Palestinian Mother 'Destroyed' After Image Used To Deny Gaza Starvation
From Canada, where she lives with her six other children, Najjar pursued a months-long effort to get those she had left out of Gaza.
She finally embraced her daughters and seven grandchildren when they arrived at Toronto's airport last month.
But when clips of the emotional reunion were posted on social media, pro-Israeli accounts mocked her physical appearance saying it disproved claims of starvation in Gaza.
"As a mother it just destroyed me," Najjar, 50, told AFP.
Najjar did not claim that she went hungry while in Gaza.
But as recently as this past weekend a post viewed more than 300,000 times across multiple platforms ridiculed her, erroneously implying she had just left Gaza.
"Did you see what that woman looked like?" the poster said, pointing out Najjar does not look undernourished.
United Nations agencies have warned that famine was unfolding in Gaza, with Israel severely restricting the entry of aid. Images of sick and emaciated Palestinian children have drawn international outrage.
The allegation has been denied by Israel. "There is no starvation in Gaza," Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said last month.
The ridicule Najjar faced is part of a broader trend.
Israeli anchors on the country's right-wing Channel 14 -- sometimes described as the Hebrew Fox News -- have laughed at "obese" mothers, alleging they steal their children's food.
For Najjar, the fact that her family's reunion got caught up in a misinformation campaign was devastating.
"After all the suffering, and losing everything, and nearly dying, some people still had the heart to mock them," she said, referring to her family.
"My daughters lived there and their children went to sleep hungry...with bombs outside their tents," Najjar said.
Pro-Israeli commentators online also focused on her grandchildren's apparently healthy appearance.
Najjar told AFP they received medical treatment, including renourishment, at a hospital in Jordan before flying to Canada.
Mert Can Bayar, a postdoctoral fellow at the Center for an Informed Public at the University of Washington, said the posts targeting Najjar are "just one little piece" of a misleading online narrative.
Toronto's Mayor Olivia Chow removed a video she had posted on Instagram in which she welcomed arriving Palestinians because of abusive comments directed at the family.
Comments on Chow's video also cited the family's physical appearance to broadly dismiss claims of starvation in Gaza.
X's chatbot Grok also misidentified a 2025 AFP photo of an emaciated child in Gaza, incorrectly saying it was taken in Yemen seven years ago, fuelling further claims that reports of starvation in Gaza have been fabricated.
Valerie Wirtschafter, a fellow at the Brookings Institution think-tank, said the claims were reminiscent of falsehoods that emerged weeks into the war alleging Palestinians had posed as so-called crisis actors and staged their injuries.
Wirtschafter said the hoax narrative "deflects from the real humanitarian harms that are happening right now."
Israel's offensive has killed at least 61,430 Palestinians, according to Gaza's health ministry, figures the United Nations deems reliable.
Hamas's October 2023 attack on Israel, which triggered the war, resulted in the deaths of 1,219 people, according to an AFP tally based on official figures. Forty-nine of the 251 hostages taken by Hamas are still held in Gaza, including 27 the Israeli military says are dead.
When Najjar left Gaza last year, her daughters -- all in their 20s -- did not have Canadian citizenship.
With the family separated, she lived with crippling fear at the prospect of receiving word that they had been killed.
While her daughters now have citizenship and are in Canada with their children, her sons-in-law remain in Gaza, where the UN's Integrated Food Security Phase Classification says "widespread starvation, malnutrition, and disease are driving a rise in hunger-related deaths."
"I just want the world to know the crisis is real," Najjar told AFP. "Denial is deadly." People make their way along al-Rashid street in western Jabalia on July 22, 2025, after receiving humanitarian aid from an aid distribution point in the northern Gaza Strip AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Int'l Business Times
9 minutes ago
- Int'l Business Times
Japan Emperor Expresses 'Deep Remorse' 80 Years After WWII
Tens of thousands of people braved blazing heat to pay their respects at a controversial Japanese shrine Friday, as Emperor Naruhito spoke of his "deep remorse" on the 80th anniversary of the nation's World War II surrender. A cabinet minister was among the visitors to Yasukuni Shrine in Tokyo, which honours 2.5 million mostly Japanese soldiers who perished since the late 19th century, but also enshrines convicted war criminals. Trips to the shrine by government officials have angered countries that suffered Japanese military atrocities, particularly China and South Korea. It came as Naruhito said he felt "a deep and renewed sense of sorrow" in a sombre speech alongside Empress Masako in an indoor arena in the centre of the city, where the national flag flew half mast outside. "My thoughts are with the numerous people who lost their precious lives in the last war and their bereaved families," the 65-year-old said. "Reflecting on our past and bearing in mind the feelings of deep remorse, I earnestly hope that the ravages of war will never again be repeated." Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba also addressed the ceremony, pledging "to uphold the painful memories of war... passing them down across generations, and pursue actions toward lasting peace". Ishiba, a political moderate, sent a customary offering to Yasukuni, according to Kyodo news. No Japanese prime minister has visited the shrine since 2013, when a trip by then-premier Shinzo Abe sparked fury in Beijing and Seoul, and a rare diplomatic rebuke from close ally the United States. With temperatures above 30C in the picturesque grounds around the shrine, there was a sea of umbrellas as people tried to shelter from the sun. At least two people became unwell in the heat and were forced to seek help. Takashi Eguchi, a 53-year-old graphic designer from Tokyo, told AFP Yasukuni served as an accessible place in the heart of the city for ordinary people to reflect on the nation's history. "We live in a moment when wars have broken out or are likely to break out in various places," he said. "So I came here to look back at what Japan has done, including its failures." Another visitor, who identified himself only by his surname Harada, came dressed in a Japanese imperial army uniform to honour the sacrifice of the war dead. "I know the time will come when war veterans will no longer be with us. I wanted to do my part to continue their legacy," said the 39-year-old from the central prefecture of Nagano. "You have to look at all aspects of wars. Good things and bad things happened." Agriculture minister Shinjiro Koizumi, seen as potential future prime minister paid a visit to the shrine early morning, as he does annually on August 15. Ishiba's chief political rival Sanae Takaichi -- who leads the nationalist wing of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party, was also there -- as were members of the "Japanese first" Sanseito party which made strong gains in July's upper house election with its "anti-globalist" drive. Naruhito, Masako and their daughter Princess Aiko are next month due to visit Nagasaki to meet survivors of the devastating atomic bomb and honour the war dead in what is reportedly the emperor's first trip there since he acceded to the throne in 2019. A Shinto priest leads Japanese lawmakers during a visit to Yasukuni Shrine in Tokyo AFP A political group queues with others to pay their respects during a visit to Yasukuni Shrine AFP A man dressed in old Japanese army uniform at the Yasukuni Shrine in Tokyo AFP
Int'l Business Times
2 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
New Compromise But Still No Deal At Plastic Pollution Talks
Countries trying to break the deadlock and strike a landmark global treaty on combating plastic pollution negotiated through the night into Friday on a last-minute revised proposal. The new draft, issued by the talks chair after the original Thursday deadline passed, contains more than 100 unresolved passages of text -- but constitutes an "acceptable basis for negotiation", two sources from different governments told AFP. However, several environmental NGOs said the new text still did not go far enough to protect human health and the environment. After three years of negotiations, nations wanting bold action to turn the tide on plastic garbage were trying to build last-minute bridges with a group driven by oil-producing states. Talks chair Luis Vayas Valdivieso issued his revised draft text after countries from all corners brutally shredded his previous version issued Wednesday, plunging the talks into disarray. The Ecuadoran diplomat spent Thursday in frantic negotiation with multiple regional groups, resulting in a new text that went some way towards appeasing both major blocs. The High Ambition Coalition, which includes the European Union, Britain and Canada, and many African and Latin American countries, wants to see language on reducing plastic production and the phasing out of toxic chemicals used in plastics. A cluster of mostly oil-producing states calling themselves the Like-Minded Group -- including Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Russia, Iran, and Malaysia -- want the treaty to focus primarily on waste management. The new text "is far from what is needed to end plastic pollution," however, "it can be the springboard to get there, if we sharpen it in a next round", Panama's negotiator Juan Carlos Monterrey said. A diplomatic source from another country told AFP it was an "acceptable basis for negotiation". A total of 185 countries have been negotiating since August 5 at the United Nations headquarters in Geneva. Five previous rounds of talks over three years failed to land a treaty. One country's chief negotiator told AFP the new draft felt "more balanced text -- not too bad but not too good either. At least it feels like the chair is listening. But many of us are asking what's going to be the next steps". As for whether there was much movement from the Like-Minded Group, the negotiator said: "Nothing. It's the same...I'm not so sure if there's momentum." The plastic pollution problem is so ubiquitous that microplastics have been found on the highest mountain peaks, in the deepest ocean trench and scattered throughout almost every part of the human body. On current trends, annual production of fossil-fuel-based plastics will nearly triple by 2060 to 1.2 billion tonnes, while waste will exceed one billion tonnes, according to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. With 15 million tonnes of plastic dumped in the ocean every minute, French President Emmanuel Macron asked: "What are we waiting for to act?" "I urge all states gathered in Geneva to adopt an agreement that truly meets the scale of this environmental and public health emergency," he posted on X. "We need to have a coherent global treaty. We can't do it on our own," said Environment Minister Deborah Barasa of Kenya, a member of the High Ambition Coalition seeking aggressive action on plastic waste. Barasa told AFP that nations could strike a treaty now, then work out some of the finer details down the line. "We need to come to a middle ground," she said. IPEN, a global network aimed at limiting toxic chemicals, said the level of ambition in the new draft text "cannot become the new normal for these negotiations". And the World Wide Fund for Nature told AFP: "Efforts to pull together a treaty that all parties will accept has amounted to a text so compromised, so inconsequential, it cannot hope to tackle the crisis in any meaningful way."
Int'l Business Times
2 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
Desperate Myanmar Villagers Scavenge For Food As Hunger Bites
People in western Myanmar have been driven to scavenging for bamboo shoots, as humanitarian workers warn a wartime blockade and aid cutbacks led by Washington have caused hunger cases to surge. "Another day has gone, and I have to struggle again for another day," fruit vendor Kyaw Win Shein told AFP in the town of Mrauk U in Myanmar's Rakhine state. "It is getting worse day by day," the 60-year-old, whose business is faltering as prices rise and incomes drop -- a grim equation driving others to scour the countryside for sustenance. Rakhine state -- a riverine slice of coastal Myanmar bordering Bangladesh -- has witnessed intense suffering in Myanmar's civil war, triggered by a 2021 coup deposing the democratic government. As the military fights an ethnic armed group, it has blockaded the territory -- throttling supplies to its estimated population of 2.5 million. The impoverished state has long been a focus of international aid organisations, but worldwide cutbacks spearheaded by US President Donald Trump's "America First" freeze on humanitarian funding have forced them to retreat. The World Food Programme (WFP) -- which received nearly half its 2024 donations from the United States -- warned last week that 57 percent of families in central Rakhine are now unable to meet basic food needs. The figure had risen from just 33 percent in December. "A deadly combination of conflict, blockades, and funding cuts is driving a dramatic rise in hunger and malnutrition," the WFP said. In northern Rakhine areas such as Mrauk U -- where conflict complicates data collection -- WFP warned the situation is "much worse". Residents said fertiliser is scarce, reducing crop yields and making produce unaffordable, driving people to desperate measures in a tightening spiral of misery. "I am not the only one who has difficulties," said fruit vendor Kyaw Win Shein. "Everyone is the same." The village of Ponnagyun is a short distance from the state capital Sittwe, at the mouth of a delta opening onto the Bay of Bengal. Rakhine cuisine is famed for its fresh, simply cooked seafood, and fish is still on sale in markets. But people have no cash to buy it. "People are starving in my village," said one resident who runs a Ponnagyun payphone shop, but asked to remain anonymous for security reasons. "People find and eat bamboo shoots mostly," he said. "People can eat it, but it's not nutritious." He said only two aid handouts reached their community in the past year. The conflict blockade is so effective that currency notes are not leaving the state to be replaced with new ones for circulation, and instead are left crumbling from wear and tear in the pockets of customers and vendors. "The commodity prices are really high," said 64-year-old Mrauk U resident Hla Paw Tun. "Many people are selling, but few are buying," he said. "We have been struggling to survive day by day." Rakhine has long been wracked by civil conflict -- the site of alleged military atrocities against the resident Rohingya minority around 2017, which some countries have deemed a genocide. More than one million Rohingya now live in Bangladeshi border camps -- and the UN said last month a massive new influx had seen 150,000 arrivals over the previous 18 months. Meanwhile, nearly half a million people remain displaced inside Rakhine. Among them is 49-year-old Hla Aye, who fled her village for Mrauk U when two bombs fell near her house. She set up as a shopkeeper, but that business quickly failed in Rakhine's hostile wartime economy. Still, she believes, her struggles may not be over yet. "I have no idea how the future will be and if it will be more difficult," she said. Nearly half of the World Food Programme's 2024 donations came from the United States AFP
