'Don't meet the criteria': Father fumes after children denied entry on 'Indigenous-only' charter flight in remote Queensland
An Aussie father was left baffled after his children were turned away from a near-empty 'Indigenous only' charter flight in north-west Queensland.
Derek Lord's children were denied entry after he tried paying for seats on a taxpayer-funded flight - designed to accommodate Indigenous students under the ABSTUDY scheme.
His children are boarding at a school in Charters Towers, southwest of Townsville, and without access to charter flights, they face a six-day journey to get home for the holiday period.
Mr Lord, an air traffic services reporting officer at Normanton Airport, told Sydney 2GB's Ben Fordham he was confused why he could not purchase tickets on the plane given they were typically half-empty.
'The booking company that now does it, which is overseas, refused to allow our children to get on because they don't meet the criteria,' he said.
'It's taxpayer funded and even if we were willing to pay, the plane is coming here – it's been paid for by everyone's taxes whether you're Indigenous or non-Indigenous, the kids are from the same town.
'And by the way, we're in the middle of a flood crisis and we couldn't get in or out.
'So, there was no way to get our kids home unless it's on a private charter ourselves, or through Rex, and Rex can be up to two to three weeks waiting for a seat.'
ABSTUDY is a federal government initiative through Services Australia which provides financial support for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students and apprentices.
Katter's Australian Party (KAP) leader Robbie Katter said the current policy was 'madness' as people from the same town and school were forced to operate under "different rules".
'The system is broken and families are paying the price,' he said on Facebook.
'Remote families being ignored, taxpayers being gouged, empty seats going to waste.
'It's not about race - it's about fairness. If the plane's already coming in, and there are spare seats, let kids get home.'
Mr Katter said his party would be "pushing hard" to fix the charter flight issue and hold both levels of government to account.
The Albanese government confirmed it was reviewing the incident.
'Charter flights are only used where it is the cheapest or most cost effective alternative, from very remote communities. The allocation of spare seats is a matter for the charter company," a spokesperson for Social Services Minister Tanya Plibersek said.
"The government agrees that empty seats should be made available for other students or community members to purchase where safe and practical to do so. The Minister will request updated advice from her department on this issue to ensure charter fees reflect value for money."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
12 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Trump meet ‘not specifically on the agenda' at NATO summit, Deputy PM says
When Australia's top leadership will meet Donald Trump in the flesh remains unknown, after Deputy Prime Minister Richard Marles admitted a face-to-face with the US President is not scheduled at this week's NATO Summit. Mr Marles is in the Netherlands for the summit representing Australia as one of the Indo Pacific Four (IP4) – non-NATO countries that work closely with the military alliance in the region. Nikkei has reported Mr Trump was seeking to meet with IP4 representatives amid growing concerns of a Chinese threat, described by his administration as potentially 'imminent'. Mr Marles, who is also defence minister, said overnight a meeting was 'not specifically on the agenda', hastily adding that he 'wouldn't want to overstate any of that'. 'I think we are in large rooms with lots of people, and these meetings, gatherings like this, end up being pretty fluid in terms of the bilaterals that you end up organising,' he told reporters from The Hague. 'But look, it is a really significant gathering for us to attend, and the importance of the NATO Summit has grown in terms of the way in which we engage with the world.' He added that how events in the Indo Pacific and in the North Atlantic 'are influencing each other is growing'. 'What's happening here in Europe, what's happening, specifically in the war in Ukraine is engaging Australia's national interests, and it's a really important gathering for us to attend,' Mr Marles said.
Perth Now
15 minutes ago
- Perth Now
‘Not on the agenda': Big Trump admission
When Australia's top leadership will meet Donald Trump in the flesh remains unknown, after Deputy Prime Minister Richard Marles admitted a face-to-face with the US President is not scheduled at this week's NATO Summit. Mr Marles is in the Netherlands for the summit representing Australia as one of the Indo Pacific Four (IP4) – non-NATO countries that work closely with the military alliance in the region. Nikkei has reported Mr Trump was seeking to meet with IP4 representatives amid growing concerns of a Chinese threat, described by his administration as potentially 'imminent'. Mr Marles, who is also defence minister, said overnight a meeting was 'not specifically on the agenda', hastily adding that he 'wouldn't want to overstate any of that'. Deputy Prime Minister Richard Marles has admitted a meeting with US President Donald Trump is not yet scheduled at this week's NATO Summit. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia 'I think we are in large rooms with lots of people, and these meetings, gatherings like this, end up being pretty fluid in terms of the bilaterals that you end up organising,' he told reporters from The Hague. 'But look, it is a really significant gathering for us to attend, and the importance of the NATO Summit has grown in terms of the way in which we engage with the world.' He added that how events in the Indo Pacific and in the North Atlantic 'are influencing each other is growing'. 'What's happening here in Europe, what's happening, specifically in the war in Ukraine is engaging Australia's national interests, and it's a really important gathering for us to attend,' Mr Marles said. More to come.
ABC News
3 hours ago
- ABC News
Childcare subsidy program leaks hundreds of millions of dollars in fraud and errors
Australia's $14 billion childcare subsidy program is haemorrhaging hundreds of millions of dollars each year due to fraud, overpayments and administrative errors, according to a landmark report from the auditor-general. The report paints a disturbing picture of a system with serious oversight gaps and estimates more than $2.6 billion has been lost from incorrect payments in the five years to 2024. It describes oversight and governance of the subsidy program as "partly effective," and monitoring and enforcement as not being properly managed. The report notes that Services Australia was unable to track childcare-related tip-offs and relied on incomplete income data, while the Department of Education, despite holding broad enforcement powers, lacked clear policies on when or how to act. "Which means it is not able to assess whether decisions to take enforcement action are fair, impartial, consistent, or proportional," the report says. In 2023-24 alone, the auditor-general estimated $484 million in incorrect payments, including fraud and non-compliance. The education department identified but failed to investigate 970 potential overpayments, and it withdrew 42 per cent of fines issued, recovering less than 1 per cent of $6.4 million in outstanding debts. With the subsidy program worth more than $13 billion a year, experts warn the real losses could be much higher than reported. The childcare subsidy is one of the government's fastest growing payments programs, supporting 1.45 million children in approved care. By 2028, annual spending is set to surge by another $3.2 billion to almost $17 billion a year. Early Childhood Education Minister Jess Walsh defended the government's record, saying Labor had delivered the highest provider claim accuracy rate on record at 96.4 per cent, up from 93 per cent before it came to government. More than $300 million in savings had already been delivered through fraud investigations, strengthened audits, better data analytics and legislative changes. "The government doesn't tolerate crooks ripping off the Child Care Subsidy. We will always look for ways to continue to improve the integrity of the system," Walsh said. "Our integrity measures have delivered additional provider audits, more fraud investigations, improved targeting through better data analytics as well as education and support to the sector." The minister confirmed the department had accepted all seven recommendations of the auditor-general's report, and urged the public to report wrongdoing via the department's anonymous tip-off portal. Those recommendations include fixing oversight gaps, strengthening internal policies, publishing a joint compliance strategy, improving intelligence on risks and tip-offs, and upgrading critical systems. And since the audit commenced, a joint governance board was established between Services Australia and the Department of Education to maintain strategic oversight of regulatory activities across both agencies. This will ensure both agencies have a joined up view of the integrity activity underway across the breadth of the subsidy, and provide senior oversight and decision making on key cross cutting issues. But as costs rise and private operators chase profits, some experts say it is time to do something more radical and change the funding model. It comes against a backdrop of a major ABC investigation into the $20 billion childcare industry which exposed a sector in crisis, plagued by systemic failures, secrecy and a rising number of serious incidents at some of the country's largest for-profit providers. It triggered a parliamentary inquiry in NSW, spearheaded by Greens politician Abigail Boyd, and the release of tens of thousands of pages of regulatory documents, which include cases of inappropriate discipline, lack of supervision, unqualified educators and poor paperwork including expired Working With Children Checks and a failure to understand policies. The documents also reveal alleged subsidy fraud including centres over-enrolling children by up to 40 per cent to claim extra funding — an illegal and dangerous practice. Childcare advocate and consultant Lisa Bryant said the report's findings came as no surprise, given the sheer scale and complexity of the subsidy system. "The childcare subsidy is mind-numbingly complex," she said. "It's beyond human understanding how the payments are calculated. Families don't understand how the money and hours are calculated and providers are also frustrated … it's no wonder money is going astray," she said. Bryant said a simpler solution would be to fund childcare providers directly, much like schools, instead of processing subsidies for more than a million families. "If the government paid providers directly, it would have a stronger policy lever," she said "It could link funding to service quality and stop the funding if they don't meet the standards." Bryant said the subsidies should be directed to the centres themselves, similar to how schools work, and if they don't provide quality services, the government has a lever to withdraw the funds. Georgie Dent, the chief executive of The Parenthood, a parent advocacy organisation representing more than 80,000 parents, carers and supporters, said the system's failures are costing children and families dearly. "When almost half a billion dollars is lost to fraud or incorrect payments in a single year, it's not just a technical glitch, it's a policy failure," she said. "This is public money intended to support children's development, family workforce participation and economic productivity. We cannot afford to have it fall through the cracks." Dent said the findings make the case for funding reform clear. "We need a direct and transparent link between funding and the quality, accessibility and integrity of early childhood education services," she said. "Strong governance, clear accountabilities and aligned incentives are not optional, they are the foundation of public trust and better outcomes for children." Greens MP Abigail Boyd said the auditor-general's report revealed a deeply flawed system where billions of taxpayer dollars were being handed to early learning providers without the proper compliance and regulatory systems in place. "It's no wonder that so many large for-profit companies view the Australian early childhood sector as such a lucrative investment," she said. Boyd warned that injecting more money into the current model won't fix its structural failures: "We need a significant overhaul to ensure that everyone can have faith in this critical sector." Chey Carter, former educator and now industry consultant at Divergent Education, says she isn't surprised there is so much leakage in the system. She says she spent time working with a Child Care System management provider and saw firsthand the mass level of confusion directors face when managing childcare subsidy payments. "The support line was flooded with basic questions, how to fix overcharging, apply CCS correctly, or reconcile enrolments. These weren't one-off mistakes; they were routine," she said. "To be eligible for CCS, providers must have fraud prevention policies and procedures in place but if we look at the policy from 'Childcare Desktop' a nationally used childcare policy provider — it states: 'staff will attend regular training to assist in the identification of fraud and corruption'. I can guarantee that the majority of the ECEC workforce have never attended such training." It seems without deeper reform including linking funding to quality and tightening accountability and oversight, the childcare system will continue to bleed public money while failing the children it's meant to serve.
