Youth over experience
The selectors' rationale hinges on undeniable statistical realities — Babar's career T20I strike rate of 129.22 and Rizwan's 125.37 lag significantly behind modern powerhouses like England's openers, who regularly exceed 140 in the shortest form of the game. In fact, since 2022, their powerplay strike rates plummeted further to 116 and 117.4 — criminally low in an era where 130 is unexceptional. This conservatism contributed to Pakistan's catastrophic 2024 T20 World Cup group-stage exit, including a historic loss to the USA. This is also why both players have remained sidelined from the T20 squad for several months.
However, discarding proven match-winners demands deeper examination. Babar and Rizwan have amassed 2,522 runs as a partnership — the highest for any Pakistani opening pair — with eight century stands. Their defenders have noted that the pair reliability provided solid starts that the middle order rarely capitalised on. Conversely, their replacements — Saim Ayub and Hasan Nawaz — have higher strike rates, but significantly lower averages, which loosely translates into more shaky starts. Should the top order collapse under pressure — especially during the match against India — the absence of Babar-Rizwan's resilience will haunt the team's legacy.
The uninspiring run of results since head coach Mike Hesson took over in May has done little to inspire confidence in the team. However, Hesson has a track record of success elsewhere, so he may know something we don't. At the end of the day, the decision is defensible, but just barely. Success will make Aqib Javed and the rest of the selectors look like geniuses. Failure, not so much.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
3 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Game must go on: Akram on Ind-Pak clash
Both Pakistan and India are set to clash on September 14 in Dubai. Photo: AFP/File Legendary Pakistan fast bowler Wasim Akram has said that whether or not India faces Pakistan in the upcoming Asia Cup 2025, cricket must continue. Speaking on the Stick With Cricket Podcast, Akram addressed the controversy surrounding the tournament schedule. 'Asia Cup schedule is out, there is backlash. But we in Pakistan are calm. We will be fine whether we play or don't play. The game must go on,' Akram said. The former captain also expressed hope for the revival of bilateral cricket between the two arch-rivals. 'I hope to see a Test series between India and Pakistan in my lifetime,' he said. 'Politics apart, I am not a politician. They are patriotic about their country, we are patriotic about ours. Let's not go below the belt. Talk about the triumphs of your country; the same goes for Pakistan and the same goes for India. It is easier said than done.' 'Players are helpless' Former Indian captain Sunil Gavaskar has said that players are 'helpless' when it comes to decisions about whether the men in blue should face Pakistan in international cricket. The debate over the upcoming Asia Cup 2025 encounter between the two arch-rivals has intensified following the unforseen tensions between both the countries, which further strained bilateral relations. Social media has since been flooded with calls to boycott Pakistan across all sports, including cricket. Even in the Legends League, the India Champions side opted not to play against Pakistan. However, in the Asia Cup, a face-off remains on the cards, with the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) confirming the team's participation when announcing the squad on August 19. Speaking to the Indian media, Gavaskar emphasised that players have no say in such matters and must follow directions. 'If the government has taken a call, I don't see how the players can be criticised or commented upon, because the players at the end of the day are contracted to the BCCI and they will be taking instructions from the government of India. So it entirely depends on that,' Gavaskar said. 'The players are helpless in this. They've been selected to play in the Asia Cup, and if the government says you have to play, then they will go out and play. If the government says you don't, then the BCCI will act accordingly,' he added. The Asia Cup will be held in Dubai and Abu Dhabi from September 9 to 28, featuring eight teams split into two groups. Group A includes India, Pakistan, UAE, and Oman, while Group B features Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, and Hong Kong. Dubai will host 11 matches, while Abu Dhabi will stage eight. The tournament opens on September 9 with Afghanistan facing Hong Kong in Abu Dhabi. India will begin their campaign against the UAE on September 10 in Dubai, followed by the much-anticipated clash against Pakistan on September 14. Their final group-stage fixture against Oman is scheduled for September 19 in Abu Dhabi. The Super Four stage will take place from September 20 to 26, with the final set for September 28 in Dubai. Pakistan squad: Saim Ayub, Fakhar Zaman, Salman Ali Agha (C), Abrar Ahmed, Faheem Ashraf, Haris Rauf, Hasan Ali, Hasan Nawaz, Hussain Talat, Khushdil Shah, Mohammad Haris (WK), Mohammad Nawaz, Mohammad Wasim Jr., Sahibzada Farhan, Salman Mirza, Shaheen Shah Afridi, Sufiyan Muqeem. India squad: Suryakumar Yadav (capt), Shubman Gill (vc), Hardik Pandya, Arshdeep Singh, Abhishek Sharma, Tilak Varma, Shivam Dube , Axar Patel, Jitesh Sharma, Jasprit Bumrah, Varun Chakravarthy , Kuldeep Yadav, Harshit Rana, Rinku Singh, Sanju Samson.
Express Tribune
9 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Asia Cup will go on without Pakistan, as they refuse to play in India
Pakistan, three-time Asia Cup champions, will not play at the Asia Cup 2025 in Bihar. The Pakistan Hockey Federation decided not to send the team to India, citing security issues, and informed both the IHF and AHF. Pakistan will be missing out on the chance to qualify for the FIH Hockey World Cup 2026 by not participating in the event. India and Pakistan have been involved in a war in May, and the diplomatic relations between the neighbours have been deteriorating ever since. Subsequently, the Green Shirts were replaced by Bangladesh in their group B. The AHF issued the new tournament schedule on Tuesday, August 19. The event will be held in Rajgir from August 29to September 7, 2025. 'This continental championship will not only crown the best team in Asia, but also the winners of Hero Asia Cup 2025 will qualify for the FIH Hockey World Cup Belgium –Netherlands 2026,' the AHF issued a press release on August 19. 'The tournament will open on 29 August with an exciting day of action, featuring reigning champions Korea beginning their title defense against Chinese Taipei at 11:00, and hosts India facing China at 15:00 in front of an expected passionate home crowd.' They elaborated that changes are also made in Group A as Oman have also withdrawn from the event, therefore, Kazakhstan are completing the line-up now. 'The participating nations are divided into two pools: Pool A consists of India, Japan, China, and Kazakhstan, while Pool B includes Malaysia, Korea, Bangladesh, and Chinese Taipei,' the AHF further elaborated in the statement. 'The pool stage will be followed by the Super4s, with the Final on 7 September 2025 between the teams finishing first and second in the Super4s. The champion will lift the Hero Asia Cup 2025 Trophy and secure Asia's spot at the FIH Hockey World Cup Belgium–Netherlands 2026.' The AHF President Fumio Ogura also highlighted the importance of the event, 'The Hero Asia Cup Rajgir Bihar 2025 will bring together the very best of Asian hockey. With World Cup qualification on the line, every match will carry enormous importance. We are confident this edition will showcase thrilling competition, inspire millions of fans, and leave a lasting legacy for the sport in Asia.'
Express Tribune
a day ago
- Express Tribune
Youth over experience
The Pakistan Cricket Board's decision to exclude stalwarts Babar Azam and Mohammad Rizwan from the national Asia Cup squad comes as a surprise, but not a total shock. While framed as a necessary evolution toward "fearless cricket", the move still risks undermining team stability for uncertain gains. The selectors' rationale hinges on undeniable statistical realities — Babar's career T20I strike rate of 129.22 and Rizwan's 125.37 lag significantly behind modern powerhouses like England's openers, who regularly exceed 140 in the shortest form of the game. In fact, since 2022, their powerplay strike rates plummeted further to 116 and 117.4 — criminally low in an era where 130 is unexceptional. This conservatism contributed to Pakistan's catastrophic 2024 T20 World Cup group-stage exit, including a historic loss to the USA. This is also why both players have remained sidelined from the T20 squad for several months. However, discarding proven match-winners demands deeper examination. Babar and Rizwan have amassed 2,522 runs as a partnership — the highest for any Pakistani opening pair — with eight century stands. Their defenders have noted that the pair reliability provided solid starts that the middle order rarely capitalised on. Conversely, their replacements — Saim Ayub and Hasan Nawaz — have higher strike rates, but significantly lower averages, which loosely translates into more shaky starts. Should the top order collapse under pressure — especially during the match against India — the absence of Babar-Rizwan's resilience will haunt the team's legacy. The uninspiring run of results since head coach Mike Hesson took over in May has done little to inspire confidence in the team. However, Hesson has a track record of success elsewhere, so he may know something we don't. At the end of the day, the decision is defensible, but just barely. Success will make Aqib Javed and the rest of the selectors look like geniuses. Failure, not so much.
