Air traffic controllers' union throws wrench in Sean Duffy's bid to boost hiring: sources
WASHINGTON — The top union for air traffic controllers is hampering Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy's plans to boost hiring by penalizing those who want to work beyond retirement age, The Post has learned.
Duffy is offering cash bonuses of up to 20% of annual salaries for Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) air traffic controllers eligible to retire but younger than the mandatory age of 56 — and hoping to retain even more through through the age of 61 via exemption waivers.
'They're fantastic, they're great at their jobs, they get to an eligible point of retirement and they take that retirement,' Duffy, 53, told reporters May 1.
6 The top union for air traffic controllers could be throwing a wrench into Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy's plans to boost hiring by penalizing those who want to work beyond their retirement age, The Post has learned.
Getty Images
'Why don't we try to incentivize those really well-experienced air traffic controllers? Let's incentivize them to stay. Let's get them to stay on. Not only do we have that experience, but they can also help train up those younger, newer controllers coming into their family.'
But the National Air Traffic Controllers Association (NATCA) has undercut the planned staffing blitz by threatening to punish any members who use waivers, according to sources familiar with the effort.
A union amendment reviewed by The Post and apparently agreed to by two-thirds of its members earlier this month will cap controller seniority on the date they start using a waiver.
6 A union amendment reviewed by The Post and apparently agreed to by two-thirds of its members earlier this month will cap their seniority on the date at which they start using a waiver.
Rob – stock.adobe.com
'Each waiver puts early retirement at risk by showing the Agency [FAA] and Congress that mandatory retirement is unnecessary,' stated the amendment, which is expected to take effect in October.
'Waivers do nothing to benefit NATCA,' it added. 'Early retirement is a privilege that we earn by working one of the most stressful jobs in history.'
'NATCA is fully committed to working with Secretary Duffy, the Department of Transportation, and the Federal Aviation Administration to ensure the national airspace system is staffed with the best and brightest air traffic controllers,' a union rep told The Post Wednesday evening.
'We continue to support Secretary Duffy's plan to supercharge staffing and modernize the air traffic control system. NATCA remains in alignment with Secretary Duffy's plan and the department's priorities.'
6 Nick Daniels heads up the air traffic controllers' union that has undercut Duffy's hiring spree.
Getty Images
'The secretary is disappointed in the decision to unfairly penalize experienced controllers,' said a DOT spokesperson.
'It's critical that we retain the best and brightest because America needs more controllers — not less. We would hope that NATCA will work with us on behalf of the American people.'
Air traffic controllers are able to apply for the waivers subject to FAA approval, so long as they maintain certain standards such as medical checks.
6 Air traffic controllers are able to apply for the waivers subject to approval by the FAA so long as they maintain certain standards such as medical checks.
REUTERS
While NACTA isn't supposed to be involved in the hiring process, it is able to determine the seniority of its members, which determines eligibility for various benefits.
Both the FAA and NATCA then work together to staff air traffic control facilities and schedule shifts.
Many air traffic controllers retire after serving 25 years, often before the mandatory 56-year threshold is reached.
6 There are more than 10,000 air traffic controllers nationwide, and the FAA is currently 3,000 or so shy of its staffing goals.
Getty Images
In March, President Trump issued an executive order that allowed Duffy 'maximum flexibility' to exempt the FAA from federal labor relations laws in managing any overseas 'installation or activity.'
Duffy reached an agreement with NACTA earlier this month offering the bonus incentive to cut down on attrition.
New York Terminal Radar Approach Control (TRACON), which supervises the most heavily trafficked airports in the country, and Philadelphia TRACON, which oversees Newark Liberty International Airport's airspace, have both suffered 'persistent low staffing levels and low training success rate[s],' according to the FAA.
6 New York Terminal Radar Approach Control (TRACON), which supervises the most heavily trafficked airports in the country, has suffered 'persistent low staffing levels and low training success rate[s],' according to the FAA.
Getty Images
'What I've done, I said, 'Hey, listen. These are the best controllers we have in the airspace. Let's give them a bonus. I'm going to give them a 20% upfront bonus to stay on the job. Don't retire. Keep serving your country,'' Duffy told NBC News' 'Meet the Press' May 11. 'And these are the best guys.'
'First and foremost, we do not believe this is an effective solution to addressing the chronic air traffic controller (ATC) staffing crisis,' the union said in February in response to Duffy's pledge to incentivize members staying beyond their retirement age.
'The solution to the ATC staffing crisis is a long-term commitment to hiring and training.'
That package included $5,000 bonuses for air traffic control academy graduates who finish initial qualification training, another $5,000 for new hires who do the same and a $10,000 bonus for grads who work at one of 13 'hard-to-staff' air traffic control facilities.
Nearly two-thirds of recruits at the FAA Academy in Oklahoma wash out, but those who make it — as well as others who train with the US military or at other credible colleges — would be able to take the cash incentives.
There are more than 10,000 air traffic controllers nationwide, and the FAA is currently 3,000 or so shy of its staffing goals.
FAA Air Traffic Organization deputy COO Franklin McIntosh told a congressional hearing Wednesday the agency expected to hire another 2,000 controllers by the end of 2025, meaning understaffing will remain a problem for another year or more.
Another former FAA official told The Post Wednesday that staffing is expected to 'get better' in the next couple weeks at the critical New York- and Philadelphia-based TRACONs due to planned telecommunications updates announced by Duffy last week.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
43 minutes ago
Pentagon draws up rules on possible use of force by Marines deployed to LA protests
WASHINGTON -- The Pentagon was scrambling Monday to establish rules to guide U.S. Marines who could be faced with the rare and difficult prospect of using force against citizens on American soil, now that the Trump administration is deploying active duty troops to the immigration raid protests in Los Angeles. U.S. Northern Command said it is sending 700 Marines into the Los Angeles area to protect federal property and personnel, including federal immigration agents. The 2nd Battalion, 7th Marines are coming from Twentynine Palms, California, and will augment about 4,100 National Guard members already in LA or authorized to be deployed there to respond to the protests. The forces have been trained in deescalation, crowd control and standing rules for the use of force, Northern Command said. But the use of the active duty forces still raises difficult questions. The Marines are highly trained in combat and crisis response, with time in conflict zones like Syria and Afghanistan. But that is starkly different from the role they will face now: They could potentially be hit by protesters carrying gas canisters and have to quickly decide how to respond or face decisions about protecting an immigration enforcement agent from crowds. According to a U.S. official, troops will be armed with their normal service weapons but will not be carrying tear gas. They also will have protective equipment such as helmets, shields and gas masks. When troops are overseas, how they can respond to threats is outlined by the rules of engagement. At home, they are guided by standing rules for the use of force, which have to be set and agreed to by Northern Command, and then each Marine should receive a card explaining what they can and cannot do, another U.S. official said. For example, warning shots would be prohibited, according to use-of-force draft documents viewed by The Associated Press. Marines are directed to deescalate a situation whenever possible but also are authorized to act in self-defense, the documents say. The AP reviewed documents and interviewed nine U.S. officials, who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss details not yet public, about the guidance being determined for the Marines. The Pentagon also is working on a memo with clarifying language for the Marines that will lay out the steps they can take to protect federal personnel and property. Those guidelines also will include specifics on the possibility that they could temporarily detain civilians if troops are under assault or to prevent harm, the first U.S. official said. Those measures could involve detaining civilians until they can be turned over to law enforcement. Having the Marines deploy to protect federal buildings allows them to be used without invoking the Insurrection Act, one U.S. official said. The Insurrection Act allows the president to direct federal troops to conduct law enforcement functions in national emergencies. But the use of that act is extremely rare. Officials said that has not yet been done in this case and that it's not clear it will be done. President George H.W. Bush used the Insurrection Act to respond to riots in Los Angeles in 1992 after the acquittal of white police officers who were videotaped beating Black motorist Rodney King. If their role expands if the violence escalates, it is not clear under what legal authority they would be able to engage, said Elizabeth Goitein, a senior director of the Liberty and National Security Program at the Brennan Center for Justice at NYU Law. 'If in fact those Marines are laying hands on civilians, doing searches, then you have pretty powerful legal concerns,' Goitein said. 'No statutory authority Trump has invoked so far permits this.' Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth tweeted late Saturday that he was considering deploying the Marines to respond to the unrest after getting advice earlier in the day from Gen. Dan Caine, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, according to one of the U.S. officials. Still, the tweet, which was posted to Hegseth's personal X account and not to his official government account, caught many inside the Pentagon by surprise. As late as Monday, the military's highest offices were still considering the potential ramifications. But the Marine Corps were asking broader questions, too: Do they send more senior, experienced personnel so as not to put newer, less experienced troops at risk of potentially making a judgment call on whether to use force against a civilian? What's lawful under a domestic deployment — where troops may end up in a policing role — is governed by the Fourth Amendment in the U.S. Constitution, which forbids seizure of persons, including temporarily restraining them, unless it could be considered reasonable under the circumstances.
Boston Globe
an hour ago
- Boston Globe
Israel attacks Yemeni port city, Houthi rebels say
Late Monday, Israel issued online warnings to Yemenis to evacuate from Ras Isa, Hodeida and al-Salif ports over what it alleged was 'the Houthi regime's use of seaports for its terrorist activities.' Hodeida also is the main entry point for food and other humanitarian aid for millions of Yemenis since the war began when the Houthis seized Yemen's capital, Sanaa, in 2014. The Houthis have been launching persistent missile and drone attacks against commercial and military ships in the region in what the group's leadership has described as an effort to end Israel's offensive in Gaza. Advertisement From November 2023 until January 2025, the Houthis targeted more than 100 merchant vessels with missiles and drones, sinking two of them and killing four sailors. That has greatly reduced the flow of trade through the Red Sea corridor, which typically sees $1 trillion of goods move through it annually. The Houthis paused attacks in a self-imposed ceasefire until the U.S. launched a broad assault against the rebels in mid-March. Trump paused those attacks just before his trip to the Mideast, saying the rebels had 'capitulated' to American demands. Advertisement Early Tuesday, U.S. Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth wrote on the social platform X that U.S. Navy ships had traveled through the Red Sea and its Bab el-Mandeb Strait 'multiple times in recent days' without facing Houthi attacks. 'These transits occurred without challenge and demonstrate the success of both Operation ROUGH RIDER and the President's Peace Through Strength agenda,' Hegseth wrote ahead of facing Congress for the first time since sharing sensitive military details of America's military campaign against the Houthis in a Signal chat. Meanwhile, a wider, decadelong war in Yemen between the Houthis and the country's exiled government, backed by a Saudi-led coalition, remains in a stalemate.
Boston Globe
an hour ago
- Boston Globe
Canada commits billions in military spending to meet NATO target
But even if Canada is able to finally hit the 2 percent threshold, that is not likely to be enough to satisfy the United States or other NATO allies. Mark Rutte, NATO's secretary general, speaking in London on Monday, called on the alliance's members to make a 'quantum leap in our collective defense' by committing to significantly higher spending targets. Rutte wants members to commit to spending 5 percent of their gross domestic products on military and defense-related activities. Trump has called for a similar spending target. Advertisement Proposals for increased spending are likely to dominate the NATO summit meeting in The Hague this month, though Rutte has not set a timeline for his increased spending plan. Carney, speaking in Toronto, said that new geopolitical threats, advances in technology, and the fraying of Canada's alliance with the United States demanded an accelerated spending schedule. 'We stood shoulder to shoulder with the Americans throughout the Cold War and in the decades that followed, as the United States played a dominant role on the world stage,' he said. 'Today, that dominance is a thing of the past.' Advertisement 'It is time for Canada to chart its own path,' he added, 'and to assert itself on the international stage.' While Carney promised to increase spending by billions of Canadian dollars, he did not specify where the funds would come from. Government officials spoke mostly in broad terms about how the money would be used. Canada's economy is heavily dependent on exports to the United States, and Trump's tariffs have targeted key industries, including autos and steel. Some economists have warned that Canada could face a recession if the tariffs persist. Carney also said the country would no longer rely as extensively on American defense contractors to supply its armed forces, underscoring Canada's strained relations with the United States and focus on shifting away from its neighbor. The Canadian government said it would immediately add 9.3 billion Canadian dollars (about $6.8 billion) to its defense budget. That will raise total defense-related spending this year to CA$62.7 billion, slightly higher than the 2 percent NATO target. To get there, the government included CA$2.5 billion in spending related to 'defense and security' for other departments, including the Canadian coast guard, an unarmed civilian agency which is under the department of fisheries. Carney's spending pledge was welcomed by defense analysts. 'This is a long-overdue announcement,' said Margaret McCuaig-Johnston, a senior fellow at the Graduate School of Public and International Affairs at the University of Ottawa. 'This significant commitment is remarkable given how quickly they're going to have to move to make 2 percent by the end of the fiscal year.' But, she added, Carney will have to add further budget increases to fund all of the programs he is promising. Advertisement Carney laid out a long shopping list for the military, including 'new submarines, aircraft, ships, armed vehicles, and artillery.' He also said the military would add drones and sensors to monitor the seafloor in the Arctic, a vast region of the country that is becoming a source of competition among global powers such as Russia and China. But Canadian officials said that this year most of the spending would go toward things like increasing the pay and the benefits of armed forces members to help ease a severe recruitment crisis, and repairing broken equipment. Carney also said that money would be directed toward much-needed improvements, noting that three of the Royal Canadian Navy's four diesel submarines were not seaworthy. 'We will repair and maintain our ships, our aircraft, and infrastructure that for too long we allowed to rust and deteriorate,' the prime minister said. Other spending will focus on artificial intelligence and computer systems, as well as ammunition production within the country. Carney also said that Canada would look to buy more goods domestically or from allies other than the United States to equip its military. 'We should no longer send three-quarters of our defense capital spending to America,' he said. Carney said Monday that details about how the country's military needs would be financed would be revealed when a budget was released in the fall. 'Our fundamental goal in all of this is to protect Canadians,' he told reporters, 'not to satisfy NATO accountants.' This article originally appeared in
