Mayes hints at possible legal action if Corporation Commission repeals renewable energy mandate
Why it matters: The future of Arizona's renewable energy mandate is on the line.
The big picture: The commission last year instructed staff to draft rules that would repeal its renewable energy standards, saying they're unnecessary and appear to drive up costs.
The Renewable Energy Standard and Tariff (REST) Rules require affected utilities to get 15% of the electricity they provide from renewable sources.
Staff in late July issued a formal proposal to repeal the standards.
Driving the news: Mayes on Monday sent a letter to the commission warning that repealing REST "isn't just nonsensical; it's unlawful."
REST isn't perfect, the AG concedes, and she would "wholeheartedly support" efforts to modernize the rules, but she opposes outright repeal.
A spokesperson for Mayes declined to comment on whether she'll sue the commission if it votes to repeal the standards.
Flashback: Mayes was a Republican member of the commission — she's now a Democrat — when it passed the REST rules in 2006.
She was part of the 4-1 majority that voted for the standards.
Zoom in: A third-party economic analysis performed for the commission found that REST repeal "could marginally reduce monthly residential electric bills" by $1-$2 and result in minor administrative cost savings for utilities.
But renewable energy-related costs for some utility customers would continue due to long-term financial obligations.
And repeal would have indirect costs including "reduced transparency, regulatory certainty and potentially slower renewable energy adoption," the analysis said.
Between the lines: Mayes argued in her letter that REST helps keep customer rates lower for millions of Arizonans and creates jobs in the renewable energy sector.
She said rate-making decisions must legally be based on "high-quality evidence, not speculation and conjecture."
"In addition to being bad policy, repealing the REST Rules as proposed here is an unlawful abdication of the Commission's duty to set just and reasonable rates," she wrote.
The other side: Commission chair Kevin Thompson told Axios he's not surprised Mayes is "rattling her saber, considering she played a pivotal part in implementing this gravy train that has cost ratepayers billions of dollars."
He said his focus is on protecting ratepayers and not pushing "costly ideological mandates."
Commission vice chair Nick Myers said he's unconcerned about a lawsuit if the commission repeals REST. "We'll let her do what she thinks she needs to do, and if she has legal grounds, bring them up," he said.
Reality check: Renewable energy accounts for about 19% of the energy that Arizona Public Service, the state's largest utility, provides its electric retail customers, the company tells Axios.
What's next: The commission will vote at a Thursday meeting on whether to instruct staff to begin the repeal process.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
an hour ago
- USA Today
Over 300 protests held Saturday against Trump redistricting push
Pro-democracy activists and labor groups held hundreds of rallies and other events across the United States on Saturday, Aug. 16, protesting the Trump administration's push for Texas to redraw its congressional map in favor of Republicans. Former Congressman Beto O'Rourke was among those who spoke on Saturday in Texas, from which dozens of Democratic state lawmakers fled to deny Republicans the quorum needed to vote on a redistricting plan that President Donald Trump had demanded. "They do this because they are afraid," O'Rourke told an audience on Saturday, speaking of those attempting redistricting. "They fear this power they see here today." More: Obama calls Texas GOP redistricting an 'assault' on democracy Drucilla Tigner, executive director of pro-democracy coalition Texas For All, told Reuters pro-democracy and labor groups held over 300 events attended by tens of thousands of people in 44 states and Washington, D.C. Many of the more than 50 Texas Democrats who fled the state have been staying in Illinois, also the site of protests on Saturday. The Texas lawmakers in Illinois are out of reach of civil arrest warrants that could be acted on within Texas. The Texas Democrats kept the map from coming to a vote during a special session Texas Gov. Greg Abbott called that ended Friday. Abbott immediately called a second special session. Abbott said that redistricting plans, legislation to increase flash flood safety in the wake of deadly July flooding, and other legislative work remain undone because Democrats are absent. California's Democratic Governor Gavin Newsom on Thursday, Aug. 14 unveiled a redistricting plan in his state that he says would give Democrats there five more Congressional seats, possibly offsetting any Republican gains in Texas. The Texas House Democrats said in a written statement on Thursday that they will only return to Texas if their state's special legislation is ended and once California's redistricting maps are introduced.
an hour ago
In Trump's redistricting push, Democrats find an aggressive identity
ATLANTA -- Fight! Fight! Fight! It's not just Donald Trump's mantra anymore. As the Republican president pushes states to redraw their congressional districts to the GOP's advantage, Democrats have shown they are willing to go beyond words of outrage and use whatever power they do have to win. Democrats in the Texas Legislature started it off by delaying, for now, Republican efforts to expand the GOP majority in the state's delegation and help preserve party control of the U.S. House through new districts in time for the 2026 midterm elections. Then multiple Democratic governors promised new districts in their own states to neutralize potential Republican gains in Washington. Their counter has been buoyed by national fundraising, media blitzes and public demonstrations, including rallies Saturday around the country. 'For everyone that's been asking, 'Where are the Democrats?' -- well, here they are," said U.S. Rep. Jasmine Crockett of Texas, one of several Democrats who could be ousted under her state's new maps. "For everyone who's been asking, 'Where is the fight?' – well, here it is.' There is no guarantee Democrats can prevent the Republican-powered redistricting, just as Democrats on Capitol Hill have not been able to stop Trump's moves. But it's a notable turn for a party that, by its own leaders' admissions, has honored conventional rules and bypassed bare-knuckled tactics. So far, progressive and establishment Democrats are aligned, uniting what has often been a fragmented opposition since Republicans led by Trump took control of the federal government with their election sweep in November. Leaders on the left say the approach gives them a more effective way to confront him. They can challenge his redistricting ploy with tangible moves as they also push back against the Republicans' tax and spending law and press the case that he is shredding American democracy. 'We've been imploring Democrats where they have power on the state and local level to flex that power,' said Maurice Mitchell, who leads the Working Families Party at the left flank of mainstream U.S. politics. 'There's been this overwrought talk about fighters and largely performative actions to suggest that they're in the fight.' This time, he said, Democrats are 'taking real risks in protecting all of our rights' against 'an authoritarian president who only understands the fight.' Texas made sense for Republicans as the place to start a redistricting scuffle. They dominate the Statehouse, and Gov. Greg Abbott is a Trump loyalist. But when the president's allies announced a new political map intended to send five more Republicans to the U.S. House, state Democratic representatives fled Texas, denying the GOP the numbers to conduct business in the Legislature and approve the reworked districts. Those legislators surfaced in Illinois, New York, California and elsewhere, joined by governors, senators, state party chairs, other states' legislators and activists. All promised action. The response was Trumpian. Govs. Gavin Newsom of California, JB Pritzker of Illinois and Kathy Hochul of New York welcomed Texas Democrats and pledged retaliatory redistricting. Pritzker mocked Abbott as a lackey who says 'yes, sir' to Trump orders. Hochul dismissed Texas Republicans as 'lawbreaking cowboys.' Newsom's press office directed all-caps social media posts at Trump, mimicking his signature sign off: 'THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS MATTER.' U.S. Rep. Al Green, another Texas Democrat who could lose his seat, called Trump 'egomaniacal.' Yet many Democrats also claimed moral high ground, comparing their cause to the Civil Rights Movement. State Rep. Ramon Romero Jr., invoked another Texas Democrat, President Lyndon Johnson, who was 'willing to stand up and fight' for civil rights laws in the 1960s. Then, with Texas bravado, Romero reached further into history: 'We're asking for help, maybe just as they did back in the days of the Alamo.' A recent Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research poll found that about 15% of Democrats' own voters described the party using words like 'weak' or 'apathetic.' An additional 10% called it 'ineffective' or 'disorganized.' Beto O'Rourke, a former Texas congressman who is raising money to support Texas Democrats, has encouraged Democratic-run statehouses to redraw districts now rather than wait for GOP states to act. On Friday, California Democrats released a plan that would give the party an additional five U.S. House seats. It would require voter approval in a November election. 'Maximize Democratic Party advantage,' O'Rourke said at a recent rally. 'You may say to yourself, 'Well, those aren't the rules.' There are no refs in this game. F--- the rules. ... Whatever it takes.' Democratic National Committee Chairman Ken Martin acknowledged the shift. 'This is not the Democratic Party of your grandfather, which would bring a pencil to a knife fight,' he said. Andrew O'Neill, an executive at the progressive group Indivisible, contrasted that response with the record-long speeches by U.S. Sen. Cory Booker, D-N.J. and the Democratic leader of the U.S. House, New York Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, in eviscerating Trump and his package of tax breaks and spending cuts. The left 'had its hair on fire' cheering those moments, O'Neill recalled, but were 'left even more frustrated in the aftermath.' Trump still secured tax cuts for the wealthy, accelerated deportations and cut safety net programs, just as some of his controversial nominees were confirmed over vocal Democratic opposition. 'Now,' O'Neill said, 'there is some marriage of the rhetoric we've been seeing since Trump's inauguration with some actual action.' O'Neill looked back wistfully to the decision by Senate Democrats not to eliminate the filibuster 'when our side had the trifecta,' so a simple majority could pass major legislation. Democratic President Joe Biden's attorney general, Merrick Garland, he said, was too timid in prosecuting Trump and top associates over the Capitol riot. In 2016, Democratic President Barack Obama opted against hardball as the Senate's Republican leader, Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, refused to consider Obama's nomination of Garland to the Supreme Court. 'These unspoken rules of propriety, especially on the Democratic side, have created the conditions' that enabled Trump, Mitchell said. Even on redistricting, Democrats would have to ignore their previous good-government efforts and bypass independent commissions that draw boundaries in several states, including California. Party leaders and activists rationalize that the broader fights tie together piecemeal skirmishes that may not, by themselves, sway voters. Arguing that Trump diminishes democracy stirs people who already support Democrats, O'Neill said. By contrast, he said, the GOP 'power grab,' can be connected to unpopular policies that affect voters' lives. Green noted that Trump's big package bill cleared the Senate 'by one vote' and the House by a few, demonstrating why redistricting matters. U.S. Rep. Greg Casar of Texas said Democrats must make unseemly, short-term power plays so they can later pass legislation that 'bans gerrymandering nationwide ... bans super PACs (political action committees) and gets rid of that kind of big money and special interest that helped get us to this place.' U.S. Rep. Lloyd Doggett, D-Texas, added that a Democratic majority would wield subpoena power over Trump's administration. In the meantime, said U.S. Rep. Julie Johnson, D-Texas, voters are grasping a stark reality. 'They say, 'Well, I don't know. Politics doesn't affect me,'' she said of constituents she meets. 'I say, 'Honey, it does' If you don't do politics, politics will do you.''
San Francisco Chronicle
3 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Oakland protestors cheer California's efforts to counter GOP-led redistricting
Nearly 2,000 miles from the epicenter of a Republican-led movement to redraw congressional maps, hundreds of people gathered Saturday morning at Oakland's Lake Merritt Amphitheater holding signs with such messages as 'HANDS OFF DEMOCRACY' and 'CALIFORNIA BITES BACK.' For about 90 minutes, that standing-room-only crowd listened to a series of speakers that included Alameda County Supervisor Nikki Fortunato Bas, Rep. Lateefah Simon and Oakland Mayor Barbara Lee. Though they each took different approaches, their speeches all focused on the same basic credo: 'Stop President Donald Trump's takeover.' More than 200 events spanning 34 states echoed that theme Saturday. In Texas, Trump is pushing a new congressional map that could net Republicans five additional seats in the 2026 midterm elections. And, experts believe, he doesn't plan to stop there. As part of his bid to maintain Republicans' slim U.S. House majority in the next elections, Trump is reportedly eyeing new maps in such states as Missouri, Florida and Ohio. Few metro areas protested those efforts in larger numbers Saturday than the Bay Area, where a broad coalition of Democratic organizations organized at least 25 such gatherings everywhere from parks to government buildings to freeway overpasses. A rally even sprouted up in a Tesla showroom at Palo Alto's Stanford Shopping Center. 'It's a real small world, and the repercussions are real and imminent,' said Rick Levine, a retired doctor who lives in Oakland and attended Saturday's rally. 'Texas is not that far away. We can't let what's happening there get any closer.' Perhaps none of the other Bay Area protests could match Oakland's star power, which might have been fitting. Just five days earlier, during a rambling press conference about crime, Trump mentioned this East Bay city of roughly 440,000 residents among the places he might deploy National Guard troops. While listing major urban centers that he accused of having egregious crime problems, he said, 'And then you have, of course, Baltimore and Oakland. We don't even mention that anymore there.' The off-hand remark gave Lee, who served in Congress during Trump's first administration and was on the House floor during the Jan. 6 attacks, timely material for Saturday's final address. But instead of dwelling on what she called the latest time 'Trump trashed us,' Lee reminded the crowd — much of which was composed of people over 60 — that she's from Texas. Minority Democrats left that state to stall the Legislature from passing Trump's redistricting plan there. Once a minimum number of legislators are present, Texas' new-look districts could still pass. 'As someone who was born in a border town, in the immigrant community of El Paso, Texas, I remember the days when Black and brown people had no political representation,' Lee said. 'But because of the sacrifices and the demands of the people, El Paso has had Latino mayors and now its first Black mayor. … Donald Trump and his MAGA extremist Republicans know what's going on there, and they're trying to stop it.' 'I know Texas well,' she added. 'This is a coordinated, dangerous effort to take power from the people.' Boos emanated from the crowd, which started at several hundred people and grew to around 1,000. The large turnout reinforced why California recently became the first Democratic-led state to insert itself into the redistricting issue. On Thursday, Gov. Gavin Newsom announced that California will hold a Nov. 4 special election to temporarily let lawmakers — not California's independent redistricting commission — draw new congressional boundaries, which could give Democrats five more House seats. Dozens of signs at Saturday's Oakland rally referenced that strategic counter. In front of protesters, a podium with a microphone sat on the back of the type of farming truck known to carry egg crates. Next to the vehicle, a huge inflatable chicken stood, with hair like Trump's and a red wattle reminiscent of his signature red tie. To keep with the poultry theme, three words were emblazoned across the adjacent sign: 'Stop Being Fowl.' At one point midway through the rally, volunteers from a local nonprofit stood on the truck holding large cardboard eggs, which a community organizer called 'hatchlings of authoritarianism.' Over the next 10 minutes, pictures of four Republicans — Sen. Ted Cruz, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott, Chief Justice John Roberts and Office of Management and Budget Director Russell Vought, a key architect of Project 2025 — 'hatched' from the eggs. Along the way, the organizer detailed how each of them was instrumental in Trump's redistricting efforts Those moments of levity soon gave way to an emotional address from Simon, who discussed seeing National Guard troops in the streets of Washington, D.C., this week and implored Democrats not to succumb to Trump's tactics. 'Republicans aren't playing by the rules,' she said. 'When they go low, we go hella high.' During Simon's speech, Oakland resident Jim Williams stood toward the back of the crowd in a navy blue hat with 'DEMOCRACY' emblazoned across the front. As he watched her raise her voice, hyping up some protesters to the point where they were jumping up and down, Williams suddenly felt optimistic. 'I just love her raw power and energy,' said Williams, 71, who tries to attend every anti-Trump rally in Oakland. 'People like Lateefah, who are kind of in that middle generation, can carry that torch for the party when people like Barbara Lee retire.'
