Qasim backs Shan as Test captain
Former Pakistan Test spinner Iqbal Qasim has questioned Saud Shakeel's credibility as a replacement for Shan Masood as Test captain, urging that recent Pakistan Test losses shouldn't be blamed solely on Masood.
During a recent interview to Cricket Pakistan, the former legend criticised the frequent captaincy changes in Pakistan cricket, pointing out that players are often appointed as captains only to be replaced shortly after.
Addressing recent demands to replace Shan with Saud as the red-ball captain, he questioned whether such a change would guarantee improved results.
"If Saud Shakeel is handed the captaincy instead of Shan Masood, what assurance do we have that he will lead the team to victories? How many times has he captained a team in his career?" Qasim remarked.
"If the captain is replaced, should we also consider dropping other players?" he added. The Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) had appointed Shan Masood as an experimental captain, and according to Qasim, Masood has gradually been growing into the role. He argued that changing the captain now is unlikely to yield significant improvements.
"If Saud Shakeel takes over, he will likely face the same challenges as Shan Masood," Qasim stated. "In my opinion, a change in captaincy will not have a major impact on the team's performance."
On Babar Azam, Qasim praised the former Pakistan captain as a talented and consistent player but acknowledged that every batsman experiences form fluctuations.
"Babar Azam is a talented player, but there comes a time when every batter's form dips," he said. "At this point, Babar will have to decide whether he wants to continue in T20I cricket. If he is committed to this format, he will need to adapt to its demands. Otherwise, he has the potential to play Test and ODI cricket for many more years."
The 71-year-old concluded by highlighting the need to support Babar Azam, calling him a national asset.
"Pakistan has invested heavily in Babar Azam. It is our collective responsibility to encourage him, not discourage him with criticism," he added.
It is pertinent to mention that Shan Masood was appointed Pakistan's Test captain in November 2023 but has struggled to deliver consistent results. Under his leadership, Pakistan played 12 Tests, winning only three while losing nine.
The team's performance in the ICC World Test Championship (WTC) 202325 was disappointing, finishing ninth on the points table. Pakistan suffered series whitewashes against Australia, Bangladesh, and South Africa, managing only two series wins against Sri Lanka and England, and a drawn series against the West Indies.
Shan's inability to consistently perform and make impactful tactical decisions has raised concerns among selectors and team management.
In contrast, Saud Shakeel has emerged as one of Pakistan's most reliable Test batsmen, boasting an average above 50 since his debut.
His composure and consistency have impressed, qualities highly valued by the PCB for Pakistan's red-ball future.
His leadership skills were on display in the ongoing Pakistan Super League (PSL) 10, where he captained the Quetta Gladiators to top the points table with six wins in nine matches, securing a playoff berth.
The possible captaincy change is viewed as part of a broader team reset following Pakistan's underwhelming WTC campaign.
For the unversed, Pakistan's next Test series is scheduled for October 2025, when South Africa will tour the country for two Tests, three ODIs, and three T20Is.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
9 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Youth over experience
The Pakistan Cricket Board's decision to exclude stalwarts Babar Azam and Mohammad Rizwan from the national Asia Cup squad comes as a surprise, but not a total shock. While framed as a necessary evolution toward "fearless cricket", the move still risks undermining team stability for uncertain gains. The selectors' rationale hinges on undeniable statistical realities — Babar's career T20I strike rate of 129.22 and Rizwan's 125.37 lag significantly behind modern powerhouses like England's openers, who regularly exceed 140 in the shortest form of the game. In fact, since 2022, their powerplay strike rates plummeted further to 116 and 117.4 — criminally low in an era where 130 is unexceptional. This conservatism contributed to Pakistan's catastrophic 2024 T20 World Cup group-stage exit, including a historic loss to the USA. This is also why both players have remained sidelined from the T20 squad for several months. However, discarding proven match-winners demands deeper examination. Babar and Rizwan have amassed 2,522 runs as a partnership — the highest for any Pakistani opening pair — with eight century stands. Their defenders have noted that the pair reliability provided solid starts that the middle order rarely capitalised on. Conversely, their replacements — Saim Ayub and Hasan Nawaz — have higher strike rates, but significantly lower averages, which loosely translates into more shaky starts. Should the top order collapse under pressure — especially during the match against India — the absence of Babar-Rizwan's resilience will haunt the team's legacy. The uninspiring run of results since head coach Mike Hesson took over in May has done little to inspire confidence in the team. However, Hesson has a track record of success elsewhere, so he may know something we don't. At the end of the day, the decision is defensible, but just barely. Success will make Aqib Javed and the rest of the selectors look like geniuses. Failure, not so much.
Express Tribune
19 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Sports Round up
TOP QUOTE Simeone: I think this has been a learning experience for myself Diego Simeone admits tactical errors contributed to Atletico's opening defeat against Espanyol TOP STORIES ATHLETICS Thompson out of Lausanne meet PARIS. Kishane Thompson, the fastest man in the 100m this year and a favourite for next month's world championships, will miss the Diamond League meet in Lausanne on Wednesday with a shin injury. "Kishane Thompson will not compete in the men's 100m," organisers said in a statement on Monday. The Jamaican sprinter has been suffering from "shin discomfort" since beating Olympic champion Noah Lyles last weekend. AFP FOOTBALL Forest sign French forward Kalimuendo LONDON. French striker Arnaud Kalimuendo has signed a five-year contract with Nottingham Forest, the Premier League club announced on Monday. According to French media, the transfer paid to ex-club Rennes is believed to be at least 30 million euros ($35 million). "Nottingham Forest is delighted to announce the signing of Arnaud Kalimuendo," read a statement on the English club's website. AFP ICONIC Pakistan's Arshad Nadeem celebrates winning the Paris Olympics javelin throw gold medal. RECORD CORNER 9.58 seconds is the number of seconds Usain bolt took to make the world recond in 100m sprint. TRIVIA Who are the current champions of the UEFA Women's European Championship? England SIDE STORIES Haller leaves Dortmund BERLIN. Borussia Dortmund on Monday confirmed striker Sebastien Haller had joined Dutch side Utrecht on a permanent deal. Haller reportedly joined on a free transfer, having been allowed to end his Dortmund contract a year early. The 31-year-old Ivory Coast international spent the second half of last season on loan at Utrecht, the club he played for between 2015 and 2017. "This summer there was quite a bit of interest from other clubs, but for me there was only one ideal scenario and that was FC Utrecht," Haller said in a statement on the club's website. The departure ends a tumultuous time for Haller at Dortmund. After arriving in a deal worth 31 million euros ($36 million) from Ajax in 2022, Haller was diagnosed with testicular cancer weeks later and missed six months while undergoing treatment. He missed a penalty on the final day of the 2022-23 season in a 2-2 home draw against Mainz which handed Bayern Munich the Bundesliga title. AFP Mueller has goal ruled out LOS ANGELES. Thomas Mueller made his Major League Soccer debut on Sunday as a second-half substitute for Vancouver Whitecaps in a 1-1 draw with Houston Dynamo that left the Germany great with "mixed feelings" after he had a goal disallowed for offside. Vancouver were up 1-0 courtesy of Brian White's sixth-minute penalty when the former Bayern Munich striker Mueller entered the contest to a massive ovation in the 61st minute. Mueller, a World Cup-winner with Germany whose storied tenure at Bayern included 13 Bundesliga titles, had made his way into Vancouver's BC Place stadium through a throng of excited supporters, high-fiving and shaking hands as he went. The Whitecaps had officially unveiled their new signing on Thursday, a week after he inked a deal through the end of the 2025 season with an option for 2026. The crowd of 26,301 stood and cheered when he was introduced before kickoff, and Mueller applauded fans in return. AFP Lukaku to miss start of Napoli's title defence MILAN. Romelu Lukaku will miss Napoli's opening fixture of their Serie A title defence after suffering a thigh injury which could keep the Belgium striker out for months, the Italian champions said on Monday. Napoli, who travel to promoted Sassuolo on Saturday, said in a statement that Lukaku had suffered a "serious" tear in his left thigh during Thursday's pre-season friendly with Olympiakos. No indication over how long Lukaku would be sidelined was given by Napoli, but Italian media reported that he could be out of action until November. Napoli suggested that Lukaku, 32, might have to undergo surgery. Lukaku was key to Napoli winning their fourth league title last season, setting up 10 Serie A goals to go with the 14 he scored under coach Antonio Conte. AFP FIFA boss condemns racial abuse BERLIN. FIFA President Gianni Infantino has condemned the alleged racial abuse which occurred during two German Cup fixtures on the weekend as "unacceptable", in a statement issued Monday. "I repeat myself and will continue to do so. There is no place for racism in football," Infantino said in the statement. On Sunday, a match between home side Lokomotive Leipzig and Schalke was halted after winger Christopher Antwi-Adjei said he was racially abused by home spectators. An announcement on the stadium PA was made condemning racist abuse. After the match resumed, the winger was booed repeatedly by the home support and Lokomotive issued an apology later on Sunday. Also on Sunday, a player from visiting side Kaiserslautern also alleged racial abuse from a member of the crowd at club RSV Eintracht. AFP Springboks suffer injury CAPE TOWN. As if the pain of a first defeat to Australia at Ellis Park in 62 years was not enough, South Africa face a heavy injury toll from the 38-22 defeat in Saturday's Rugby Championship opener, with captain Siya Kolisi sidelined for an extended period. Kolisi suffered a knee injury as Australia rallied from 22 points down in a stunning second-half display and is out of the second test in Cape Town on Saturday and likely the two-match tour to New Zealand that follows. Kolisi is expected to be out for four weeks, which means he will miss the Springboks' eagerly anticipated clash with New Zealand at Eden Park on September 6, where they are seeking a first win since 1937. Loose-forward Pieter-Steph du Toit suffered a concussion in the weekend defeat and will also miss the second game as he goes through return to play protocols. REUTERS
Express Tribune
20 hours ago
- Express Tribune
New faces, new hopes: Why Pak's young guns can light up Asia Cup
YOUNG SIDE: The Pakistan team was celebrating their victory against West Indies in the T20I series. Photo: AFP/File The announcement of Pakistan's squad for the upcoming UAE T20 Tri-Series and the much-anticipated Asia Cup 2025 has sparked intense conversations across the cricketing world. The omission of experienced duo like Babar Azam and Mohammad Rizwan from the 17-member squad is not just a headline—it marks a shift in Pakistan's T20 philosophy. Yet, as the dust settles, one truth emerges: Pakistan's young guns have both the talent and temperament to seize the moment and fill the void left by two of the country's most consistent performers. Pakistan's white-ball head coach Mike Hesson was quick to underline the thought process behind the selection. On social media, he described the squad as 'a great blend of energy and experience,' highlighting the balance between established performers and fresh talent. With names like Shaheen Shah Afridi and Haris Rauf providing stability and firepower in the bowling department, and rising stars like Saim Ayub, Sahibzada Farhan, and Hasan Nawaz bringing aggression to the batting order, Pakistan have deliberately chosen a squad built for the demands of modern-day T20 cricket. Young brigade steps in At the heart of this transition are players who represent Pakistan's future. Saim Ayub has already shown flashes of brilliance with his bold stroke play and fearless approach, while Sahibzada Farhan has made a strong case for himself with three Player-of-the-Match awards in just six T20Is. Fakhar Zaman, though not entirely new, continues to offer the kind of explosive batting that can change games within a few overs. Add Mohammad Haris's natural attacking flair with the bat and skills behind the stumps, and Pakistan suddenly look like a side ready to match, if not surpass, the strike rates that Babar and Rizwan were often criticised for. This new approach aligns with the global evolution of T20 cricket. Powerplay overs are no longer about consolidating; they are about striking hard and fast. Pakistan's decision to opt for aggressive openers reflects a broader recognition of what it takes to win at the highest level. In this sense, the likes of Saim and Farhan are not just replacements—they are the embodiment of a new mindset. Confidence Hesson Hesson's emphasis on bowling variety is equally crucial. With five frontline seamers and two mystery spinners, Pakistan's attack is tailor-made for UAE conditions, where adapting quickly is often the difference between victory and defeat. He also stressed that this squad represents 'a much-improved fielding side,' another area where Pakistan have historically lagged but now seem determined to catch up. If the bowlers can complement the batting firepower with discipline and sharpness in the field, Pakistan will enter the Asia Cup as genuine contenders. Aqib's assurance Selector and former pacer Aqib Javed also brought clarity to the debate surrounding Babar and Rizwan. He reminded fans and critics alike that exclusions in cricket are rarely permanent. 'Whoever performs will play,' he said, stressing that opportunities in the national side depend on consistency and form, not past reputation. For Babar and Rizwan, both of whom are still competing in international leagues, the message is clear: performance will dictate their return. This perspective is vital for Pakistan cricket. It ensures accountability and avoids the pitfalls of over-reliance on individuals. It also motivates the younger players, who now know that strong performances will not go unnoticed. Sahibzada Farhan's resurgence, Saim's learning curve, and Fakhar's adaptability are examples of how patience and faith in talent can pay off. The road ahead Pakistan's group in the Asia Cup—featuring arch-rivals India alongside Oman and UAE—offers the perfect stage for this new-look side to test its mettle. The Pakistan-India clash on September 14 in Dubai will be the ultimate litmus test, not only for the youngsters stepping into the spotlight but also for the selectors' bold strategy. If they succeed, Pakistan may have found a new formula to rival India's explosive top order. Transitions are rarely smooth in cricket, especially when they involve moving on from iconic figures like Babar and Rizwan. But every era demands its heroes, and this squad is brimming with candidates ready to answer that call. The Asia Cup 2025 might just be remembered not as the tournament where Babar and Rizwan were absent, but as the stage where Pakistan's next generation announced itself to the world.
