‘Not meant to be': Manitoba Museum reflects as Bay charter heads elsewhere
The Manitoba Museum might have one of the largest collections of Hudson's Bay artifacts, but its CEO isn't bitter the defunct retailer's crown jewel isn't destined for her institution.
There will soon be a new home for the 355-year-old royal charter that birthed the Bay, giving it extraordinary control over a vast swath of unceded lands — and enormous influence over settlers' early relations with Indigenous Peoples.
It will wind up at the Canadian Museum of History, pending court approval of a plan to let the Weston family buy the charter and donate it to the Gatineau, Que., organization.
'I'm glad that it has ended up at a museum. I think that's important,' said Dorota Blumczynska, CEO of the Manitoba Museum in Winnipeg.
'But I'm not going to sugarcoat the fact that we had certainly hoped that it would be in Manitoba and that it would be in the Manitoba Museum.'
The document became available after the Bay filed for creditor protection in March under the weight of tremendous debt. To recover whatever cash it could for creditors, it liquidated all of its stores and hatched a plan to put its most prized possessions — 1,700 art pieces and 2,700 artifacts — on the auction block.
Before an auction could begin, the Westons swooped in, pitching the Bay on a $12.5 million purchase and immediate donation of the document.
Prior to the announcement, historians and Indigenous communities were worried the charter would wind up on the wall of a deep-pocketed private collector, taking the historic document out of public view and perhaps, the country.
Many thought the charter was best suited for a public institution and named the Manitoba Museum as an ideal home.
After all, a 1994 donation from the Bay gave it 27,000 items linked to the business, including furnishings from the company's former head office in London, England and a birch bark canoe from the early 20th century.
The charter is 'a very complimentary piece to all the stories that we share about the Hudson Bay Company at the Manitoba Museum,' Blumczynska said.
'If it could have been here, that would have been wonderful, but it wasn't meant to be,' she said.
A purchase wouldn't have been 'in the realm of the possible' because the Manitoba Museum has 'limited means.'
It didn't even try to court donors to make a purchase on its behalf because Hudson's Bay moved so rapidly from creditor protection to complete collapse, she said.
'We didn't have the means really to very quickly respond in order to activate donors to try to put together a bid,' Blumczynska said.
Another possible home for the charter might have been the Archives of Manitoba, which holds the Hudson's Bay Company Archives. They're comprised of Bay maps dating back to 1709, videos, audio recordings and so many diaries, letters and research notes that textual records alone take up more than 1,500 linear meters of shelf space.
Asked about the proposed plan for the charter, Manitoba government spokesperson Glen Cassie said, 'at this time, it would not be appropriate for the province to comment.'
He referred The Canadian Press to Anna Gibson Hollow, president of the Association of Canadian Archivists.
She said archivists have 'mixed feelings' about the Westons' plan. They're relieved it involves housing the charter in a Canadian heritage organization but are a bit disappointed it's not destined for the Manitoba archives, which are 'more than equipped to preserve and provide access to the charter.'
Yet there are many reasons why the Canadian Museum of History will be a fitting alternative.
It has roots dating back to 1856 and a collection so expansive it traces Canada's history from the dawn of human habitation to the present — a span of some 15,000 years.
Plus, it's a Crown corporation, so the donation will make the charter 'effectively the property of the people of Canada,' the Westons said in a June letter they sent the Bay pitching the plan.
The donation comes with a stipulation that the charter be shared with other museum and Indigenous groups across the country.
The document has seldom been seen by the public. It long resided at the Bay's Toronto head office before being recently moved to a secure facility as it awaited auction.
It was temporarily loaned to the Manitoba Museum in 2020, but the COVID-19 pandemic reduced opportunities for public viewing.
Blumczynska said her museum would 'absolutely welcome it back.'
'We look forward to when it's going to be able to visit Manitoba and Manitobans again,' she said.
She would also welcome any other Bay artifacts donors want to buy from the company's eventual auction because the museum's collection is always growing.
'We certainly look at the HBC collection, not as something that is static, but rather as something that we continue to try and understand better and fill out the gaps (with) the collection that may still be in the hands of Canadians and who generously want to give to the public,' she said.
'Every single year, descendants or families who discover things sometimes in their basements or in their attics or collections approach the museum for an assignment of an artifact and then donate it.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 8, 2025.
Tara Deschamps, The Canadian Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
4 minutes ago
- CTV News
Air Canada flight attendants to protest on Monday ahead of strike deadline
Watch More than 10,000 Air Canada flight attendants could go on strike Aug. 16 if an agreement isn't reached, protests will be held Monday in support of the union.
Globe and Mail
4 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Landlords say Ruby Liu's plan to take over 25 Hudson's Bay properties ‘defies commercial common sense'
Several of Canada's most prominent real estate companies are slamming an attempt from a B.C. billionaire to take over 25 former Hudson's Bay leases, saying her plan for their spaces 'defies commercial common sense' and is 'entirely unrealistic.' The landlords, including Cadillac Fairview, Oxford Properties, Ivanhoé Cambridge, KingSett Capital Inc., Morguard Investments Ltd. and Primaris Real Estate Investment Trust, made filings Saturday that ask the Ontario Superior Court to stop Weihong (Ruby) Liu from moving in. Most said they are opposed to Ms. Liu becoming a tenant because she has no detailed or credible business plan and despite owning three B.C. shopping centres, lacks the experience or staff she'd need to successfully operate a retailer out of the Bay's former digs. Her business is 'an empty shell without any guarantee of financial means beyond Ms. Liu's bare assertion that she will keep it afloat,' said Rory MacLeod, Cadillac Fairview's executive vice-president of operations, in an affidavit. 'All of the indications are that [her company] will run out of money before the first store opens.' His affidavit and a slew from other retail executives up the ante in a battle that has been festering between Ms. Liu and landlords since the Bay announced in May that it had chosen her to buy 28 of its leases. The first three got court approval and were transferred in short order because they were at Ms. Liu's three malls. HBC pushes for court approval for plan to sell 25 store leases to B.C. billionaire The remaining 25, however, have been much more fraught. Those leases cover some of the country's most prized retail space and came with cheaper rent and very attractive terms for the Bay, which filed for creditor protection under the weight of tremendous debt in March. For example, the Bay paid $1.3-million in annual rent for 152,420 square feet at Fairview Mall in Toronto, court documents show, which is a fraction of what non-anchor tenants would pay for the same space. Unable to get most landlords onside with a lease transfer, the Bay asked a court at the end of July to force property owners to accept Ms. Liu as a tenant. Ms. Liu and the Bay have until next Tuesday to respond to its landlords' allegations. A judge will hear the matter at the end of the month. Ms. Liu has said she wants to turn the Bay stores she is hoping to buy into her own department store named after herself. She has repeatedly told The Canadian Press her stores will not just offer retail space but also dining, entertainment, kids play and recreation areas. Mr. MacLeod says she's also talked of outfitting Bay spaces with grocery stores, educational centres, senior's facilities, robotics and musical performances. Cadillac Fairview says leases at the six malls she wants from the company – Fairview Mall, Sherway Gardens, Masonville Place and Markville in Ontario, Market Mall and Chinook Centre in Alberta and Richmond Centre in B.C. – don't allow for anything other than a department store to be operated there. 'Despite her private assurances that she intends to respect the lease terms, Ms. Liu has consistently presented a different idea to the public, one that would not be compatible with the leases,' Mr. MacLeod said. First Nations groups raise questions about lack of consultation before sale of 1670 Hudson's Bay Company charter When Oxford met with Ms. Liu, it got the impression her goal is to run her own mall within anchor tenant spaces and felt she has ambitions that stretch well beyond what is permitted in the Bay's leases. Nadia Corrado, a vice-president with Oxford, alleged in an affidavit that Ms. Liu criticized the food court at Hillcrest Mall, north of Toronto, and shared a vision for including Asian fine dining, 'when the food court forms part of the shopping centre owned by Oxford – and not part of the HBC premises she is seeking to take an assignment of.' Affidavits from landlord executives also raised concerns with the timelines and budget in her business plan. Ms. Liu has said she will be ready to open at least 20 stores within 180 days of obtaining leases and will spend $120-million on 'overdue' repairs to roofs, HVAC systems, washrooms, elevators and escalators and $135-million on initial inventory. Cadillac Fairview says her proposed timeline is 'entirely unrealistic' for a new brand, let alone an established one, and her plan is underfunded based on the high number of repairs properties need and expensive terms suppliers will require her to agree to. Mr. MacLeod estimates the stores will need more than $15.8-million in repairs before the end of 2026 to bring the leases into good standing. By 2027, Ms. Liu will need to spend another $5.7-million on repairs, not including taxes, permits or fees for expedited labour. Over the next 10 years, he estimates Ms. Liu will be required to spend at least $43.1-million on the Cadillac Fairview leases alone. Ruby Liu lacks 'foundational' experience to run former HBC stores, Cadillac Fairview CEO says Ms. Corrado from Oxford said Ms. Liu's $8-million budget for renovations at Southcentre Mall in Calgary was also insufficient. She alleged Ms. Liu was surprised she'd be responsible for exterior or structural parts of the leased spaces, like the roof, and said Ms. Liu indicated her proposed budget did not account for such costs. Even if her budget for renovations changes, landlords have concerns about whether she can secure inventory. Though Ms. Liu maintains companies are willing to supply her with inventory, a KingSett Capital affidavit said evidence she's filed in court mostly amounts to letters from merchants saying they have capacity to support her stores, rather than committing to a relationship. The landlords also took issue with her staffing estimations, which show she will need 1,800 employees to carry out her plan. If all 1,800 are sales staff that would only leave 64 people on the floor of each of her 28 stores. Mr. Macleod from Cadillac Fairview said such staffing levels are 'inadequate to support a countrywide chain' and 'inconsistent with a retail location even a fraction of that size.' 'With my decades of experience in commercial real estate, it is apparent to me and Cadillac Fairview that [Ms. Liu] will fail and again leave these stores vacant,' he said. Ruby Paola, a managing director with landlord Ivanhoe Cambridge's parent company, also agreed Ms. Liu is 'most likely to fail' because her retailer is 'uncertain, untested and unknown.' If that happens, it will 'negatively impact the mall for many, many years to come and will likely far exceed the costs to be expended by Ivanhoe in redeveloping the space.'
CTV News
34 minutes ago
- CTV News
Back-to-school shopping: Why tariffs could mean higher prices this year
Retail experts expect back-to-school shopping to be hit by tariff costs, but the picture is complicated. Expect to see items that come through the U.S., such as electronics and clothes, to see big increases in prices, especially goods from Southeast Asia, due to President Donald Trump's tariffs, according to retail analyst Bruce Winder. 'Tariffs are certainly having an impact on back-to-school shopping in a way that's a bit unique,' Winder told CTV News. Many sellers loaded up on inventory in anticipation of tariffs, and those sticker prices aren't likely to climb higher. But Winder says some big brands in Canada may up their prices here to match an increase in the U.S. — a process known as harmonizing prices that leaves customers in both countries paying more. 'I think you're going to see a little bit of inflation across the board everywhere,' said Winder. Another factor? Some brands potentially taking advantage of customer tariff psychology to raise prices. 'They did that during the pandemic, they sort of realized the consumer was in the mindset that prices would increase, and they snuck up prices a little bit,' Winder said. His best advice is to shop around and check all the deals and sales in advance — doing your homework before your kids are assigned any at school. If the impact of tariffs is uncertain, certified financial planner Adam Chapman says parents should control what they can: 'buy the things your kid needs and stop there.' Chapman says parents are, perhaps unknowingly, using the tariffs to justify 'turning wants into needs.' 'One of the best things that most parents can do is… wait until your kids actually arrive in the classroom and you actually know what's actually needed,' he told CTV News. The vast majority of Canadian parents — 89 per cent — feel school supplies have been climbing in price, according to a new study from online shopping reward program The study doesn't mention tariffs, with 76 per cent of parents blaming inflation for climbing prices. Seventy-five per cent of those surveyed shop sales or use deal sites to help lower back-to-school costs. That tracks with what one Ottawa kids' consignment store is seeing this back-to-school season: more sales. 'It's definitely been a lot busier than last year,' Elizabeth Ferguson of The Thrifted Mini told CTV News. 'We're looking at a bigger increase in sales, and a lot of new people, fresh faces that are coming in.' She often hears parents citing tariffs as a reason for shopping second-hand, as well as a preference for supporting a local business, buying sustainably, and choosing products that are already in Canada.
