Food drones buzzing like 'lawnmowers' over Dubliners' heads could be 'harmful', says Councillor
Food delivery drones buzzing like "lawnmowers or mopeds" over Dubliners' heads is "not acceptable", according to a Dublin City Councillor.
Cabra-Glasnevin Cllr Gayle Ralph has called for an immediate review of how drone delivery trials "align with existing planning and aviation regulations" after Deliveroo announced a new drone delivery trial yesterday with Manna, an established global drone delivery operator. The takeaway app released footage of its first-ever drone delivery — a portion of fresh sushi and sashimi from popular Japanese restaurant Musashi.
The service is currently based in Blanchardstown, and Deliveroo say they will use the initial weeks to assess how drones can help serve suburban and harder-to-reach locations. Over the coming days, people in a 3km radius of Blanchardstown will be able to order from selected restaurants including Musashi, WOWBurger, Boojum, and Elephant & Castle.
Orders can be flown to customers in as little as three minutes, the food app has claimed. Manna is also looking to trial drone deliveries from a new base in Dublin Industrial Estate in Glasnevin, according to the Dublin Inquirer, with questions persisting over noise, privacy, safety concerns, and what planning permission is needed.
Cllr Ralph said there have already been significant complaints from residents in Dublin 15 about drone noise, which has been likened to 'lawnmowers or mopeds,' with reported levels up to 65 decibels. The noise, the Fine Gael rep says, would be particularly disruptive in densely populated areas like Glasnevin.
She added that nearby Drumcondra is Ireland's Autism Friendly Town for 2025, and introducing drones would be "simply incompatible with the needs of our neurodiverse community". She said: "The announcement of Deliveroo's partnership with Manna to begin drone deliveries raises a number of concerns for me as a public representative, particularly around safety, noise pollution, and privacy.
"While I appreciate the potential innovation drones can bring to logistics and delivery services, we must not allow technological novelty to outpace the regulatory frameworks that protect our communities. Residents in Dublin 15 have already reported significant noise issues, likening the drone sounds to lawnmowers or mopeds.
"That's not acceptable in a densely populated city. The presence of cameras on these drones, regardless of their stated purpose, continues to worry many constituents.
"We need full transparency and independent verification regarding data protection, especially when such devices operate over residential areas. Drumcondra has proudly been named Ireland's Autism Friendly Town for 2025.
"Introducing drones that generate noise levels of up to 65 decibels is simply incompatible with the needs of our neurodiverse community. For autistic residents, many of whom are sensitive to sound, this disruption is not just inconvenient, it is harmful."
Cllr Ralph is calling for:
A full environmental and community impact assessment before any further expansion of drone delivery trials
Mandatory public consultation for all drone delivery operations in Dublin
A clear, enforceable framework for drone flight paths, operational hours, noise thresholds, and privacy protections
An immediate review of how these trials align with existing planning and aviation regulations.
She added: "Innovation must go hand in hand with responsibility. The public is being left somewhat in the dark, with no clear process for feedback or safeguards against noise, safety, and disruption.
"Until these concerns are properly addressed, I cannot support the widespread rollout of commercial drones over Dublin's skies." In their announcement of the partnership yesterday, Deliveroo said: "Drone deliveries can significantly cut wait times and reduce emissions, offering a faster and more sustainable alternative to traditional delivery methods, particularly suited to suburban locations where Deliveroo is looking to increase its presence."
Chief Business Officer at Deliveroo Carlo Mocci added: 'Our mission is to bring local neighbourhood favourites to as many people's doors as possible, and constantly raise the bar on the experience and service we provide - so I'm thrilled to launch drone deliveries in Dublin today. We're excited to explore how drones can help us reach new customers, complementing our existing rider model and if successful, the prospect of expanding drone deliveries across Ireland and into other markets.'
Join our Dublin Live breaking news service on WhatsApp. Click this link to receive your daily dose of Dublin Live content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
For all the latest news from Dublin and surrounding areas visit our homepage.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
16 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
US and China extend trade truce for another 90 days
US President Donald Trump has extended a trade truce with China for another 90 days, delaying once again a dangerous showdown between the world's two biggest economies. Mr Trump posted on his Truth Social platform that he signed the executive order for the extension, and that 'all other elements of the Agreement will remain the same'. Beijing at the same time also announced the extension of the tariff pause, according to the Ministry of Commerce. The US has realised it does not have the upper hand The previous deadline was set to expire at 12.01am on Tuesday. Had that happened the US could have ratcheted up taxes on Chinese imports from an already high 30%, and Beijing could have responded by raising retaliatory levies on US exports to China. The pause buys time for the two countries to work out some of their differences, perhaps clearing the way for a summit later this year between Mr Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping, and it has been welcomed by the US companies doing business with China. China said on Tuesday it would extend relief to American companies who were placed on an export control list and an unreliable entities list. After Mr Trump initially announced tariffs in April, China restricted exports of dual-use goods to some American companies, while banning others from trading or investing in China. The Ministry of Commerce said it would stop those restrictions for some companies, while giving others another 90-day extension. Reaching a pact with China remains unfinished business for Mr Trump, who has already upended the global trading system by slapping double-digit taxes – tariffs – on almost every country on earth. The EU, Japan and other trading partners agreed to lopsided trade deals with Mr Trump, accepting once unthinkably US high tariffs (15% on Japanese and EU imports, for instance) to ward off something worse. US President Donald Trump speaks with reporters in the James Brady Press Briefing Room at the White House (Alex Brandon/AP) In June, the US and China reached an agreement to ease tensions. The US said it would pull back export restrictions on computer chip technology and ethane, a feedstock in petrochemical production, and China agreed to make it easier for US firms to get access to rare earths. 'The US has realised it does not have the upper hand,' said Claire Reade, senior counsel at Arnold & Porter and former assistant US trade representative for China affairs. In May, the US and China had averted an economic catastrophe by reducing massive tariffs they'd slapped on each other's products, which had reached as high as 145% against China and 125% against the US. Those triple-digit tariffs threatened to effectively end trade between the US and China and caused a frightening sell-off in financial markets. In a May meeting in Geneva, America's tariffs went back down to a still-high 30% and China's to 10%. Ms Reade does not expect much beyond limited agreements such as the Chinese saying they will buy more American soybeans and promising to do more to stop the flow of chemicals used to make fentanyl and to allow the continued flow of rare-earth magnets. But the tougher issues will likely linger, and 'the trade war will continue grinding ahead for years into the future', said Jeff Moon, a former US diplomat and trade official.
Irish Independent
16 hours ago
- Irish Independent
US and China extend trade truce for another 90 days
Mr Trump posted on his Truth Social platform that he signed the executive order for the extension, and that 'all other elements of the Agreement will remain the same'. Beijing at the same time also announced the extension of the tariff pause, according to the Ministry of Commerce. The previous deadline was set to expire at 12.01am on Tuesday. Had that happened the US could have ratcheted up taxes on Chinese imports from an already high 30pc, and Beijing could have responded by raising retaliatory levies on US exports to China. The pause buys time for the two countries to work out some of their differences, perhaps clearing the way for a summit later this year between Mr Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping, and it has been welcomed by the US companies doing business with China. China said on Tuesday it would extend relief to American companies who were placed on an export control list and an unreliable entities list. After Mr Trump initially announced tariffs in April, China restricted exports of dual-use goods to some American companies, while banning others from trading or investing in China. The Ministry of Commerce said it would stop those restrictions for some companies, while giving others another 90-day extension. Reaching a pact with China remains unfinished business for Mr Trump, who has already upended the global trading system by slapping double-digit taxes – tariffs – on almost every country on earth. The EU, Japan and other trading partners agreed to lopsided trade deals with Mr Trump, accepting once unthinkably US high tariffs (15pc on Japanese and EU imports, for instance) to ward off something worse. ADVERTISEMENT In June, the US and China reached an agreement to ease tensions. The US said it would pull back export restrictions on computer chip technology and ethane, a feedstock in petrochemical production, and China agreed to make it easier for US firms to get access to rare earths. 'The US has realised it does not have the upper hand,' said Claire Reade, senior counsel at Arnold & Porter and former assistant US trade representative for China affairs. In May, the US and China had averted an economic catastrophe by reducing massive tariffs they'd slapped on each other's products, which had reached as high as 145pc against China and 125pc against the US. Those triple-digit tariffs threatened to effectively end trade between the US and China and caused a frightening sell-off in financial markets. In a May meeting in Geneva, America's tariffs went back down to a still-high 30pc and China's to 10pc. Ms Reade does not expect much beyond limited agreements such as the Chinese saying they will buy more American soybeans and promising to do more to stop the flow of chemicals used to make fentanyl and to allow the continued flow of rare-earth magnets. But the tougher issues will likely linger, and 'the trade war will continue grinding ahead for years into the future', said Jeff Moon, a former US diplomat and trade official.
RTÉ News
a day ago
- RTÉ News
What's the social impact of food delivery drones in Irish skies?
Analysis: There are many issues from noise to privacy which need to be considered around fast food drone deliveries in Ireland Back in 2020, a RTÉ report on Manna's new drone delivery service showed two cappuccinos being delivered by one of the company's drones in Oranmore in Co Galway. A member of the public summarises the milestone as 'this is space age!' Five years on, Manna is the leading company operating drone deliveries in urban areas in Ireland, with a service which appeals to those looking for a futuristic and novel way for ordering their takeaway pizza or coffee. Other drone delivery companies are also conducting trials and operating in Ireland. This includes Wing, operated by Google's parent company Alphabet that has conducted trials in Lusk and South Dublin and Iona, a company focused on deliveries to rural and underserved areas. From RTÉ Radio 1's Saturday with Colm Ó Mongáin, the positives and potential negatives that come with drones On its website, Manna promotes its drone delivery service as beneficial to local communities, with fast delivery, cleaner air and less traffic. They address complaints about issues of privacy by arguing that the drone cameras only operate when deliveries are being lowered. In terms of noise pollution, Manna refer to a report undertaken by Dr. John Kennedy, Associate Professor in Vibrations, Acoustics and Dynamics at Trinity College Dublin. This study analyses the noise of their drones using their Blanchardstown delivery service and claims its fly-over noise is just marginally above the noise found in a 'typical urban setting with steady traffic'. But what is the social impact of such novel technologies as they are implemented at a much faster pace than any means of adequately regulating them? Issues other than noise need to be taken into consideration when analysing this. For example, scaling up drone delivery services across cities might involve an increase in the number of drone stations similar to Manna's Blanchardstown base, which has been subject to complaints about noise and privacy intrusion. It might see the development of larger hubs, such as the Amazon drone-beehive concept, a multi-storey tower surrounded by drone launching pads and with terminals for truck delivery at ground level. While there are EU regulations on the operation of drones above 250 grams in weight or ones that record personal data (image or sound), there is a lack of information about drone flight pathways: for example, there is no drone equivalent to the flight tracking website Flightradar24. The only information available, thanks to recent EU regulations, is the geographical zone map for the usage of drones across Ireland. Safety concerns about the social impact of drones have been well documented. An academic paper from 2016 records concerns including navigation and piloting mistakes, crashes into public infrastructure (such as electricity poles), roads or private property, hijacking of their GPS systems, and the possibility of the payload becoming unattached during flight. It also points out that both the freedom from harm and the freedom from fear of harm are basic human rights. It's no surprise that local Irish communities are starting to mobilise around this issue and taking the matter into their own hands considering the lack of adequate discussion and consultation on the use of drone delivery services. Manna's plans to operate drones from other areas in Dublin, such as Dundrum and Glasnevin, have already ran into objections and opposition. Dún Laoghaire Rathdown Co Council said they have received 148 submissions over Manna's proposal to locate a new aerial delivery hub on lands to the rear of the Holy Cross Church in Dundrum. Writing on behalf of the Holy Cross Church and Pastoral Centre, Monsignor Paul Callan said their objection was on the basis of the drones potentially crating a "hostile noise environment" against the Centre's aim to offer "a quiet respite to the demands of modern life". From RTÉ Radio 1's Liveline, listeners call in to give out yards about drones Manna's counterargument is that they have support from local residents in the areas where they operate and they have submitted a letter in support of their drones to Dublin 15 local representatives signed by 400 local residents. But Cllr John Walsh, representing Castleknock in Dublin 15, launched an online petition calling on the Government to regulate commercial drone delivery services, which he said are impacting communities across Dublin 15. Walsh's petition has gathered more than 1,100 signatures to date, nearly three times the number claimed by Manna. In some cases, local communities have engaged directly with Manna to address their concerns. In the Glasnevin/Drumcondra area, the Griffith Avenue & District Residents Association has mobilised the local community and subsequently arranged a meeting with Manna to discuss and set exclusion zones from drone deliveries. All these developments highlight the pressing need for a much wider consultation process with the whole Dublin population on this matter, rather than unevenly distributed and localised interventions. It also highlights the need for more transparency and better understanding of the need and rights of citizens rather than implying that the issues can be simply resolved through technical improvements. This will become increasingly important as more innovative and 'smart' technologies are implemented in Dublin and other major urban areas in Ireland, with ever increasing autonomy and the use of AI, and all its potential issues. Most importantly, we need to be able to understand how all these technologies can impact us before they arrive unannounced at our door with a greasy takeaway.
