Louisiana environmental activist loses freedom of speech lawsuit against parish officials
NEW ORLEANS (AP) — Louisiana parish officials who threatened to arrest and imprison an environmental activist as she attempted to speak during a public meeting did not violate her right to freedom of speech, a unanimous civil jury ruled Wednesday.
Joy Banner had sought more than $2 million in damages from two St. John the Baptist parish officials — Parish President Jaclyn Hotard and councilmember Michael Wright — who she said blocked her from raising allegations of corruption tied to industrial development at a public meeting. While Banner's attorneys said the case had important implications for protecting outspoken citizens from government censorship, lawyers representing the parish said they were model officials trying to curtail disruption and keep the meeting on track.
The case is part of a broader series of disputes playing out in courts and public hearings between grassroots community groups and Louisiana officials over industrial expansion in the 85-mile (136-kilometer) chemical corridor between Baton Rouge and New Orleans, often referred to by environmental activists as 'Cancer Alley" because of its high pollution levels.
Banner, co-founder of the environmental and racial justice organization The Descendants Project, gained a national reputation fighting against an $800 million grain terminal slated for her predominantly Black community in St. John the Baptist parish. The project was later aborted.
In a November 2023 parish council meeting, Banner sought to oppose an agenda item introduced by Hotard to use taxpayer funds for a lawyer to defend parish officials from ethics complaints. The state ethics board had launched an investigation after Banner filed a complaint pointing out that Hotard's mother-in-law, Darla Gaudet, owned a marine transport company that owned land near the proposed site for the grain terminal.
As Banner began to discuss these concerns during the public comment period, councilmember Michael Wright repeatedly banged his gavel and both he and Hotard told Banner she was not speaking on topic as she made her remarks.
Wright then quoted from an obsolete law under which anyone who publicly shared testimony given to a state ethics board investigation could be subject to one year of imprisonment. A federal judge deemed the law unconstitutional years ago.
'When I heard the words imprisonment and misdemeanor, I thought, 'That's it, I'm going to jail, I've messed everything up, my business is going to be ruined, my name is going to be ruined.' I was terrified and shocked," Banner later testified.
Ike Spears, the parish officials' attorney, noted that they had also interrupted and instructed to stay on topic other members of the public who spoke during the public comment period. He described Banner as a 'disruptive citizen' striving to become a 'social media influencer' and garner media attention from the litigation.
'She wants us to reward this conduct with $2 million plus,' Spears told jurors.
Banner's attorney William Most countered that her intended comments at the public meeting were 'vital' to informing the parish about Hotard's potential conflicts of interest.
'Joy Banner was treated differently than anyone else: She was the only person threatened with arrest and she was also the only one to raise the issue of Hotard's family business interests,' Most said. 'She was directly on topic."
Hotard also used vitriolic language to describe Banner, including fantasizing about strangling her, in text messages to her mother-in-law that were introduced as evidence. Most said the messages indicated that Hotard had a personal motivation to shut down Banner's participation in a public meeting.
The state ethics board ruled last year that Hotard had not violated state ethics laws.
Yet Hotard's mother-in-law later revealed during a deposition for Banner's lawsuit that Hotard's husband is a beneficiary of a trust that owned land overlapping with the planned railroad route leading into the proposed grain terminal.
Spears acknowledged that Hotard would 'probably' personally benefit from the grain terminal's approval. But he said increased tax revenue and good-paying jobs were the parish president's driving motivation in supporting the project.
Hotard, who was not present for the verdict, did not respond to an emailed request for comment.
The jury sent a 'strong message against frivolous lawsuits,' Wright said in an emailed statement to The Associated Press. 'This is a significant victory for St. John Parish and a promising sign for businesses and industries considering the River Parishes as their home.'
Juror Cam Owen said he was ready to vote in Banner's favor following closing arguments. He changed his mind — and came to tears during deliberations — after closely reviewing the facts and video footage of the public meeting, which he described as the 'deciding factor" for the jury. Owen said jurors calculated the amount of time Banner was able to speak and concluded she was able to express most of her viewpoint.
'At the end of the day, you know, they did try to stop her, but she did actually say what she had to say,' Owen said.
The jury also ruled that the parish had not violated Louisiana's open meetings law.
Banner said she had no regrets about bringing the lawsuit and said it uncovered the parish president's hidden financial interests.
'The purpose of this case was for transparency,' Banner said. 'I think it's important to hold people accountable for the things that we feel are wrong.'
'I hope you can heal,' Eastern District of Louisiana Judge Nannette Jolivette Brown told Banner and the parish officials after the verdict. 'This is only one part of the process.'
___
Brook is a corps member for The Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues. Follow Brook on X: @jack_brook96.
Jack Brook, The Associated Press
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
an hour ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Friends say Minnesota shooting suspect was deeply religious and conservative
NEW YORK (AP) — The man accused of assassinating the top Democrat in the Minnesota House held deeply religious and politically conservative views, telling a congregation in Africa two years ago that the U.S. was in a 'bad place' where most churches didn't oppose abortion. Vance Luther Boelter, 57, was at the center of a massive multistate manhunt on Sunday, a day after authorities say he impersonated a police officer and gunned down former House Speaker Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark, in their home outside Minneapolis. Democratic Gov. Tim Walz described the shooting as 'a politically motivated assassination.' Sen. John Hoffman, also a Democrat, and his wife, Yvette, were shot earlier by the same gunman at their home nearby but survived. Friends and former colleagues interviewed by The Associated Press described Boelter as a devout Christian who attended an evangelical church and went to campaign rallies for President Donald Trump. Records show Boelter registered to vote as a Republican while living in Oklahoma in 2004 before moving to Minnesota where voters don't list party affiliation. Near the scene at Hortman's home, authorities say they found an SUV made to look like those used by law enforcement. Inside they found fliers for a local anti-Trump 'No Kings' rally scheduled for Saturday and a notebook with names of other lawmakers. The list also included the names of abortion rights advocates and health care officials, according to two law enforcement officials who could not discuss details of the ongoing investigation and spoke to AP on condition of anonymity. Both Hortman and Hoffman were defenders of abortion rights at the state legislature. Drew Evans, superintendent of the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, said at a briefing on Sunday that Boelter is not believed to have made any public threats before the attacks. Evans asked the public not to speculate on a motivation for the attacks. 'We often want easy answers for complex problems,' he told reporters. 'Those answers will come as we complete the full picture of our investigation.' Friends told the AP that they knew Boelter was religious and conservative, but that he didn't talk about politics often and didn't seem extreme. "He was right-leaning politically but never fanatical, from what I saw, just strong beliefs,' said Paul Schroeder, who has known Boelter for years. A glimpse of suspect's beliefs on abortion during a trip to Africa Boelter, who worked as a security contractor, gave a glimpse of his beliefs on abortion during a trip to the Democratic Republic of Congo in 2023. While there, Boelter served as an evangelical pastor, telling people he had first found Jesus as a teenager. 'The churches are so messed up, they don't know abortion is wrong in many churches,' he said, according to an online recording of one sermon from February 2023. Still, in three lengthy sermons reviewed by the AP, he only mentioned abortion once, focusing more on his love of God and what he saw as the moral decay in his native country. He appears to have hidden his more strident beliefs from his friends back home. 'He never talked to me about abortion,' Schroeder said. 'It seemed to be just that he was a conservative Republican who naturally followed Trump.' A married father with five children, Boelter and his wife own a sprawling 3,800-square-foot house on a large rural lot about an hour from downtown Minneapolis that the couple bought in 2023 for more than a half-million dollars. Seeking to reinvent himself He worked for decades in managerial roles for food and beverage manufacturers before seeking to reinvent himself in middle age, according to resumes and a video he posted online. After getting an undergraduate degree in international relations in his 20s, Boelter went back to school and earned a master's degree and then a doctorate in leadership studies in 2016 from Cardinal Stritch University, a private Catholic college in Wisconsin that has since shut down. While living in Wisconsin, records show Boelter and his wife Jenny founded a nonprofit corporation called Revoformation Ministries, listing themselves as the president and secretary. After moving to Minnesota about a decade ago, Boelter volunteered for a position on a state workforce development board, first appointed by then-Gov. Mark Dayton, a Democrat, in 2016, and later by Democratic Gov. Tim Walz. He served through 2023. In that position, he may have crossed paths with one of his alleged victims. Hoffman served on the same board, though authorities said it was not immediately clear how much the two men may have interacted. Launching a security firm Records show Boelter and his wife started a security firm in 2018. A website for Praetorian Guard Security Services lists Boelter's wife as the president and CEO while he is listed as the director of security patrols. The company's homepage says it provides armed security for property and events and features a photo of an SUV painted in a two-tone black and silver pattern similar to a police vehicle, with a light bar across the roof and 'Praetorian' painted across the doors. Another photo shows a man in black tactical gear with a military-style helmet and a ballistic vest with the company's name across the front. In an online resume, Boelter also billed himself as a security contractor who worked oversees in the Middle East and Africa. On his trip to the Democratic Republic of Congo, he told Chris Fuller, a friend, that he had founded several companies focused on farming and fishing on the Congo River, as well as in transportation and tractor sales. 'It has been a very fun and rewarding experience and I only wished I had done something like this 10 years ago,' he wrote in a message shared with the AP. But once he returned home in 2023, there were signs that Boelter was struggling financially. That August, he began working for a transport service for a funeral home, mostly picking up bodies of those who had died in assisted living facilities — a job he described as he needed to do to pay bills. Tim Koch, the owner of Metro First Call, said Boelter 'voluntarily left' that position about four months ago. 'This is devastating news for all involved,' Koch said, declining to elaborate on the reasons for Boelter's departure, citing the ongoing law enforcement investigation. Boelter had also started spending some nights away from his family, renting a room in a modest house in northern Minneapolis shared by friends. Heavily armed police executed a search warrant on the home Saturday. 'I'm going to be gone for awhile' In the hours before Saturday's shootings, Boelter texted two roommates to tell them he loved them and that 'I'm going to be gone for a while,' according to Schroeder, who was forwarded the text and read it to the AP. 'May be dead shortly, so I just want to let you know I love you guys both and I wish it hadn't gone this way,' Boelter wrote. 'I don't want to say anything more and implicate you in any way because you guys don't know anything about this. But I love you guys and I'm sorry for the trouble this has caused.'
Los Angeles Times
2 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
Protester shot and killed at ‘No Kings' rally in Utah, police say
A demonstrator was shot and killed at Salt Lake City's 'No Kings' protest when a man believed to be part of the event's peacekeeping team fired at another man allegedly aiming a rifle at protesters, authorities said Sunday. Police took the alleged rifleman, Arturo Gamboa, 24, into custody Saturday evening on a murder charge, Salt Lake City Police Chief Brian Redd said at a Sunday news conference. The demonstrator, Arthur Folasa Ah Loo, 39, died at the hospital. Detectives don't yet know why Gamboa pulled out a rifle or ran from the peacekeepers, but they accused him of creating the dangerous situation that led to Ah Loo's death. The Associated Press did not immediately find an attorney listed for Gamboa or contact information for his family in public records. Redd said a man dressed in a brightly colored vest fired three shots from a handgun at Gamboa, inflicting a relatively minor injury but fatally shooting Ah Loo. The gunshots sent hundreds of protesters running, some hiding behind barriers and fleeing into parking garages and nearby businesses, police said in a statement. 'That's a gun. Come on, come on, get out,' someone can be heard saying in a video posted to social media that appears to show the events. 'No Kings' protests swept across the country Saturday, as millions rallied in cities nationwide against what demonstrators view as President Trump's monarch-like, authoritarian excesses. Confrontations were largely isolated. The Utah chapter of the 50501 Movement, which helped organize the protests, said in a statement on Instagram that they condemned the violence. The Utah chapter did not immediately respond to AP questions about the peacekeeping team. It was unclear who hired the peacekeepers, whether they were volunteers or what their training was prior to the event. Redd said that the peacekeepers' actions are also part of the investigation. The shooter and another person in a vest allegedly saw Gamboa separate from the crowd of marchers in downtown Salt Lake City, move behind a wall and withdraw a rifle around 8 p.m., Redd said. When the two men in vests confronted Gamboa with their handguns drawn, witnesses said Gamboa raised his rifle into a firing position and ran toward the crowd, said Redd. That's when one of the men dressed in the bright vests shot three rounds, hitting Gamboa and Ah Loo, said Redd. Gamboa, who police said didn't have a criminal history, was wounded and treated before being booked into jail. Police said they recovered an AR-15 style rifle, a gas mask and a backpack at the scene. Bedayn writes for the Associated Press.
Indianapolis Star
2 hours ago
- Indianapolis Star
IMPD responds after video of arrest in downtown Indy sparks criticisms
Multiple videos circulating on social media June 15 depict an Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department officer shooting a man with a high-pressure air launcher before tackling him to the ground in downtown Indianapolis. The videos caused some in the community to question whether the IMPD officer used excessive force and if the department would hold the officer accountable, leading IMPD to release a statement saying the incident would undergo a "thorough administrative review." "It's important to note that the videos currently circulating capture only a portion of the incident and what was occurring in the area at the time," the department's statement read. "We are continuing to gather information about what led up to and followed the events depicted in the video clips." A video shared on social media starts by showing a Black man attempting to walk away from an IMPD officer, while asking the officer "why are you walking up with that," pointing to a weapon in the officer's hands. The officer can then be seen putting his hand on the man's chest and slightly pushing the man back. The man then slaps the officer's hand, after which the officer shoots him three times with a TIB90 Pepper Ball launcher from Sabre Red — a projectile weapon that law enforcement describe as nonlethal. "Are you serious? What am I doing," the man says after being shot, according to the video. The officer can then be seen grabbing the man as he tries to tackle him to the ground. At one point, the officer yells at the man to "get on the ground," before pushing him to the ground. That's when three other IMPD officers can be seen getting on top of the man as they try to detain him. While the man is on the ground, another officer can be seen punching him multiple times, before he goes motionless for a few seconds as police attempt to place handcuffs on him. In the video, a bystander can be heard yelling, "What is they doing. They're beating the f--- out of him." Police then sit the man up before taking him away, according to the video. Shortly after 4 p.m. June 15, IMPD released a statement about the videos, acknowledging the department had seen them and offering preliminary details of what officers say took place. Shortly after bars in downtown Indianapolis closed for the night, officers in IMPD's event response group were working to manage a large crowd that had formed after two men started to fight one another, shortly before 3:30 a.m., according to the statement. Officers intervened and separated the two men after giving verbal orders, police said. One of the men then attempted to walk away from the altercation, while the other remained. That's when the man seen in the video allegedly "squared his shoulders" towards an officer, according to police. This prompted the officer to stick out his hand to create some distance from the man before the man slapped his hand away, the statement read. The officer then fired three shots at the man, as depicted in the video. The department said the officer threw the man to the ground because he believed the man was attempting to flee, and another officer punched the man three times in order to "gain control" of the situation. IMPD has not released the names of the officers involved. The man was preliminarily charged with disorderly conduct, battery of a public safety official, resisting law enforcement and possession of marijuana, according to police. Police later determined the man was armed, and officers recovered a weapon on the ground after he was taken into custody. The department noted the incident will go through the administrative review process to determine if the office's use of force was reasonable.
