Kenny MacAskill defends Kneecap after 'kill your MP' video
MacAskill, a former Scottish justice secretary, insisted there had been a 'kneejerk reaction' to Kneecap's comments, adding that calls to have them banned from the TRNSMT festival in Glasgow are 'utterly pointless'.
He claimed on the BBC's Scotcast the band are being targeted for being outspoken on the actions of Israel in Gaza and what they said on stage in November 2023 was a 'throwaway comment'.
A video emerged from a November 2023 gig, appearing to show a member of the group saying: 'The only good Tory is a dead Tory. Kill your local MP.'
John Swinney said Kneecap should be cut from the TRNSMT line-up on the back of the comments saying they had 'crossed a line'.
READ MORE: Kneecap break silence amid calls to prosecute and cut from TRNSMT
But MacAskill said the reaction to the clip had been 'ludicrous'.
He said: 'I think it's a kneejerk reaction to Kneecap, I think it's utterly pointless.
'The band have issued an apology for what was a throwaway remark some two years ago taken entirely out of context.
'There was a time when I grew up when people were calling for the banning of the Beatles because of things they had said relating themselves to being bigger than Jesus Christ or whatever. We've moved on from there, they've apologised for it, said it wasn't to be taken in the context that had been put forward, so let them get on with it.
'This is just ludicrous.'
MacAskill said the 'real wrong' was the actions of Israel in carrying out a genocide in Gaza, which Kneecap has consistently called out.
(Image: Andrew Gardner/The Argus) The Alba leader went on: 'This is two years ago, no one was expressing outrage two years ago. What has happened since then is not just that Kneecap have exploded in terms of getting the band's profile, but they've been very outspoken regarding the genocide that's taking place in Gaza.
'People seem outraged about Kneecap having mentioned that throwaway line and yet Britain is facilitating genocide in Gaza, kids are dying by the score on a daily basis.
'I think I know where the real wrong is and the real wrong is what is being perpetrated by Israel, not a remark by the band Kneecap several years ago.'
When it was suggested to him there are other views on what is happening in Gaza, MacAskill criticised the BBC's coverage of Israel's assault on the enclave.
He said: 'There are not alternatives to what is going on in Gaza. Let's be clear, there is a genocide in Gaza, that is fully accepted and documented.
'That is why the BBC has been getting into disrepute with its failure to call out Israel's action and the reason Kneecap is getting focus now is because they have been outspoken, they are capturing a generation of young people who are also appalled at a genocide that is taking place within their lifetime.
'So this is about closing down arguments about actions of Israel. Nothing to do with the throwaway remark.'
READ MORE: Politicians want to cancel Kneecap – but stay silent on Chris Brown playing Hampden
In a statement posted on X, the Belfast group – Liam Og O Hannaidh, Naoise O Caireallain and JJ O Dochartaigh – said they 'reject any suggestion that we would seek to incite violence against any MP or individual.
The band said they have never supported Hamas or Hezbollah and condemned all attacks on civilians, apologising to the families of murdered MPs Jo Cox and Sir David Amess, saying 'we never intended to cause you hurt'.
They said a video extract had been deliberately taken out of context and was being 'exploited and weaponised'.
The band's gig at the Eden Project scheduled for July has been cancelled following the emergence of the footage.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
STV News
40 minutes ago
- STV News
Seed potato farmers left in limbo after EU trade deal reached
Seed potato farmers in Scotland say they need to know 'sooner rather than later' when they can resume exporting their products to the EU. In March, a political agreement between Europe and the UK was reached after crops were banned post-Brexit, which farmers say cost the industry tens of millions of pounds. Scotland's seed potatoes are exported worldwide, but until recently, farmers haven't been able to sell them into the EU. The multi-million pound industry says a clear timeline is needed quickly if they're to make the most of the agreement. Farmer Robert Doig told STV News: 'We lost all our European market in Brexit, it went to zero…for those doing business with the EU it was sort of a catastrophe. 'But the EU seed still came in so we lost our market and had another one coming in. 'The seed potato industry has contracted a little bit.' He says the details of the deal need to come sooner rather than later. Farmers now predominantly export seed potatoes into North Africa, with Egypt and Morocco the largest export markets. Scott Walker, chief executive of GB Potatoes, said: 'This has been extremely welcome. 'The timing of those details is important to allow farmers to meet the EU's demand.' NFU Scotland president Andrew Connon said last month: 'This agreement marks a welcome shift towards reducing the red tape and costs that have frustrated Scottish farmers and food exporters for years. 'While details are still emerging, anything that helps restore smoother trade with our largest export market is a positive step.' He added: 'The devil will be in the detail. We need to ensure this works across all sectors – from livestock to seed potatoes and delivers real benefits on the ground. 'The principle of the deal is dynamic alignment with EU policy, but we need to understand what the exceptions might be and how this might work in practice.' The UK Government say the specifics of the deal will be decided on in the coming months. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Five councillors in court over health and safety matter
Scottish Tory councillor James Adams, who represents Kilmarnock West and Crosshouse, will appear alongside them. It is understood the charges relate to their capacity as trustees of the Kilmarnock Leisure Centre Trust, and not as councillors. Ms Maitland has represented Kilmarnock South since 2017, and serves as the member with responsibility for health and social care, while Mr Linton, who represents Kilmarnock and Crosshouse, was elected in 1999 and holds responsibility for resources and economy. Ms Leitch represents the Ballochmyle ward, which covers Auchinleck, Catrine, Cronberry, Logan, Lugar, Mauchline, Muirkirk and Sorn. Mr Douglas represents Kilmarnock East and Hurlford. All five councillors will appear at Kilmarnock Sheriff Court on Thursday June 12 on a pleading diet. In a statement provided to The Herald, East Ayrshire Council said: 'East Ayrshire Council can confirm that Claire Leitch, Iain Linton, Clare Maitland and Barry Douglas are four of the six trustees of the Kilmarnock Leisure Centre Trust, which provided leisure facilities at the Galleon Leisure Centre in Kilmarnock." The council later confirmed Mr Adams, who is also a trustee, will also appear. The spokeswoman added: 'The case is due to call in court as a pleading diet later this week in relation to a health and safety matter, which involves them in their capacity as trustees rather than as councillors. 'As this is a live matter that has not yet called in court, the council would confirm that out of respect and deference to the court process, it would not be appropriate to comment further at this stage.' Police Scotland and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service did not respond to request for comment.
Glasgow Times
an hour ago
- Glasgow Times
Winter fuel u-turn should have been done long ago says SNP
After Rachel Reeves announced the change that means pensioners with an income of put to £35,000 a year will now get the payment, Scotland's Social Justice Secretary said many will still miss out. The UK Government decision is a partial reversal of the decision last year to axe the payment of up to £300 for all but the lowest income pensioners. READ NEXT: Rachel Reeves reveals changes to Winter Fuel Payments this year The decision, one of the first of the new Labour Government, was met with an outcry among anti-poverty campaigners and older people's groups. The Scottish Government also hade to postpone its plan to roll out a Scottish payment by one year. The Scottish policy will see pensioners on the highest incomes receiving £100 and £305.10 for those on the lowest. Shirley-Anne Somervile, Scottish Social Justice Secretary said: "I welcome any extension of eligibility by the UK Government, but this is a U-turn the Chancellor should have made a long time ago. "But there is still no detail about how the Chancellor intends to go about that. "Unfortunately, it still sounds as if many pensioners will miss out." She added: "The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government wrote to the Chief Secretary to the Treasury last week to urge the UK Government to share its plans with us as quickly as possible, so that we can understand any implications for our own programmes and, crucially, our budget." Scotish Labour defended the Chanceloors decision. Paul O'Kane, MSP said: "The winter fuel payment is a devolved payment in Scotland and Scottish Labour has long been clear that we want to see it reinstated for the majority of pensioners up here - but despite their loud spin, the SNP voted against our attempts to do so. "The SNP must not go ahead with plans that would rob poorer pensioners in order to fund payments for millionaires. "The SNP must re-examine their own proposals in light of this game-changing announcement, ensure payments reach those most in need, and give a cast-iron guarantee that no struggling Scottish pensioners will be left out of pocket under their plans."
