Christchurch Hospital's specialist trauma service made no difference in first year
Photo:
RNZ / Nate McKinnon
A "minimally resourced" specialist trauma service at Christchurch Hospital failed to make any difference for patients in its first year, due to poor staffing and limited operating hours, new research has found.
Christchurch Hospital, the largest trauma centre in the South Island, established a specialist trauma admitting service in January 2022.
Internationally, such services have been shown to improve survival rates and recovery for patients admitted to hospital after major trauma.
However, the Otago University study, published in
The New Zealand Medical Journal
on Friday, which involved nearly 800 patients, found "no measurable improvement" in major trauma outcomes for those admitted in its first year of operation, compared with those admitted the year before.
The authors, including surgeons, said "resourcing limitations have undermined the potential impact of this service".
"The Christchurch TAS was launched without adequate funding, resulting in significant staffing shortfalls, including limited trauma surgeon involvement (fewer than four hours per week), no dedicated house officer and restricted operational hours (Monday to Friday only)," it said.
"As a result, trauma patients admitted over the weekend were initially managed by the on-call surgical teams before being handed over to the TAS on Monday, potentially leading to delays or inconsistencies in tertiary survey completion.
"This has meant that patients admitted over weekends are initially managed by on-call teams before being transferred to the TAS, introducing delays and potential inconsistencies in care."
Due to staffing shortages there were periods when the service was not functioning at all, which probably diluted its impact, the report noted.
"An example of this is when there was a lack of registrar cover, and so the entire service was closed over the Christmas and New Year period in 2023/2024."
Another limitation was "inconsistent or missing data", which may have affected the accuracy of outcome measures and "masked potential areas of improvement", researchers said.
Injury is the leading cause of death in New Zealand for those under the age of 35, and the second most common reason for hospitalisation.
Although most New Zealand hospitals have dedicated trauma assessment teams (including staff from emergency medicine, general surgery, anaesthetics and nursing), only two of the country's seven tertiary hospitals provide ongoing inpatient trauma-specific care through dedicated trauma admission teams.
Health NZ has been approached for comment.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
7 hours ago
- RNZ News
Christchurch nurses regularly in tears over staff shortages
Nurse Bruce MacIntosh joined other nurses on strike in Christchurch today. Photo: RNZ/Rachel Graham A Christchurch nurse, who joined others on strike this afternoon , says staff shortages are so bad he is regularly seeing colleagues in tears. Nurses from theatre, post-anaesthetic care and radiology wards at Christchurch Hospital walked off the job from 2 to 4pm on Friday over a breakdown of collective bargaining. About 80 supporters and nurses gathered in Hagley Park, across the road from Christchurch Hospital, waving flags and posters calling for safe staffing. New Zealand Nurses Organisation delegate and operating theatre assistant Bruce MacIntosh said he is constantly seeing the impact of the staffing shortages. "Its incredible when you go around the wards, and see it like we do and meet with the delegates regularly. It is a crisis. Some of the delegates are crying on the night shift when they can't fill the (staffing) spots," said MacIntosh. "It is risky for the nurses, because if something goes wrong their name is on the block, which is a risk to their practice. So, not only is there risk to the patients, but also risk to the practitioners, the nurses." Nurse Averil Cooper said she too was making a stand for the safety of the patients and nurses' registration. "We have no staff, very little staff. They are run ragged and putting their scope of practice and registration on the line," said Cooper. She said the staff are dealing with chaos every day. Gayl Marryatt, a registered nurse and NZNO delegate, said the strike was part of a rolling strike being taken by the union. She said it was to highlight that multiple parts of the hospital are being affected by the short staffing. Nurses planned to hold nation-wide industrial action on 2 September and 4 September. Health NZ said contingency plans were in place during the strike. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
7 hours ago
- RNZ News
The Panel with Anna Dean and Ed McKnight Part 1
Professor Michael Baker Photo: Supplied / Luke Pilkinton-Ching Tonight, on The Panel, Wallace Chapman is joined by panellists Anna Dean and Ed McKnight. First up, he government has confirmed how much it cost us to break the contract with South Korean ship builders for new ferries: $144 million. Was it worth it? then everyone is coming down with winter colds and illnesses - it feels bad this year, but is it? Public health expert Michael Baker says it's actually pretty normal.
NZ Herald
13 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Parents left out-of-pocket as dentist moves to Panama
Melissa Ferguson said her son, now 13, was about halfway through his treatment and 'taking a break' while they waited for the last of his baby teeth to fall out, when the clinic suddenly closed. 'It would have been nice to get, at least a refund.' Ferguson was recommended True Alignment in Alpha St by a friend after a community dentist suggested her son needed orthodontic treatment. 'Looking at the website, they claimed to be 'no extractions', very gentle care and I thought 'Oh that sounds like a great way to go'.' After a free consultation including X-rays, Ferguson was told her son did not have enough space in his jaw for all of his adult teeth and that his jaw needed to be 'grown out'. 'It all sounded very legit and like a good plan.' Growth orthodontics including orthotropics, is a controversial orthodontic approach focused on facial growth and considered unscientific by many orthodontists. 'The thing was you pay for all of the treatment up front and with him being so young I realised we were probably going to be looking at many years of orthodontic care and I thought at least it's all covered under one lump sum,' Ferguson said. The money covered the aligners, treatment, consultations and X-rays, though they had to do 'self-scans' – where Ferguson photographed her son's teeth and provided them to the clinic through an app. Ferguson said despite advertising 'no extractions', the clinic removed one of her son's teeth soon after treatment began. Just when her son was taking a break from treatment, Ferguson received an email from Kruger explaining the clinic could no longer operate. In the email, seen by RNZ, Kruger said he had been told he could not advise her 'as it is regarded as treating a patient without a license! Its absurd and it sickens me [sic]'. He urged Ferguson to create a group and 'hound the idiots that have caused this problem'. 'Make them be answerable to their vindictive and unfair predatory behavior against me that really is hurting you [sic]. 'My evidence is strong that we have been unfairly treated leaving you in the wake of the destruction without any care now.' Melissa Ferguson's son's teeth about 18 months into treatment with True Alignment Orthodontics. Photo / RNZ He said he did not have a solution, but was holding meetings. 'We are looking at all angles but have to be very careful how we do it.' Kruger said action needed to be taken 'against those that caused this'. 'The names and contact details of the offenders are on my website. Ask them what now?' Ferguson said she felt some of the messaging was 'aggressive'. She tried to access her son's patient files and couldn't. Ferguson took her son to another dentist for a second opinion and was told he didn't need treatment and likely never did. In a separate email dated January 24, 2024 from the new practice owners, seen by RNZ, they said they could not afford to honour the treatment. 'The huge number of patients needing to finish their Invisalign care has overwhelmed our schedule,' they wrote. 'Our initial intention to help patients free of charge has been challenged. 'We did not receive money from Dr Kruger or True Alignment nor did we give money to buy his business. 'We started a new business in its place to try and help the situation and to hopefully create a strong general and cosmetic dental practice.' Under the heading 'Where did the money paid to True Alignment Orthodontic and Dental go?', the two dentists said 'Patient money paid staff wages, Invisalign lab fees, building rent, utilities, supplies and overhead(s)'. 'We have been told there is no money to refund to patients or to help us cover the costs of finishing treatments.' They said money paid by patients to Kruger covered business costs. 'The business was dissolved and there was no money left.' At the time of the closure, Kruger blamed two orthodontists who complained to the Dental Council about concerns they had with his treatment of some patients. Kruger was already in Panama where he said he had been operating remotely for several years. Under New Zealand rules, dentists don't have to be specially trained to carry out orthodontics, but they must directly supervise any dental assistants undertaking the treatment. RNZ understands the clinic was shut by Kruger after he did not renew his annual practising certificate. In an online discussion of the situation by affected parents, provided to RNZ, two parents said they pre-paid in full the week of the closure and their respective children were due to have their first appointment on the day the clinic shut. One had paid $10,300. Another had a payment plan and had paid $8500 but her child had not received any treatment while payment was under way. One mother said her daughter began treatment at 6, and another said their child's unfinished treatment left them with teeth that didn't line up and an incorrect bite. Another said their child had a twisted bottom jaw and incorrect bite, while another said they'd paid $11,000 upfront and had 18 months of treatment and while 'taking a break' the clinic closed. The parents complained of being unable to access files, get information out of the clinic, contact Kruger, and of being out of pocket. At least one said they reported the case to police and another said they were advised by the Dental Council to complain to the Privacy Commissioner to recover patient files and lodge a claim with the Disputes Tribunal to recover their money. RNZ spoke to Kruger in Panama, where his website advertises that he runs several businesses, including consulting for dental and orthodontic practices, and another in tourism in Boquete. He said he was consulting to dentists in the United States and Australia by providing clear aligners and getting 'lots of referrals'. Kruger blamed the closure of the clinic on a Waikato orthodontist he alleged was 'very aggressive against a dentist doing orthodontics because he felt they had to be a specialist which is nonsense'. 'I've seen orthodontists do terrible work.' Asked what happened to the practice's 450 patients, Kruger answered: 'Good question, I dunno. I wasn't allowed to talk to them. If I did, I was going to get a $10,000 fine.' The former True Alignment Orthodontics clinic in Cambridge. Photo / Googlemaps He said at the time he encouraged patients on his website to start a 'class action suit' against the Dental Council. 'They've made this decision with no evidence, no proof whatsoever, and with me providing evidence that I've done no harm... that I'm not actually treating patients in New Zealand. 'I'm working as a consultant to a company in Panama that was at that time providing clear aligners directly to the patient in New Zealand and they were being looked after by dentists who are registered in New Zealand.' He claimed he wasn't treating the patients, only providing aligners to a dentist at True Alignment, and said he didn't own the practice. According to the Companies Office, Kruger was the sole director and shareholder of TSM, the company based in the same building as the practice at 82 Alpha St, when the last annual return was filed in June 2023. He is still listed as the current director and shareholder, however, he said TSM was a management company that managed staff at True Alignment. When asked about the money paid by Ferguson for her son's unfinished treatment, Kruger hung up. Kruger has operated dental practices in Cambridge under different names since 1993 including The Smile Center, Gentle Dental, Gentle Orthodontics and Growth Orthodontics. Gentle Orthodontics and Gentle Dental were put in liquidation in 2010 owing $481,000. Dental Council chief executive Marie MacKay said Kruger was registered with the council but did not hold a current practising certificate and could not legally practise in New Zealand. 'Dr Kruger has previously publicly acknowledged that complaints against him were under investigation, however in accordance with privacy legislation, we are not able to disclose the details of any complaints or investigation.' She said the Dental Council did not hold any authority over a practitioner's ability to register, practise, or provide clinical advice in any other jurisdiction than New Zealand. -RNZ
