Personal Loans and EMIs Do Not Override Maintenance Obligations: Delhi High Court
recently said that personal loans or EMIs were voluntary obligations.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
These cannot override the obligation of an earning spouse to maintain the other spouse or the child, it added.
A division bench of justices Navin Chawla and Renu Bhatnagar noted that deductions such as house rent, electricity charges, repayment of personal loans, premiums towards life insurance, or EMIs for voluntary borrowings do not qualify as legitimate deductions for the purpose of maintenance. The court stated, "A person cannot wriggle out of his/her statutory liability to maintain his/her spouse and dependents by artificially reducing his/her disposable income through personal borrowings or long-term financial commitments undertaken unilaterally.
"
The court was hearing an appeal filed by the husband challenging a family court order of April 19, which allowed the wife's application filed under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. The husband was directed to pay a monthly payment of Rs 15,000 towards the maintenance of the wife and the child.
In his plea, the husband argued that the family court failed to consider the fact that he was consistently paying EMIs towards a property loan.
He also mentioned that he was paying for a mediclaim policy in which the wife and their child were also covered.
The bench rejected the husband's contention that EMIs and other loan obligations eroded his take-home income. It noted that the wife was suffering from a medical condition and was simultaneously responsible for the care and upbringing of the minor child born out of the wedlock.
"These are considered to be voluntary financial obligations undertaken by the earning spouse, which cannot override the primary obligation to maintain a dependent spouse or child," the bench said.
The bench emphasised that maintenance is not to be assessed based on the net income after such personal deductions, but rather on the free income that reflects the actual earning capacity and standard of living of the party concerned.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
16 minutes ago
- Hans India
Nation will forever remember those who were martyred in Pahalgam terror attack, and for country: K'taka CM
Bengaluru: "The nation will forever remember, with indebtedness, those who were martyred in the recent terrorist attack in Pahalgam and in the subsequent conflict between India and Pakistan," stated Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah on Friday. Addressing a gathering on the occasion of India's 79th Independence Day, CM Siddaramaiah further stated, "We bow our heads in humble respect to their indomitable courage and supreme sacrifice." "Since Independence, countless soldiers have made the supreme sacrifice in wars and conflicts to protect our nation. Even Prime Ministers have laid down their lives in the face of terror attacks. In building the nation's economy, countless workers, farmers, scholars, scientists, teachers, and activists, representing all productive sections of society, have played an active role. On this auspicious occasion, it is our duty to remember and honour them as well," he stated. "Karnataka stood at the forefront of India's freedom movement. Brave sons and daughters such as Kittur Rani Chennamma, Sangolli Rayanna, Dondiya Wagh, the heroic Bedas of Halagali, Mylara Mahadevappa, and Boodi Basappa Nayak inspired generations with their valour. Historic centres of resistance such as Srirangapatna, Surapura, Kittur, Esuru, Vidurashwatha, Shivapura, Ankola, and many others were alive with the spirit of freedom. Lakhs of people participated actively, and thousands laid down their lives for the cause. We must honour them all with heartfelt gratitude," CM Siddaramaiah stated. Surveys by leading national institutions reveal a stark truth: The wealthiest 10 per cent of our population hold 80 per cent of the nation's wealth, yet they contribute only about 3 per cent of the GST collected. The remaining 90 per cent ordinary people who work daily for food and clothing shoulder nearly 97 per cent of GST payments, CM Siddaramaiah noted. "How can any economy sustain itself under such circumstances? How can we fulfil the spirit of our Constitution? How can we reduce this growing inequality? These questions troubled us deeply. It is with the intention of finding answers to these very questions that we launched the Guarantee Schemes and other welfare programmes," CM Siddaramaiah stated. The ideology of Manuvad asserts that only the powerful should thrive while the rest remain as labourers and subordinates, an idea similar to Social Darwinism. In contrast, our Constitution stands firmly for Samvidhanvad, the principle that the weakest and most vulnerable must receive priority, he underlined. "This year, we are setting up 500 Karnataka Public Schools (KPS) at a cost of Rs 2,500 crore. We are providing nutritious food to 53 lakh children, ragi malt, milk, eggs or bananas on all school days, and a hot mid-day meal", CM Siddaramaiah stated. Recently, the State Education Policy Commission, chaired by Professor Sukhadeo Thorat, submitted its report. For the first time, steps are being taken to frame a comprehensive, Karnataka-specific education policy which will lead to holistic development of our youth, CM Siddaramaiah added. "We have all observed how our younger generations are caught in the distraction of mobile phones and the Internet. They are facing deep distress resulting in depression, anxiety, sudden anger, and hatred. We must collectively find new ways to address this social challenge. In this regard, we have launched the 'Mobile Bidi - Pustaka Hidi ('Put Down Your Phone – Pick Up a Book)' and 'Odu Karnataka ('Read Karnataka)' campaigns" CM Siddaramaiah stated. "We have declared Karnataka a Naxal-free state. Now, we must all work together to declare our proud state drug-free. In this fight, every citizen must act like a warrior. The government is already working on this mission, involving all stakeholders," the CM stated. Karnataka is facing discrimination in the distribution of resources from the Centre. There is growing concern that Constitutional bodies like the Income Tax Department, Enforcement Directorate, CBI, and others are not working to uphold the true values of democracy and cooperative federalism as enshrined in the Constitution. Every responsible citizen must raise their voice in this regard, he said.
India Today
35 minutes ago
- India Today
ICICI Bank Lowers Minimum Balance. Check new rules & penalties
ICICI Bank Cuts Minimum Balance. Check new rules & penalties 14 Aug,2025 Credit: Reuters Minimum balance rules for savings accounts opened on or after August 1, 2025 relaxed after earlier rise faced backlash. Credit: Getty Reduction in minimum balance requirement Urban/metro branches – Rs 15,000 (down from Rs 50,000), semi-urban – Rs 7,500, rural – Rs 2,500. Revised Monthly Average Balance (MAB) Those with older accounts will continue to follow the earlier rules, which in some cases mean keeping a higher amount in their accounts. Older accounts remain unaffected 6% of the shortfall amount or Rs 500, whichever is lower — higher than the earlier penalty rate. Penalty for shortfall The move aims to address public backlash and make account maintenance more affordable, especially for customers in cities. Reason for the change
Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
Bihar govt to spend Rs 35.64 crore on interstate bus services for migrant workers
Patna: Migrant workers from Bihar living in other states will soon find it easier to return home during major festivals like Chhath, Diwali, Holi and Durga Puja, with the state government announcing a Rs 35.64 crore initiative to provide smoother transport facilities. Chief Minister Nitish Kumar, in his Independence Day address, said the move aims to reduce the annual rush and ticket shortages faced by people travelling back to Bihar during the festive season. Under the plan, the government will launch interstate bus transport services on a Public–Private Partnership (PPP) model, ensuring more buses, regulated fares, and improved connectivity between Bihar and major states such as Delhi, Gurugram, Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, and Rajasthan. 'This will significantly reduce problems of high fares and non-availability of bus tickets,' Kumar said, adding that the scheme is expected to be operational before the festive season. Every year, thousands of Biharis working outside the state face long waits and inflated fares to return home for celebrations. The new interstate service aims to ease that journey and make festive homecomings stress-free. To encourage operators, the government will provide grants of Rs 150 per seat during peak season and Rs 300 per seat in the off-season. This is expected to increase the number and improve the connectivity of buses running between Bihar and major states such as Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Haryana and Rajasthan. The total estimated expenditure over five years is Rs 35.64 crore, with an additional 2 per cent contingency fund of Rs 71.28 lakh, bringing the overall cost to Rs 36.35 crore. For 2025-26, Rs 7.27 crore will be drawn from the Bihar Contingency Fund. Passenger groups have welcomed the initiative, saying it will help end the long-standing issues of ticket shortages and inflated fares during the festive rush. The government believes the scheme will ensure stability in fares and significantly reduce travel hassles for those returning home for celebrations.
