Are we entering the era of the quarterback goalkeeper?
As we enter a tactical reaction period to structured pressing; do you think we'll see the development of the 'Quarterback Keeper?' Will the Pep Guardiolas of the world have midfielders breaking from the back running post patterns while fullbacks run a curl? – David
I've no idea what those terms mean but I assume they're from American football? If so, I wouldn't fixate on them; while it's certainly possible for sports to draw inspiration from each other, they very rarely map precisely on to each other. Will players start moving in different patterns to now? Possibly, but football is 150 years old; there is very little new under the sun.
I think what we are seeing now, though, is more structured patterns, automations, practised and practised so they can be deployed in games when an appropriate situation occurs. That's particularly true of counter-attacks; Jogi Löw's Germany were masters of that. On the one hand, if everybody knows where everybody is about to run, moves can be made quicker, gaining vital fractions of seconds on a defence. But there are other coaches, such as José Mourinho, who believe football is too fluid and chaotic for automations to be more than intermittently effective; they prefer to instil a mindset so players instinctively make the right decisions in any given circumstance.
And as for goalkeepers effectively becoming playmakers, that's been in the game for decades. Ederson, perhaps, has taken it further than anybody else, but look at Stanley Menzo at Ajax in the 80s, or René Higuita with Colombia and Atlético Nacional. When Higuita was dispossessed to allow Roger Milla his second for Cameroon in the last 16 of the 1990 World Cup, the general sense, in the UK at least, was that a 'crazy' keeper had got his comeuppance. Look back on it, though, and with modern eyes it's apparent that Higuita has come out to deal with a long ball, and is looking to draw a Cameroon player out of position to give his outfielders a numerical advantage. The problem comes when Luis Carlos Perea plays a terrible pass back to him, allowing Milla to steal in. 'We quickly realised that we had something special: an extra outfield player,' Francisco Matura, his coach both at club and national level, explained in an interview with The Blizzard. Within our gameplan we had a structure with five lines and every line was separated by 10 metres. That meant we had 11 players instead of 10 able to generate play. It wasn't us insisting that he should get out of his area and play but the system that encouraged it.'
Sometimes when I attend games at West Brom, as a goalkeeper prepares to take a goal kick, all 20 outfield players will congregate in a small area to one side of the pitch around the halfway line. The goal kick is contested by the players and then normal play resumes. I am completely baffled as to 1) why this happens, and 2) why the kicking team never leaves a player in the wide open space on the other side of the pitch to take full advantage of an open path to goal. Perhaps you could offer an explanation for this bizarre tactic? – Robert
This is a related issue to the first question. In the 1980s this was common; almost nobody played out from the back, keepers always kicked long and, either because of the way they naturally kicked (eg, a right-footer will usually kick with a slight right-to-left drift) or because of where the best headers tended to play, those kicks would be directed to one side or the other. With both sides pushing up to catch the opposition offside from the second ball, the effect was that 20 outfielders would end up in a small box around halfway, slightly pushed into the half being attacked by the team taking the goal kick. As to why one player doesn't break off into space; he wouldn't be in space for long because a marker would follow him.
Football used to be a more a game of territory than possession. The logic was that if you could get the ball into the opposition half, they were under pressure. One mistake could lead to a shooting chance. The mentality has changed over the past two decades, largely because of improvements in pitch technology. Now, with far fewer bobbles, the first touch can be taken almost for granted, so the game becomes far less about winning the ball back after a poor touch than about manipulating the shape of the game and creating overloads. Possession matters more than position. As pressing structures have improved, though, it's become increasingly risky to play out from the back – and the problem if a side goes long with full-backs dropping to receive a short pass is that it effectively takes offside out of the equation. And so the result is the hoof into a tight knot of players near halfway and a scramble to win the second ball.
I find it interesting that no one has picked up the fact that Arsenal might be struggling because of Declan Rice's current position (left-sided No 8). Arteta still hasn't fixed the gap that Granit Xhaka left. Rice plays better, and so do Arsenal, when he plays in his natural position. Thoughts? – Nelson
I think this has been widely recognised as a problem for both Arsenal and England. Rice is occasionally portrayed as a defensive midfielder, but he is not. He is a box-to-box player who is very good at making forward surges from deep. He does not, though, have the tactical brain to operate as an effective deep-lying midfielder, which he is often asked to do. Granit Xhaka, as you say, fulfilled that role last season, and although Thomas Partey has done so this season, the Ghanaian has been less convincing. Martin Ødegaard's slight downturn in form this season can probably in part be attributed to Xhaka's departure. What Arsenal could really do with is a peak-era Jorginho. The present version, at 33, has managed just 544 league minutes this season.
This is an extract from Soccer with Jonathan Wilson, a weekly look from the Guardian US at the game in Europe and beyond. Have a question for Jonathan? Email soccerwithjw@theguardian.com, and he'll answer the best in a future edition

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


NBC Sports
an hour ago
- NBC Sports
Trackhouse Racing engineer excited for chance to return home with NASCAR race in Mexico
MEXICO CITY — Somewhere along pit road Sunday at Autódromo Hermanos Rodríguez, Jose Blasco-Figueroa will stand in line with his Trackhouse Racing teammates and hear something he's never heard ahead of a NASCAR Cup race. The Mexican national anthem. Just the thought of that had the 52-year-old Mexico City native 'getting emotional' when he talked with NBC Sports earlier this month. But there's something else that makes the senior performance engineer's path to this weekend even more special. He became an American citizen in April. The first Cup race he heard the 'The Star-Spangled Banner' after becoming a U.S. citizen was the Coca-Cola 600 at Charlotte Motor Speedway. Set against the backdrop of Memorial Day weekend, the emotional pre-race ceremonies reached a crescendo with the anthem and flyover. Blasco-Figueroa admits he 'kind of felt different' hearing the anthem as a citizen compared to previous times. 'It felt great.' Just as he imagines what it will be like to hear the Mexican anthem ahead of the first NASCAR Cup points race outside the continental U.S. since 1958. 'Going back there and listening to it, that, to me, is going to be probably the best part of the race regardless of what happens,' he said. 'Because … I haven't heard it (at a Cup race before). I haven't experienced that.' Dustin Long, He is here 25 kilometers from his mother's home helping oversee engineering aspects for Trackhouse drivers Ross Chastain, Daniel Suarez and Shane van Gisbergen. Each has won a road course race with the Next Gen car (since 2022). Blasco-Figueroa never imagined his path leading to NASCAR. He didn't come from a racing family but his interest in the sport was raised when he received a battery-powered toy Formula One car as a child. Intrigued by how things worked, he became an engineer. He spent his first 23 years in Mexico City and joined General Motors. The company sent him to Michigan for about 18 months before he returned to Mexico. He left GM to earn his master's degree in England. He hoped to get a job with a Formula One team but nothing materialized. Blasco-Figueroa returned to work for GM in Mexico. At one point, he was working for GM, teaching automotive engineers and working with a NASCAR Mexico Series team. He eventually quit his GM job to focus on racing. In 2016, he went to Charlotte, North Carolina, dropping his resumes off at race shops. A few days later, he had three job offers. He's worked at BK Racing, Richard Childress Racing and now Trackhouse Racing. He's working on different projects for Trackhouse and teaching some of the younger engineers Blasco-Figueroa recently completed the 'Data Science and Machine Learning: Making Data-Driven Decisions' 12-week program by the MIT Institute for Data, Systems and Society. He spent eight to 12 hours a week on the course. 'You got to keep up with technology,' Blasco-Figueroa said. 'Data science is taking over many things. … AI is just a small part of data science. For us, right here, racing, the amount of data we have is huge.' 'A lot of people just think about racing on the part of you've going to make fast cars. Yes, you've got to make fast cars, but you got to race, right? That's why strategy also is a part of the game. How you manage your car, how you manage your tires. All of that is coming into place. We just saw it in the (Coca-Cola) 600. (William Byron) dominated the race. Did he win it? No. We won it (with Chastain). Why? Strategy.' Should Trackhouse win Sunday in Mexico, it would complete a memorable day for Blasco-Figueroa that started with hearing the Mexican anthem for the first time before a Cup race.

NBC Sports
an hour ago
- NBC Sports
Nico Young breaks American record in 5000m
Nico Young broke the American record in the men's outdoor 5000m to win at a Diamond League meet in Oslo on Thursday. Young, a 22-year-old who placed 12th in the Olympic 10,000m, clocked 12 minutes, 45.27 seconds. Grant Fisher, the Olympic 5000m and 10,000m bronze medalist, held the previous American record of 12:46.96, set in 2022. Young's previous outdoor 5000m personal best was 13:11.30 from 2022, which put him outside the 30 fastest Americans in history going into Thursday. Young also ran 12:51.56 indoors on March 2, ranking him fifth all-time worldwide and second among Americans indoors behind Fisher's world record of 12:44.09. Young became the third American man to win a 5000m on the Diamond League, an annual series of track and field meets that launched in 2010. The others were Ben True in 2015 and Paul Chelimo in 2018. Young earned his first career win outside of the U.S. His first race outside the country was at the Paris Olympics, according to track and field statistics website Oslo marked his Diamond League debut. Uganda's Joshua Cheptegei owns the outdoor world record of 12:35.36, recorded in 2020. Also Thursday, Norwegian Karsten Warholm ran the fastest time in history in the 300m hurdles -- 32.67 seconds to beat his previous record of 33.05. Warholm is the Tokyo Olympic gold medalist and world record holder in the 400m hurdles. The 300m hurdles is not contested at major meets like the Olympics and World Championships. 🤯 U.S. OUTDOOR 5K RECORD FOR NICO FREAKIN YOUNG! 🤯 Young runs 12:45.27 to beat Grant Fisher's 12:46.96.#OsloDL & #DiamondLeague coverage presented by@FleetFeetSports & @tracksmith Nick Zaccardi,


New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Christian Pulisic breaks silence on USMNT Gold Cup drama after ‘out of line' jabs by legends
Christian Pulisic believes those questioning his commitment to the U.S. Men's National Team are 'way out of line.' The star winger/midfielder has faced blowback from USMNT legends Landon Donovan and Tim Howard for his choice to skip the upcoming Gold Cup, but he told CBS Sports Golazo's 'Call It What You Want' show Thursday that he 'sticks with his decision' — regardless of what his childhood idols might think. 'It's tough, especially when some of them as well even privately, the way they talk to me and clearly want to show support and be a friend and everything, and then it goes and they say something slightly different publicly,' Pulisic said. 'Does it hurt me, am I surprised by it? Not really.' 'To question my commitment, especially towards the national team, in my opinion, that's way out of line.' After playing a nine-month season with AC Milan, Pulisic asked USMNT head coach Mauricio Pochettino to be left off the roster for the Gold Cup. 'Towards the second half and towards the end of the season, my body just started talking to me and my mind and I started to think what is gonna be best for me leading into next year and going into the World Cup?' Pulisic explained on the podcast. 'And was that to play eight more games and then get no rest at all, go straight into preseason, and then grind another year and go straight into the World Cup? That's not what I felt was best for my body.' 3 Christian Pulisic will not play for the U.S. Men's National Team at this summer's Gold Cup. Jayne Kamin-Oncea-Imagn Images Pulisic said he did ask the coaching staff to play in the USMNT's two recent friendlies — against Turkey (June 7) and Switzerland (June 10) — but the coaches declined, opting for roster continuity heading into the Gold Cup. 'I fully respect that,' Pulisic said. 'I didn't understand it, but it is what it is.' Donovan had indirectly criticized Pulisic on Fox Sports over the weekend during the UEFA Nations League final won by Cristiano Ronaldo's Portugal team, saying: 'I can't help but think about our guys on vacation not wanting to play in the Gold Cup. It's pissing me off.' 3 United States' Landon Donovan controls the ball during a training session on May 14, 2014. AP 3 United States' Tim Howard in a World Cup qualifying match in Sept. 2013. AP Howard, on the May 28 episode of the Unfiltered Soccer podcast, raised concerns that Pochettino would 'not know what his best team is made of in the most difficult moments' with key players like Pulisic skipping the Gold Cup. Pulisic's father, Mark, mocked Donovan by posting a screengrab of him asking ChatGPT about Donovan's sabbatical in 2012-13. The USMNT's Gold Cup roster will also be missing Antonee Robinson (knee surgery), and Weston McKinnie, Gio Reyna and Timothy Weah, who are all playing in the upcoming Club World Cup.