Family of girl who died at Irish college seek review of CHI care
Children's Health Ireland
(CHI).
After waiting four months for a response, Amelia Belle Ferguson's family received a list of answers to their questions from CHI last week. But they say they have more questions about their daughter's care.
Suzi Mangan and Brian Ferguson, Amelia's parents, and Amelia's sister Poppy held a protest with the support of friends and family outside the Department of Health last week. They called for more transparency and scrutiny of the care she received and the information CHI shared with them in the final months of her life.
Amelia died after collapsing while out on a walk during her time at an Irish college in Co Galway last summer. Her heart had been beating in chaotic rhythms and ultimately failed. Since she was a baby she had been receiving care from CHI for a pre-existing condition with her heart that meant she required a pacemaker.
READ MORE
Suzi Mangan and her daughter Poppy Ferguson hold a photo of Suzi's older daughter Amelia Belle Ferguson, who died in June 2024. Photograph: Bryan O'Brien
Ms Mangan said the family had raised concerns with CHI about whether issues raised at what would become Amelia's final appointment in May 2024 should have been taken more seriously. The family also say they only learned important details about her health records after she died.
Despite what Ms Mangan said were concerns raised at Amelia's last appointment, CHI would later send a letter saying her cardiovascular examination that day was 'normal'. It arrived on the day of Amelia's funeral. CHI has apologised to the family for the letter.
The family first formally sought answers to a series of questions about Amelia's care in April of this year, giving CHI four weeks to respond. Ms Mangan said she received a lengthy response from CHI the day before the demonstration was scheduled to take place outside the Department of Health.
[
A Gaeltacht tragedy: 'I never would have sent her if I thought anything was wrong'
Opens in new window
]
'I believe they only responded because they knew the protest was happening and the answers I received are inadequate,' Ms Mangan said.
'The answers I received didn't actually answer all of my questions, they are vague and some are just about their general protocols but not actually what I asked in relation to Amelia's individual case.
'It shouldn't have to be like this.
'We need honesty, transparency, accountability, and internal and external investigations done if a child dies under their care,' Ms Mangan said. 'Families shouldn't have to go through this horrendous system.'
Amelia Belle Ferguson in 2023: Photograph: Ferguson family
A spokeswoman for CHI said the hospital group would support a request from the family for an inquest into Amelia's death. But Ms Mangan said she does not want an inquest, but a specific external review of how the case was handled by CHI.
CHI had previously said it could not 'provide details about the care provided to individual patients publicly', but that it remained committed to working with her family 'to answer any and all questions they have about Amelia's care with us'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
We Don't Use Words Like ‘Crazy': Irish readers will find many points of comparison to this insider's view of the crumbling NHS
We Don't Use Words Like 'Crazy': On The Frontline of Mental Health Author : Elliot Sweeney ISBN-13 : 978-1785122064 Publisher : Blink Publishing Guideline Price : £20 'In mental health , it's not hard to get away with bad practice,' Elliot Sweeney ruefully notes of his chosen career . A nurse in this field for 20 years, he is ideally placed to comment on how some in the profession, are 'more interested in cutting corners, publishing papers and booking holidays than doing some good', while also sympathetic to how difficult the work is, and the gaping holes in provision. The term 'firefighting' is repeated. Sweeney writes specifically of the crumbling NHS , but Irish readers will find many points of comparison with overextended mental health services here, and understand that 'without gallows humour, the bleakness would overwhelm'. READ MORE Some reminders – for example, that mental health is 'a serious business' – may feel a tad obvious to younger generations, used to a certain amount of lip service on this issue, but Sweeney jumps right into the less palatable cases. A mother poisoning her children, suffering from factitious disorder, more colloquially known as Munchhausen's by proxy (a diagnosis medical dramas and crime novels are fond of), is not an immediately sympathetic character. Nor is someone wielding a knife in public – knowing that severe mental illness means one is more likely to be the victim of, rather than perpetrator of, violence does not magic away the real danger of such moments. Sweeney is aware of the tensions between an individual's agency and the risk they pose to themselves or others; with a novelist's eye, he shows rather than tells of the bind health professionals often find themselves in. He knows the system is broken and how many have fled; he's still there. His case studies – careful composites, as is the usual practice in books of this kind – illustrate a variety of suffering and labels, and explore what it means to help in such cases. Sometimes he can't. One particularly volatile patient demonstrates how essential professional boundaries are. [ 'Immense progress': Use of restraint and seclusion in mental health centres falls Opens in new window ] Psychiatrists tend to be the ones writing memoirs such as these; nurses – those who are 'hauled in for answers' if something goes wrong – are less represented. This is a welcome addition to the mental-health-workplace canon from someone not yet burned out: 'Beneath the crackle and static of paranoia,' he writes, 'I hear the pathos of a human in pain. It's this I try to focus on.'
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Prison cells likely to be fitted with remote monitors following spike in inmate deaths
Irish prison cells are likely to be fitted with remote 'signs of life' monitors in the near future following a sharp increase in inmate deaths last year. The 'non-intrusive' technology will alert prison staff if an inmate shows signs of a medical emergency. It will be rolled out on a trial basis by the Irish Prison Service (IPS), with Limerick and Cloverhill prisons as the potential first sites, with a view to then introducing it to the wider prison estate. The IPS is currently obtaining advice on the legal implications of such technology. READ MORE The move follows concerns raised by the Office of Inspector of Prisons about a dramatic increase in the deaths of people in custody last year. There were a record 22 deaths in prison custody in 2024, an 83 per cent increase on the previous year. A further nine people died while on temporary release. Preliminary figures for 2025 shows the increase has stabilised somewhat. In the first seven months of the year, eight people died in custody, according to figures provided by the Office of the Inspector of Prisons. One further inmate died after suffering a medical emergency in an open prison and was being transferred to hospital while another died while on temporary release. [ Prison service embarks on €400m building project to ease overcrowding Opens in new window ] The IPS has told the prison watchdog it has established a working group to examine the technology. Photograph: Alan Betson/ The Irish Times The inspectorate has repeatedly criticised the manner in which in the IPS monitors vulnerable inmates. Staff sometimes fail to check on prisoners regularly and have on occasion falsified monitoring records, according to various inspectorate reports. In its most recent report, which concerns the death of a severely mentally-ill Spanish resident in Cloverhill Prison , the inspectorate recommended the introduction of 'remote monitoring of vital signs technology' to improve healthcare monitoring. Similar recommendations were made in relation to the death of another prisoner in 2024. In response, the IPS told the prison watchdog it has established a working group to examine the technology and that Cloverhill and Limerick have been identified as potential sites for a pilot project. It said it was currently undertaking market research to 'identify a product which can provide minimally invasive monitoring of prisoner life signs'. It is also awaiting legal advice from the Chief State Solicitors Office regarding the legality of installing the technology in cells housing vulnerable prisoners, including close supervision cells and special observation cells. A IPS spokesman said on Thursday this assessment was ongoing. Such technology typically monitors several health indicators, including movement, breathing heartbeat and can provide early warning of a medical emergency. It can also monitor signs a prisoner is engaging in self-harm. Last year, Chief Inspector of Prisons Mark Kelly said remote monitoring would be helpful in monitoring prisoners who may have ingested drugs to smuggle them into prison. Relying on a prisoner's cellmate to raise the alarm if they have a medical emergency is not sufficient, he said. 'Nor is visual observation by prison staff from outside their cells always sufficient to detect a risk to life.'
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
A sting in the tail of summer: Are there more biting insects in Ireland these days?
With Ireland's long warm summer attracting more people outdoors , getting bitten by insects – or stung by wasps and bees – can be painful and have debilitating consequences. Many of us have experience of the discomfort of getting bitten abroad in sunnier climes, but has the warmest and sunniest Irish spring on record , followed by some very hot July and August days in parts of the country, resulted in more biting insects here than usual? While heat accelerates the development of eggs and larvae, resulting in faster breeding cycles for many insects, and warm and sunny days encourage more movement of bees, wasps and other flying insects, rain and wind can quickly destroy their habitats. So, it's too early to say if the 2025 weather conditions in Ireland drastically increased the number of insects. But the warm sunny days certainly encouraged humans out of doors much more, increasingly their likelihood of being bitten by horseflies, midges and perhaps even mosquitoes, or stung by bees or wasps. The warm weather also means that doors and windows are also left open more often – attracting more insects indoors. READ MORE How best can I avoid being bitten by flying insects or stung by wasps or bees? The best way to avoid being bitten by mosquitoes, midges and horseflies is to cover up, especially when walking in fields, parks, woodlands and boglands. Keeping to footpaths and avoiding long grass reduces your chances of coming into contact with insects close to the ground. Wearing long trousers (lightweight hiking trousers are perfect, even on warm sunny days) with socks and shoes and long-sleeved tops gives flying insects little access to skin. Bees and wasps are attracted to sweet-smelling foods and drinks, so when picnicking outdoors, it's important to keep food and drink covered and to remain vigilant when eating and drinking. Don't camp close to ponds or stagnant water as these can be areas where horseflies and mosquitoes proliferate. Dr Diarmuid Quinlan: 'Bees leave a barb in your skin so it's important to scrape it out' Dr Diarmuid Quinlan , medical director of the Irish College of General Practitioners , advises people to wear light-coloured clothing and to avoid strong-smelling perfumes to deter insects. He also recommends adults pay close attention to young children when families are able to eat outside in the summer months on beaches, in gardens or in parks. 'Wasps can easily get into a glass bottle or a can, or land on an ice cream, so it's important to be conscious of young children when eating and drinking outdoors,' he says. People who are particularly prone to getting bitten should use insect repellent sprays just before going outdoors. Repellents that contain 50 per cent DEET (diethyltoluamide) are most effective, but the American Environmental Protection Agency also recommends oil of the lemon eucalyptus tree as a plant-based alternative. [ 14 tips to prevent and treat insect bites and stings Opens in new window ] How will I know if I have an insect bite or a bee/wasp sting? The general symptoms of bites and stings are pain, swelling and itchiness. 'Most people will recover in a few hours, but bees leave a barb in your skin so it's important to scrape it out with the edge of a nail or a bank card,' Dr Quinlan explains. Ticks also remain attached to the skin and must be removed very carefully using tweezers, making sure to remove all of it. What is the best way to treat an insect bite or a sting? The treatment for insect bites and bee/wasp stings is the same, according to Paul Kelly from Kelly's pharmacy in Tramore, Co Waterford. The area around an insect bite or bee/wasp sting should be cleaned and kept clean to avoid it becoming infected. A cold compress can be placed on the bite or sting for about 20 minutes to reduce the swelling. 'The body releases histamines, so if there is a lot of swelling, take oral antihistamines to help reduce the swelling,' he says. Dr Quinlan advises: 'Anti-histamines are very safe and effective medicines which work fast and are absorbed into the body within 20 minutes.' Anti-inflammatory topical treatments such as hydrocortisone cream will also help minimise itchiness, redness and swelling. Over-the-counter pain-relieving medications can be used to counter the effects of particularly painful bites, such as those from a horsefly. [ Heat wave advice: How to look after your pet, garden and family in the hot weather Opens in new window ] Although it can be difficult, it is best to avoid scratching the surface of the bite or sting as this can open the wound and so increase the risk of infection. Broken skin which becomes further inflamed can, in rare cases, develop into cellulitis and require treatment with antibiotics. According to the HSE, cellulitis is a common bacterial skin infection that's treated with antibiotics. It can be serious if it's not treated. The HSE online fact sheet on treating bites and stings advises people not to use home remedies such as bicarbonate of soda and vinegar as treatment for insect bites or bee/wasp stings. Mosquitoes in Ireland don't carry diseases such as West Nile virus and dengue, which are circulating via mosquitoes in southern European countries. What if I suddenly feel nauseous, dizzy and feverish after an insect bite or sting? Uncommonly, someone can have an allergic reaction to a bee sting or insect bite. If you feel suddenly nauseous, dizzy or feverish, or if you have a fast heart rate, swollen mouth, lips, tongue or throat and difficulty swallowing or breathing, call 112 or 999 or go to your nearest emergency department.
