‘Shielded from arrest': What Supreme Court of Appeal ruling means for 180,000 Zimbabweans in South Africa
Scores of Zimbabweans during a picket at the Union Buildings in Pretoria.
Image: Jonisayi Maromo/IOL
The Supreme Court of Appeal has dismissed with costs the Department of Home Affairs' attempt to overturn an interim interdict, previously granted in favour of the Zimbabwe Immigration Federation, protecting nearly 200,000 Zimbabwean Exemption Permit (ZEP) holders against arrest and deportation.
After winning Part A of the court wrangle, the federation will be heading back to the court, for Part B, to argue before court that the Department of Home Affairs overreached in 2021, when the then home affairs minister Aaron Motsoaledi announced the termination of the ZEP.
The special permit dispensation has allowed 180,000 Zimbabwean nationals to live and work in South Africa since 2009.
In the federation's view, the jurisdiction to terminate the ZEP lies with Parliament, not the minister.
IOL had an interview with Vindren Magadzire, director of the Zimbabwe Immigration Federation who said his organisation's case revolves around the termination of the ZEP programme by the minister of home affairs.
Vindren Magadzire, director of the Zimbabwe Immigration Federation
Image: Supplied
Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
'The programme allowed approximately 180,000 Zimbabweans to live and work in South Africa. In 2021, the minister of home affairs announced plans to terminate the ZEP permits, sparking legal actions from the Zimbabwe Immigration Federation,' Magadzire told IOL.
'The Zimbabwe Immigration Federation was inspired to go through courts due to the South African minister of home affairs' decision to terminate the permits. The decision would have significant implications for approximately 180,000 Zimbabweans living and working in South Africa under the ZEP permit program.'
Magadzire said his organisation is requesting the superior court to declare the termination of the ZEP permits unlawful, setting aside the termination decision, and protecting permit holders rights.
In Magadzire's view, a lasting solution would be granting the ZEP holders permanent residence status in South Africa.
'The latest development in the court case is that the Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed the minister of home affairs appeal. This decision upholds a Johannesburg High Court interdict that shields approximately 180,000 ZEP holders from arrest and deportation,' said Magadzire.
Last year, IOL reported that the High Court in Pretoria heard arguments from the Helen Suzman Foundation to enforce the court's order that the ZEP remains valid, while the minister of home affairs conducts a fair and rational inquiry into the impact of its termination.
The foundation turned to court in a bid to give ZEP holders a lifeline.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Efforts to mobilise men against GBV and spread of HIV continue
Alexandra men are intensifying their mission to mobilise others, giving them a platform to address gender-based violence and the spread of HIV. This follows the inaugural sitting of the Men's Parliament under the theme 'Deepening accountability among men and boys to respond decisively to South African socio-economic challenges', on May 23 at the Constance Connie Bapela Council Chamber in Johannesburg. Read more: GBV Brigades and police meet ahead of major campaign The co-chairperson of the Men's Parliament Charles Mphephu said that ahead of its first sitting, outreach campaigns were conducted in the sub-district. Even after the first sitting of the parliament, he noted that efforts to expand their reach had intensified. 'On May 26, we started at Madala hostel, and we went to Nobuhle hostel to engage with those men. We moved to the Council at Pan next to the Alexandra Magistrates' Court. We were also at the Organic market and Last Gate in Tsutsumane, and we engaged with men,' Mphephu noted. Also read: Alex CPF concerned about GBV victims reluctance to press charges The goal is to help men change their harmful social behaviour, which exacerbates the rate of GBV and the spread of HIV. Speaking during the first sitting of the parliament, the secretary of the City of Johannesburg men's sector Sibusiso Sithole stressed that young men often lacked the support they needed compared to young women. 'We are forgetting that these young women will eventually date at some point. And the person they will be dating is the same person who was in high school with them, standing there in the corner and not receiving any support, not receiving any information around GBV or [HIV] treatment.' In his closing remarks, Mphehu urged men to make sure that every ward in their region supported this men's initiative. 'The vision is to institutionalise a responsive men's movement, and the mission is to call men to action, to stand up and be counted as relevant in building a men's society movement that is robust, accountable and follows the rules of law.' He concluded by the end of December, they planned to reach 3 500 men, and were currently approaching a milestone of 500. Follow us on our Whatsapp channel, Facebook, X, Instagram, and TikTok for the latest updates and inspiration! Have a story idea? We'd love to hear from you – join our WhatsApp group and share your thoughts! Related article: Community safety stakeholders strategise for an effective GBV campaign At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
IOL News
5 hours ago
- IOL News
Controversial resettlement of Afrikaners in the US sparks debate
The South African delegation led by President Cyril Ramaphosa with the US delegation and President Donald Trump at the White House Image: GCIS THE LATEST group of white Afrikaners, who are part of a broader plan to relocate about 8 000 in the ensuing months to the US, made their way to their new homeland on Friday. Their move is a part of a controversial resettlement initiative initiated by former President Donald Trump, who cited concerns over alleged persecution and the spectre of "white genocide" in South Africa. Jaco Kleynhans, head of Public Relations for the trade union Solidarity, revealed that the latest group included families with children and that efforts to secure future flights are already underway. 'The second group departed on a commercial flight on Thursday and landed in Atlanta on Friday,' he confirmed. 'Several more groups will follow in the coming weeks.' The resettlement programme originated from Trump's executive order issued in February, which highlighted the Expropriation Act 13 of 2024 as one enabling the alleged persecution of Afrikaners. The first group, numbering over 49 individuals, arrived last month aboard a chartered private plane, sparking major discussions around immigration, safety, and identity. The US Embassy in Pretoria, in conjunction with the State Department, is currently processing the applications of thousands of Afrikaners, as reported by Kleynhans. 'They are settling in southern states like Texas, North and South Carolina, Kansas, Oklahoma, and Nebraska,' he noted, highlighting the continuous flow of individuals seeking refuge from South Africa. While Solidarity strives to guide prospective immigrants through the application process, Kleynhans maintained that the focus remains on ensuring a secure future for Afrikaners in their homeland. 'We remain 100% convinced that South Africa must create a home for all its people,' he stated, adding that nearly 20% of Afrikaners have already left the country to escape unemployment and social unrest. The ongoing migration has raised eyebrows, with some critics suggesting that the refugee initiative is politically charged. Kleynhans dismissed such claims, asserting that any shift in American policy could only occur through domestic electoral processes. 'If Americans disagree with Trump on this, they can elect a different president in three years,' he said. Kallie Kriel, CEO of AfriForum, expressed empathy for those departing, if not for the reasons prompting their emigration. He referenced the 'hateful chants', including the provocative phrase 'Kill the Boer', which he believes has exacerbated feelings of insecurity among Afrikaners. He emphasised the need for a broader conversation on inclusion and community safety, insisting that no demographic group should be targeted for violence. International relations expert Dr Noluthando Phungula commented on the situation, suggesting that claims of white genocide seem to persist unchallenged within US policy discussions, potentially obscuring the reality many Afrikaners face. Professor Siphamandla Zondi from the University of Johannesburg shared a similar sentiment, forecasting an increasing number of people seeking a new life in the US as economic concerns continue to drive migration.
IOL News
11 hours ago
- IOL News
The logic behind Dawie Roodt's conclusion that 'Most South African universities must be closed'
History has no blank pages. Lest we forget the teaching of Hendrik Verwoerd that: 'There is no place for [the Bantu] in the European community above the level of certain forms of Labour…. What is the use of teaching the Bantu child mathematics when it cannot use it in practice'. Exactly 31 years into a democracy, Roodt still dreams of an apartheid where whites saw themselves as the chosen (theologically, racially, politically, economically) nation of South Africa, 'De la Rey, De la Rey, sal jy die Boere kom lei'. A declaration by Roodt that 'most South African universities must be closed' and that only 10% should be allowed at universities is traced in the Afrikaner ideology, apartheid and a view 'net vir die blankes', an education for a few. Apartheid was a policy of segregation and political, social, and economic against black South Africans. The current statistic suggests that there are around 7% whites in the country, and this is the basis of Roodt's argument. In apartheid South Africa, schooling was compulsory for whites but not for Africans. Roodt has exceptions a 3% perhaps for future expansion of the white race or he wants to have exceptions for 'clever blacks' or house negros or Uncle Toms or Tengo Jabavu(s) who might be useful for the system for a whiteness project. Before we rush to conclude and argue that at least the 1953 Bantu Education Act created an opportunity for blacks to study or to even suggest that Verwoerd did not imply exclusion of black in all education, it is important to recall that the Act was created for black South Africans and to prepare them for lives as labouring class. Roodt base his argument on skills relevancy and on performance, and of course, the preceding sentence exposes his background and that his logic is rooted in the Bantu Act.
