Labour leader Chris Hipkins dismisses criticism of Covid-19 overspending as 'Treasury spin'
Photo:
RNZ / Mark Papalii
Labour leader Chris Hipkins is dismissing what he calls "Treasury spin" after its analysts said the last government overspent during the Covid-19 pandemic against official advice.
Treasury's 2025 Long Term Insights Briefing
, released this week, calculated the total cost of the pandemic at about $66 billion, or roughly 20.4 percent of GDP.
The report said
Treasury advocated for more targeted support
in late 2020 into 2021 and explicitly warned "against any further stimulus" by Budget 2022.
But responding to questions from RNZ on Friday, Hipkins was unapologetic about his party's economic response to Covid-19.
"We prioritised keeping people alive and keeping people in jobs," he said.
"I'm never going to claim that we got everything perfect... but prioritising jobs and prioritising lives was the right thing to do."
Hipkins claimed other countries also spent up large with the same objectives, but Treasury said New Zealand was near the top of the chart when considering spending as a percentage of GDP.
"If you listen to the Treasury spin, then you're going to get one view," Hipkins told RNZ. "If you speak to other economists, you'll get a different view.
"Our job was to support New Zealanders through the global pandemic, making sure that we saved lives and kept people's jobs, and we were very successful in doing that: one of the lowest death rates in the world, one of the lowest rates of unemployment in the world, and one of the fastest rates of economic growth in the world."
About half of the total Covid-19 response cost was directly tied to the pandemic, such as the wage subsidy scheme, or health initiatives like vaccination, contact tracing and quarantine.
The remainder went to a wide range of initiatives like: "tax changes, training schemes, housing construction, shovel-ready infrastructure projects, increases to welfare benefits, the Small Business Cashflow Scheme, Jobs for Nature, additional public housing places and school lunches".
Treasury said that had "a lagged impact on the economy and proved difficult to unwind in later years".
But Hipkins said Treasury had mischaracterised some of that spending, such as the provision of distance-learning for school students.
"Making sure that kids could keep learning while they were at home during lockdown was an essential Covid-19 expense," Hipkins said.
The report comes during a prolonged economic downturn, with both the government and opposition parties trading blame over its cause.
Finance Minister Nicola Willis was quick to wield Treasury's findings as evidence that Labour had been undisciplined in its spending.
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
Finance Minister Nicola Willis was quick on Thursday to wield Treasury's findings as evidence that Labour had been undisciplined in its spending, driving up inflation, and fuelling a cost-of-living crisis.
"Treasury's language is spare and polite, but its conclusions are damning," she said. "New Zealanders are still paying the price of the previous government extending a big-spending approach initially intended for a pandemic response.
"The lesson from Labour's mishandling of the Covid response is that while there are times when governments have to increase spending in response to major events the fiscal guardrails should be restored as soon as possible."
To that, Hipkins scoffed: "By comparison to this government's track record, I'll take our one any day".
Hipkins said Willis should stop blaming others and instead accept the consequences of her government's spending cuts.
"The wreckage that she is leaving in her wake at the moment is obvious for all New Zealanders to see. Unemployment is going up," he said.
"Economic growth has collapsed. Essential services that the public rely on a daily basis are falling into disarray, and this is all on Nicola Willis watch."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
22 minutes ago
- RNZ News
New political poll predicts hung Parliament
In preferred prime minister ratings, Christopher Luxon and Chris Hipkins both sit at 20.2 percent. Photo: RNZ The race for Election 2026 appears to be on a knife edge, with a new political poll predicting a hung Parliament. The latest Taxpayers' Union-Curia Poll - taken between 3 and 5 August - comes after a string of negative headlines about the economy. Labour has overtaken National as the largest party, gaining 2 points to 33.6 percent, while National drops 2.1 points to 31.8 percent. The Greens are up 0.4 points to 9.8 percent, ACT is down 0.5 points to 8.6 percent, New Zealand First is down 2 points to 7.8 percent and Te Pāti Māori down 0.3 points to 3.2 percent. If an election were held today, the centre-right bloc would lose four MPs for a total 61 seats, while the centre-left bloc would gain four MP and also reach a total 61 seats. With neither bloc having the upper hand, it would be a hung Parliament. The last Taxpayers' Union-Curia Poll showed the coalition parties reasserting their lead with enough support for 65 seats, driven by a surge in support for New Zealand First. For the minor parties, TOP is up 1.4 points to 2.6 percent, Outdoors and Freedom is up 1 point to 1.1 percent and Vision NZ is up 0.4 points on 0.4 percent. Cost of living remains voters' most important issue at 24.4 percent (+2.8 points), closely followed by the economy more generally at 20.7 percent (+1.6 points). Health is the next largest issue on 10.0 percent, followed by employment on 6.0 percent. In preferred Prime Minister ratings, Christopher Luxon is up 0.5 points to 20.2 percent while Chris Hipkins is up 0.6 points to also sit at 20.2 percent. Winston Peters is down 1.1 points to 8.2 percent, Chlöe Swarbrick is up 1.0 point to 8 percent, and David Seymour is up 0.5 points to 6.2 percent. The poll was conducted by Curia Market Research Ltd for the Taxpayers' Union. It is a random poll of 1000 adult New Zealanders and is weighted to the overall adult population. It was conducted by phone (landlines and mobile) and online, has a maximum margin of error of +/- 3.1 percent and 6.2 percent were undecided on the party vote question. Curia is a long-running and established pollster in New Zealand, which has resigned its membership from the Research Association New Zealand (RANZ) industry body. Polls compare to the most recent poll by the same polling company, as different polls can use different methodologies. They are intended to track trends in voting preferences, showing a snapshot in time, rather than be a completely accurate predictor of the final election result. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
22 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Sinking millions into Auckland's heritage buildings
Auckland Museum's latest exhibition DIVA celebrates the figures that have defined generations in music, fashion, and performance. Photo: Sharon Brettkelly The discovery of deadly abestos dust at Auckland Museum has thrown its $40 million centenary year plans up in the air as it grapples with the hefty costs of losing visitors and making the building secure. The museum is now partly open after three weeks of full closure and many of the exhibition rooms on the north side will reopen in October. But the big drawcard for international tourists - the Māori Court - will stay closed indefinitely as experts work through the delicate job of getting the asbestos out of the ceiling. The problem has hit takings at the museum hard, with June visitor numbers nearly half of projections of 18,000 a week, and July down by more than a third on expectations. Chief executive David Reeves tells The Detail he does not know where the money will come from to cover the millions of dollars in losses and the cost of removing the asbestos. "It's a pretty serious matter. Over the last few years we've spent down our reserves, we've redeveloped the building. It's a tricky situation and the museum board are really quite concerned about it," Reeves says. Clearing the microscopic fibres will drag on the museum for years and Reeves says the $30-$40 million planned spend on the centennary celebrations in 2029 is looking uncertain, while other projects are also under review. "It's a terrible thing that the museum board and the executives have been handed," says Newsroom co-editor Tim Murphy. "They've been, out of nowhere, almost crippled in their business and their vision for the museum by asbestos dust that as it turns out is the byproduct of a poorly done renovation of decades ago where material was just left behind." Instead of the usual throng of visitors in the grand foyer and Māori Court at the museum's northern end, it is full of pipes, tubes and pumps and just a few key workers. Asbestos experts have assessed the best ways to remove the dust, which is not only in the roof cavity above the court, but on some artefacts. One possible option of lifting the roof off the museum to extract it has been eliminated, says Reeves. But getting to the source of the asbestos in the void above the court's curved glass ceiling is difficult because the space is too small for people. The likely option is that workers will take out the ornate heritage ceiling in sections but only after they have removed the precious artefacts underneath. Reeves calls the problem an octopus with more than eight tentacles. "We'll get there," he says. "Unfortunately at great cost." Contrast that with another historic Auckland building, St James Theatre off Queen Street where restoration work will start next month, with the help of $30 million in government and Auckland Council funding, after lying derelict for more than a decade. "That beautiful old theatre that three times hosted Queen Elizabeth on her royal visits and was a fantastic centrepiece for performance, music, theatre productions and cinema for years and generations will be restored," Murphy says. The funds were allocated by previous council and government and the money finally landed just weeks ago and reluctantly handed over by the current council and government. Whether Auckland needs another venue in its arts precinct on Queen Street is another question. Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here . You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter .
RNZ News
22 minutes ago
- RNZ News
How many home loan applications are turned down - and why?
In June there was $4.6 billion in new lending for property purchases across 7700 borrowers. Photo: RNZ Only a small number of people applying for home loans are being turned away - and usually there is a way to get them across the line in future, brokers and banks say. Loan Market adviser Karen Tatterson said she would normally talk to clients before she set up a meeting to understand their financial situation and whether they were in a position to go ahead with a home loan application. She said in 80-90 percent of cases, people were able to apply. "If they are not then I would normally undertake some planning with them and set out a pathway to get them in that position." That might include setting savings goals and a timeline to get to the point where they would qualify for a home loan. "I would then agree to a check in in a nominated timeframe - say three months or six months depending on their circumstances and agree to touch base with them again for a review. I often do a periodic check in to see how they are going with their plan. "Ironically most people I see or speak to are actually ready to buy. They are more often than not seeking an understanding of and support through the approval process." There was $4.6 billion in new lending for property purchases in June across 7700 borrowers. At Squirrel, chief executive David Cunningham said fewer than 5 percent of applications for a home loan were declined. "An adviser has multiple options so that would likely be materially lower than for a bank. Also, low quality deals would be less likely to be submitted by a broker." He said people were sometimes told to reduce or eliminate their personal debt and buy now pay later, and build their savings. Westpac said when an application did not meet its criteria, the bank tried to work with the customer on ways to improve their chances of success in future. "Therefore, while we can't give an exact number of customers who aren't approved for lending, the vast majority are ultimately approved. The most common reasons home loan applications may initially not be approved are that the customer does not have enough deposit, or doesn't meet our serviceability criteria to repay the loan." BNZ general manager of home lending product James Leydon said the number of applications turned down was low. "We understand how stressful buying a home can be and we want to make sure the experience is as smooth as possible. This includes letting customers know what their likelihood of being able to secure a home loan is, prior to any paperwork or formal application process kicks off. "Having an in-depth conversation upfront prior ensures our home loan partners not only understand the customers' situation at the time of enquiry but also enables them to make suggestions on how a customer can improve their financial situation and secure a pathway to home ownership." Glen Mcleod, head of Link Advisory, said most people he met were eligible to apply, even if they first believed they were not. "When we assess their situation, we explore a wide range of low-deposit purchase options, including support through Kāinga Ora's First Home Partner and the First Home Loan scheme. These initiatives are designed to help first-home buyers with smaller deposits enter the market. "It's also possible to secure a loan of up to 90 percent of the property's value through several banks, especially when clients have a live deal in place and meet affordability criteria. Some lenders may consider 95 percent lending under specific conditions, though this is less common and subject to stricter assessment. "For those just beginning their home ownership journey and who haven't yet saved a deposit, we work closely with them to build a plan. This includes strategies to grow their deposit, improve financial habits, and assess affordability. In these cases, it's rarely a 'no'-more often, it's a 'not yet'." He said sometimes people could be approved with help from family. "Ultimately, fewer than 5 percent of the people I speak with are unable to move forward. That means for the vast majority, there is a way-and we're here to help them find it." Income The income you need to be able to buy a house depends on your circumstances - banks look at things like whether you have kids, how many cars you're running and what other financial commitments you have. As a general indicator, a couple with a joint income of $150,000, two children and two cars might be able to borrow about $900,000. You'd need income of about $102,000 in that scenario to borrow $500,000. Deposit You generally can get a loan with a deposit of 10 percent, although it helps if you have a deal already signed with a seller (with a finance condition). If you're a couple earning less than $150,000 a year, a First Home Loan could be an option - this can mean you only need a 5 percent deposit. Debt Cunningham said it was common to see people with $20,000, $30,000 or $40,000 of debt. But he said it was a problem when the required repayments reduced the amount of income people had available to service the loan. People were often advised to focus hard on paying off debt before they submitted their application. "It might be that you have a flasher can than you need so you might think about trading down." He said a $5000 credit card debt might not be an issue but when there were three or four loans, it could become a problem. "The big thing is what is the repayment That's a deduction from their income." Buy now pay later could be a headache, too, he said. "For people looking to buy a house, it's not a good idea to use." Decent credit Cunningham said banks would also want to see a good credit history. If the applicant had defaulted on a debt or was frequently behind on their bills, it mighrt make it harder to get approval. It helped if there was a good explanation for why it had happened, he said. As part of the process, the lender or borrower would run a credit check that was "very comprehensive", he said. "Make sure you're taking care of all your bills and if there's something missed, make it up as soon as possible." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
