KCCI slams FBR proposals
Listen to article
President of the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI), Muhammad Jawed Bilwani, has strongly criticised the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) for what he termed its authoritarian conduct and disregard for the Business Anomalies Committee, comprising presidents of chambers and trade bodies from across Pakistan.
Following extensive consultations with its members, KCCI has launched a citywide protest by displaying banners across Karachi against what it calls "oppressive" provisions in the Finance Bill 2025-26, particularly the proposed Section 37AA in the Sales Tax Act.
"This is just the beginning," Bilwani said in a statement. "The protest will escalate, with press conferences by KCCI and other major chambers. If our demands are ignored, we may have no choice but to call for citywide or even nationwide strikes."
He dismissed the finance minister's claims of a "public-friendly" and "business-friendly" budget as detached from reality. "Industrialists and exporters unanimously agree — there is no relief." Bilwani outlined a grim outlook for the business environment, citing high energy costs, poor infrastructure, gas shortages, water scarcity, and delayed tax refunds. "Our exports survive not because of policy support, but due to the resilience of our business community. Some buyers are even advising us to shift operations to more stable, business-friendly countries."
Criticising Section 37AA as a "draconian law," he said it allows FBR to freeze bank accounts, seize funds, and arrest taxpayers based solely on suspicion, regardless of their past compliance. "Who will continue to do business under such hostile conditions?"
He revealed that many businessmen have asked KCCI to help them explore options for relocating abroad. "We still want to stay and contribute. But we need the government and prime minister to listen and give us confidence."
Bilwani stressed that this frustration is nationwide. "Faisalabad, Lahore, Sialkot — all major export hubs — are raising the same concerns."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
5 hours ago
- Express Tribune
NA passes Finance Bill with Rs463b new taxes
Listen to article The National Assembly on Thursday approved the Rs17.6 trillion worth budget along with Rs463 billion new taxes, bringing the digital economy under the purview of tax laws but almost nullified the single largest enforcement measure to ban economic transactions by ineligible persons. The National Assembly approved the second budget of the government of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif with a comfortable majority. During a voting on one clause, the coalition government mustered the support of 201 Members of the National Assembly as against 57 votes of the opposition parties. It was also the second budget presented by Minister for Finance Muhammad Aurangzeb in the National Assembly. With the approval of the assembly and subsequent assent by President Asif Ali Zardari, the Finance Act 2025 will come into effect from Tuesday. The National Assembly approved a Rs17.6 trillion budget for the fiscal year 2025-26, making the single largest allocation of Rs8.2 trillion for the interest payments. The defense spending would consume Rs2.55 trillion, the single largest expense in the budget, excluding expenses on the armed forces development programme and military pensions. The subsidies are the third biggest head with over Rs1.1 trillion allocation, followed by over Rs1 trillion for pensions, Rs1 trillion for development spending and another Rs917 billion for running the civil government. The National Assembly also approved to effectively exempt the income of Beaconhouse National University, Federal Ziauddin University, Punjab Police Welfare Organization and Army Officers Benevolent Fund and Bereaved Family Scheme from the tax. Tax on the contracts of the National Logistic Cell (NLC) has been set at a minimum of 3% of the gross value of the contracts. But if the total liability is more than the collected tax, the NLC will be charged at the normal income tax rate of 29%, according to the bill approved by the National Assembly. Arrest powers for the Federal Board of Revenue will stay in the law but with inclusion of some more safeguards, as stated by both Pakistan People's Party Bilawal Bhutto Zardari and Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar. This is the best budget that any government can give in challenging circumstances, said the chairman FBR while talking to The Express Tribune. He said some fundamental principles have been set in the budget, including creating deterrence against frauds and giving a framework for registration of taxpayers for the sales tax purposes. To discourage use of cash, the chairman FBR said that the National Assembly has approved not to give expenses' allowance in case the value of the cash payment is over Rs200,000. Likewise, the input tax adjustment has also been disallowed on cash payments of supplies beyond a certain threshold, he added. Langrial said that the foreign vendors and the digital marketplaces have also been brought under the ambit of the tax laws. The National Assembly approved Rs463 billion worth of new tax measures, including Rs36 billion that were introduced after the presentation of the budget in the National Assembly on June 12th. The biggest measures in the budget were imposing taxes, both on sales and income, on the online platforms, e-commerce, cash-on-delivery by couriers, and tax on digital services like streaming. A new climate support levy Rs2.5 per liter levy is imposed on every liter of petrol and diesel. Another new tax of 1% to 3% has been imposed on conventional fuel-based cars to subsidize electric vehicles. The pensioners have been brought in the tax net, but only annual pensions of above Rs10 million are taxed at the rate of 5%. The fourth new tax is Rs10 federal excise duty on every one-day-old chick sold in the country. The government had claimed collecting Rs389 billion in the next fiscal year on the back of the single largest enforcement measure of banning the economic transactions by the ineligible persons. The Finance Minister had warned in his post-budget press conference that if the Parliament did not pass this law then up to Rs500 billion mini-budget would have to be introduced. The government on the "instructions" by the Prime Minister has tamed down these stringent powers. The National Assembly approved that the ban on buying a residential plot or houses by an ineligible person will apply only if the value of the property is over Rs50 million. This limit is over Rs100 million for commercial plots or properties. The ineligible persons can still buy up to Rs7 million cars. The chairman FBR Rashid Langrial said that in the first step, the government has established the principle of ineligible and the limits can be revised in the future. Early this year, the FBR chairman had informed the National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance that due to almost no capacity of the FBR to audit the tax statements, the rate of success in inquiring the people about the source after making these purchases was only 3.7%. The ineligibility condition will apply only if the value of cash withdrawal from the bank account is more than Rs100 million per annum. The ineligibility condition on stock market investment would be applicable, if the cumulative investment in a year is more than Rs50 million. However, the ineligible persons cannot maintain saving accounts in the banks. The finance minister also announced to exempt a residential property owner from payment of up to 6.5% withholding tax at the time of sale, if the property is sold after retaining it for at least 15 years. The National Assembly also approved to increase the income tax rate on the income derived from the debt portion of mutual funds issued to companies from 25% to 29%. It also approved to increase the income tax rate on profit earned from giving loans to the government from 15% to 20%. The National Assembly slapped a Federal Excise Duty (FED) of Rs10 per day-old chick. The government has estimated that about 1.5 billion chicks are produced every year and it will collect Rs15 billion by taxing a product that is a common diet of the poor and the rich. The National Assembly approved 10% sales tax on the import of solar panels. Tax Fraud arrest powers The National Assembly approved to give the arrest powers to the FBR in the sales tax fraud cases after multiple rounds of negotiations between the PPP and the PML-N. According to the law passed by the National Assembly, a person cannot be arrested at the inquiry stage of the sales tax fraud. In case of arrest, the accused will have the right to get bail from the court. These two new safeguards were added after the latest round of negotiations between the PPP and the PML-N on Wednesday. Chairperson of the Pakistan Peoples Party Bilawal Bhutto Zardari said on Thursday that his party was wholeheartedly supporting the federal budget after the government accepted its demands to exempt income tax on salaried individuals earning Rs100,000 and reduce sales tax on solar panels. However, contrary to Bilawal's claim, the government has not exempted the Rs1.2 million salaried incomes from the tax. The rate of income tax on up to Rs1.2 million annual incomes will be 1%, compared to 5% before the budget, according to the bill approved by the National Assembly. The income tax on annual income of Rs1.2 million has been exempted on the PPP demand, said Bilawal Bhutto while speaking at the floor of the house. Bilawal further said that the government also agreed to the PPP's reservations about giving arrest powers to the FBR. The government agreed that the arrest powers will only be limited to sales tax forgery and at the inquiry stage no arrest will be made, said Bilawal. The tax fraud will also be a bailable offense, said the PPP chairperson while announcing his party's agreement with the government on the arrest powers. The Express Tribune reported on Thursday that the PPP had refused to vote on the bill due to a proposal to give arrest powers to the FBR. However, Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar convinced PPP to withdraw the objections. Dar also told The Express Tribune that new safeguards have been added in the Finance Act to address the PPP's concerns. The PPP chairman said that the government also increased the BISP budget by 20% on the demand of the PPP. The government has allocated Rs716 billion for the BISP for the next fiscal year.
Express Tribune
7 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PSX faces profit-taking after two days of gains
Listen to article Stocks came under selling pressure at the Pakistan bourse on Thursday as the benchmark KSE-100 index gave up early gains and closed with a drop of over 700 points amid profit-taking. At the commencement of trading, the market extended its healthy momentum of the past two days, hitting intra-day high at 123,418 within the very first hour. However, profit-taking emerged soon afterwards, which gradually took the index to intra-day low of 122,142 before the end of trading. "Stocks closed under pressure amid economic uncertainty ahead of the outcome of Pakistan-US reciprocal tariff talks to avoid potential 29% tariffs on exports," said Arif Habib Corp MD Ahsan Mehanti. Uncertainty about federal cabinet's approval of the revised Finance Bill 2025, along with concerns over tax collection targets and expanded powers for taxmen, which could affect industries, fuelled the bearish close, he added. At the end of trading, the KSE-100 index settled at 122,046.46, down 715.18 points, or 0.58%. Early gains were extended up to 123,418 before the market came off highs to close 0.58% lower day-on-day at 122,046, Arif Habib Limited (AHL) wrote in its daily report. On KSE-100, 71 stocks declined and only 27 advanced, reflecting a broadly negative sentiment. Engro Holdings (+2.22%), National Foods (+8.07%) and Pakistan Petroleum (+0.79%) were the top contributors to index gains. On the other hand, Bank AL Habib (-2.84%), Lucky Cement (-1.86%) and HBL (-2.59%) were the major drags, it said. AHL pointed out that the Supreme Court granted relief to the cement sector by suspending the Lahore High Court's directive that required Punjab-based manufacturers to pay 6% of the ex-factory price in royalty on limestone. Apart from that, The Organic Meat Company (+5.64%) announced plans to export beef casings to Europe, a significant move seen by investors as a step towards diversification and growth. "Heading into last session of the week, the KSE-100 is up 1.69%," AHL said and anticipated that 120k would continue as the support level and a base for push towards 130k. Topline Securities reported that after two consecutive sessions of strong gains, the local bourse witnessed a round of profit-taking, driven by fiscal year-end considerations and short-term portfolio rebalancing. The benchmark index saw a volatile ride, climbing as high as 656 points before slipping to the low of 715 points. It settled at 122,046, reflecting a cautious investor mood as the quarter was drawing to a close. Engro Holdings, National Foods, Pakistan Petroleum and Tariq Glass Industries provided the biggest support, adding 228 points to the index. Meanwhile, Bank AL Habib, Lucky Cement, HBL, Pakistan Services and Systems Limited dragged the index down by 407 points, it said. KTrade Securities observed that the PSX showed signs of buyers' exhaustion as investors booked profits following a recent rally driven by the US-brokered ceasefire between Iran and Israel. Selling pressure was concentrated in banking, cement and technology sectors and market sentiment remained cautiously optimistic, contingent on the ceasefire's sustainability, it mentioned. JS Global analyst Mubashir Anis Naviwala, in his review, wrote that the market opened on a positive note, touching intra-day high of 123,418 early in the session. However, broad-based profit-taking set in after two strong bullish days, which dragged the index into the red. Naviwala saw a positive near-term outlook as dips may offer attractive entry opportunities. Overall trading volumes increased to 758.5 million shares compared with Wednesday's tally of 749.8 million. The value of shares traded was Rs30 billion. Shares of 473 companies were traded. Of these, 200 stocks closed higher, 237 fell and 36 remained unchanged. Pakistan International Bulk Terminal was the volume leader with trading in 37.5 million shares, losing Rs0.06 to close at Rs8.52. It was followed by WorldCall Telecom with 33.3 million shares, falling Rs0.04 to close at Rs1.45 and Pervez Ahmed Consultancy with 33 million shares, gaining Rs0.25 to close at Rs3.29. Foreign investors sold shares worth Rs967 million, the National Clearing Company reported.
Express Tribune
7 hours ago
- Express Tribune
KCCI slams FBR proposals
Listen to article President of the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI), Muhammad Jawed Bilwani, has strongly criticised the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) for what he termed its authoritarian conduct and disregard for the Business Anomalies Committee, comprising presidents of chambers and trade bodies from across Pakistan. Following extensive consultations with its members, KCCI has launched a citywide protest by displaying banners across Karachi against what it calls "oppressive" provisions in the Finance Bill 2025-26, particularly the proposed Section 37AA in the Sales Tax Act. "This is just the beginning," Bilwani said in a statement. "The protest will escalate, with press conferences by KCCI and other major chambers. If our demands are ignored, we may have no choice but to call for citywide or even nationwide strikes." He dismissed the finance minister's claims of a "public-friendly" and "business-friendly" budget as detached from reality. "Industrialists and exporters unanimously agree — there is no relief." Bilwani outlined a grim outlook for the business environment, citing high energy costs, poor infrastructure, gas shortages, water scarcity, and delayed tax refunds. "Our exports survive not because of policy support, but due to the resilience of our business community. Some buyers are even advising us to shift operations to more stable, business-friendly countries." Criticising Section 37AA as a "draconian law," he said it allows FBR to freeze bank accounts, seize funds, and arrest taxpayers based solely on suspicion, regardless of their past compliance. "Who will continue to do business under such hostile conditions?" He revealed that many businessmen have asked KCCI to help them explore options for relocating abroad. "We still want to stay and contribute. But we need the government and prime minister to listen and give us confidence." Bilwani stressed that this frustration is nationwide. "Faisalabad, Lahore, Sialkot — all major export hubs — are raising the same concerns."
