The powerful women behind a social media ban campaign
Photo:
Sharon Brettkelly
A year ago, a group of rich-lister mums met with other high fliers from all walks of life and political hues with one thing in mind.
Many were strangers to each other but the thing that united them was the push to bring in a
law to get under-16-year-olds off social media
.
Such is the power of the group B416 and their cause that politicians from all corners came along to their launch last month, including ACT's David Seymour - who doesn't support a social media ban.
It took place just days after National's Catherine Wedd put forward her Social Media Age-Restricted Users Bill, a private members bill.
Since the launch, the move has faced criticism of moral panic, overreach and that a ban will risk the lives of vulnerable young people.
But B416, which is co-chaired by entrepreneur Cecilia Robinson and includes multi-millionaire toy maker Anna Mowbray, says it is time to listen to parents who want to protect their children from social media harm.
Founding member Malindi MacLean, who heads Outward Bound, says a lot of the criticism is from people who are not parents.
"It's really important to keep [in mind] the lived experience of parents. They are day in, day out experiencing the impact of social media addiction, or addictive behaviours of their children.
"A parent who has just been dealing with their teenager who is self harming or has sextortion or
dealing with cyber bullying
... it's not something that you can argue with."
The Social Media Age-Restricted Users Bill is in the biscuit tin at Parliament, which means it may never see the light of day before the next election.
Photo:
RNZ Pacific/ Koroi Hawkins
Those arguing against a potential law that would force social media giants to use age verification measures on under-16s include retired district court judge David Harvey; youth mental health activist Jazz Thornton, Victoria University media lecturer Alex Beattie and the online counselling service Youthline.
Judge Harvey says the proposed bill is flawed and could get the government in trouble with freedom of expression laws. There's also a risk that it will exclude the likes of YouTube, he says. Thornton believes a blanket ban will cause harm to the most vulnerable children and even lead to deaths; while Beattie argues social media can be a good communication tool for children and parents, and is not an addiction like smoking.
MacLean says she welcomes the debate but her group wants progress. Hence the extensive billboard and social media campaign.
She says the time and resources put into the campaign would be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars. But the influential group has tapped into many communities for contributions and support.
"That just shows the appetite for change. The other thing is we've had a lot of support from organisations pro bono because most of them are human beings who also understand the issues."
Wedd's private members bill is in the biscuit tin at Parliament, which means it may never see the light of day before the next election. That's not good enough for B416, which wants to see a policy by the end of the year, following Australia's world first law and trials of the age-verification technology already underway.
Tech expert Danu Abeysuriya of digital firm Rush tells
The Detail
how the technology could work and why it is important for New Zealand to follow Australia and others.
"We are a small nation and we don't represent a lot of revenue for large tech companies like Google, Facebook or X or Twitter. They focus on social media and to those companies our ad revenue is relatively small.
CEO of digital firm Rush, Danu Abeysuriya
Photo:
Sharon Brettkelly
"Whatever we have to do we should still attempt to be practical otherwise we risk being alienated from those platforms. The balancing act is aligning what we do with what the rest of the world does."
Abeysuriya says there are a number of age verification options but one of the simplest would be a digital token that could be bought from the Warehouse or the local petrol station or even the child's school.
Other technology could be used to put children off using social media, such as slowing down internet traffic. In this case the government would mandate Internet Service Providers such as One NZ to run traffic at half-speed in specific time periods.
"It creates a bit of friction," says Abeysuriya. "If the TikTok video loads really slowly the kids might not watch the TikTok video, they might do something else like read a book."
He says the solutions are ideas and nothing will be perfect.
"The bravery to move is the thing that needs to happen here."
Check out how to listen to and fol low The Detail
here
.
You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on
or following us on
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
11 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Christchurch Hospital's specialist trauma service made no difference in first year
Christchurch Hospital is the largest trauma centre in the South Island. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon A "minimally resourced" specialist trauma service at Christchurch Hospital failed to make any difference for patients in its first year, due to poor staffing and limited operating hours, new research has found. Christchurch Hospital, the largest trauma centre in the South Island, established a specialist trauma admitting service in January 2022. Internationally, such services have been shown to improve survival rates and recovery for patients admitted to hospital after major trauma. However, the Otago University study, published in The New Zealand Medical Journal on Friday, which involved nearly 800 patients, found "no measurable improvement" in major trauma outcomes for those admitted in its first year of operation, compared with those admitted the year before. The authors, including surgeons, said "resourcing limitations have undermined the potential impact of this service". "The Christchurch TAS was launched without adequate funding, resulting in significant staffing shortfalls, including limited trauma surgeon involvement (fewer than four hours per week), no dedicated house officer and restricted operational hours (Monday to Friday only)," it said. "As a result, trauma patients admitted over the weekend were initially managed by the on-call surgical teams before being handed over to the TAS on Monday, potentially leading to delays or inconsistencies in tertiary survey completion. "This has meant that patients admitted over weekends are initially managed by on-call teams before being transferred to the TAS, introducing delays and potential inconsistencies in care." Due to staffing shortages there were periods when the service was not functioning at all, which probably diluted its impact, the report noted. "An example of this is when there was a lack of registrar cover, and so the entire service was closed over the Christmas and New Year period in 2023/2024." Another limitation was "inconsistent or missing data", which may have affected the accuracy of outcome measures and "masked potential areas of improvement", researchers said. Injury is the leading cause of death in New Zealand for those under the age of 35, and the second most common reason for hospitalisation. Although most New Zealand hospitals have dedicated trauma assessment teams (including staff from emergency medicine, general surgery, anaesthetics and nursing), only two of the country's seven tertiary hospitals provide ongoing inpatient trauma-specific care through dedicated trauma admission teams. Health NZ has been approached for comment. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
11 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Police minister blames previous government for poor asset management
Police Minister Mark Mitchell. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii The Police Minister says the force's asset management has been of concern "for some time". RNZ reported on Thursday that Police admit over 170 back-office job cuts last year ate into its ability to manage costly assets. Mark Mitchell said the previous government failed to invest for six years in core operations. "This was allowed to deteriorate quickly," he said in a statement. The National-led government has since put about $240 million in to meet cost pressures, and more for vehicles and a boat, Mitchell said. He did not mention asset management systems, which a Treasury report showed were at least five years behind being fixed to work properly. Police said it has realigned leadership to manage assets better. Earlier this year, it was rated the worst out of 16 agencies Cabinet put on watch to do better in 2023. Yet in 2024, Police cut the back-office staff anyway, saying it would not hurt the front line. Eleven of the 16 agencies were on track to be up to Cabinet standards by this financial year, the report back to Treasury in February said. This included Health New Zealand (HNZ), though last year it had a raft of non-compliances - including one which HNZ said would take until 2028 to fix: Meshing finance, asset and investment management policies "to ensure assets are maintained to deliver the required level of service quality". Along with that hangover of poor asset management, Health NZ also justified its lack of a national health plan financially adept enough to persuade the Auditor-General as being because it was always going to take several more years to make it "mature" enough. It was not clear how this shortcoming fit with it complying with Cabinet's directive to improve asset management. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
Golden Bay residents call for investment to future-proof emergency phone line
Tasman was hit by heavy rain last month. Photo: RNZ/Mark Papalii A group of Golden Bay residents want to see government investment in the region's communications network, so residents have reliable access to the 111 line during emergencies. Project STRIM (strengthening telecommunications resilience in Mohua) was set up by a group of Golden Bay residents after damage to the fibre optic cable that runs along State Highway 60 in July, resulted in a day long outage where residents were unable to call 111. Founder Axel Downard-Wilke said it was after that outage he posted about his concerns on social media and said the community should do something to improve its resilience, which led to the group's formation. "It's really a life or death situation if you need to make a 111 call, it's no good driving to a community hub where there's a Starlink system, you need to be able to use your phone reliably so we need a backup system," Downard-Wilke said. "The other thing of course, is when the Alpine Fault goes no technician can drive their van over with all the specialist equipment that's needed to find faults and fix them." He said the group wanted to see a feasibility study done and Crown funding set aside to future-proof the communications network, as had been done on the West Coast. In 2023, the government spent $435.4 million on a connectivity package for Westland with 118km of fibre laid between Te Anau and Milford Sound to improve resilience and connectivity. At a Tasman District Council meeting on Thursday, Downard-Wilke asked the council to send letters in support of a scoping report and funding for a more resilient system to Government ministers, Chorus and Civil Defence. Golden Bay is currently serviced by a single fibre optic cable that runs between Motueka and Tākaka. During bad weather on 3 July, the fibreoptic cable at Uruwhenua Bridge on State Highway 60 was severed, knocking out connection to about 1100 households. The cable was thought to have been damaged by a slip, but it was later revealed that rats had chewed through it. Downard-Wilke said it wasn't the first time such an outage had affected the community. In September 2023, the cable was accidentally severed by contractors and in August 2022 a slip at Birds Hill took out the road connection and the fibre optic cable with it. While other parts of the country were reliant on a single fibre cable, Downard-Wilke said he thought Golden Bay was the biggest community in the country that relied on a single cable, and was vulnerable to failures. "Whoever thought that having a system with a single point of failure is a good idea. I don't know what they were thinking. "If that goes, nothing goes." A large washout across a highway during extensive flooding and heavy rain in the Nelson Tasman areas. Photo: Supplied/ Nick Smith Telecommunications Forum chief executive Paul Brislen has said the key was to have multiple different types of networks (fibre, mobile, fixed wireless connections and satellite) so there wasn't a single point of failure. He also said telecommunications network companies were doing work to ensure cities were connected by a loop, instead of a point-to-point connection, so if half the cable was knocked out, traffic could be connected via the other side of the cable. A Chorus spokesperson said a second fibre optic cable for the Tākaka and Golden Bay area was not feasible as there was only one point of entry, it would follow roughly the same route and be exposed to the same risks. It said a second cable laid on a different route would face challenges due to the geography and topography of the area and would require significant funding and considerable feasibility work. The spokesperson said Chorus was aware of several regions connected to the fibre network via a single cable, some with larger populations that Golden Bay, and that came with risks that were actively managed. "We have robust monitoring and assurance processes in place to respond swiftly to any service disruptions, particularly those caused by adverse weather or natural events." An example of some of the widespread damage to roads and infrastructure in the Nelson Tasman areas. Photo: Supplied/ Nick Smith Golden Bay Community Board deputy chair Grant Knowles said the July outage was concerning and the inability to call 111 took was a shock to many. "I think it was a surprise to people that they couldn't get hold of emergency services or the chemist, for instance, couldn't let people know that they had a prescription to pick up, it was quite a broad problem." Tākaka residents then received an emergency alert during heavy rain on July 11, warning them to expect flooding and to be prepared to evacuate and Knowles questioned how people would be informed of alerts if there was no mobile coverage. The town's population grew significantly over summer, which was often when it experienced heavy rain and slips which could knock out the cable as had happened in 2022. Knowles said the region remained vulnerable during weather events and natural disasters and there was an urgent need for a backup communications system. He hoped the government would take the community's concerns, seriously. "It needed to be there yesterday, I mean, it should never have got to this point." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
