Educationists question revisions in 3-language policy: How can schools adjust to frequent changes?
The government's announcement of the formation of a new committee for fresh recommendations on the issue has left many of them baffled, as unit tests are only a month away.
Teachers have urged the government to wait until the next academic year before implementing any new decisions.
After multiple revisions, the Maharashtra government on Sunday halted the three-language policy by revoking two contentious Government Resolutions (GRs) issued in this regard.
As Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis made the announcement, he also informed about the formation of a new committee headed by Dr Narendra Jadhav to further analyse the policy of introducing a third language in Classes 1 to 5 of Marathi and English medium schools under the Maharashtra State Board.
Questioning the government's intentions, Mahendra Ganpule, former head of the Maharashtra School Principals Association, said, 'The state is simply playing with the future of lakhs of young children. From the imposition of Hindi as the third language to making it optional and changing its learning goals, the government has altered its stance multiple times on the third language—so much so that it also included readjusting the timetable structure for schools.'
'It is not easy to fix a timetable for any school, which is generally finalised well before schools reopen after the summer break. But in June, a new structure was imposed to accommodate the third language, and now there is a pause on its implementation. How are schools expected to adjust to these frequent changes,' he asked.
Ganpule highlighted how some schools might have had to rejig their timetable to match the new structure issued by the State Council for Educational Research and Training (SCERT), which now requires another revision.
'When will they focus on academics?' he questioned, pointing out that unit tests are approaching in August.
The state's school education department initially introduced the third language in Class 1 and made it mandatory to teach Hindi. Following backlash, a revised order stated that students could opt for any other language in place of Hindi, but a teacher would be provided only if there were at least 20 students in a class requesting the alternative—thereby making Hindi the default third language. While opposition continued, School Education Minister Dada Bhuse later announced that in Classes 1 and 2, the third language would focus only on spoken skills, and the reading/writing component would be introduced in Class 3.
Finally, the Chief Minister halted the entire process on Sunday by revoking the two GRs.
'Although the Chief Minister has announced the cancellation of the 'Three Languages from Grade 1' directive, considering past experiences, it is difficult to place trust in this,' said Dr. Madhav Suryavanshi, Chief Coordinator, Education Development Forum, Yashwantrao Chavan Center.
He added, 'Previously, despite public assurances by the Chief Minister and the Education Minister that three languages would not be made mandatory from Grade 1, the government ultimately implemented the decision to mandate three languages from Grade 1 from this academic year. Unless an official order is issued cancelling the 'Three Languages from Grade 1' decision, this government's stance cannot be trusted.'
Questioning the urgency, senior educationist Vasant Kalpande urged the state government to wait until the next academic year. 'This academic year has already started. Instead of disturbing it, it will be better if the government takes time to make a final decision. A new committee is set to study the three-language policy. They should be given time for a thorough study, and their recommendations should be made public for suggestions and objections before a final decision is taken.'
Kalpande further emphasised that when educational decisions are made without taking into confidence all those concerned with the decision, then those become issues of identity. 'When educational issues take on the form of linguistic, caste-based, religious, or cultural identity matters, political interference becomes inevitable. This is exactly what happened in the case of this arbitrarily made decision. It can be avoided if adequate time is spent to follow the procedure.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
10 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Senior Chinese diplomat Liu Jianchao taken in for questioning: Report
Liu Jianchao, a senior Chinese diplomat widely seen as a potential future foreign minister, has been taken away by authorities for questioning, the Wall Street Journal reported on Sunday. His detention marks the highest-level probe involving a diplomat since China ousted its former foreign minister and President Xi Jinping's protégé, Qin Gang.(AFP File Photo) Liu was taken away after returning to Beijing in late July from an overseas work trip, WSJ reported, citing people familiar with the matter. China's State Council Information Office, which handles media queries for the Chinese government, and the Chinese Communist Party International Liaison Department did not immediately respond to Reuters' request for comment. Liu, 61, has led the Communist Party's body in charge of managing ties with foreign political parties. Since taking the role in 2022, he has travelled to more than 20 nations and met officials from more than 160 countries. Liu's busy schedule, especially his meetings with the former U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken in Washington, stoked expectations that the former ambassador and ministry spokesman was being groomed to be the next foreign minister. His detention marks the highest-level probe involving a diplomat since China ousted its former foreign minister and President Xi Jinping's protégé, Qin Gang, in 2023 following rumours of an extramarital affair. Born in the northeastern province of Jilin, Liu majored in English at Beijing Foreign Studies University and studied international relations at Oxford before taking up his first post as a translator with the foreign ministry. He has served in China's mission to Britain and later as ambassador to Indonesia and the Philippines. During his time as ministry spokesman, he was known for humorous off-the-cuff comments while making a no-nonsense defence of China's interests.
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
Experts express concern over declining Kannada medium schools in Karnataka
BENGALURU: The All-Karnataka Unaided Private Educational Institutions Association has urged the State Government to take immediate steps to protect Kannada medium schools and relax strict regulations imposed on them. Association state president Revanasiddappa Jalade and state honorary president CN Bhan-dari said that thousands of Kannada schools have shut down in the last 9–10 years due to 'excessive government rules'. 'Rural students are losing access to affordable education in their mother tongue because the state is not filling teacher vacancies and not providing basic facilities,' said Jalade. The forum alleged that many private Kannada medium schools have become weak and unsustainable. 'Our mother tongue must survive, and so must Kannada schools. But government negligence is leading to their decline,' they said. The association submitted a petition to the CM and the Education Minister demanding measures, including subsidising private institutions set up after 1995, simplifying conditions for starting Kannada schools, easing permission renewal processes, re-implementing the RTE for private schools, filling vacancies in aided institutions, curbing unauthorised coaching centres, and halting the replacement of Kannada schools with English-medium Karnataka Public Scho-ols. 'Our demands are simple: appoint teachers, provide infrastr-ucture, and protect Kannada medium education,' they said. The association will protest at Freedom Park on August 19.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
School entry age to remain 5 years, says TN education secretary B Chandra Mohan; SEP aims for future ready, inclusive learning
Tamil Nadu's school education policy prioritizes future-readiness through a two-language approach, conceptual clarity, and life skills. The entry age remains at five, and the existing 10+2 system continues. School entry age will continue to be five years, says school education secretary B Chandra Mohan . In an interview to TOI on Saturday, a day after the release of the state education policy (SEP) for school education, he discusses the objectives of the policy, how the govt plans to achieve them, and addresses criticism that the SEP is similar to the national education policy (NEP). Edited excerpts: ■ What is the objective of the state education policy? You Can Also Check: Chennai AQI | Weather in Chennai | Bank Holidays in Chennai | Public Holidays in Chennai To build an inclusive, equitable, resilient, and future-ready school education system in Tamil Nadu. Technology is changing, requirements are changing, and the socioeconomic profile of the state is changing. Artificial intelligence is going to change everything as we know it. We have to prepare children for the future, though we may not anticipate everything that will happen. Making our children future-ready is the focus of the SEP and the vision behind it. ■ How do you plan to achieve it? Many ways. The two-language policy will connect us to our culture, roots and identity, giving us a context to who we are, where we come from and what we want to achieve. It helps us understand the societal context and lived reality of our people. English proficiency will help us connect to and navigate the world, opening doors of opportunity and progress. Focus on conceptual clarity, contextual application of concepts, scientific temper, experiential learning, problem solving and working with diverse teams are skills that will help. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Use an AI Writing Tool That Actually Understands Your Voice Grammarly Install Now Undo Physical education for fitness and health. Life skills will help sharpen students' minds and prepare them to face real-life challenges with confidence and adaptability. ■ Educationists say the SEP doesn't have broader ideas related to school education. Access to schools was the primary concern of govts for the last many years. Now, the focus is on quality and transformational education. ■ There's criticism that the SEP appears to be similar to NEP except for a few provisions. In the educational discourse anywhere in the world, classifications such as primary, upper primary, secondary, and higher secondary are standard. The inputs at these levels are defined by appropriate learning outcomes. There may be some overlaps in some aspects. For example, children from Class I to III have to learn basic literacy and numeracy. This is not only at the national level, but across the world. The difference is in what kind of emphasis you are giving, what is the content you are teaching, and how you contextualise it. Every child will learn about his village, district, state, nation, culture, mores, festivals, arts, history and this will enable him to stay connected to his roots and build character and identity. ■ SEP for school education does not mention early childhood education. The original report is much larger containing three sections – early childhood education, school education, and higher education. We have now brought out the school education part. The departments concerned are working on the other parts and will shortly be releasing them. ■ NEP mentions six years as the school entry age. Tamil Nadu follows five years. What will it be now? What exists and is being practised has evolved over a period of time as per local needs. The age of school entry will continue to be five years. There are many such things we have been following, which we will continue to follow. ■ NEP also mentions the new school education system of 5+3+3+4. But, the SEP says there will be only board exams from Class X onwards, and it indicates that the 10+2 system is to be continued. As I said, whatever we are currently following, we will continue to follow. ■ SEP stresses assessment reforms. Are open-book exams a possibility in the near future? We are due for the regular review of the school curriculum. We will basically ensure that the curriculum is redesigned and rationalised with focus being future skills, strong conceptual understanding, problem solving skills, scientific temper, climate literacy, digital literacy, and financial literacy. When you are revamping the curriculum, it becomes necessary and essential to change your assessment tools to check whether these objectives are achieved or not. So, we are planning to revamp the assessment system. Details will be worked out by the State Council for Educational Research and Training (SCERT) and the Directorate of Government Examinations in consultation with experts. ■ How does the policy plan to eradicate drug abuse, caste violence, and sexual abuse from school campuses? In the SEP, there is an entire chapter that talks about safe, inclusive schools and holistic child development. We want to ensure, through various strategies, that schools become institutions of social integration. Especially now, we are seeing caste-based issues cropping up in schools. The govt has taken a firm view that this is not acceptable. We will ensure that the learning and activity are so designed that children learn, play, and grow together with mutual respect and work as a team based on diversity. We will also ensure gender-sensitive, child-friendly infrastructure in the schools. We also want to improve the mental health and emotional well-being of students. ■ Some also criticise that the existing schemes are given as solutions to future problems. How do you respond to this? A new policy does not mean that it negates everything that was done in the past. A good policy builds on what was done in the past, learns lessons, and reimagines them for the future. That is what this policy is designed to do. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
