Adani names two dead Australian war veterans in documents alleging protest conspiracy against it
The fourth version of Adani Mining's claim against environmental activist Ben Pennings – which has been afoot for more than four years – now names Kokoda veteran and climate activist Bill Ryan as an alleged co-conspirator. Ryan died in 2019, aged 97.
'Why the hell can't Adani leave Dad to rest in peace rather than drag us through this bullshit?,' Ryan's son, Colin, told Guardian Australia.
The Queensland supreme court struck out substantial parts of Adani's claim last year, describing some elements as 'confused and embarrassing'.
Adani's allegations of a conspiracy – which accused Pennings of acting with 'unknown conspirators' to disrupt the company's contractors – were disallowed by Justice Susan Brown, who gave Adani leave to replead its case.
Sign up for the Afternoon Update: Election 2025 email newsletter
In its new filing – the fourth version of Adani's statement of claim since launching the case in 2020 – the company has now named four alleged co-conspirators it says were involved in an agreement with Pennings to participate in direct protest action against contractor Downer Group in 2017.
Mike Fitzsimon (referred to in Adani's claim as 'Mike Fitzsimmons'), a Vietnam veteran who died in 2022, is listed as a co-conspirator alongside Pennings and Ryan.
The other alleged co-conspirators named by Adani are elderly Vietnam veteran Maurice Tolley and 'Donna Smits', whose name also appears to be misspelled in the document. They were named in court documents, but only Pennings is being sued by Adani.
'Dad had a tough life, served his country in war and tried to protect us all [with his climate activism],' said Colin Ryan.
'He died a hero to thousands but now I have to tell the grandkids and great-grandkids he's part of some Adani conspiracy theory in the supreme court.'
Sign up to Afternoon Update: Election 2025
Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key election campaign stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
Pennings said Ryan and Fitzsimon were 'heroes, dedicating their final years to protect us from climate breakdown'.
'I'm not sure what's happened that's led Adani to pick them out now, years after they have passed away. It is just another twist and turn in this harrowing five-year saga.'
The company said in a statement that its legal proceedings were 'solely against Mr Pennings', and that other alleged co-conspirators were 'simply named in our evidence of Mr Pennings' activities'.
'Any attempt by Mr Pennings or Mr Ryan's family to suggest otherwise is incorrect and speaks to the way Mr Pennings has conducted himself throughout this case,' the statement said.
'We make no apologies for protecting our rights and the rights of hard-working Queenslanders to go about their legal and legitimate work.'
Adani said its amended pleadings presented a 'strong case' against Pennings, including that he sought to disrupt the operations of the Carmichael coalmine, its suppliers and contractors.
Justice Paul Freeburn published an interlocutory judgment in the case in March, establishing a timeline for Pennings to file an amended defence. He said the case appeared to be 'making no real progress towards a trial'.
'And so, some four-and-a-half years into the litigation, the plaintiffs have recently filed and served their fourth version of the statement of claim and now expect, by their proposed directions, a further amended defence, a reply and a regime for particulars and disclosure. This is in respect of events that occurred between 2015 and 2020 – that is, between five and 10 years ago,' Freeburn said.
'The proceeding has not languished through a lack of resources. The judgment of Brown J in December 2024 explains that a costs statement prepared by the plaintiffs, in respect of some costs orders in favour of the plaintiff, claimed $1.1m.
'That was described by Her Honour as a 'startling amount' given the applications occupied less than two days [of] hearing time, albeit with some level of complexity.
'On any view, the litigation has consumed large slabs of the parties' resources and the court's resources. It is hard to escape an overall impression that the parties are mired in the trenches of interlocutory warfare.'
Adani claimed Pennings had 'spent years trying to delay these civil legal proceedings from going to trial'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
8 hours ago
- The Guardian
Four-day work week? Six weeks of holidays? Australians have a choice about how to bank productivity gains
One of the ideas that has captured many peoples' attention amid the flurry of proposals ahead of the economic roundtable is the Australian Council of Trade Unions' vision of a four-day working week. The peak union body argued that working less could actually be productivity enhancing, although the studies behind those claims aren't too rigorous. While many Australians would certainly welcome a three-day weekend, Jim Chalmers has made it clear that working towards a national four-day working week is not on the government's agenda, while reaffirming Labor's commitment to flexible work. Employer groups have been scathing, and it's not likely to be a big discussion point on day two of the three-day roundtable. Clearly not on board with the treasurer's 'open hearts and open minds' approach to this week's talkfest, the Australian Industry Group's chief executive, Innes Willox, called the four-day working week idea 'another populist, anti-productivity thought bubble'. Willox calculated that at the current dismal rate of productivity growth it would take 26 years to get to the point where we could drop a day's work without going backwards economically. But as the ACTU secretary, Sally McManus, explained to the Conversation's Michelle Grattan: the labour movement doesn't expect a revolution in the working week to happen overnight. 'To be clear, we weren't asking for a change to the workplace laws for the government to do something,' McManus said. 'We were raising this in the context of a discussion both around productivity and around AI as an important part of the distribution of the benefits of productivity growth or, for that matter, productivity growth out of less jobs, out of AI.' The longer arc of Australian history has been towards shorter working weeks and longer holidays. But that progress stopped a few decades back, settling on the current set-up of a 38-hour full-time job, two-day weekend and four weeks' paid leave. But there has been progress in other ways (assuming 'progress' is working less – many believe hard work is an end in and of itself). For example, since the turn of the century, the share of full-time employed Australians who say they work longer than 50 hours weekly has gone from 25% to 15%. Meanwhile, part-time work has flourished, fed in particular by a surge in women entering the jobs market. (Which means households overall are probably working harder.) Since the turn of the century, the female employment to working-age population ratio has climbed from 50% to over 60%, according to data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics. (The equivalent workforce participation rate for men is just under 68% and hasn't moved much over 25 years.) Of course, the working from home phenomenon that emerged with Covid has been a revolution for many, particularly working families. Thankfully, employers are on board and hybrid work looks set to stay. But to many Australians juggling work and other commitments, time still feels like the greatest luxury. In which case, why shouldn't the reward for lifting productivity growth be fewer working hours for the same pay? Some fascinating research earlier this year by Rusha Das, an economist at the Productivity Commission, showed we would have a three-day working week today if we had collectively decided in 1980 to spend all the productivity gains of the following decades on leisure time instead of higher incomes. Das calculated that Australians used only a quarter of the productivity 'dividend' from the past 40-plus years to work less, while we banked the remaining three-quarters as higher income. 'We have largely traded it for higher incomes, and more and better stuff,' she said. One of the great things about a more efficient and dynamic economy is that it can give us more choices about what we want to do – how much more we want to buy, how much more we want to work and how much more we want to devote to family, hobbies or helping others. This may be getting ahead of ourselves – we have to raise our economic speed limit before we decide how much faster we want to drive. But we'd be mad to limit our thinking to the notion higher productivity is all about generating more income. The ACTU's four-day work week proposal is a good reminder of that.
Daily Mail
17 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Aussie share no-one has heard of POPS: Stock surges 72 times over - $14k instantly turns into $1m
An obscure rare earth miner's share price has skyrocketed from just four cents to $2.82 in a matter of hours. The 70-fold increase in the Kaili Resources share price occurred on Monday turning a modest $14,000 investment into a $1million windfall. The surge happened within just five-and-a-half hours from the start of trade, with the share price peaking at 3.30pm Sydney time, or just 30 minutes before the close of trade. But the Australian Securities and Investments Commission imposed a trading halt on Monday, that will continue until Wednesday, following a request from the company. 'Trading in securities in the entity will be temporarily paused pending a further announcement,' the ASX said. By then, profit takers had already sold, causing the price to more than halve back to $1.08 by the late afternoon. This was still the highest closing price since June 2002. Those who held on without profit selling still made a significant profit, with an initial $1,000 investment still worth $27,000. An obscure rare earth miner's share price has skyrocketed from just four cents to $2.82 in a matter of hours The surge from Friday's close at 3.6c started after Kaili Resources announced that afternoon that South Australia 's Department of Energy and Mining had given it approval to drill at three tenements in Lameroo, Karte and Coodalya in the Murray Basin. Kaili Resources, established in 1997, has languished under 80c for the last 20 years Kaili chairman Donghai Zhang and director Chunlin Liu are connected with the Chinese Yitai Group, which controls Inner Mongolia Yitai Coal Co.
Rhyl Journal
a day ago
- Rhyl Journal
Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney can leave ‘legacy' in Wales' World Cup plan
The UK is the sole bidder to host an expanded 48-team tournament in 2035 – and the Football Association of Wales has targeted two venues among the 16 stadiums planned. The FAW wants one in the south of the country – probably Cardiff City Stadium rather than Welsh rugby's Principality Stadium home – and one in the north, Wrexham's redeveloped SToK Cae Ras home. Wrexham's Hollywood owners Reynolds and McElhenney are seeking to expand the Red Dragons' stadium, with a proposed 7,750-seater Kop stand taking capacity to around 18,000. The pair – who were at the Cae Ras on Saturday to watch newly-promoted Wrexham play their first home game in the Championship – said in May 2024 that development on all four sides of the ground could lead to 'between 45,000 and 55,000 people in there'. 'The Kop development is a significant first step and the vision for the stadium is incredible,' FAW chief executive Mooney told the PA news agency. 'What Ryan and Rob are doing is amazing. They are looking to look to invest in the stadium and build up the Cae Ras, which is the oldest international ground in the world, and there is a potential North Star for them. 'The city and the club have a chance to bring a World Cup to North Wales. What a story that would be. What a legacy for Ryan and Rob to leave Wrexham.' The FAW and Wrexham held talks over the Women's World Cup last week and Wales will host the 2026 European Under-19 Championship next summer. All games will be played in the north at Bangor, Colwyn Bay, Deeside, Denbigh, Deeside and Wrexham, with the Cae Ras hosting the final. 'It's our 150th anniversary next year, we were founded in Wrexham, and the story is very powerful for us,' added Mooney, who said the FAW will launch a 10-year strategy for Welsh football in 2026. 'The impact of Ryan and Rob has been manna from heaven for us, the timing of it. 'We've been very fortunate over the last few years to get to a men's World Cup, first women's Euro, and have our young teams starting to qualify for major championships. 'That has coincided with Ryan and Rob coming in. Wrexham has already started collecting a lot of our national team players, and will produce lots of players for us in the future with their investment in youth development and Academy. 'There is a symbiotic relationship there where we can create a lot of value for each other. 'People all over the world are talking about Wrexham and that inspires partners like FIFA, commercial bodies and Governments to get involved.' The UK's formal bid for the 2035 Women's World Cup will be submitted in November and likely to be approved by FIFA next year, with all four home nations automatically qualifying for the tournament.
