logo
Teal MP Sophie Scamps forced to defend comments linking death of NRL player Keith Titmuss to 'lethal humidity' caused by climate change

Teal MP Sophie Scamps forced to defend comments linking death of NRL player Keith Titmuss to 'lethal humidity' caused by climate change

Sky News AU30-04-2025
Teal MP Dr Sophie Scamps has apologised to the family of Manly Sea Eagles player Keith Titmuss after being filmed suggesting climate change may have played a role in his death.
Titmuss died in 2020 after suffering a seizure at Manly's training ground in Narrabeen, with a coronial inquest later finding he had likely suffered a fatal heat stroke.
The Daily Telegraph published footage of Dr Scamps at a Doctors for the Environment Australia conference in February, where she mentioned his death in the context of 'lethal humidity' caused by climate change.
'With every rise of one degree in temperature you have seven degrees increased per cent in humidity, so the death of that young man – and I'm not saying – the death of the young man the rugby league player when it was 33 degrees a very humid day, died from heat stress – you know, after a training session,' Dr Scamps said in the video.
The remarks angered Titmuss' family, with his mother Lafo accusing Dr Scamps of using her son's death to 'gain political points'.
Speaking to 2GB's Ben Fordham on Wednesday, Dr Scamps said she was 'deeply sorry' for the upset she caused.
'If there's any distress or upset... deeply, deeply sorry, that was never my intention at all of course," she said.
'Our community was heartbroken for their family I must say … love and best wishes and deep apologies if there was any... if she is upset. "
Mr Fordham said the death of the young footballer was a 'very delicate area' to be delving into, which prompted a further apology from Dr Scamps.
'I didn't actually mention the young man by name, nor did I say it was directly linked to climate change. The question was, what are doctors worried about with increasing temperatures?' she said.
'There is a concern from doctors all around the world that … we had the hottest year on record last year... and the last ten hottest years have been in the last ten years.
'Whatever we have, we have a warming climate.
'It is very unfortunate that I've upset the family but it's about even healthy young people... our bodies are not adapted to dealing with humidity.'
When asked why she did not apologise to Titmuss' family immediately after the matter was first brought to her attention, she said she did not have their number.
'It was great to have this opportunity today to say that I am deeply sorry to the family today,' she said.
Speaking to The Australian on Tuesday, Lafo hit out at the Teal MP as she declared her son's death had nothing to do with climate change.
"I'm disappointed that (Dr Scamps) is using my son's name to try and gain political points when all she needed to do was read (the Deputy State Coroner's) findings, which mention nothing about climate change,' she said.
Speaking separately to the Sydney Morning Herald, Ms Lafo said: 'The whole family are annoyed they are using Keithy's death for political gain."
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Successful or not, NRL court cases shine spotlight on player safety
Successful or not, NRL court cases shine spotlight on player safety

Sydney Morning Herald

time05-08-2025

  • Sydney Morning Herald

Successful or not, NRL court cases shine spotlight on player safety

Struggling to comprehend his downward spiral after a life-altering training session now the subject of a multi-million dollar Supreme Court action, Lloyd Perrett was allegedly told there was nothing wrong with him. 'The plaintiff's mental health deteriorated by reason of his concern at his physical deterioration and how that would affect his future while at the same time being told by the Club's personnel that there was nothing wrong with him and that nothing could be done about it,' according to Perrett's statement of claim, lodged with the Supreme Court on Monday. Given he has just launched a legal action, Perrett has most certainly done something about it. As to whether there is something wrong with Perrett, and whether former employer Manly was negligent during a contentious pre-season workout at the Narrabeen Sports Complex on November 6, 2017, that is the $5 million question. Perrett claims he suffered exertional heatstroke, heat stress-induced seizure and psychiatric injury after participating in running sessions in which he was deprived of water. The former Bulldogs prop said he was never the same player or person after being in 'a comatose state for two days', and revealed he had considered taking his own life after his career was cut short prematurely. It's not the only league-related matter before the Supreme Court. Former Canterbury forward Jackson Topine is suing the Bulldogs, claiming he was subjected to 'assault' when forced to wrestle up to 35 teammates during a training session last year. The Bulldogs have vowed to vigorously defend the matter. Meanwhile, over in the UK, more than 1000 rugby union and rugby league players have launched a concussion class action. Such lawsuits have raised fears that it's only a matter of time before doctors and lawyers kill off rugby league as we know it. However, it's important to distinguish between the concussion cases – which are facing their own challenges – and alleged negligence off the field. Only last month, the judge presiding over the concussion class action in the UK blasted the lawyer bringing the claim, accusing him of a 'complete misunderstanding of his responsibilities' and having 'a problem with the English language.' Senior Master Jeremy Cook said that medical records were missing in about 90 per cent of cases, in a huge setback for the plaintiffs. Closer to home, the most famous concussion case was brought by former Newcastle Knights winger James McManus. After seeking a $1 million payout, McManus said he was 'broken' after the NRL in 2021 stated the matter 'has been resolved in the Knights' favour.' The Australian Rugby League Commission has also withstood a legal challenge launched by premiership-winning prop Michael Greenfield over its handling of shoulder charges.

Successful or not, NRL court cases shine spotlight on player safety
Successful or not, NRL court cases shine spotlight on player safety

The Age

time05-08-2025

  • The Age

Successful or not, NRL court cases shine spotlight on player safety

Struggling to comprehend his downward spiral after a life-altering training session now the subject of a multi-million dollar Supreme Court action, Lloyd Perrett was allegedly told there was nothing wrong with him. 'The plaintiff's mental health deteriorated by reason of his concern at his physical deterioration and how that would affect his future while at the same time being told by the Club's personnel that there was nothing wrong with him and that nothing could be done about it,' according to Perrett's statement of claim, lodged with the Supreme Court on Monday. Given he has just launched a legal action, Perrett has most certainly done something about it. As to whether there is something wrong with Perrett, and whether former employer Manly was negligent during a contentious pre-season workout at the Narrabeen Sports Complex on November 6, 2017, that is the $5 million question. Perrett claims he suffered exertional heatstroke, heat stress-induced seizure and psychiatric injury after participating in running sessions in which he was deprived of water. The former Bulldogs prop said he was never the same player or person after being in 'a comatose state for two days', and revealed he had considered taking his own life after his career was cut short prematurely. It's not the only league-related matter before the Supreme Court. Former Canterbury forward Jackson Topine is suing the Bulldogs, claiming he was subjected to 'assault' when forced to wrestle up to 35 teammates during a training session last year. The Bulldogs have vowed to vigorously defend the matter. Meanwhile, over in the UK, more than 1000 rugby union and rugby league players have launched a concussion class action. Such lawsuits have raised fears that it's only a matter of time before doctors and lawyers kill off rugby league as we know it. However, it's important to distinguish between the concussion cases – which are facing their own challenges – and alleged negligence off the field. Only last month, the judge presiding over the concussion class action in the UK blasted the lawyer bringing the claim, accusing him of a 'complete misunderstanding of his responsibilities' and having 'a problem with the English language.' Senior Master Jeremy Cook said that medical records were missing in about 90 per cent of cases, in a huge setback for the plaintiffs. Closer to home, the most famous concussion case was brought by former Newcastle Knights winger James McManus. After seeking a $1 million payout, McManus said he was 'broken' after the NRL in 2021 stated the matter 'has been resolved in the Knights' favour.' The Australian Rugby League Commission has also withstood a legal challenge launched by premiership-winning prop Michael Greenfield over its handling of shoulder charges.

Knights shun cold turn, rugging up in Mark Hughes beanies ahead of bumper Raiders clash
Knights shun cold turn, rugging up in Mark Hughes beanies ahead of bumper Raiders clash

The Advertiser

time26-06-2025

  • The Advertiser

Knights shun cold turn, rugging up in Mark Hughes beanies ahead of bumper Raiders clash

Former Knights great turned crusader against and survivor of brain cancer, Mark Hughes, launched the ninth Beanies for Brain Cancer NRL round on Wednesday, as his former club fielded a small army of beanies in training that morning. Hughes, who debuted in 1997 at 20 years old and played on the wing in that year's memorable grand final win over Manly, was diagnosed with an avocado-sized brain tumour in 2013. Since founding the charity in his name in 2014, the annual beanies campaign and its partnered NRL round, have become a marquee date in the calendar. The charity is a juggernaut research funder, hires specialist nursing staff to guide patients through their own battles, and coordinates leading thinkers in the sector. More than one million beanies have been sold since the first NRL round in 2017, funnelling some $35 million towards research and patient support. A turn to the colder conditions as winter sets, and the forecast showers toward the weekend could temper crowd numbers from the team's last home game against the Roosters on June 14. But club officials were expecting as many as 20,000 fans to turn out to support the cause. Club spokesperson Frank Barrett said the Knights were chomping at the bit to return to home turf for the round that was close to the team's heart. Knights players, including returned scion Dom Young, took to the training field on Wednesday morning sporting the MHF headwear ahead of the team's clash with Canberra Raiders on Friday, June 27. The club is coming off a win against the Dolphins in Perth last weekend, and will kick off against the Raiders at 8pm on Friday after the NSW Cup at 5.30pm. Gates open at 5.15pm. Former Knights great turned crusader against and survivor of brain cancer, Mark Hughes, launched the ninth Beanies for Brain Cancer NRL round on Wednesday, as his former club fielded a small army of beanies in training that morning. Hughes, who debuted in 1997 at 20 years old and played on the wing in that year's memorable grand final win over Manly, was diagnosed with an avocado-sized brain tumour in 2013. Since founding the charity in his name in 2014, the annual beanies campaign and its partnered NRL round, have become a marquee date in the calendar. The charity is a juggernaut research funder, hires specialist nursing staff to guide patients through their own battles, and coordinates leading thinkers in the sector. More than one million beanies have been sold since the first NRL round in 2017, funnelling some $35 million towards research and patient support. A turn to the colder conditions as winter sets, and the forecast showers toward the weekend could temper crowd numbers from the team's last home game against the Roosters on June 14. But club officials were expecting as many as 20,000 fans to turn out to support the cause. Club spokesperson Frank Barrett said the Knights were chomping at the bit to return to home turf for the round that was close to the team's heart. Knights players, including returned scion Dom Young, took to the training field on Wednesday morning sporting the MHF headwear ahead of the team's clash with Canberra Raiders on Friday, June 27. The club is coming off a win against the Dolphins in Perth last weekend, and will kick off against the Raiders at 8pm on Friday after the NSW Cup at 5.30pm. Gates open at 5.15pm. Former Knights great turned crusader against and survivor of brain cancer, Mark Hughes, launched the ninth Beanies for Brain Cancer NRL round on Wednesday, as his former club fielded a small army of beanies in training that morning. Hughes, who debuted in 1997 at 20 years old and played on the wing in that year's memorable grand final win over Manly, was diagnosed with an avocado-sized brain tumour in 2013. Since founding the charity in his name in 2014, the annual beanies campaign and its partnered NRL round, have become a marquee date in the calendar. The charity is a juggernaut research funder, hires specialist nursing staff to guide patients through their own battles, and coordinates leading thinkers in the sector. More than one million beanies have been sold since the first NRL round in 2017, funnelling some $35 million towards research and patient support. A turn to the colder conditions as winter sets, and the forecast showers toward the weekend could temper crowd numbers from the team's last home game against the Roosters on June 14. But club officials were expecting as many as 20,000 fans to turn out to support the cause. Club spokesperson Frank Barrett said the Knights were chomping at the bit to return to home turf for the round that was close to the team's heart. Knights players, including returned scion Dom Young, took to the training field on Wednesday morning sporting the MHF headwear ahead of the team's clash with Canberra Raiders on Friday, June 27. The club is coming off a win against the Dolphins in Perth last weekend, and will kick off against the Raiders at 8pm on Friday after the NSW Cup at 5.30pm. Gates open at 5.15pm. Former Knights great turned crusader against and survivor of brain cancer, Mark Hughes, launched the ninth Beanies for Brain Cancer NRL round on Wednesday, as his former club fielded a small army of beanies in training that morning. Hughes, who debuted in 1997 at 20 years old and played on the wing in that year's memorable grand final win over Manly, was diagnosed with an avocado-sized brain tumour in 2013. Since founding the charity in his name in 2014, the annual beanies campaign and its partnered NRL round, have become a marquee date in the calendar. The charity is a juggernaut research funder, hires specialist nursing staff to guide patients through their own battles, and coordinates leading thinkers in the sector. More than one million beanies have been sold since the first NRL round in 2017, funnelling some $35 million towards research and patient support. A turn to the colder conditions as winter sets, and the forecast showers toward the weekend could temper crowd numbers from the team's last home game against the Roosters on June 14. But club officials were expecting as many as 20,000 fans to turn out to support the cause. Club spokesperson Frank Barrett said the Knights were chomping at the bit to return to home turf for the round that was close to the team's heart. Knights players, including returned scion Dom Young, took to the training field on Wednesday morning sporting the MHF headwear ahead of the team's clash with Canberra Raiders on Friday, June 27. The club is coming off a win against the Dolphins in Perth last weekend, and will kick off against the Raiders at 8pm on Friday after the NSW Cup at 5.30pm. Gates open at 5.15pm.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store