How Carmel plans to stay No. 1
Why it matters: One of Central Indiana's fastest-growing suburbs, Carmel is looking to maintain its reputation as a model city as it faces scrutiny around governance, equity and long-term planning.
What they're saying:"I was very familiar with our residents' high expectations, and I embrace it," Carmel Mayor Sue Finkam told Axios. "I'd rather have engagement over apathy any day."
Driving the news: The latest example of the city's self-reflection was last week's Affiliate Review Committee meeting when results of a fiscal and legal review were shared.
The review found that mismanagement and an overreliance on city backing led to Carmel investing more than $8 million into the award-winning winter attraction Christkindlmarkt since 2017 with no return.
Flashback: The Carmel City Council created the committee last fall to examine the city's relationship with Carmel Christkindlmarkt Inc. and other affiliates brought on during the last administration.
State of play: Officials said steps taken since the shakeup have resulted in the city being reimbursed $284,000 this year for the first time in the Christkindlmarkt's history.
Yes, but: The meeting brought criticism from community members that the process was one-sided and that key Christkindlmarkt leaders, like former board chair Sue McDermott, were never consulted as the probe took place.
The latest: Councilor Jeff Worrell, a sponsor of the proposal to establish the review committee, said findings being presented does not mean the search for understanding and improvement is over.
"There is a segment of our population that sees these findings … (and says) 'Something happened. Why was that? What were the circumstances?'" Worrell said. "I'm a big believer in there being two sides to every story."
The other side: As the city grapples with these difficult discussions, it has added another award to the mantle.
The 2025 Niche rankings named Carmel the best place to live in Indiana, and the second best suburb in the U.S.
In the statewide rankings, it also took No. 1 for best place to raise a family, best place for young professionals and the best public schools.
Between the lines: Finkam sees the affiliate review committee as part of a larger effort to keep Carmel high in the rankings and meet the expectations of residents who moved there in search of the best.
What's next: Carmel's recently formed Advisory Commission on Housing will implement the 13 recommendations made last year by the Finkam-formed Carmel Housing Task Force to fix problems related to access and options.
Plus: Worrell, who launched a civility campaign at the start of the 2024, said that push for more politeness in Carmel is growing, too.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
4 hours ago
- Axios
Minneapolis mayor makes high-stakes pitch for budget trims, tax hike
Mayor Jacob Frey is asking Minneapolis to tighten its belt. Why it matters: The mayor proposed Wednesday to increase the city's property tax levy by 7.8% next year — Minneapolis' largest levy hike since 2010, if enacted — though the increase could've been higher without $23 million in cuts the mayor has suggested. He contends the budget proposal shields taxpayers from a flood of rising costs without employee layoffs or deep cuts to core services like road repairs or police. What they're saying:"This was not an easy budget year. But it's also not a crisis budget. This is a disciplined budget," Frey is expected to say in his budget address Wednesday morning, according to draft text shared with Axios. Zoom in: If Minneapolis made no major budget changes, city officials would've needed a much larger levy increase next year — as much as 13% — to keep up with rising costs, mostly for salaries, benefits and construction expenses. By eliminating two dozen vacant positions and making other money-saving accounting moves, city officials were able to reduce next year's levy increase. Minneapolis would also save $3.6 million by eliminating "double-time" overtime pay for police officers. (The department has spent record amounts on OT amid a staffing shortage, per the Star Tribune.) The big picture: The mayor now has to sell the $2 billion budget proposal to the City Council — which is controlled by Frey critics — during an election year, as even some of the mayor's council allies are pleading for limits to the levy increase. Friction points: The mayor's budget saves money by ending or reorganizing programs that the council funded, but were deemed "untested or unsustainable." For example, instead of four Open Streets festivals, the mayor proposes to fund only three — and Frey has already faced criticism for stifling the event. The city would also continue a sidewalk-shoveling partnership with neighborhood groups, but abandon other efforts to explore city-run sidewalk clearing programs that have intrigued council members. What we're watching: How the council — which makes most final budget decisions — responds. Last year, Frey's council critics banded together to reshape the budget, and ultimately overrode the mayor's veto of their rewritten spending plan. What's next: The city's Board of Estimate and Taxation will set the maximum levy amounts later this fall, though the council can always approve smaller tax increases.
Axios
6 hours ago
- Axios
Mayes hints at possible legal action if Corporation Commission repeals renewable energy mandate
Attorney General Kris Mayes signaled she might take the Corporation Commission to court if it dismantles renewable energy standards she helped create nearly 20 years ago. Why it matters: The future of Arizona's renewable energy mandate is on the line. The big picture: The commission last year instructed staff to draft rules that would repeal its renewable energy standards, saying they're unnecessary and appear to drive up costs. The Renewable Energy Standard and Tariff (REST) Rules require affected utilities to get 15% of the electricity they provide from renewable sources. Staff in late July issued a formal proposal to repeal the standards. Driving the news: Mayes on Monday sent a letter to the commission warning that repealing REST "isn't just nonsensical; it's unlawful." REST isn't perfect, the AG concedes, and she would "wholeheartedly support" efforts to modernize the rules, but she opposes outright repeal. A spokesperson for Mayes declined to comment on whether she'll sue the commission if it votes to repeal the standards. Flashback: Mayes was a Republican member of the commission — she's now a Democrat — when it passed the REST rules in 2006. She was part of the 4-1 majority that voted for the standards. Zoom in: A third-party economic analysis performed for the commission found that REST repeal "could marginally reduce monthly residential electric bills" by $1-$2 and result in minor administrative cost savings for utilities. But renewable energy-related costs for some utility customers would continue due to long-term financial obligations. And repeal would have indirect costs including "reduced transparency, regulatory certainty and potentially slower renewable energy adoption," the analysis said. Between the lines: Mayes argued in her letter that REST helps keep customer rates lower for millions of Arizonans and creates jobs in the renewable energy sector. She said rate-making decisions must legally be based on "high-quality evidence, not speculation and conjecture." "In addition to being bad policy, repealing the REST Rules as proposed here is an unlawful abdication of the Commission's duty to set just and reasonable rates," she wrote. The other side: Commission chair Kevin Thompson told Axios he's not surprised Mayes is "rattling her saber, considering she played a pivotal part in implementing this gravy train that has cost ratepayers billions of dollars." He said his focus is on protecting ratepayers and not pushing "costly ideological mandates." Commission vice chair Nick Myers said he's unconcerned about a lawsuit if the commission repeals REST. "We'll let her do what she thinks she needs to do, and if she has legal grounds, bring them up," he said. Reality check: Renewable energy accounts for about 19% of the energy that Arizona Public Service, the state's largest utility, provides its electric retail customers, the company tells Axios. What's next: The commission will vote at a Thursday meeting on whether to instruct staff to begin the repeal process.
Axios
6 hours ago
- Axios
Washington state dead last in U.S. police staffing
Washington state ranks last in law enforcement staffing for the 15th year in a row, according to FBI data analyzed by the Washington Association of Sheriffs & Police Chiefs (WASPC). Why it matters: Low staffing levels stretch departments thin, impact officer safety, slow response times and, according to law enforcement leaders, create a cycle that pushes more officers out of the profession. "Tired officers, running from call to call by themselves, are the worst possible outcome — for wellness, for victims, and for de-escalation," Steve Strachan, executive director of WASPC, tells Axios. Driving the news: WASPC released its annual Crime in Washington report on July 28, offering a state snapshot of crime and policing in 2024. By the numbers: Washington added 292 officers statewide last year and the number of officers per capita rose slightly from 1.34 in 2023 to 1.36, according to FBI data. But Washington is still in 51st place, behind all 50 states and D.C., according to WASPC's analysis. Zoom in: After losing 355 officers through resignations, retirements and other exits, the Seattle Police Department's force is growing for the first time in years. The city has hired more than 100 new recruits this year, with a goal of 150 by December — part of a push to rebuild toward around 1,300 deployable officers, according to the department. What they're saying:"Public safety is a core function of government, and for too long we have not treated it that way," Strachan says. There are always so many competing worthy programs and initiatives for public dollars, he said, and "a lack of understanding that we need both programs for prevention as well as accountability for criminals." The big picture: WASPC tells Axios it would cost more than $1 billion annually to bring Washington up to the national average for police staffing — based on the state Department of Commerce's $154,704 per-officer estimate. To lead the nation? Try 30,589 more officers — and nearly $5 billion a year.
