Yes/No survey results on future of Bell's Sports Centre do not give the full picture say campaigners.
Respondents' comments, obtained under FoI, show broad range of preferences for the iconic city building.
Campaigners fighting to save Perth's iconic Bell's Sports Centre have been angered by a council survey on the building's future use.
They say that while simple yes/no answers were sought to questions — including its conversion into an unheated facility — respondents' comments suggest a broader range of preferences.
The survey, which received 1981 responses, was carried out between mid November 2024 to mid January 2025.
However, the comments only came to light following a Freedom of Information request by campaigners.
The FoI had initially been turned down by PKC.
Survey feedback is to be included in a paper to go before councillors in the coming months to decide the building's future.
Bill Powrie of campaign group Perth and Kinross Community Sports Network (PKCSN) said: 'Having analysed the results of the 1600 comments made by respondents to the council survey, which were only obtained at the second time of asking through an FoI request, it became apparent to me many respondents wanted to qualify their answers.
'For example, many people who voted yes to question five, the unheated option, then went on to make a comment which indicated that they wanted to keep Bell's open for heated indoor sports.
'For a clearer picture of what the public want the question should have been asked if they supported an unheated 3G option or heated for a number of sports.'
The conversion of Bell's into an unheated events space for indoor sports pitches was backed by 1198 survey respondents while 783 disagreed.
One response backing the unheated option, which campaigners say shows the nuanced nature of the results, states: '[I} partially agree.
'I would like to still be able to play badminton there. That being said, I believe the venue can accommodate multiple sports/activities.
'Yes, by all means a footie indoor [pitch] would be useful, but so is badminton, hockey, squash and keeping the sports centres open for school use too. In winter the schools need use of an indoor space for their PE lessons.'
Another response states: 'Having answered 'yes' I think that [the unheated events space] is an appropriate use, but I also think that some form of heating should be available [for] other sports, eg: indoor tennis, badminton, indoor bowling, fitness classes, volleyball and other mass participation events....[this] brings people into the [city] centre to the benefit of the centre and other businesses at a 'slow' time of year.'
Bell's was shut after floodgates were left open in October 2023 causing £2m in damage.
Services — provided by arm's-length PKC external organisation Live Active Leisure (LAL) — were transferred to the Dewars Centre and the school estate in Spring 2024.
The building was listed by Historic Environment Scotland last year and the family of its late Perth architect, John Davidson, are among those backing the campaign to keep it open as a multi-use sports facility.
An online Change.org petition to reopen Bell's as a multi-use indoor sports venue currently has more than 3600 signatures.
Sports club group Perth and Kinross Community Sports Network (PKCSN) - made up of 12 sports and 3500 members – has also set up a Go Fund Me page to raise money for an assessment on keeping Bell's open as a heated indoor sports facility catering for a range of sports.
A Perth and Kinross Council spokesperson said: 'Almost 2,000 people responded to the consultation on the future of Bell's Sports Centre.
'A summary of responses has been provided to councillors and will be used to inform our proposals for the sports centre when they are presented to council in June.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Courier
13-05-2025
- The Courier
Perth campaigners raise equality fears over Bell's Sports Centre plans
Bell's Sports Centre campaigners have demanded answers from Perth and Kinross Council's chief executive as they raise equality fears over the local authority's plans for the facility. Bill Powrie, a member of Perth and Kinross Community Sports Network (PKCSN), wrote to local authority boss Thomas Glen about the proposal to turn the North Inch complex into an unheated arena. The campaign group fear the plan could negatively impact groups most at risk of discrimination, like the elderly, women and disabled sports players. Speaking about over 50s, Bill said: 'This group needs low impact sports like badminton and table tennis that can be played into your 80s. 'Women in the main do not play football and neither do the many disabled people who used to play wheelchair sports like boccia in Bell's. 'These people will be severely affected if the plans go ahead.' The campaigners' complaint is not the first time the local authority has been accused of sacrificing sports that cater for the elderly and disabled in recent years. It was also levelled at the council and Live Active Leisure (LAL) when they made the decision to axe indoor bowls from the city entirely when they moved the gym from Bell's to Dewars Centre. A team of Perthshire international bowls players with disabilities stated the council were putting their future in the sport at risk while Age Scotland also criticised the move. That was only 12 months ago, now the council is facing the same criticism again. The latest census results on the council website states that the Perth and Kinross population is 'evidently aging', with a quarter of residents 65 or over. Last year, The Courier revealed that LAL failed to carry out any consultation in their Equality and Fairness Impact Assessment (EIFA) regarding the move from Bell's. In the section of the report set aside for outlining the findings of said consultation, LAL wrote: 'None.' Under the Equality Act 2010, a public body or organisation is required to eliminate discrimination, advance equality of opportunity, and foster good relations between equality groups. In their report, LAL was unable to find any positive outcomes for closing Bell's for those with disabilities and the single positive for the elderly was that there were good bus routes to Dewars. To further his point, Bill told the chief executive that there are already other facilities within Perth that have, or will have, artificial pitches. He said: 'There are plenty of 3G pitches coming on stream in the near future. 'St Johnstone Football Club, Jeanfield Swifts are building two, Tulloch and when Perth High School is knocked down there will be two more pitches created. 'The usages quoted for football are 20,000 but Bell's used to have 260,000 usages every year.' The future of Bell's, alongside the much-maligned PH2O Thimblerow project, is set to go before council again next month. A spokesperson for the local authority said: 'We recognise the value of sport and recreation for people's general wellbeing. 'We have met with the Perth and Kinross Community Sports Network and their proposals will be considered as part of our response to the consultation. 'Our plans for Bell's and the new PH20 facility, will, alongside our school estate, cater for sports such as badminton. 'These plans are also informed by the findings of our Leisure Assets Review, which looked at demand and usage across all our facilities in Perth and Kinross, and the available capital budget.' The Courier was told that the chief executive, Mr Glen, will reply to Bill 'in due course'.
The Courier
08-05-2025
- The Courier
Campaigners accuse council of running 'misleading' consultation on Bell's Sports Centre in Perth
Campaigners have accused Perth and Kinross Council of running a 'misleading' consultation over the future of Bell's Sports Centre in Perth. The local authority's survey asked the public if they would like to see the facility reopened as an unheated events space with 3G sports pitches. However, Perth and Kinross Community Sports Network (PKCSN) argue the wording of the consultation is inherently flawed as it provided no option for people to vote on the reopening of the facility as an indoor sports venue. Instead, the public were simply asked to leave a comment with other ideas. PKCSN believe respondents could have believed it was a choice between unheated or nothing. With nearly 2,000 votes, the consultation results show a 60/40 split for people said 'Yes' to the unheated idea. But a further breakdown of results obtained through a Freedom of Information (FOI) request show that some of those who voted 'Yes' also commented that they would prefer a fully heated reinstated Bell's. Bill Powrie, campaigner with PKCSN, has a petition to save Bell's which demands it is reopened as multi-use indoor sports venue. It has already garnered over 3,700 signatures. He believes this means that the vast majority of people who have responded to either the consultation or petition are in favour of reinstating the facility as a fully-heated indoor sports venue. Bill told The Courier: 'The survey was misleading. 'If you combine the results of the survey and my petition then 78% are still in favour of indoor.' A report written by council officers ahead of the consultation also appears to suggest the local authority only ever wanted to consider an unheated option. An appendix to the report concludes: 'It is recommended that community engagement is undertaken on the future of Bell's through a survey and supporting communication campaign to encourage participation. 'Survey options to include: 'Do nothing beyond essential maintenance requirements which are the responsibility of the owner of a Category B listed structure. 'Convert the dome to an unheated event space/ multi-use sports pitch venue. 'Invite community suggestions for other unheated use.' Bill also slammed the estimated cost of the unheated option of £5m to £6m which is contained in the same report. Bill said: 'I don't believe that £5m to £6m represents good value for money for a few artificial football pitches.' The future of Bell's is set to go before councillors again next month. A council spokesperson said: 'Almost 2,000 people responded to the consultation on the future of Bell's Sports Centre. 'A summary of responses has been provided to councillors and will be used to inform our proposals for the sports centre when they are presented to council in June. 'Question five of the survey asked respondents if they agreed with the proposal to turn Bell's (into) an unheated sports centre. 'Question six asked those who disagreed with the proposal what uses they proposed instead.'
The Courier
07-05-2025
- The Courier
New design shows how Bell's Sports Centre in Perth could look
A new design shows how Bell's Sports Centre in Perth could look if it is reopened as a fully-heated indoor sports facility. Campaigners believe the iconic North Inch complex should be reinstated to serve the sporting communities that used it before it was shut by flooding. However, the local authority has put forward plans to turn Bell's into an unheated event space with sports pitches. The Perth and Kinross Community Sports Network (PKCSN), which represents a dozen local sports clubs, is against the council's proposals. AJ Fitchet Architects have drawn up a design for Bell's Sports Centre. Image: ajfitchet architect This view has been backed by nine national sporting bodies and nearly 3,700 people who have signed a petition to save the facility. The campaigners enlisted the help of architect Alastair Fitchet, who has worked pro bono with them for the last six months to help design new drawings for the facility. Councils Bell's plans make no sense to architect Alistair, who owns Ajfitchet Architects in Dundee, told The Courier it is important Bell's and its B-listed dome structure are protected. He said: 'I feel it's incredibly important. 'To be taking the heart of out the building and seeing what Perth and Kinross Council are looking to put in doesn't make any sense to me.' How volleyball courts with stands could look at Bell's. Image: Ajfitchet Architect The architect called the structure 'iconic' and says his new redesign 'acknowledges' the listed status. 'The dome is the key part,' Alastair says. 'I don't see any way a building like this would get built today. 'We need to protect it.' He has also incorporated elements to make the building more green and energy efficient. The proposed badminton setup at the redesigned Bell's. Image: Ajfitchet Architect The architect acknowledges his designs are at early stage of the process but hopes it will help spark the imagination for what is possible at Bell's. PKCSN is currently hosting a GoFundMe to raise money for surveyors to cost the designs. 'The people of Perth are being deprived' The controversial plans for Bell's tie into the council's overall new leisure centre proposals which have been met with a huge backlash by residents as they don't feature a dedicated leisure pool. PKCSN also argues the indoor sports provision at the new facility is far less than they already had at Bell's. David Munro, chairperson of the campaign group, told The Courier: 'The people of Perth are being deprived. 'They're being deprived of local sport, they're being deprived of the chance to participate in and watch national and international level sports. Dave Munro and Bill Powrie on Crieff Road, Perth. Image: Steve MacDougall/DC Thomson 'The only people I've spoken to that are in favour of an unheated option are a few councillors.' The future of the facility is set to be discussed by the council next month, alongside plans for PH20. A local authority spokesperson said: 'Almost 2,000 people responded to the consultation on the future of Bell's Sports Centre. 'A summary of responses has been provided to councillors and will be used to inform our proposals for the sports centre when they are presented to council in June.'
