Why Stars goalie was benched, roasted by coach in season-ending loss to Oilers: ‘status quo … not working'
The 26-year-old goalie, considered to be among the best in the NHL, was pulled by Stars coach Peter DeBoer and replaced by veteran backup Casey DeSmith just 7:09 into the first period of the must-win Game 5 of the Western Conference Final. With the Stars already trailing the best-of-7 series 3-1, things got bad quickly on home ice Thursday when they fell behind 2-0, with Oettinger allowing two goals on two shots to start the game.
Advertisement
DeBoer called for a timeout, blew a gasket yelling at his players, and then, maybe, blew any chance of coming back against the Oilers when he yanked his star — no pun intended — goaltender and replaced him with one who hadn't played in a month.
The veteran coach stood behind his shocking decision after the Stars were eliminated with a 6-3 loss in Game 5.
'We had talked endlessly in this series about trying to play with a lead, and obviously we were in a 2-0 hole right away,' DeBoer explained. 'I didn't take that lightly and I didn't blame it all on Jake, but the reality is, if you go back to last year's playoffs, he's lost six of seven games to Edmonton. And we give up two goals on two shots in an elimination game. So, it was partly to spark our team and wake them up. And partly knowing that status quo had not been working, and that's a pretty big sample size.'
Advertisement
Ouch.
Coach and goalie have some serious fence-mending to do before training camp begins in September.
If DeBoer had left it at that he was simply trying to spark the Stars with this bold move, well, OK. But to lay it out there and trash your goalie, who was pretty much your best player throughout the season and Stanley Cup Playoffs, that's something else.
Oettinger didn't speak to the media postgame. But his teammates had his back.
'It's unacceptable for us to hang him out like that,' forward Jason Robertson said. 'The whole playoffs, he's been our guy, the whole season. Just unacceptable from us.'
Advertisement
Related: Panthers rally past Hurricanes 5-3 in Game 5, return to Stanley Cup Final again: takeaways
Stunning decision by Stars coach likely sealed their fate in West Final
Credit: Jerome Miron-Imagn Images
Slow starts were an issue all postseason for the Stars. They allowed the first goal in 15 of their 18 playoff games this spring, a stunning statistic when you consider that they still reached the conference final. Oettinger started each of those 18 games in goal, so he takes some blame for Dallas consistently falling behind. But, to be fair, his outstanding play was a major reason why the Stars were able to regroup and win so often after these poor starts.
Advertisement
And it wasn't all on the goalie by any means. Time and again, the Stars failed to start on time. Thursday was just the latest example. Rookie Mavrik Bourque took a mind-numbingly careless high-sticking penalty 1:47 into the game, and the Oilers converted for a power-play goal by Corey Perry, who was left wide open in front of Oettinger, 44 seconds later.
The Stars defense broke down again at 7:09, allowing Mattias Janmark to get behind everyone, accept a Victor Arvidsson feed, break in all alone, and beat Oettinger through the pads for the Oilers second goal on as many shots.
That's when DeBoer popped his cork and pulled his goalie. The move didn't pay off. DeSmith was all out of sorts allowing a Jeff Skinner goal less than a minute later at 8:07 and it was 3-0.
Advertisement
'We were not ready,' forward Mikko Rantanen said. 'We were not helping Jake at all on the first two goals. That's on us and not on Jake.'
Though the Stars showed some fight and twice battled back to within a goal, that three-goal deficit was impossible to completely erase. So, for the third straight season, they were eliminated in the Western Conference Final.
As for DeBoer's postgame comments, he wasn't exactly wrong about Oettinger's numbers and record against the Oilers his past seven starts against them in the 2024 and 2025 conference finals. Last year, the Stars blew a 2-1 series lead and lost in six games to the Oilers. This year, they staged a wild rally to win Game 1 and then lost four straight.
Advertisement
As for Oettinger, he begins a lucrative eight-year, $66 million contract with an $8.25 million average annual value next season. He has 30+ wins in four straight seasons and will challenge Connor Hellebuyck to be the No. 1 goalie for the United States at the 2026 Milan-Cortina Olympics.
So, he's not going anywhere.
DeBoer? His future is less clear after this controversial decision and biting postgame commentary, despite leading three different teams to the conference finals in his past six seasons as an NHL coach.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
10 hours ago
- Yahoo
This physical winger has a chance to become a valuable cog in the Edmonton Oilers Bottom-6
The Top 20 countdown of our 2025 Cult of Hockey Prospect Series continues. Again, these are the twenty young men in the system today closest to making an impact with the big club. Players only fall off the list once they: -Make the NHL -Get dealt to a different organization -Age out, or… -Drop off the map. Lets proceed… 2025 Edmonton Oilers Top Prospect Rankings #15 – David Lewandowski (Voters: David Staples, Kurt Leavins, Jim Matheson, Ira Cooper). Physical wingers with some skill and on their ELC's are like found gold in the NHL. Will David Lewandowski be that for the Oilers? Selected in this past June's draft in Round Four, #117 overall, this left-shot winger out of Schwatzinger, Germany stands 6'1 and weighs in at 177 LB. If you look at this prospect through the lens of well-known and respected draft projections, this was a shrewd pick-up by Edmonton. Elite Prospects had him ranked #77, Daily faceoff #86, Flo Hockey #69 and his consolidated ranking rang in at #94. From the outside in, that looks like a win. The eighteen-year-old will turn 19 in February. In his first season in the Western Hockey League, Lewandowski was productive, going 15-24-39 in 52 GP adding 21 PIM. He also had a goal and an assist in four playoff games. In addition, he had a goal and an assist in four games at the Hlinka Gretzky Cup. Prior to that, Lewandowski also managed to play seven games with Dusseldorf EG in the Deutsche Eishockey Liga (DEL), which is Germany's top professional league as a seventeen-year-old. He also has international experience. But that small sample playing against men as a teenager stands out more to me. Here is what the scouts say: Elite Prospects: -Lewandowski is a dominant puck protector who throws reverse hits and bulldozes contact. His shooting has been a constant threat across his career. He rips pucks off his outside leg and possesses a powerful catch-and-release shot that he leverages with higher-end precision. Even more impressive, his physical skills – puck protection, especially – are the most translatable aspects of his game. Dobber Prospects: -A smart, solid, all-around forward with a strong shot and sub-par skating, though he has a straightforward path to the NHL. A solid all-around player'. Other pluses: -Lewandowski knows where the blue paint is. He has a nose for the net and seems to relish the journey in getting there. -Consistently positive reviews for his defensive play and strong along the walls. -Those that know him say he has a high Hockey IQ and plays a mature game. Where he needs work: -Foot speed, foot speed, foot speed. If this kid can get his boots moving quicker and more efficiently, it could lead to a breakout year with the Saskatoon Blades and a brighter NHL outlook. For now, while his skating is not a liability per se, he lacks the extra gear to separate from defenders. General observations: -Good hockey DNA. David's Dad Eduard played w0 pro seasons in Europe, including the KHL, DEL and the Olympics in 2006. -There is some suggestion that this kid may not be done growing. You never really know, but an extra inch could be a real plus. -If his boots are only average, then his fitness level will be one of the keys to this kid making it or not. A big summer will be critical. -A trusted colleague of mine who saw Lewandowski a lot in person last season said to me 'Oilers got a good one, keep an eye on him'. Noted. Projection: -A fourth line NHL-er? That is what his skill set would seem to project. If we further assess him by draft pedigree, about eighteen per cent of Round Four forward picks turn into NHL players. And as I have already mentioned, if Lewandowski arrives in that position on an ELC…that would be a significant advantage. -In the meantime, he has another full year in the WHL. Could he have a ticket to Bakersfield by the fall of 2026? -0- Next up…prospect #14 from my Cult of Hockey colleague David Staples. Now on Bluesky @ Also, find me on Threads @kleavins, Twitter @KurtLeavins, Instagram at LeavinsOnHockey, and Mastodon at KurtLeavins@ This article is not AI generated. Recently, at The Cult… STAPLES: Can the Edmonton Oilers win it all with such a top-heavy lineup LEAVINS: Will this Oilers prospect dog have his Day? Bruce McCurdy, 1955-2025. Don't miss the news you need to know — add and to your bookmarks and sign up for our newsletters here.
USA Today
15 hours ago
- USA Today
How many innings are played in the Little League World Series? LLWS rules
The Little League World Series is currently taking over the ESPN family of networks with games in the United States bracket and international bracket. As you are watching the Little League World Series, you'll notice some subtle differences between Little League rules and that of Major League Baseball or NCAA baseball. The biggest difference is the number of innings played for the 12U All-Stars in the modified double-elimination tournament held in Williamsport, Pennsylvania, each year. Here's everything to know about how many innings are in a Little League World Series game and the other important rules about players and Little League Baseball. How many innings are in a Little League World Series game? Under normal circumstances, a complete Little League World Series game is played over six innings. If the home team is winning the game entering the top of the sixth inning and gets three outs against the visiting team, then the game will end with five and a half innings played as the home team will not bat in the bottom of the sixth inning. Can a Little League World Series game go into extra innings? Yes. If the score is still tied after six complete innings, then the two teams will go into extra innings starting with the seventh inning. The difference with the seventh inning and every inning needed after that, is that a runner starts the seventh inning (and beyond) on second base. That runner, according to Little League, 'is scheduled to bat last in that respective half inning.' What are the special circumstances for an abbreviated Little League World Series game? A Little League World Series game can end before the sixth inning under what Little League calls the 'Run Rule." If, after three innings (or two-and-a-half if the home team is winning), one team is winning by 15 runs or more, the game will end. If, after four innings (or three-and-a-half if the home team is winning), one team is winning by 10 runs or more, the game will also end early. When is a Little League World Series game considered an official game? According to Little League, 'each tournament game must be played to the point of being an official game," which means at least four innings played (or three-and-a-half innings if the home team is ahead) and the game isn't shortened by the 15-run rule or the 10-run rule. How many innings can a Little League Baseball player throw in a game? Little League Baseball doesn't have a strict per-game pitching innings limit. However, Little League does monitor how many pitches a player can throw in a game and there are corresponding days of rest tied to how many pitches a player throws in each game. The maximum number of pitches a player can throw in a Little League World Series game is 85 pitches. However, a pitcher can go over the 85-pitch threshold to finish an at-bat that started under 85 pitches, but that batter would be the last one before the pitcher must be removed from the mound. The pitching ranges and corresponding days of rest are as followed: Sherlon Christie is a social media editor for USA TODAY Sports. You can reach him via email at schristie@ and on X, Instagram and Threads at @sherlonchristie
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
How miserable are Nashville pro sports fans? It's been 'woeful'
Fans of Nashville's three professional sports — the Tennessee Titans, Nashville Predators, and Nashville SC — may feel they are among the most miserable in the country. And according to a misery index published by ESPN, they are correct. The "Sports Misery Index" is a tool that calculates the misery of your fandom among professional teams, giving you an average misery score that is generally higher if your team loses a lot of regular season games and has little to no postseason success. The higher the misery index, the more miserable the fan. For example, the Colorado Rockies have a misery score of 95 (out of 100), one of the highest among professional teams. Fans of the Kansas City Chiefs have a score of zero. Note that the number of years you've been a fan of the team does factor into the score. For example, if you've been a fan of the New England Patriots for just the past five years, your misery score is 92. If you've been a fan of the Patriots for 15 or more years, your misery score is zero. So where do Nashville sports fans rank? How miserable are fans of Tennessee Titans, Nashville Predators, and Nashville SC? By combining the misery score of the Titans, Predators, and Nashville SC, fans can expect a score of 84 out of 100. That places them in the "Woeful" category, the highest level of misery possible. Note this calculates fans of 15 or more years of the Titans and Predators and fans of five or more years for Nashville SC. These results may not be surprising considering how poorly Nashville sports have performed, especially recently. The Titans are coming off a 3-14 season and have not won a playoff game since January 2020, when they beat the Baltimore Ravens in the divisional round. The Predators finished third worst in the NHL last season and have not won a playoff round since 2018, when they beat the Colorado Avalanche in six games. Though they did not make the postseason last year, Nashville SC has had the most recent success, making it to the quarterfinal round of the MLS Cup in 2021. Overall fans of Tennessee sports — which includes the Memphis Grizzlies — can expect a score of 74, which puts fans in the "Flailing" category. The Grizzlies have qualified for the playoffs in four of the last five years, beating the Minnesota Timberwolves in the first round of the NBA playoffs in 2022. Note that college teams are not included in the index. Adding to the misery, none of Tennessee's major professional sports have won a championship in their history. Two teams came close — the Titans lost to the St. Louis Rams in Super Bowl 34 in 2000 and the Predators lost to the Pittsburgh Penguins in the Stanley Cup Final in 2017. ESTES: The Titans are trying hard to be a closer team. Will that make them a better one? Alex Daugherty is the Predators beat writer for The Tennessean. Contact Alex at jdaugherty@ Follow Alex on X, the platform formerly called Twitter, @alexdaugherty1. Also check out our Predators exclusive Instagram page @tennessean_preds. This article originally appeared on Nashville Tennessean: Are Nashville pro sports fans miserable? Here's how one site ranks them
