logo
Priyadarshini Mattoo rape-murder: Consider afresh case for premature release of convict facing life sentence, HC tells Sentence Review Board

Priyadarshini Mattoo rape-murder: Consider afresh case for premature release of convict facing life sentence, HC tells Sentence Review Board

Indian Express02-07-2025
The Delhi High Court on Tuesday directed the Sentence Review Board (SRB) to consider afresh the case for premature release of Santosh Kumar Singh, who is facing a life sentence for the 1996 rape and murder of 25-year old law student Priyadarshini Mattoo.
Holding the SRB's decision to deny Singh, along with two other prisoners, premature release as suffering from 'material procedural and legal infirmities', the court highlighted several lacunae in the current process undertaken by the board while deciding applications for early release of prisoners.
Justice Sanjeev Narula directed the SRB to convene its next meeting within three months from Tuesday, when the cases of the three petitioners shall be placed for reconsideration 'based on a fresh evaluation of all material and reports,' and a fresh decision shall be rendered within four months.
To ensure adequate deliberation and proper application of mind in each case, the HC directed that the SRB shall take up only as many cases as can be reasonably decided in one meeting, keeping in mind the principles of natural justice reiterated in the present judgment.
Justice Narula also issued a slew of recommendations to better align SRB's processes and ensure informed decision-making for considering the early release of convicts.
Justice Narula recommended that the GNCTD (Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi) and the Department of Prisons 'take expeditious steps to institutionalise the involvement of mental health professionals in the premature release process'. He added that 'a system for psychological assessment of eligible convicts carried out by qualified clinical psychologists or psychiatrists, should be introduced, either by amending the existing framework under the DPR (Delhi Prison Rules) or by issuing appropriate administrative guidelines'.
The order further outlined, '…in appropriate cases, the SRB may also consider calling for independent psychological evaluations, especially where the decision hinges on the convict's likelihood to reoffend. A mere reliance on jail conduct or anecdotal impressions from prison staff does not adequately capture the psychological dimensions of reform and risk.'
It also recommended GNCTD to 'evolve a structured protocol for incorporating victim perspectives in the premature release process', noting that 'a clear procedure should be established to locate, contact, and document the views of victims or their families in a sensitive and time bound manner, ensuring their voices are heard without causing re traumatisation'.
The order suggested the SRB maintain a written record of whether victims' input was received or solicited, and how such input was weighed in the final decision. 'This would enhance transparency, fortify public confidence in the process, and promote a restorative understanding of justice that respects both the rights of convicts and the dignity of victims,' it added.
In four petitions, Singh, along with three other prisoners, had questioned the functioning of the SRB, while seeking directions for their early release.
Singh has already served around 29 years and 11 months in jail with remission and 22 years without remission. Eligible for open jail, he is currently permitted to exit the prison complex daily from 8 am to 8 pm to work as a legal consultant with a real estate company.
Singh, in a 2023 petition, had sought quashing of the recommendation of the SRB rejecting his premature release in a October 21, 2021 meeting. Thereafter, his case was considered in 2024 and again rejected.
Mattoo was raped and murdered in January 1996. Singh, a law student of Delhi University, was acquitted by the trial court in the case on December 3, 1999, but the HC had on October 27, 2006 reversed the decision, holding him guilty of rape and murder and awarded him death penalty. Singh challenged his conviction and death sentence awarded by the HC. In October 2010, the Supreme Court upheld Singh's conviction but commuted the death sentence to life imprisonment.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

NALSA launches Veer Parivaar Sahayata Yojana to aid defence personnel
NALSA launches Veer Parivaar Sahayata Yojana to aid defence personnel

Business Standard

time25 minutes ago

  • Business Standard

NALSA launches Veer Parivaar Sahayata Yojana to aid defence personnel

The National Legal Services Authority (NALSA) on Saturday launched the Veer Parivaar Sahayata Yojana 2025 here to strengthen legal aid for defence personnel. The yojana was launched in collaboration with the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh and the Jammu & Kashmir Legal Services Authority during the North Zone Regional Conference on "Reaffirming the Constitutional Vision of Justice for Defence Personnel and Tribals" at SKICC here. Presiding over the event, Supreme Court Judge and Executive Chairman of NALSA, Justice Surya Kant, said the gathering in Kashmir was not just about technical discussions, but also about national integration and honouring the selfless service of the armed forces. Justice Kant said Veer Parivaar Sahayata Yojana 2025 marks a historic step in NALSA's 30-year journey of delivering justice to the marginalised. "Members of our armed forces and their families face legal hurdles like any other citizen whether land disputes, service entitlements, or matrimonial issues but their unique service conditions make access to justice more difficult. This scheme is our solemn pledge to stand beside those who protect our borders, ensuring that their rights are not left unprotected," he said. He outlined the three pillars of the yojana a dedicated network of legal services clinics at Zilla, Rajya, and Kendriya Sainik Boards; trained nodal officers, legal aid counsels and PLVs (including ex-servicemen) to assist families in a compassionate and timely manner; and digital access and online redressal mechanisms such as e-Lok Adalats and online mediation to ensure speed and convenience. Justice Kant said the Constitution, through Article 39A, mandates equal access to justice for all, and "if we fail to extend this support to our jawans and their families, we fail in our constitutional duty". "This yojana is our way of saying that just as they safeguard our freedom, we safeguard their dignity and rights," he said. Union Minister of State (Independent Charge) for Law and Justice Arjun Ram Meghwal commended NALSA's initiative, stating that the scheme resonates with the government's commitment to inclusive justice, digital empowerment, and fast-tracking cases involving defence personnel. Chief Justice of the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh, Justice Arun Palli, praised the scheme and emphasised the need for judiciary-led technological interventions to prioritise and fast-track such cases, ensuring that the limited leave time of defence personnel is not spent in prolonged legal processes. The launch of Veer Parivaar Sahayata Yojana 2025 marks a milestone in bridging the gap between legal services and the nation's defenders, echoing NALSA's motto of "Access to Justice for All.

'Unparalleled courage, valor displayed by...': PM Modi, Prez Murmu lead nation in paying tributes to Kargil bravehearts
'Unparalleled courage, valor displayed by...': PM Modi, Prez Murmu lead nation in paying tributes to Kargil bravehearts

India.com

time25 minutes ago

  • India.com

'Unparalleled courage, valor displayed by...': PM Modi, Prez Murmu lead nation in paying tributes to Kargil bravehearts

File/Archival Kargil Vijay Diwas: President Droupadi Murmu and Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday led the nation in paying tributes to military personnel who fought valiantly in harsh conditions to hand Pakistan a crushing defeat in the 1999 Kargil conflict. On July 26 that year, the Indian Army announced the successful culmination of 'Operation Vijay', declaring victory after a nearly three-month-long battle on the icy heights of Kargil in Ladakh. India observes the day as 'Kargil Vijay Diwas' every year. Over 500 soldiers made supreme sacrifice in the conflict. In her message, President Murmu, who is also the Supreme Commander of the military, said: 'This day symbolises the extraordinary valor, courage, and steadfast determination of our jawans.' Modi said Kargil Vijay Diwas reminds the country of unparalleled courage and valour of its soldiers who sacrificed their lives in defending the country's pride. Various events were organised across the country, including at the Kargil War Memorial in Drass, to mark the occasion. In the event at Drass, Army Chief Gen Upendra Dwivedi, highlighting the Army's 'unique victory' on the Kargil peaks 26 years ago, said the military achieved a 'decisive victory' during Operation Sindoor as well continuing that tradition. 'It was the time when India made it clear that no evil intention will be allowed inside its borders, no harm will be allowed to the unity and integrity of India,' he said, referring to victory in Kargil. 'Continuing this tradition, during Operation Sindoor too, Indian military with the same indomitable courage and firm resolve targeted Pakistan backed terrorist infrastructure and thwarted other aggressive actions of Pakistan with effective pretense and achieved a decisive victory,' he said. 'Operation Sindoor is our resolve, message and answer,' he said. The Army Chief further added: 'With the unwavering trust of the countrymen and the political freedom granted by the government, the Indian armed forces gave a determined, precise and decisive response.' In his message, Chief of Defence Staff Gen Anil Chauhan said the Kargil conflict remains a stark reminder of Pakistan's 'treachery' and that India's adversaries will continue to test its resolve. But the nation will always come out victorious over the enemy's 'deceit and aggression' as was evident in Operation Sindoor, he added. Defence Minister Rajnath Singh also paid glowing tributes to the military personnel who made supreme sacrifices in the conflict. 'On Kargil Vijay Diwas, I pay heartfelt tributes to our bravehearts who displayed extraordinary courage, grit and determination in defending our nation's honour in the toughest of terrains,' Singh said. 'Their supreme sacrifice during Kargil war is a timeless reminder of the unwavering resolve of our Armed Forces. India shall remain forever indebted to their service,' he said in a social media post. Singh and the top military brass also paid tributes to the fallen heroes at the National War Memorial. In his remarks, Chief of Defence Staff Gen Chauhan said Kargil Vijay Diwas is not only about remembering the past but also about drawing inspirations for the future. 'Our adversaries will continue to test our resolve, but the legacy of Kargil reminds us that our jointness, preparedness and unwavering courage — proven once again by the success of Operation Sindoor — will always triumph over the enemy's deceit and aggression,' he said. Gen Chauhan said Kargil Vijay Diwas reminds every Indian of the unparalleled bravery and patriotism of the valiant soldiers who fought fearlessly to safeguard India's territorial integrity as also, the 'bitter truth of Pakistan's betrayal'. 'Pakistan Army's ploy to extend the conflict beyond the Great Himalayan Range by sending regular troops disguised as Mujahideens, remains a stark reminder of their treachery,' he said. Chief of the Naval Staff Admiral Dinesh K Tripathi said the legacy of the Kargil 'bravehearts' stands as a testament to the unwavering devotion to the service of the nation. 'Your sacrifice will remain a beacon of inspiration, not only for future citizens of our country but also for those who choose to serve in the defence forces with 'Duty-Honour-Courage!',' he added. Chief of the Air Staff Air Chief Marshal A P Singh the Indian Air Force remains committed to defend the sovereignty of the nation and uphold the proud traditions of courage, honour and duty as exemplified by the bravehearts. (Only the headline has been reworked by staff. Copy comes from an agency feed)

‘Maldives' tourism set to increase with PM Modi's visit': Maldivian President Mohamed Muizzu
‘Maldives' tourism set to increase with PM Modi's visit': Maldivian President Mohamed Muizzu

Hindustan Times

timean hour ago

  • Hindustan Times

‘Maldives' tourism set to increase with PM Modi's visit': Maldivian President Mohamed Muizzu

The tourism in Maldives is set to grow with Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit, Maldivian President Mohamed Muizzu said on Saturday, adding that India is one of the major countries that helps tourism in the island nation. PM Modi attended the 60th Independence Day celebrations of Maldives at the Republic Square in Male as the Guest of Honour.(DPR PMO) Muizzu also said that he is hopeful about a free trade agreement with India, adding that he is 'very hopeful' about the talks. "India is one of the major countries that helps the Maldives' tourism, with the Prime Minister's visit, it is going to increase, and our people-to-people connection will also be enhanced," the Maldivian President said as Prime Minister Narendra Modi concluded his two-day visit to Maldives. '...I am very hopeful. We have started it (FTA talks) and we will conclude it very soon...' he added. He also said that India would be a 'crucial partner' for the country in the future. 'We all have seen how India has helped the Maldives in the past, and nobody will doubt how India will be a very crucial partner going forward,' Muizzu said. The Maldivian President further hailed India as 'one of the major countries' in terms of its contribution to Maldives' tourism. Muizzu said that the tourism would increase following PM Modi's visit. '…Our people-to-people connection will also be enhanced,' he added. When asked if he plans to visit India soon, Muizzu said he hopes to do so. 'I don't know whether this year or maybe in the near future,' he said. This came even as PM Modi attended the 60th Independence Day celebrations of Maldives at the Republic Square in Male as the Guest of Honour. Modi took to X to say he was 'deeply honoured' to have attended the celebrations, adding that the bilateral relations between the nations would strengthen after 'productive talks' with Muizzu. Modi's visit to Maldives marked a reset in the ties between India and Maldives, after relations deteriorated following Mohamed Muizzu's election pinned on the 'India Out' campaign. However, diplomatic relations between the two nations came back on track after Muizzu's visit to India in October. Modi's visit to Maldives marks the first by any foreign leader after Muizzu's election. During Modi's visit, Muizzu referred to India as 'Maldives's closest and most trusted partner'. Apart from signing multiples MoUs, both countries also launched talks on the free trade agreement (FTA) negotiations. India also extended Line of Credit (LoC) of ₹4,850 crores to Maldives, and a stamp commemorating the 60th anniversary of establishment of India-Maldives diplomatic relations was issued.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store