Rich McKay: There was a long, good discussion about Lions' playoff seeding proposal
The exact wording of the Lions' proposal was, 'to amend the current playoff seeding format to allow Wild Card teams to be seeded higher than Division Champions if the Wild Card team has a better regular season record.'
Chairman of the Competition Committee Rich McKay acknowledged on Tuesday that tabling the measure indicates there is 'some' support for making a change. But McKay also noted he's been through this kind of discussion multiple times before and there wasn't much different in 2025.
'And it always gets back to, the traditionalist says, 'I want to win the division. I want the division to mean something,'' McKay said on Tuesday. 'Well 'something' could be that you qualify for the playoffs. That's something. But people say, 'No, I want to host a playoff game.' Then the other idea is, are you diminishing division championships — which we do not want — because I think it's served us very well to use divisions.
'Then the discussion was, OK, what if you said, win the division get a home game … unless your record is .500 or below? Then you don't. There was some talk about that. So, I think people want to keep looking at it. It doesn't mean it will come back up and get passed in May. It very well may be a different discussion if the season is extended. But it was a long discussion, it was a good discussion.'
Of the coaches who went on the record this week about the proposal, Mike Tomlin, Sean Payton, and Sean McVay were among those who did not want to see the seeding format change — with all three citing winning the division as meaningful. Washington's Dan Quinn, who was Seattle's assistant head coach and defensive line coach in 2010, also on Tuesday that he's not in favor of that change after being involved with Marshawn Lynch's 'Beastquake' run that helped the 7-9 Seahawks beat the 11-5 Saints.
'I would be really bummed,' Quinn said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
28 minutes ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Cleveland has cut AL Central deficit from 15 1/2 games to 6. The record divisional comeback is 14
It's been a tough few weeks for the Cleveland Guardians — except on the field. Star closer Emmanuel Clase joined teammate Luis Ortiz in being placed on leave as part of an investigation into sports betting. Then the front office traded away former Cy Young Award winner Shane Bieber as he neared a return from Tommy John surgery — not exactly the type of move a team makes when it fancies itself a contender. And yet, the Guardians have won nine of their last 11, even after a loss Sunday to the Chicago White Sox. They are a half-game behind the New York Yankees for the final wild card in the American League. After losing to Detroit on July 6 — just over a month ago — the Guardians had dropped 10 in a row and trailed the AL Central-leading Tigers by 15 1/2 games. That lead is now six. If Cleveland actually catches Detroit and wins the division, it would be the biggest comeback in the divisional play era. Here are the largest comebacks to date, according to Sportradar. 1978 New York Yankees (14 games): New York won the AL East thanks to Bucky Dent's homer in a one-game playoff at Fenway Park, and although this was a painful episode in Red Sox history, the Yankees won this more than Boston lost it. New York went 30-9 to finish the regular season. After stumbling in early September, the Red Sox later won eight in a row to force the playoff. 1995 Seattle Mariners (13 games): After a win on Aug. 2, the California Angels led Seattle by 13 in the AL West and Texas by 11. Then the Angels went 22-34 the rest of the way while the Mariners were 36-20. When the teams met in a one-game playoff, it was a 9-1 blowout in Seattle's favor, and although wild cards were in the playoffs for the first time, California couldn't even salvage one of those. 2012 Oakland Athletics (13 games): Fresh off two straight pennants, the Texas Rangers led the Angels by 6 1/2 and the A's by 13 at the end of June. But Oakland went 33-13 down the stretch, forcing the Rangers to settle for a wild card. 1973 New York Mets (12 1/2 games): Tug McGraw's famous phrase — 'Ya gotta believe!' — was a rallying cry of this comeback. New York was 12 1/2 back in early July and still in last place in late August, but the Mets took a weak NL East with an 82-79 record and then beat Cincinnati to win the pennant. 2006 Minnesota Twins (12 1/2 games): Detroit was 35-14 and led the Twins by over a dozen games, but there was enough time left for Minnesota to edge the Tigers in the AL Central when Detroit dropped five in a row to end the regular season. Although there are similarities between 2006 and this year, the good news for the Tigers is that they did make the World Series that season as a wild card. Trivia time Which team did the Red Sox a momentary favor by routing the Yankees 9-2 to help force that playoff game in 1978? Line of the week Shea Langeliers had five hits — including three solo homers — for the Athletics a 16-7 win over Washington on Tuesday night. Langeliers became the fourth catcher with two three-homer games, joining Johnny Bench, Gary Carter and Travis d'Arnaud. Comeback of the week The New York Mets led Milwaukee 5-0 in the fourth inning Sunday, but nobody who has watched those two teams recently should have been shocked when the Brewers chipped away and eventually won 7-6 on a solo homer by Isaac Collins in the bottom of the ninth. Milwaukee, which had a win probability of 7.1% in the fourth according to Baseball Savant, has won nine in a row to take a five-game lead over the Phillies and Blue Jays for baseball's best record. The Mets, on the other hand, have dropped seven straight and lead Cincinnati by only 1 1/2 games for the National League's final wild card. Cleveland, which won just 69 games that season. ___
New York Times
an hour ago
- New York Times
Tigers' Riley Greene keeps slugging even as he approaches strikeout record
DETROIT — Friday afternoon, Riley Greene stepped into the left-handed batter's box when there were only a handful of people on the field at Comerica Park field. Tigers hitting coach Keith Beauregard fed balls into a pitching machine. Greene laced a few balls to right field, then center. In his next round, he worked the opposite field gap. Advertisement He stood off to the side with Michael Brdar, another one of Detroit's three hitting coaches, talking about his swing. Greene mimicked his load and the initial movement of his top hand. He went through his finish and his follow-through. Tigers legend Alan Trammell stood behind the cage, too. The back of his shirt bore one of the team's mantras. Everything matters. Greene is rarely one to hit on the field. After he took batting practice before the All-Star Game, he said, 'I haven't hit on the field in two years.' Greene often prefers the confines of the Tigers' underground cage, where music blares and hitters can go through their routines in privacy. Here amid another brutal slump, though, Greene was changing things up. He wanted to see the ball jump off his bat and land in the Comerica Park grass. Mired in the dog days, he wanted to have some fun with teammates Spencer Torkelson and Dillon Dingler. 'It's good to know I can still hit baseballs,' Greene said at his locker afterward. Greene has always been a streaky hitter, but his most recent cold spell has been arguably his worst. From the second game of a July 2 doubleheader to Friday's series opener against the Angels, Greene was hitting .173. He belted five home runs in that span, but he also struck out 47 times in 115 plate appearances. He is MLB's leader in strikeouts, and if he continues punching out at anything close to this recent rate, he could threaten to set an MLB record. Mark Reynolds holds the mark for single-season strikeouts by a hitter at 223. Greene has punched out 156 times through 119 games this season. If he continues on that pace, Greene would finish the year with 212 strikeouts, tied for the ninth-worst mark ever. Friday afternoon in Detroit, Tigers manager A.J. Hinch did not try to downplay the struggles. He seemed to support the slight change to Greene's routine. 'We've all seen the last month,' Hinch said. 'When you keep trying to do the same thing over and over again, it's the definition of insanity.' At times this year, Greene has played like precisely the hitter he was drafted to be, an aircraft carrier who has achieved the top level of his power potential. Greene has launched 27 home runs, tied for fourth in the American League. He was an All-Star starter who also has the steepest swing in the game, entering the weekend at an average path tilt of 45 degrees. Advertisement Greene is swinging more aggressively than ever this season. The home runs have been a reward. The strikeouts have been the obvious, unintended cost. 'No,' Greene said when asked if he expected an uptick in strikeouts entering the year. 'I think that it comes with it, and I like hitting homers, and sometimes I get excited and I swing at balls in the dirt that aren't even close. It is what it is. It happens. It's the game. Just try to shorten that and not chase as much and get better pitches to hit.' (Baseball Savant) There's a temptation to view Greene through one of two lenses: a frustrating player who strikes out far too much or a dynamic difference maker worthy of a massive contract extension. The reality, as it often does, lies somewhere in between. Greene is a uniquely talented hitter. He is one of Detroit's best homegrown position players in eons. He is 24 years old and is capable of becoming one of the best players in the American League. Yet there are still flaws he is working to overcome. On 13 occasions this year, Greene has struck out three times in a game. Twice, he has achieved the notorious Golden Sombrero — four strikeouts in a single game. 'I feel like I'm not seeing the ball,' Greene said Friday. 'I'm not focusing on the ball. Focusing on different things. Thinking about different things. Got to simplify and stick to my strengths and not go to other people's strengths. Stick to mine. Hunt my zones. Do some damage.' We have seen Greene endure these sorts of droughts. He has often come out of them with incredible stretches of strong performances. Take this weekend as evidence. Greene had two hits Friday night against the Angels. On Sunday, he hit three balls that left the bat at 100 mph or greater, including a line-drive home run. Advertisement 'I say this over and over when people ask me: Do they need encouragement? Do they need a pat on the back? Do they need a kick in the ass?' Hinch said. 'They need hits. That's the best remedy for guys to feel better about themselves.' As Greene searches for more hits, he is trying different things. He shaved down to a goofy mustache, then regrew his beard. He hit on the field. He is working to cover both the high fastballs that he has whiffed on at a concerning rate and lay off the low spin that has caused him to chase at a troublesome clip. 'You can't (cover both),' Greene said. 'You got to pick one and you got to stick to one and whatever happens, happens. They're not always going to throw a fastball up for a strike and then throw a curveball down for a strike. They're not gonna do it. No one can do that every single time.' Greene's troubles have mirrored those of a Tigers team that entered Sunday with MLB's worst walk rate since the All-Star break. As the Tigers look to keep what could be a special season afloat, Greene should play a key role in determining whether the Tigers can recapture their magic or continue a downward slide. 'We are a different offense when he's a part of it,' Hinch said. '(But) he doesn't have to carry this offense. We need to do a lot of things better as a collective group.' Friday against the Angels, Hinch dropped Greene to sixth in the batting order, the lowest he has hit in a start since he batted sixth in his MLB debut. Saturday, Greene did not start against a left-handed pitcher. Sunday, though, Greene was back in the cleanup spot. He notched two hits and drove in three runs. He looked like a middle-of-the-order force, and the Tigers earned a series victory. 'It sucks to struggle,' Greene said Friday. 'It is what it is. It's only a matter of one pitch and one swing, and then the floodgates open.' Spot the pattern. Connect the terms Find the hidden link between sports terms Play today's puzzle
3 hours ago
Kerry Carpenter homers and drives in 3 to lead Tigers over Angels 9-5
DETROIT -- Kerry Carpenter homered and drove in three runs to help the Detroit Tigers beat the Los Angeles Angels 9-5 on Sunday. Carpenter doubled and scored in the first, hit a sacrifice fly in the second and added a three-run homer in the fourth. Casey Mize (11-4) got the win, allowing two runs on three hits in five innings. He walked two and struck out five. Jack Kochanowicz (3-10) took the loss. He gave up seven runs on 10 hits in three-plus innings. The Tigers took a 2-0 lead in the first, stringing together four straight two-out hits that included RBI singles by Riley Greene and Zach McKinstry. Carpenter's sacrifice fly made it 3-0 in the second, and the Tigers added four more in the fourth. Javier Baez reached on an error, took third on a base hit by Cole Keith and scored on Gleyber Torres' single. Carpenter followed with his 21st homer, giving Detroit a 7-0 lead. Nolan Schanuel hit a two-run homer in the fifth, and Logan O'Hoppe made it 7-3 with an RBI single in the sixth. Greene hit a two-run homer in the sixth while Luis Rengifo hit a two-run shot in the eighth. Angels CF Bryce Teodosio, who missed Saturday's game after hitting his head on the fence on Friday, ran into LF Taylor Ward and RF Jo Adell on eighth-inning fly balls. Luckily, no one was injured on either play. Carpenter has a .600 slugging percentage against right-handed pitchers since the start of 2024, the third highest in the majors. Shohei Ohtani (.688) and Aaron Judge (.682) are the leaders among players with at least 500 plate appearances against righties. The Angels return for a three-game series with their crosstown rivals, the Los Angeles Dodgers. RHP Jose Soriano is scheduled to start Monday's opener. Detroit travels to Chicago for three games against the White Sox. RHP Chris Paddack (4-10, 4.91) will pitch on Monday evening. After playing 13 of their last 16 games at home, the Tigers play 13 of the next 19 on the road.
