted murder of the senior PSNI officer in Omagh, Co Tyrone, on 22 February 2023. Caldwell was shot several times while he was off duty and with his young son, packing up after coaching a youth football team. The attack was claimed by the New IRA. Caldwell has since retired from the PSNI on medical grounds. A number of people have previously appeared in court charged with offences linked to the shooting attack. Caoimhin Murphy, 25, from Altowen Park, Coalisland, and Liam Robinson, 45, of Ardstewart, Stewartstown, are both charged with preparation of terrorist attacks and perverting the course of justice. Both men appeared in court today via videolink from Musgrave Street police station in Belfast. Neither responded when asked if they understood the charges. A detective sergeant told the court he could connect both men to the offences. After the court was told there was a challenge to the connections, a prosecution barrister said the investigation into the shooting of Caldwell had been a 'complex, circumstantial case,' pointing out that several people had already been charged. She said: 'When the original individuals were charged that was subsequent to the attempt on DCI Caldwell on the 22 February of 2023. 'Investigations obviously continued and through those investigations it was ascertained the case is there was a prior attempt on the 1 February 2023.' She said of the first attempt on the detective's life that an Audi and a Volkswagen vehicle had been used and when he was later shot, two Ford Fiestas had been used. She told the court the case against Murphy is that it is alleged he had moved a vehicle involved in the first failed attack, moved a vehicle involved in the later attack and had been involved in burning a car after the detective was shot. The case against Robinson is that it is alleged he assisted in the recovery of a vehicle used in the first attempt, moved a vehicle in the second attempt and assisted in burning a car. The detective sergeant told the court: 'The investigation has identified what is believed to have been a failed attempt to attack DCI Caldwell on 1 February. 'On this occasion DCI Caldwell wasn't at Youth Sport, which would have been his usual routine. 'At that time a Volkswagen Tiguan on false registration plates was observed on CCTV entering the youth sports site in similar fashion to the movements of the Fiesta number one on the 22nd, the evening of the attempt.' Advertisement The officer laid out elements of the police investigation which stretched over events on a number of dates in February 2023 and included phone and CCTV evidence and what police believe are suspects taking place in 'walk and talk' conversations. He said the shooting of the detective is believed to have been 'a joint venture between a number of active service units', including Belfast and Tyrone New IRA. The officer told the court that on the night Caldwell was shot, he had arrived at football training earlier than usual. He said police believe the attack had been planned to take place when he arrived at the sports complex, but was delayed because of his early arrival. He added: 'He was not shot until 8 o'clock that night, an hour and a half after what we would suggest was the planned attack.' Murphy's defence solicitor Peter Corrigan told the court there was 'not one iota' of surveillance evidence linking his client to any of the vehicles used in the shooting. Robinson's solicitor Gavin Booth said it was not part of the prosecution case that his client had taken part in the shooting of Caldwell and had been in Coalisland at the time of the attack. The prosecuting barrister said it was a 'circumstantial case in its truest form'. She said: 'One strand may be weaker than the other, that is what a circumstantial case is. 'But when they are all layered on top of the other the consequences of those meetings, the prosecution says that there is sufficient material before the court to connect both accused to the charges.' Corrigan: 'It is a circumstantial case, but it is a circumstantial case which fails at connection because there are alternative explanations. 'It is all based on speculation and conjecture and does not close alternative explanations.' District Judge Rafferty said he was satisfied both could be connected to the offences. Police objected to a bail application for Robinson, with the detective sergeant stating it is believed he has a 'trusted role' in the IRA. He added: 'The New IRA have made a claim of responsibility for this terrorist attack. 'In addition to trying to justify the shooting of DCI Caldwell as a senior Crown forces member, the group further claimed that Irish Republican Army intelligence are now in possession of security information regarding the out of bounds movement of Crown force personnel.' He added: 'The threat to the life of John Caldwell continues to this day with his name appearing on a bonfire in the Creggan estate as we speak along with cross-hairs indicating he continues to be a target.' He said the threat posed by the group was 'real and imminent'. The judge denied bail to Robinson. Both defendants were remanded in custody. Robinson will appear in court again on 2 September and Murphy will appear on 20 August to make a bail application.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Airport security man demoted for kissing colleague should get job back, says WRC
Airport chiefs have been urged to give a security worker his old job as a supervisor back after he was demoted for kissing a subordinate while they were at work together on a screening line two summers ago. The decision to demote the worker from airport search supervisor to a junior position on the airport search unit was 'excessive', a Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) adjudicator decided in a non-binding recommendation under the Industrial Relations Act 1969. The tribunal heard the supervisor had more than five years' service on the airport search unit, screening passengers and baggage, with two years as supervisor, when he was placed under investigation in September 2023 and suspended. The employer said it considered the complainant to have committed gross misconduct by 'kissing a colleague during active operational duties' on the two days before his suspension. READ MORE The other worker, a more junior airport search unit officer, had been operating an x-ray machine on one occasion, and was working in a 'premium services area' under the supervisor on the other occasion. The outcome of the disciplinary process was that the complainant was demoted from his €46,000 a year supervisor post and placed on a final written warning. The decision reflected the 'safety-critical nature of the breaches, the worker's leadership responsibilities and the need to preserve the integrity of security operations', the employer submitted. The disciplinary officer's view was that the kissing 'had the potential to compromise both safety and the employer's reputation'. The demotion and warning were upheld on appeal, an internal appeals officer taking the view that the sanction was 'consistent with those issued in comparable cases', the tribunal heard. Joseph Ateb of the Siptu Workers' Rights Centre, who appeared for the worker, said his client had appealed the decision as being 'excessively harsh' and contended that his previous good record in employment was not given due consideration. The final written warning had expired by the time the WRC heard the case, leaving only the demotion as an issue, the tribunal noted. Adjudicator Breiffni O'Neill wrote that the employer's decision not to consider transferring the supervisor to another department 'calls into question the true extent of the safety concerns'. 'This inconsistency undermines the credibility of the employer's rationale and suggests a lack of proportionality,' he wrote. 'In light of the worker's unblemished prior record, his acceptance of responsibility and the employer's failure to consider a less punitive and reasonable alternative, I find that the additional sanction of demotion was excessive,' Mr O'Neill wrote. His recommendation on the dispute was that the demotion be rescinded and that the worker be reinstated as a supervisor 'with full restoration of duties and remuneration' within a week. The recommendation was published without the names of either the worker or his employer, in line with the WRC's usual practice under the Industrial Relations Act's voluntary arbitration process.
Sunday World
8 hours ago
- Sunday World
New IRA had planned earlier attack on detective John Caldwell, court told
Mr Caldwell was shot several times while he was off duty Police have uncovered what they believe was a failed attempt to murder detective John Caldwell in the weeks before he was seriously wounded in a gun attack by dissident republicans, a court has heard. The details were revealed as two men appeared at Dungannon Magistrates' Court on charges linked to the attempted murder of the senior Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) officer in Omagh, Co Tyrone, on February 22 2023. Mr Caldwell was shot several times while he was off duty and with his young son, packing up after coaching a youth football team. The attack was claimed by the New IRA. Forensic officers at the scene of the shooting in 2023 (Liam McBurney/PA) Mr Caldwell has since retired from the PSNI on medical grounds. A number of people have previously appeared in court charged with offences linked to the shooting attack. Caoimhin Murphy, 25, from Altowen Park, Coalisland, and Liam Robinson, 45, of Ardstewart, Stewartstown, are both charged with preparation of terrorist attacks and perverting the course of justice. Both men appeared in court on Wednesday via videolink from Musgrave Street police station in Belfast. Neither responded when asked if they understood the charges. A detective sergeant told the court he could connect both men to the offences. After the court was told there was a challenge to the connections, a prosecution barrister said the investigation into the shooting of Mr Caldwell had been a 'complex, circumstantial case,' pointing out that several people had already been charged. She said: 'When the original individuals were charged that was subsequent to the attempt on DCI Caldwell on the 22nd February of 2023. 'Investigations obviously continued and through those investigations it was ascertained the case is there was a prior attempt on the 1st February 2023.' She said of the first attempt on the detective's life an Audi and a Volkswagen vehicle had been used and when he was later shot, two Ford Fiestas had been used. She told the court the case against Murphy is that it is alleged he had moved a vehicle involved in the first failed attack, moved a vehicle involved in the later attack and had been involved in burning a car after the detective was shot. The case against Robinson is that it is alleged he assisted in the recovery of a vehicle used in the first attempt, moved a vehicle in the second attempt and assisted in burning a car. The detective sergeant told the court: 'The investigation has identified what is believed to have been a failed attempt to attack DCI Caldwell on the 1st February. 'On this occasion DCI Caldwell wasn't at Youth Sport, which would have been his usual routine. 'At that time a Volkswagen Tiguan on false registration plates was observed on CCTV entering the youth sports site in similar fashion to the movements of the Fiesta number one on the 22nd, the evening of the attempt.' The officer laid out elements of the police investigation which stretched over events on a number of dates in February 2023 and included phone and CCTV evidence and what police believe are suspects taking place in 'walk and talk' conversations. He said the shooting of the detective is believed to have been 'a joint venture between a number of active service units', including Belfast and Tyrone New IRA. The officer told the court that on the night Mr Caldwell was shot, he had arrived at football training earlier than usual. He said police believe the attack had been planned to take place when he arrived at the sports complex, but was delayed because of his early arrival. He added: 'He was not shot until 8 o'clock that night, an hour and a half after what we would suggest was the planned attack.' Murphy's defence solicitor Peter Corrigan told the court there was 'not one iota' of surveillance evidence linking his client to any of the vehicles used in the shooting. Robinson's solicitor Gavin Booth said it was not part of the prosecution case that his client had taken part in the shooting of Mr Caldwell and had been in Coalisland at the time of the attack. The prosecuting barrister said it was a 'circumstantial case in its truest form'. She said: 'One strand may be weaker than the other, that is what a circumstantial case is. 'But when they are all layered on top of the other the consequences of those meetings, the prosecution says that there is sufficient material before the court to connect both accused to the charges.' Mr Corrigan: 'It is a circumstantial case, but it is a circumstantial case which fails at connection because there are alternative explanations. 'It is all based on speculation and conjecture and does not close alternative explanations.' John Caldwell's life is still under threat, a court was told (David Young/PA) District Judge Rafferty said he was satisfied both could be connected to the offences. Police objected to a bail application for Robinson, with the detective sergeant stating it is believed he has a 'trusted role' in the IRA. He added: 'The New IRA have made a claim of responsibility for this terrorist attack. 'In addition to trying to justify the shooting of DCI Caldwell as a senior Crown forces member, the group further claimed that Irish Republican Army intelligence are now in possession of security information regarding the out of bounds movement of Crown force personnel.' He added: 'The threat to the life of John Caldwell continues to this day with his name appearing on a bonfire in the Creggan estate as we speak along with cross-hairs indicating he continues to be a target.' He said the threat posed by the group was 'real and imminent'. The judge denied bail to Robinson. Both defendants were remanded in custody. Robinson will appear in court again on September 2 and Murphy will appear on August 20 to make a bail application.
