Police officers detained after son smacked win appeal over arrests
In a ruling on Monday, Mr Justice Bourne overturned the decision.He said: "In my judgment, on a proper analysis of the evidence at trial, the police did not show that there was an objective basis for the belief that it was necessary to arrest either claimant."The judge said in a 30-page ruling that at the time of the incident, the couple's son, referred to as ABD, had "an unfortunate history of challenging behaviour" and had begun attending a youth centre to access mental health services.The couple cancelled ABD's birthday party in March 2019 after he misbehaved, causing him to go to his room, where he "kicked things around".This led his mother to smack her son while his father was asleep, which she said "was not hard and did not cause any injury or leave any mark".
ABD attended a youth centre the following day and told staff that he had been assaulted by his mother and that his father had done nothing to stop it.Despite offering to be interviewed voluntarily, both parents were arrested and detained for more than seven hours.ABD returned to the family home the following day, with police deeming that the children were not at risk of harm and telling the couple that they would face no further action three days after their arrest.
In his ruling, Mr Justice Bourne said he was "unable to agree" with the trial judge's finding that there was a "rational basis" for officers to conclude that voluntary interviews were not an option.He said: "In the present case, no reason has been identified which actually explains why voluntary interviews were not a viable alternative."It follows that the arrests were unlawful and the claims should have succeeded."
Additional reporting by PA Media.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
16 minutes ago
- The Independent
Police descend on New York City skyscraper after police officer and three others killed in Manhattan shooting
A police officer and three other people have been killed following a shooting at a skyscraper in New York on Monday (28 July). Eyewitness footage taken from a nearby hotel shows NYPD officers entering the office building located in Midtown Manhattan. The gunman, who also died from a self-inflicted wound, was identified by police as Shane Tamura, a 27-year-old from Las Vegas. Tamura is accused of walking into the lobby with an A4 assault rifle and 'spraying' ammunition inside, killing four including police officer Didarul Islam, a father of two whose wife is pregnant with a third child.
BBC News
17 minutes ago
- BBC News
Man, 19, arrested after woman and baby attacked at Portishead Marina
A teenager has been arrested after a woman and child were targeted in an unprovoked attack. Police were called to Portishead Marina, in North Somerset, shortly after 10:00 BST on Sunday to reports that a man had attacked the pair and assaulted a man who had tried to intervene. The child was taken to hospital but has since been discharged. A 19-year-old man was arrested at the scene, with police confirming he had since been released on bail under the condition he did not return to Portishead. Avon and Somerset Police said officers spoke to witnesses at the scene, but has asked anyone with information about the incident to get in touch.
The Sun
17 minutes ago
- The Sun
Horror as nursery plunged into lockdown after two killed in quadruple stabbing at central London business
PARENTS have opened up after a horrifying, quadruple stabbing plunged a nearby nursery into lockdown. Emergency services rushed to a local business - near to the nursery -at 1pm on Monday, after four people were attacked. 2 2 Four people were stabbed in total, with two sadly passing away from their injuries. A 58-year-old was pronounced dead at the scene and a 27-year-old man later died in hospital. Police have detained a man in connection with the incident, who is now in critical condition in hospital. The fourth man reportedly sustained injuries which were not life threatening. The horrifying incident has left the community shaken, particularly after a nearby nursery was plunged into lockdown. One mum opened up about the horrifying moment that she heard about the stabbing near Long Lane in Southwark. Choosing to remain anonymous, she told MailOnline: "[The nursery] sent us an alert while I was at work saying that there'd been a stabbing and that the roads would be cordoned off. "It's terrifying. When I walked down to the nursery I was trying to find out information about whether it was targeted or random, because you hear a lot about stabbings in London." She added: "It's really shocking. To have this in an area where I'm raising a child makes me worry that I shouldn't be living somewhere like this now that we have a family." Detective Chief Superintendent Emma Bond, who leads policing for the area, said: "Our investigation is in the early stages and we are working hard to understand the full circumstances of this shocking incident. "At this point, we do not believe it to be terrorism-related and there is no further risk to the public. "There will be a heavy police presence in the area throughout today and I would encourage anyone with information to speak with officers or contact the Met by other means." At the time, a spokesperson for London Ambulance Service said: 'We were called at 1.04pm today to reports of a stabbing on Long Lane, SE1. 'We sent a number of resources to the scene, including ambulance crews, advanced paramedics, incident response officers, a command support vehicle and paramedics from our tactical response unit. "We also dispatched a trauma team in a car from London's Air Ambulance, which consisted of a paramedic and a doctor in a car. 'We treated four people at the scene. We took three patients to major trauma centres as a priority. "Very sadly, despite the best efforts of our crews, a person was pronounced dead at the scene.' Like us on Facebook at @TheSun.
