logo
Iran returns to talks as ‘non-declared' nuclear power

Iran returns to talks as ‘non-declared' nuclear power

Deccan Herald4 days ago
Hardly a month into the Israel-Iran ceasefire initiated by United States President Donald Trump, new attempts to kickstart talks have begun. In consultation with Washington, the three European powers (E3) — France, the United Kingdom, and Germany — who are signatories of the 2015 Iran deal (JCPOA) are trying to reopen negotiations over the limits of Iran's nuclear activities. But they are dealing with a transformed Iran — a veritable non-declared nuclear weapon State in secret possession of 409 kilogrammes of highly-enriched uranium enough to make 10 nuclear bombs, and answerable to none.Tehran's admission that the damage to its nuclear sites inflicted by the US air strikes is 'serious and severe' messages that any resumption of uranium enrichment activity as such will take time. Equally, its readiness for talks with the E3 is logical, as the countdown has begun for the expiry of the JCPOA in October, and the stage is shifting to the UN Security Council by the end of August when the European powers take the call to invoke the snapback mechanism and restore UN sanctions.Iran held consultations with the senior officials of Russia and China in Tehran last Thursday. Although Russia and China cannot exercise veto to block the snapback mechanism, they hold veto power vis-à-vis any E3 move to push the deadline for extending sanctions. Tehran expects Russia and China to prevent or mitigate the consequences of any restored sanctions.Another round of discussion with the E3 at the official level was held in Istanbul on Friday. Little emerged from the meeting, but the Iranian side said the talks were 'frank and detailed,' addressing issues including last month's war and the possible restoration of sanctions. According to Kazem Gharibabadi, Iran's deputy foreign minister, 'Both sides came to the meeting with specific ideas, the various aspects of which were examined. It was agreed that consultations on this matter will continue.' .Trump warns Iran that its nuclear sites could be bombed again.The E3 realise that there is hardly any time left to reach an agreement by the end of August, and would rather kick the can down the road by extending the timeline for actually restoring the sanctions. Against this backdrop, Manouchehr Mottaki, a former foreign minister and an influential member of the Majlis representing Tehran, has warned in an interview on Sunday that any move by the E3 to trigger the snapback mechanism of the JCPOA to pressure Tehran will instantaneously prompt the parliament to approve a motion to pull Iran out of the NPT.The main sticking point continues to be the Trump administration's insistence at Israeli behest that Iran give up enrichment of uranium altogether and Iran's refusal to do so insisting it would instead agree to strict limits on that enrichment of the kind laid out in the 2015 deal.Interestingly, some of the Europeans are reportedly less adamant so long as limits on enrichment are severe and monitored more closely than they are now. Considering that E3 is in constant consultations with Washington, the Trump administration too may have an open mind. Herein, possibly, lies the 'breakthrough' that Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi, in a recent interview with Fox News, claimed to have reached in his talks with US special envoy Steve Witkoff which the sudden Israeli attack on June 13 disrupted.Meanwhile, two related issues arise — first, the whereabouts of 408 kg of highly-enriched uranium [at 60 per cent] that Iran reportedly removed from its nuclear sites prior to the US bombing on July 22, and, second, Iran's revised parameters for any future IAEA inspection.Iran has agreed to allow a technical team from the IAEA to visit Tehran in the coming weeks 'to discuss a new modality" on future interaction but 'not to go to the [nuclear] sites.' Technical level discussions on the nitty gritty of the IAEA safeguards are time-consuming. Meanwhile, what is happening to the 409 kg of 60 per cent enriched uranium is the million dollar question. In a recent podcast, the professor emeritus of science, technology, and international security at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and a former Pentagon adviser, Theodore Postol, suggested that Iran must now be viewed in geopolitical terms as a 'non-declared nuclear weapon state', having shown in an experiment in early 2023 already that it could enrich uranium at 83.7 per cent, enough to make nuclear weapons. Postol points out that Iran now needs almost no enrichment effort to go to 90 per cent or above to produce nuclear bombs. There is no more monitoring of its production of centrifuges for the next several months at least, and each cascade can produce an estimated one bomb every 4-5 weeks. This can be done in total secrecy as no gigantic facility like Natanz is needed for it. A cascade can be installed in a room of 60 square meters with access to minimal electricity to operate the cascade — as little as 20 watts. Therefore, according to Postol, all that is needed is a small operation, if push comes to shove. In comparable circumstances, he recalled, Pakistan needed just 15 days after India tested.Truly, this is a surreal situation. Look at the interplay of light and shade where images can be truths and semi-truths or quasi-truths bordering on fakes. Trump believes Iran's nuclear sites have been 'obliterated' (quasi-truth) while Iran says US bombing inflicted 'serious and severe' damage to its nuclear site (semi-truth). The E3 plans to trigger the JCPOA's snapback mechanism because Iran has violated the 2015 deal (quasi-truth) while Iran warns that if UN sanctions are restored in any such contrived manner, it will quit NPT (truth). The E3 is exploring ways and means of deferring restoration of sanctions (truth) but Iran disfavours it (semi-truth) while Russia and China will need to co-operate with the E3 and the US in the UNSC, for which the international climate is hardly conducive (truth). Iran underscores removal of Western sanctions as an absolute prerequisite (truth) while the E3 and the US remain ambivalent (truth). Iran rules out weaponisation (half-truth) while it is already a de facto non-declared nuclear power (truth) in possession of 409 kgs of highly-enriched uranium from which an estimated 10 nuclear bombs can be made in a small operation.Enter Russian President Vladimir Putin. On Monday, Putin had a telephone conversation with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Interestingly, Putin 'expressed its willingness to facilitate in every possible way the search for negotiated solutions to the Iran nuclear issue.' This is happening even after Trump brushed aside any scope for Russian mediation. By the way, Postol also advised Israel that it is 'absolutely reckless' on its part not to believe that Iran is already a de facto nuclear weapon state. He specifically warned that any eruption of conflict may put Tel Aviv and Haifa in danger of annihilation.(M K Bhadrakumar is a former diplomat)Disclaimer: The views expressed above are the author's own. They do not necessarily reflect the views of DH.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘Everyone's a loser': From Canada to Laos, Trump's sweeping tariffs spare no one, not even the US
‘Everyone's a loser': From Canada to Laos, Trump's sweeping tariffs spare no one, not even the US

First Post

time21 minutes ago

  • First Post

‘Everyone's a loser': From Canada to Laos, Trump's sweeping tariffs spare no one, not even the US

President Donald Trump's tariff onslaught this week left a lot of losers – from small, poor countries like Laos and Algeria to wealthy US trading partners like Canada and Switzerland. They're now facing especially hefty taxes – tariffs – on the products they export to the United States starting Aug. 7. read more President Donald Trump's latest wave of sweeping tariffs is shaking the foundations of global trade and leaving a trail of economic pain across rich and poor nations alike. Countries such as Laos, Algeria, Canada and Switzerland are now facing steep levies as Trump intensifies his protectionist agenda. But while allies scramble for exemptions and rivals brace for economic fallout, but analysts say no one has truly come out ahead not even the United States. 'In many respects, everybody's a loser here,'' Barry Appleton, co-director of the Center for International Law at New York Law School told AP. Since returning to the presidency six months ago, Trump has torn up traditional trade norms, replacing multilateral agreements with a unilateral approach driven by threats and economic clout. 'The biggest winner is Trump,' said Alan Wolff, former deputy director-general of the World Trade Organization. 'He bet that he could get other countries to the table on the basis of threats, and he succeeded dramatically.'' STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Trump's tariff regime began on April 2, dubbed 'Liberation Day' when he imposed 'reciprocal' taxes of up to 50% on imports from countries with which the U.S. runs trade deficits, and a 10% baseline tax on others. Declaring the trade imbalance a national emergency under a 1977 law, Trump bypassed Congress to implement the sweeping changes, now being challenged in court. After an initial market selloff, Trump paused the new tariffs for 90 days to allow room for negotiations. Some countries took the opportunity to strike deals, though often under heavy pressure. The United Kingdom agreed to a 10% tariff, up from 1.3%, despite having maintained a trade surplus with the U.S. for nearly two decades. The European Union and Japan settled for 15%, lower than the threatened 30% and 25%, respectively. Other countries that agreed to higher tariffs include Pakistan, South Korea, Vietnam, Indonesia, and the Philippines. Even those with reduced levies compared to April levels remain far worse off than pre-Trump norms. Angola's tariffs dropped from 32% to 15%, but were below 1.5% in 2022. Taiwan saw its April rate of 32% lowered to 20%, but still faces a financial burden. '20% from the beginning has not been our goal, we hope that in further negotiations we will get a more beneficial and more reasonable tax rate,' Taiwan's President Lai Ching-te said Friday. Trump also rolled back Lesotho's tariff from 50% to 15%, but economic damage there may already be done. On the harsher end, nations that refused to bend or angered Trump in other ways got slammed. Laos and Algeria whose GDPs per capita are a fraction of America's now face tariffs of 40% and 30%, respectively. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Brazil was hit with a 50% tax, reportedly in retaliation for its treatment of former President Jair Bolsonaro. Despite a consistent U.S. trade surplus with Brazil, the tariff went ahead. Canada was slapped with a 35% import tax, a move some analysts tie to Ottawa's plan to recognise Palestinian statehood, a position contrary to Trump's strong support of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Switzerland, which didn't secure a deal, was struck with a 39% tariff, more than the 31% initially proposed. 'The Swiss probably wish that they had camped in Washington'' to make a deal, Wolff commented. 'They're clearly not at all happy.'' Trump's actions are now facing legal scrutiny. A group of American companies and a dozen states are suing, arguing that he overstepped his authority under the 1977 law. A New York court recently blocked the tariffs, but allowed collection to continue pending appeal, which may end up before the US Supreme Court. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Judges on the US Court of Appeals have expressed scepticism about the justification behind Trump's measures. 'If (the tariffs) get struck down, then maybe Brazil's a winner and not a loser,'' Appleton said. Although Trump frames tariffs as a way to tax foreign countries, in practice, U.S. importers bear the cost and pass it on to American consumers. Goldman Sachs estimates that foreign exporters have absorbed only a fifth of the tariff burden, leaving U.S. businesses and households to shoulder the rest. Major retailers and manufacturers including Walmart, Nike, and Ford — have raised prices in response. 'This is a consumption tax, so it disproportionately affects those who have lower incomes,'' said Appleton. 'Sneakers, knapsacks … your appliances are going to go up. Your TV and electronics are going to go up. Your video game devices, consoles are going to up because none of those are made in America.'' With average U.S. tariffs rising from 2.5% at the start of 2025 to 18.3% — the highest since 1934 — Yale's Budget Lab estimates the policy will cost the average American household $2,400 this year. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'The U.S. consumer's a big loser,″ Wolff concluded. With inputs from agencies

'US Tariffs Will Hurt Andhra Aqua Farmers, We Will Help Them': Chandrababu Naidu
'US Tariffs Will Hurt Andhra Aqua Farmers, We Will Help Them': Chandrababu Naidu

NDTV

time39 minutes ago

  • NDTV

'US Tariffs Will Hurt Andhra Aqua Farmers, We Will Help Them': Chandrababu Naidu

Hyderabad: Andhra Pradesh is exploring options to ensure the fallout of the US imposing 25 per cent tariffs on India does not affect the state's aqua farmers, Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu said on Saturday. Addressing farmers for the first time since US President Donald Trump announced the tariff hike, Mr Naidu in his first comment on the US tariff hike said the state government is supporting aqua farmers by giving them electricity at 1.50 paise per unit. "The increase in tariffs in America will burden the aqua farmers in the state," he said. "We have taken note of the matter and we will discuss it with farmers in a day or two. Then we will make an action plan." The chief minister said fishermen were given Rs 10,000 earlier. "But now we will give Rs 20,000 each. We have given financial aid to 1.30 lakh people under the Matsyakarula Sevalo," he added. Prime Minister Narendra Modi has also said the welfare of farmers, small industries and young people remains the government's "top priority" as the country stays on track to become the world's third-largest economy. At an event in Uttar Pradesh's Varanasi, his Lok Sabha constituency, the prime minister reaffirmed the resilience of the Indian economy amid turbulence triggered by the US tariff hike, saying India must remain vigilant about its economic interests and adopt "swadeshi (indigenous)" products. "There is an atmosphere of global instability. All countries are focusing on their individual interests. India is going to become the third biggest economy in the world and this is why India will have to stay alert as far as its economic interests are concerned," PM Modi said. Apart from the tariffs, Mr Trump announced a penalty on India for buying Russian oil.

Ukraine Uncovers Major Drone Procurement Corruption Scheme
Ukraine Uncovers Major Drone Procurement Corruption Scheme

NDTV

time39 minutes ago

  • NDTV

Ukraine Uncovers Major Drone Procurement Corruption Scheme

Kyiv: Ukraine's anti-corruption bodies said on Saturday they had uncovered a major graft scheme that procured military drones and signal jamming systems at inflated prices, two days after the agencies' independence was restored following major protests. The independence of Ukraine's anti-graft investigators and prosecutors, NABU and SAPO, was reinstated by parliament on Thursday after a move to take it away resulted in the country's biggest demonstrations since Russia's invasion in 2022. In a statement published by both agencies on social media, NABU and SAPO said they had caught a sitting lawmaker, two local officials and an unspecified number of national guard personnel taking bribes. None of them were identified in the statement. "The essence of the scheme was to conclude state contracts with supplier companies at deliberately inflated prices," it said, adding that the offenders had received kickbacks of up to 30% of a contract's cost. Four people had been arrested. "There can only be zero tolerance for corruption, clear teamwork to expose corruption and, as a result, a just sentence," President Volodymyr Zelenskiy wrote on Telegram. Zelenskiy, who has far-reaching wartime presidential powers and still enjoys broad approval among Ukrainians, was forced into a rare political about-face when his attempt to bring NABU and SAPO under the control of his prosecutor-general sparked the first nationwide protests of the war. Zelenskiy subsequently said that he had heard the people's anger and submitted a bill restoring the agencies' former independence, which was voted through by parliament on Thursday. Ukraine's European allies praised the move, having voiced concerns about the original stripping of the agencies' status. Top European officials had told Zelenskiy that Ukraine was jeopardising its bid for European Union membership by curbing the powers of its anti-graft authorities. "It is important that anti-corruption institutions operate independently, and the law adopted on Thursday guarantees them every opportunity for a real fight against corruption," Zelenskiy wrote on Saturday after meeting the heads of the agencies, who briefed him on the latest investigation.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store