Suge Knight Reveals Bombshell New Claims About Tupac's 1996 Death — Including Alleged Connections of Rapper's Mother and Diddy (Exclusive)
Duane 'Keefe D' Davis has been charged with Shakur's murder and pleaded not guilty
Court filings include past police interviews in which Davis claimed Sean "Diddy" Combs was involved in ordering the hit on Shakur and rap mogul Suge Knight. Combs has long denied any involvement in the shooting and Las Vegas police say he "has never been considered a suspect"Nearly three decades ago, around 11 p.m. on September 7, 1996, Marion 'Suge' Knight — then the 31-year-old CEO of Death Row Records and one of the most feared kingpins in the music business — drove a black BMW 750 sedan east through Las Vegas, a block off the strip.
In the passenger seat sat rapper Tupac Shakur aka 2Pac, just 25, whose cultural footprint had already eclipsed his multi-platinum catalog. Dressed in a Versace shirt and gleaming gold chain, Shakur was still out on bond, still basking in the glow of stardom, brushing off a violent altercation with a Crip gang member inside a Sin City casino that had transpired just hours earlier after a Mike Tyson boxing match.
Trailing behind Knight and Shakur was the Death Row convoy of about ten cars that snaked through traffic like shadows. Then, at the corner of Flamingo and Koval, beneath the buzz of the Strip's neon haze, a white, late-model Cadillac pulled up alongside.
According to Las Vegas prosecutors' July 2024 filings, South Side Compton Crips member Orlando 'Baby Lane' Anderson didn't have the correct angle to shoot. This came after a separate court filing in December described him as the alleged shooter.
Anderson allegedly handed the semiautomatic .40 Glock to fellow gang member Deandre 'Big Dre' Smith, who opened fire from the backseat of the vehicle — 13 shots in total. Four bullets struck Shakur in the chest, arm and thigh. Knight was grazed in the head by shrapnel but survived. Shakur, who had worn a bulletproof vest regularly, was not wearing one that night.
Related: Tupac Shakur Murder Suspect Once Claimed Diddy Was Involved in Ordering Hit on Rapper and Suge Knight
Inside the BMW, Tupac's unreleased 1997 track 'Never Had a Friend Like Me' was playing, Knight recalls. Speaking from California's Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility, where he is serving 28 years for a fatal hit-and-run, Knight, now, 60, reflected on the moment that altered everything as the only living witness to the deadly shooting.
'Tupac is my favorite person in the world. It was a part of me that changed my life forever,' he says, voice quivering. 'He didn't have to die. A part of me died when he died.'
Related: Suge Knight Says Diddy Belongs in Prison for Assaulting Cassie: 'Never Disrespect a Woman Like That' (Exclusive)
For nearly 30 years, no one was held accountable for Shakur's murder. The shooting occurred on one of the most surveilled intersections in America, amid surging tensions between rival gang-affiliated record labels. Many have pointed to a deeper reason the case went cold: an unwillingness to cross lines of influence, power and fear that ran far beyond music.
But in September 2023, the tides finally turned. Duane 'Keefe D' Davis — a former Crips leader and the last known living suspect from the infamous white Cadillac that night — was arrested and charged with orchestrating the hit. Prosecutors allege Davis played point man in the murder that's haunted hip-hop for decades.
Months later, in a bombshell court filing dated July 18, 2024, the Clark County District Attorney's office revealed a long-buried 2009 police interview in which Davis, speaking as a former confidential informant for two years, not only allegedly detailed his own role in the killing — but repeatedly pointed the finger at music mogul Sean 'Diddy' Combs, then known as Puffy, as the man who allegedly ordered Tupac Shakur's assassination.
Related: Tupac Shakur Murder Suspect Once Claimed Diddy Was Involved in Ordering Hit on Rapper and Suge Knight
Davis accused Combs of being enraged by Tupac's relentless taunts.
The DEA and U.S. Department of Justice also released a report about a 2008 interview in which Davis claimed Combs said he "needed to get rid of Knight and Shakur" and offered Davis $1 million to "handle the problem."
Knight, still grappling with it all, doesn't mince words: 'I end up with a bullet an inch into my skull, but at the same time, everybody knows where a million dollars came from,' he says, pausing momentarily. "Like what would Pac want? What he really want is truth. I believe that if something smells like sh--, look like sh--, it's sh--.'
Combs has long vehemently denied any role in the shooting, and a public information officer for the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department told PEOPLE on July 24, 2024. "Sean Combs has never been considered a suspect in the Tupac Shakur homicide investigation." He has never been charged in connection to the murder. Combs is currently facing serious unrelated federal charges, including sex trafficking, racketeering and transportation to engage in prostitution. His fate will be decided by twelve jurors in the coming weeks in the Southern District of New York.
Related: Sean 'Diddy' Combs Is Not Testifying at His Sex-Trafficking Trial (Exclusive)
Davis, who pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder, remains in custody awaiting trial, which is now delayed until February 9, 2026. His defense claims new witness testimony could place him outside of Vegas and 300 miles away in Los Angeles during the time of the incident. But prosecutors continue to cite his own confessions, most notably his 2019 memoir Compton Street Legend.
Back in '96 in Vegas, after shots were fired, Knight — bleeding from his scalp — made a frantic U-turn and headed west at a high speed toward Las Vegas Boulevard. Meanwhile, two patrol officers on an unrelated call nearby had heard the gunfire and called for backup. They chased down the BMW, which had two blown tires. Once stopped, officers called for medical assistance.
'I got out and tried to tell the officers what happened while I was bleeding everywhere,' says Knight. 'Also, I then was getting Tupac out the car, even when the door was open. I had to go over there bleeding everywhere, take the seat belt off him. When we get into the ambulance, Pac is funny as f---. He cracking jokes. I'm cracking jokes. Pac's like, 'Sh--, when we heal up, you know what we doing.' That type of sh--.' The ambulance transported them to the University Medical Center of Southern Nevada.
At the hospital, Knight was treated for minor injuries and released while Shakur was listed in critical condition. 'When I came to see him, Pac was sitting up talking. He [allegedly] said, 'Well, look. One, bring me a blunt. Matter of fact, bring me two blunts.' And I said, 'You going to smoke in the hospital?' He [allegedly] said, 'Yeah, I am.''
Knight chuckles softly recalling that moment — Tupac joking, allegedly requesting Hennessy too. Knight says Shakur grabbed him closer, as Knight kissed him on his forehead, and the two said, "I love you" to each other. But that joy cracked under the weight of what came next.
Before the second of two emergency surgeries, including one to remove Shakur's right lung to stop internal bleeding, he made a chilling request. As he lay in his hospital bed, fading in and out of consciousness, Knight claims Shakur allegedly turned to him, desperately begging to be killed. He spoke with eerie clarity, suggesting they could even capture it on camera, that he'd record a will or even lay down a song explaining everything. It wouldn't matter, Shakur said. The world would still make Knight pay the ultimate price for it.
Knight recalls them both laughing, but beneath the nervous laughter was a hard truth: Shakur believed he was going to be sent back to prison once the chaos subsided, a payback for the brutal casino beatdown caught on security footage hours before the brutal shooting.
Prison, to Tupac, wasn't just a fear — it was a fate he believed was worse than death. "I'll die before I go back," he allegedly told those around him. Still, suicide was off the table. According to Knight, he believed taking his own life would bar him from heaven, a line he wouldn't cross. So instead, he turned to his crew — and then to Knight. "Kill me. Shoot me," he urged. Knight says he refused. 'No, Pac. We can't do it.'
In the haze of hospital lights, beeping monitors and heartbreak, Knight claims Shakur made a final, desperate request to his mother, Afeni: let him go.
According to Knight, who was by the rapper's side as he lay wracked with pain and failing fast, Shakur pleaded with his mother to help him end his life. Knight claims she allegedly gave him pills in an attempt to honor his wishes.
'The doctors came in and brought him back,' Knight recalls. 'And his mom [allegedly] said, 'Don't ever do that again. If he's having complications, don't touch him. Don't bring him back. Let him go.'' It was a mother's raw act of mercy, Knight says — a final promise to her son to respect his suffering.
Doctors, trying to relieve pressure on his battered body, reportedly placed Shakur in a medically-induced coma and hooked him to a respirator, according to Knight. But the damage was irreversible. On September 13, at 4:03 p.m., Shakur was pronounced dead.
What followed, Knight claims, was as surreal and raw as Tupac himself. Immediately after his death, Knight says Afeni, who died at age 60 in May 2016, turned to him and insisted her son be cremated, right then and there. 'She came up to me and said, 'Get it done. Now,'' Knight remembers.
'I told her, 'Look, I don't know if I can do that.'' He said he hesitated not out of defiance, but because Shakur, just weeks earlier, had allegedly laid out a different vision for his send-off. They had talked about it in the studio. 'He told me, 'When I go, I want every rapper at my funeral to grab the mic. I want them to kiss me head to toe. Just like in 'Life Goes On.'' Knight pauses. 'He didn't want to be cremated.'
Related: Tupac Shakur's Mother Afeni Shakur Davis Dies at 69: Police
But Afeni wouldn't hear it. 'She gave me one of those mama looks, like, 'Shut your a-- up and do what I said.' Then she started cussing me out. 'Get this sh-- done!'' Knight says. He did what she asked. 'I paid someone a million dollars cash to take care of it.'
Later that night, a circle of Shakur's closest friends gathered to honor him the way they believed he would've wanted. The bag containing Tupac's cremated ashes was passed around. Some, allegedly, were rolled into a blunt and smoked.
'I was so happy to say I was on probation — I couldn't smoke,' Knight says. 'I told his mother, 'Moms, I'd love to, but if I hit that, I'll get in trouble.'' He laughs. 'I was probably the only one who didn't hit him.'
Shakur came into the world already bearing the weight of revolution. His lyrics dripped with pain, purpose and paranoia — songs about "thug life," desperation and street justice that read like dispatches from the front lines of America's forgotten neighborhoods. But for all his fire and charisma, Shakur was, at his core, a troubled and sensitive soul. He spent his early years ricocheting through one inner-city zip code after another, chasing stability that never came.
By the time the spotlight found him, Tupac had already become a walking contradiction: platinum-selling poet, convicted felon, street prophet, media pariah. Shakur's fourth album, All Eyez on Me, was climbing the charts again and had sold nearly 3 million copies, while his previous release, 1995's Me Against the World, sold 2 million copies.
He appeared in three movies: Juice (1992), Poetic Justice (1993) and Above the Rim (1994) and just wrapped two 1997 films—Gridlock'd and Gang Related, in which he played a detective. Since '91, he'd been arrested eight times. He served eight months in prison for a sexual abuse conviction in 1994 and was named in two wrongful-death lawsuits — one involving a 6-year-old boy caught in the crossfire between Shakur's crew and rivals in Northern California in Marin City in 1992. It was settled for an undisclosed amount in November 1995.
Still, nothing could match the chaos that followed his death.
Rumors ignited within hours: who pulled the trigger, who ordered the hit, who knew more than they were saying. In a 179-page court filing submitted in 2024, prosecutors finally unpacked years of whispers and street talk in granular detail, laying out an explosive account of what allegedly happened before, during and after that fateful night in Las Vegas.
The evening had started with spectacle: Mike Tyson knocked out Bruce Seldon at a boxing title match at the MGM Grand, where Knight and his Mob Piru Blood affiliates were in attendance. After the fight, the entourage ran into Orlando Anderson, an alleged South Side Crip connected to Bad Boy Records, then headed by Sean "Diddy" Combs. It wasn't a random encounter. The crew recognized Anderson from a previous scuffle where he allegedly tried to steal a Death Row necklace off Trevon "Tre" Lane.
According to a 2009 police interview with Davis, the response was immediate and violent. Shakur, Knight, and Lane swarmed Anderson, throwing fists and kicks, dislocating his shoulder in the process. Security broke it up. By 8:55 p.m., the Death Row crew had left the building. But police haven't determined if Anderson or Smith allegedly pulled the trigger.
The orders, prosecutors allege, came from Davis himself.
According to grand jury testimony cited in the filing, Davis allegedly said he 'commanded' his soldiers (Anderson, Smith and driver Terry Brown) to 'confront Knight and Shakur and hunt them down.' Davis, who was riding in the passenger seat at the time of the shooting allegedly said he gave his gang members the 'ultimate green light to do something to their a----.'
Davis added, according to the filing: 'Tupac chose the wrong game to play and the wrong n----s to play with."
In the 2009 police interview, Davis said he obtained the firearm from drug trafficking associate Eric 'Zip' Martin.
Homicide detective Dan Long asked Davis, 'Um, Puffy Combs. Does he play a role in this thing?'
'Yeah, I think he did,' Davis responded. 'That's what we think. That's word on the street.'
He claimed that Diddy was terrified of Knight, and once, in front of a crowd of about 45 men, Combs allegedly said, "Man, ah, I would give anything for that dude['s] head," referring to Knight. According to Davis, 'He was real scared of the guy,' he continued. 'He said that s— in front of everybody.'
'Was [Combs] implying that he would pay to have it done?' Davis' attorney asked.
'Yeah, yeah,' Davis responded. 'He said it.'
This wasn't the first time Combs and Knight had been at odds. At the 1995 Source Awards in New York City, Knight took a direct shot from the stage to diss Diddy without calling him out by name: 'Any artist out there that want to be an artist and stay a star, and don't have to worry about the executive producer trying to be all in the videos, all on the record, dancing… come to Death Row!' he said. Knight mocked Diddy for inserting his ad-libs on Bad Boy artists' songs and shimmying throughout their videos.
'It was real embarrassing the way he did it,' Davis said in his recorded statement to police. '[Diddy] was real scared of [Knight]. He didn't even want to come out here [to California]. Davis admitted Knight probably would have tried to kill Diddy if he'd had the chance.
'Did Puffy have any problems with Tupac?' Detective Long pressed Davis in 2009.
'[Tupac] told [Diddy] he's a f----- and all that s---." Davis replied, claiming Combs had said, 'Yeah, f--- that dude.'"
By then, the war between Bad Boy and Death Row was boiling over. After Tupac was ambushed and shot five times in the lobby of Quad Studios in Times Square 1994, he blamed Combs and the Bad Boy crew for setting him up, which Combs has always denied. But a year later, Combs released Biggie's single 'Who Shot Ya?' which was widely viewed as taking aim at Shakur, who responded with the vicious 'Hit 'Em Up,' pushing their rivalry to the brink.
In the aftermath of Shakur's murder, new claims emerged. According to a grand jury exhibit cited in the prosecutors' filing in 2024, Davis alleged that Combs asked Davis after Shakur's murder, 'Is that us?' The filing states: 'Sean Combs reached out to defendant [Davis] wondering if South Side Crips were responsible for Shakur's death. Defendant, beaming with pride, answers, 'Yes.''
After the shooting, Davis claimed Combs owed him and his crew money.
'I knew we was like, 'Damn, we can get paid now,'' Davis said to police in 2009. A few months later, Davis said he met "Zip" Martin at a hot wings restaurant in Los Angeles. Although Davis claimed he had plenty of money back then, he wanted his nephew Anderson and his crew to get paid. Davis claimed Martin told him that he would check with Combs and have the money sent to them, but Martin never followed through.
'I wish I never met Puff Daddy, period, I swear to God,' Davis told police in 2009. 'He messed up my life, man. I was rich, up under the radar, all that, man. It's all gone.'
Related: Tupac Shakur Murder Suspect Once Claimed Diddy Was Involved in Ordering Hit on Rapper and Suge Knight
Years later, Knight finally got the confrontation he'd imagined. In June 2007, he says the moment he'd long anticipated finally arrived: an alleged face-to-face with Combs. But this wasn't some back-alley confrontation in Compton or backstage standoff, it happened at the Roosevelt Hotel in Hollywood, with Prince allegedly playing puppet master.
'I'm sitting there, eating,' Knight recalls, leaning into the memory like a punchline. 'And everybody's always thinking the gangster's the guy in the room looking all hard and tough. But let me tell you, the gangster was Prince.'
According to Knight, the icon himself sent someone mid-show to summon him. 'They come over and say, 'Man, Prince is performing right now, and he wants you to come watch the show.' Who gonna say no to Prince? Sh--' Knight says, laughing. 'You already know.'
Escorted through the venue, Knight was led to a special table Prince had set aside, which was prime real estate in a packed house. 'Prince comes up playing the guitar, I never seen Prince smile so much in my life,' Knight remembers. 'Laughing, happy. And I tell him, 'We both had two of the best rappers in hip-hop.''
Then, Knight saw the seating arrangement. 'He set me down at this table where Puffy was there. Nas was there, other people. Prince knew what he was doing. Must've been pissed at Puffy. I think he [allegedly] planted me at that table on purpose.'
Knight claims the tension cracked soon after. 'I got under Puff's skin,' he says, claiming he whispered some things in his ear, it probably hit a nerve. 'I told him, 'Let's go to the restroom together and get it out of the way.' You know, settle it.'
But Combs, Knight claims, wasn't interested in squaring up.
'He stood up, heated. That's when I realized he wasn't ready for it — 'cause not only did they rush him out, they [allegedly] threw coats and shit over his head so you couldn't see his face and had jackets to hide him.'
For Knight, the moment was peak Hollywood meets hip-hop war story, velvet rope diplomacy brokered by the most unlikely shot-caller in purple.
"This story is beyond ridiculous and completely false," Combs told AllHipHop.com in 2008 about a retracted Los Angeles Times story that claimed he had knowledge of Shakur's death. "Neither Biggie [Smalls, the late rapper] nor I had any knowledge of any attack before, during or after it happened. It is a complete lie to suggest that there was any involvement by Biggie or myself." Combs' legal team could not be reached for comment.
'I just want to take a deep breath and heal,' Knight says quietly, reflecting on the night that changed everything. Then, without hesitation, he adds: '[I believe] Diddy does deserve jail for it.'
Knight also told PEOPLE in June he believes Combs deserves to be behind bars for assaulting Cassie Ventura in a Los Angeles hotel on March 5, 2016.
Related: Suge Knight Says Diddy Belongs in Prison for Assaulting Cassie: 'Never Disrespect a Woman Like That' (Exclusive)
For Knight, everything — his empire, his purpose, his identity — shifted after Tupac's death. He says it altered his life. It wasn't just the end of a great friendship; it was the death of an era. 'There is nothing better than Pac. There is no one greater than him, better than him,' Knight says, his voice thick with finality. The loss ran so deep, it pushed him out of the very world he helped define.
'After Tupac's passing, I exited the music business. 'Cause there was just... no way. I didn't wanna be in the studio with another artist. I didn't wanna go on tour with another artist. I didn't wanna. I lost trust in so many people. I lost trust in hip-hop.'
Related: Tupac Shakur's Death: Details of the Rapper's 1996 Murder and Ongoing Investigation
Even now, while incarcerated, he can't bring himself to play Tupac's music. The memories, once electric, are too heavy. 'Every time I heard a Tupac song, I didn't play it. Because it brought back so much... great things. But it made me wanna do bad things.'
What still haunts him most is the look in Tupac's eyes that night in Vegas: the trust, the bond, the unspoken vow between them. 'When those bullets was going in the car, I knew I saved his life — for a little while. He trusted me. I knew he really loved me, and I loved him,' Knight says. 'I grabbed him, pulled him down. It was like slow motion. When something hits you in the head, your thoughts slow down. You just know, you're pretty much dead. And when Pac died, I saw the whole sky turn a reddish orange.'
Knight didn't feel the pain. Not then. All he felt was responsibility. 'That was my watch. I got him out of prison. It was on me to make sure he became the artist everybody knew he already was… the best.'
And even now, all these years later, Suge Knight is still trying to make peace with the weight of that promise.
Read the original article on People
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
19 minutes ago
- CBS News
Human remains found at California fireworks warehouse explosion site, officials say
Authorities say human remains have been found after the Tuesday explosion and fire at a fireworks warehouse in the Northern California community of Esparto. On Friday, Yolo County officials announced that human remains were located after coroner's division personnel were allowed to access the site for their investigation. No positive identifications of the remains have been made at this time, officials said. Officials have said seven people were "unaccounted for" after the July 1 incident at Devastating Pyrotechnics. The Yolo County Sheriff's Office confirmed the building was a fireworks warehouse in the area of county roads 23 and 86A. Several structures on the property caught fire after the explosions, with the flames spreading into multiple grass fires with a combined burn area of approximately 80 acres, the Esparto Fire Protection District said. The initial explosion happened around 5:50 p.m. on Tuesday. Here's a look at the facility before and after the explosions. On Thursday, CBS Sacramento confirmed through public records that a Yolo County sheriff's lieutenant was listed as an owner of the property. An Esparto volunteer firefighter was also tied to a fireworks business license with the same address as the facility, records show. CBS Sacramento reached out to both for comment but has not received a response. As of Thursday evening, investigators were finally able to enter the property, but information remained limited. Officials also said they were using drones to understand the scene and improve coordination across teams due to the presence of explosive materials. Crews are also working to cool any remaining hotspots. Esparto Fire Chief Curtis Lawrence said two people were injured and received medical care. He said no firefighters have been injured. Yolo County officials issued mandatory evacuations for a one-mile stretch on the south side of the facility that remained in effect Thursday. Law enforcement officials said streets around the evacuation zone and leading into the facility were shut down. Cal Fire will be taking the lead in the investigation. Yolo County said Wednesday that the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) was called in to assist with the investigation. Who are the seven people unaccounted for? CBS Sacramento has spoken to people who said they had loved ones believed to have been inside the facility at the time of the incident, but they have not been able to contact them. Cal Fire said late Wednesday morning that seven people were not accounted for and that first responders are working to determine their whereabouts. Syanna Ruiz, 18, said her boyfriend and his two brothers are missing. She said that her boyfriend, Jesus Ramos, 18, had his first day on the job at the facility on the day of the explosions. She identified Jesus' brothers as Johnny Ramos, 22, and Junior Melendez, 28. "We last spoke to them around 2 or 3 when they were supposed to be leaving, and then we found out about it through a report or something on Instagram and we came instantly," Ruiz said Wednesday. "Praying to God that they're alive and maybe they just need medical attention." A fourth individual was identified by family members to CBS Sacramento as Carlos Rodriguez. The remaining three people were not yet identified. Officials have not confirmed the identities of the seven people unaccounted for. What we know about Devastating Pyrotechnics . Devastating Pyrotechnics has an active fireworks license through the state as an importer and exporter, according to state records. It also has an active license through the state for public displays. The Esparto warehouse was cited as a storage facility for commercial fireworks. However, Stephanie Cormier, the director of the Yolo County Planning Commission, confirmed to CBS Sacramento late Thursday afternoon that Devastating Pyrotechnics has no local licenses to store fireworks on the property or a business license. Cormier said it is an agricultural property that is limited to agricultural use at the local level. Fire officials said they have been to the Esparto warehouse for safety checks in the past, but did not provide information on whether there were any safety concerns or when the last time the business was checked. Devastating Pyrotechnics released the following statement on Wednesday on its website: "Our hearts and thoughts are with those we lost, their families, and everyone impacted in our community. We are grateful for the swift response of law enforcement and emergency personnel. Our focus will remain on those directly impacted by this tragedy, and we will cooperate fully with the proper authorities in their investigation." Aside from the two injuries reported by law enforcement, there have been no confirmed deaths. A previous version of the website stated the business has another location in San Francisco and has been serving Northern California for 30 years. The website now only shows the statement released by the business. The statement also refers all further inquiries to a lawyer. CBS Sacramento reached out to the lawyer for further comment but received the same statement that was posted to the website. Where are Esparto and Yolo County located in California? Yolo County borders the west side of Sacramento County. Esparto is a small, rural town located about 14 miles west of the city of Woodland in Yolo County and about 35 miles northwest of the city of Sacramento. Some residents of the area told CBS Sacramento that windows to their homes were rattled by at least two separate explosions. Some described their house shaking like during an earthquake, with explosions going off seemingly every five minutes. Nearly 2,200 Pacific Gas and Electric customers in the area were left without power due to the incident. PG&E said only 33 customers remained without power as of Thursday evening. Smoke plume from the explosion and fire CBS News San Francisco CBS Sacramento's First Alert Weather Team confirmed the smoke plume from the initial explosion reached between 10,000 and 15,000 feet in elevation.
Yahoo
35 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Patel and Ratcliffe try to bolster claims that FBI and CIA conspired against Trump
The release of formerly classified FBI and CIA documents this week illustrates how President Donald Trump's appointees at both agencies are trying to use the levers of government to prop up his long-standing assertions that intelligence agencies conspired against him. The FBI released emails on Tuesday that purport to show an effort by the bureau's leaders in 2020 to cover up a source's claim that there was a Chinese plot to throw the presidential election to Joe Biden. In a statement to the Daily Mail, Trump's FBI director, Kash Patel, said the emails reveal that bureau leaders 'chose to play politics and withhold key information from the American people.' And CIA Director John Ratcliffe released an internal agency analysis related to the 2020 election that he argued showed that Democratic appointees 'manipulated intelligence and silenced career professionals — all to get Trump.' Patel's and Ratcliffe's claims went beyond the information contained in the released documents. The documents do not describe definitive evidence that any official acted out of political motive or engaged in anything beyond the good-faith debate that is typical of the intelligence verification and analysis process. The emails do show that at least one FBI official raised the concern that the report conflicted with congressional testimony at the time by Director Christopher Wray, who said the FBI was not aware of any Chinese attempt to interfere in the presidential election. A former FBI official told NBC News that Wray does not recall being made aware of the report. A former senior FBI official said he was not aware of the report either. The former official, who requested anonymity, noted that the bureau produces hundreds of reports every day based on such tips, which do not always pan out. Patel also promoted an article by the right-wing journalist John Solomon than mentioned that U.S. Customs and Border Protection had seized fake licenses that were arriving mostly from China and Hong Kong around the time the FBI received the tip. According to a 2020 news release from CBP, 20,000 fake licenses were seized in Chicago between that January and June. It said 'most were for college-age students,' a population that has historically sought licenses with fake birthdays so underage students can purchase alcohol. The FBI did not respond to a request for comment from Patel regarding the fake licenses. Dozens of judges, including Trump appointees, have found no evidence of widespread or systemic voter fraud affecting the 2020 election, despite allegations promoted by Trump and his allies since he lost that year's presidential race. The day after Patel released the emails, though, Trump appeared to mention them during a press conference where he talked about 'China and the license plates' and claimed that 'tens of thousands of cards' were used to vote in the 2020 election. The emails released by Patel offer a window into the deep concern among senior career FBI analysts about an intelligence report from an agent in the Albany field office based on a single, unvetted source making a historic allegation: that the Chinese government sent thousands of fake IDs to help people fraudulently vote for Biden. The report was ultimately withdrawn over concerns about its veracity. Two FBI officials familiar with the matter told NBC News that the tip was not credible intelligence and never should have been sent out in an intelligence report. The CIA analysis cited by Ratcliffe found procedural faults with how the agency crafted its assessment that Russia tried to denigrate Hillary Clinton and help Trump get elected in 2016. But it didn't question that broad conclusion — one echoed by two exhaustive congressional investigations. Yet Trump appointees and allies quickly argued the documents vindicated Trump's long-running claims that he had been wronged by intelligence agencies investigating foreign election interference. The CIA review found that 'Obama's Trump-Russia collusion report was corrupt from start,' read the headline of a New York Post piece by conservative columnist Miranda Devine. A press release from the chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, Chuck Grassley of Iowa, said the 'bombshell' FBI emails showed 'FBI headquarters interfered with [an] alleged Chinese election interference probe' to shield then-Director Christopher Wray 'from political blowback.' The FBI emails show that senior career public servants at the bureau had concerns about the reliability of information from a confidential human source who claimed that the Chinese Communist Party planned to use fake IDs to cast ballots for Biden in the 2020 election. The information came from a source that an FBI agent based in Albany, New York, had just met, who in turn got it from a separate unnamed source. The emails say the source in Albany also repeated a claim made on social media that the Chinese government was intentionally spreading Covid in the U.S. — an allegation that has never been corroborated. One email released by the FBI said the information had not been verified through other intelligence-gathering methods. The emails say top bureau intelligence analysts Nikki Floris and Tonya Ugoretz ordered the intelligence report recalled because it lacked corroboration. Floris was forced out of the FBI earlier this year, and Ugoretz — who was promoted to become the FBI's top intelligence official — was recently placed on leave. The FBI has not said why. Floris and Ugoretz did not respond to requests for comment. The emails lay out an internal debate over the reliability of the intelligence, which former FBI agents say is typical. The Albany office, backing its agent, sought to prevent the report from being recalled. Senior FBI officials, meanwhile, pushed for corroboration of the source's allegations. In a Sept. 25, 2020, email, an assistant section chief in the Criminal Intelligence Branch said the claim about Chinese election interference was 'getting a lot of attention from all HQ divisions.' The assistant section chief added, 'We know that the source is first contact and hasn't been re-interviewed. Are you considering recalling the [intelligence report] until you can track the source down and re-interview? Everything election is getting scrutiny, and we just want to be sure we have reliable sourcing.' In a Sept. 28 email, another official noted that the allegation that China was trying to influence the election in favor of Biden, as well as previous seizures of fake driver's licenses imported from China, 'were all documented in some fashion on open sources.' The official added that 'Given the lack of specifics we received in the initial reporting, my first opinion was that the [confidential human source] wants to help and is probably supplementing his reporting via open sources.' Ultimately, the emails show, an FBI official who specializes in Chinese foreign interference instructed the Albany office that 'we have not approved a re-issue' of the report 'specifically because of our concerns that the reporting is not authoritative.' The new head of the FBI's Office of Congressional Affairs is Marshall Yates. A former Republican aide on Capitol Hill, Yates has ties to figures that have long backed Trump's false claim that the 2020 election was stolen. Yates was chief of staff to former Rep. Mo Brooks, R-Ala., on Jan. 6, 2021, when Brooks spoke at Trump's rally in support of efforts to overturn his election loss. Yates then went on to work for the Election Integrity Network, a project headed by Republican lawyer Cleta Mitchell, a key figure in the efforts to overturn the 2020 election. In a 2022 speech in New Mexico, Yates said the 'election objection did not go as we wanted in 2020, on Jan. 6,' but that 'luckily' it had 'sparked a grassroots movement across the country for election integrity.' The FBI did not reply to a request for comment about Yates' involvement. The internal review released by Ratcliffe last week examined how the CIA put together a 2017 intelligence assessment that concluded that Russia interfered in the 2016 election to help Trump defeat Hillary Clinton. The review found some deviance from standard procedures, but it defended the assessment's overall findings. The report disclosed that two senior leaders of a CIA mission center focusing on Russia objected to the conclusion that Russia's goal was to help secure Trump's victory but agreed that Putin hoped to denigrate Clinton and undermine the U.S. democratic process. The review also cited complaints by some CIA officers that they felt rushed by a tight deadline to produce the assessment. The CIA director at the time, John Brennan, was a Democratic political appointee who has since become an ardent Trump critic. In a second post on X, Ratcliffe argued that the complaints about the process were evidence the 'assessment was conducted through an atypical & corrupt process under the politically charged environments' of Brennan and then-FBI Director James Comey. The CIA declined to comment when asked to explain the basis for Ratcliffe's accusation. A special counsel appointed during the first Trump administration looked extensively into how the CIA crafted its assessment but filed no criminal charges and reported no clear evidence that political bias tainted the process. A bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee investigation in 2020 concurred with the 2017 intelligence assessment and found no reason to dispute its conclusions. This article was originally published on
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Canadians in ICE detention centres left in legal limbo as families try to secure release
Relatives of Canadians detained by ICE in the United States say they're furious and frustrated by the treatment of their loved ones and the battles they're having to fight for even the most basic information. Global Affairs Canada said it's aware of roughly 55 Canadians in U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody, though it said that the numbers can fluctuate. Cynthia Olivera — born in Mississauga, Ont., but living in Los Angeles — was arrested last month when she and her husband went to an immigration office to complete an interview for her U.S. citizenship application. Paula Callejas of Montreal was in the process of finalizing a work visa when she was arrested for a misdemeanor — and then transferred to an ICE facility. Olivera and Callejas's families told CBC News the weeks since their arrests have been a nightmare, filled with phone calls to lawyers and ICE bureaucracy. "We're completely concerned for her overall safety and health," a member of Callejas's immediate family told CBC News. CBC is not naming the family member over concerns they may have their own immigration issues while travelling to the U.S. Olivera's husband, Frank Olvera, said what was meant to be a routine immigration interview ended up feeling more like a trap. "We were flabbergasted," Olvera told CBC News. "No due process." Olivera, 45, moved to the U.S. with her family when she was young, her husband said. The two met in the '90s, married (she kept her last name), had children together and have been living in L.A. since then. "About two years ago, since the children are now older, we decided to hire a lawyer and start the immigration process the correct way," Olvera said. But instead of completing the interview, Olivera was arrested by immigration officials over a decades-old border issue, her husband said. "They lured us into our immigration appointment … took my wife, put her in handcuffs, swept her away," he said. "They didn't even give us an opportunity at the interview. Nothing." Olvera said that in 1999, Olivera had travelled to Canada to attend her mother's funeral and was initially denied re-entry because she was pregnant and told border agents she planned to have the child in the U.S. Olivera is now being held by ICE at a detention centre in El Paso, Texas, Olvera said. Earlier this year, U.S. President Donald Trump issued a raft of executive orders that aim to clamp down on illegal immigration and advance his goal of overseeing the largest deportation operation in American history. Stephen Miller, White House deputy chief of staff and the main architect of Trump's immigration policies, has pushed ICE to aim for at least 3,000 arrests a day, up from about 650 a day during the first five months of Trump's second term. Earlier this week, Trump and Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem toured a new immigration detention facility in Florida that officials have dubbed "Alligator Alcatraz." "We are going after murderers and rapists and traffickers and drug dealers and getting them off the streets and getting them out of this country," Noem said after the facility tour. Callejas was in the process of finalizing a work visa when she was charged with a misdemeanor in Florida. Although she pleaded not guilty to the charge, she was handed over to ICE and has been held for more than three months. The 45-year-old had been travelling to the U.S. in recent years with plans to expand her swimsuit business, according to her family. When reached for comment, ICE confirmed that both Callejas and Olivera are in custody but offered few details. Callejas's family said she has been transferred multiple times and last they heard she was in Arizona. But ICE told CBC News that it "seems" she is in El Paso. "We feel completely stressed out because we have no idea if one day she's going to be there or somewhere else," Callejas's relative said. Callejas's family is also now on the hook for her legal fees in both her criminal and immigration cases. They said they want her returned to Canada so she can deal with her misdemeanor charge. At least one Canadian detained by ICE was eventually released. Jasmine Mooney from B.C. was arrested and held for nearly two weeks after trying to get a work visa renewed. She returned to Canada in mid-March. Johnny Noviello, another Canadian citizen, died while in ICE custody last week. His death is under investigation. Olvera said his wife agreed to be deported so that she can at least continue her citizenship application in Canada before returning to her family. But he said there doesn't seem to be any urgency on ICE's part. "There is absolutely no reason why ICE cannot deport her. They're just taking their sweet old time and I don't know why," Olvera said. "We're willing to pay the ticket, whatever it takes. I'm willing to pay for an ICE agent to escort her to Canada if that's what's needed. I'm willing to pay for the ICE agent trip back." Like Callejas, Olivera has been transferred multiple times, her husband said. Both women's families raised concerns about the conditions of their detention. "The food is not great. The conditions of the sleeping arrangements — she tried to give us a hint that pretty much they get crammed up. It's really inhumane," Callejas's family member said, noting that all the calls are recorded. Olvera described a similar situation at the facility where his wife is being held. "It's horrible. They're treated like animals. Sometimes they get hot food, sometimes they don't," he said. Olvera — a third-generation American whose family immigrated from Mexico — said he typically votes Democrat but voted for Trump in November because he wanted a change. Now he appears to be questioning that decision. "I'm ashamed to be an American right now. I turn on the TV and I see them running around.… they're just chasing brown people nowadays," he said. On the day of his wife's arrest, Olvera said he and his lawyer weren't allowed to exit out the front of the building. "They escorted us out the back of the building by the trash cans, the loading dock," he said. "They didn't want to go back through the lobby where we entered from, because they're trapping a bunch of people at these immigration appointments." Unlike Olivera, Callejas may not want to return to the U.S. once her cases are resolved. "It was her dream to live in Florida just because of the business and [her] passion," the family member said. "After all of this, she's actually given up on that dream. She just wants to get out."
