Whanganui Politician Crosses Boundaries To Stop Seabed Mine
Australian company Trans-Tasman Resources wants to mine the seafloor in the shallows of South Taranaki Bight, promising a harmless operation that'll bring profits, jobs and exports.
It's seeking permission for the proposed mine via the pro-development Fast-track Approvals Act.
Whanganui District Councillor Charlotte Melser presented her 3000-signature Concerned Communities petition to New Plymouth District Council on Tuesday, saying many locals had signed.
'Your silence on the proposal does not go far enough for many in your community,' she told councillors on NPDC's Strategy and Operations Committee.
Melser wants Taranaki and Whanganui councillors to instruct staff to research ecological, economic and cultural impacts, informing councils to speak against the Fast-track mining bid.
'What I'm angling for is a united voice… to make sure all relevant information is put in front of the decision-making panel.'
For centuries coastal communities have relied on the abundant South Taranaki Bight, said Melser.
'It's truly such a thriving ecosystem down there.
'Do we really need to put it at risk to fill the coffers of an Australian mining company?'
Opponents say Trans-Tasman's waste sediment would smother the extensive reefs of the Pātea Banks, stunting food-chain photosynthesis by cutting sunlight.
They fear underwater industrial noise would disrupt rare Maui dolphins and pygmy blue whales.
Trans-Tasman Resources (TTR) has consents to vacuum-up 50 million tonnes of seabed sediment every year for 35 years, extracting iron, vanadium and titanium for export.
But despite a decade in the courts TTR still hasn't won permission to discharge 45 million tonnes of unwanted sediment – a recognised pollutant – back into the ocean.
The mining company says most of the daily 165,000 tonnes of waste would sink to the seabed in a 'controlled process'.
It says superfine sediments drifting from the mine would be insignificant in the turbid Tasman Sea.
In 2021 the Supreme Court unanimously rejected the company's case and ordered it to start again.
But a year ago TTR quit the resulting environmental hearing in favour of a fast-track application.
The Environmental Protection Authority will soon name an expert panel to hear submissions, then advise Government ministers.
'Once the panel is established, your council will have only 20 working days to complete your submission,' Melser advised.
'The timeframes are tight, so I ask that you make some time today, or as soon as is practicality possible, to come to a position on this amongst yourselves so you can direct your policy team to get on with the work.'
Her last-ditch appeal left committee members unable to act: one of them must instead take a notice-of-motion to the next council meeting.
Trans-Tasman's executive chairman Alan Eggers was pleased the application is progressing along the fast-track.
'We have proposed a set of operating conditions and management plans to generate much-needed growth, create high-paying jobs and minimise any environmental impacts in the South Taranaki Bight.'
Opponents filled the council's public gallery at Tuesday afternoon's meeting, including a couple of dozen from Protect Our Moana Taranaki.
Co-founder Tihikura Hohaia hoped councillors understood the range of people against the mine.
'It's so widespread: surfers, fishers, boaties, yeah – and also dairy farmers.'
'We had a farmer bring a butchered sheep to [a protest last month]. They don't want to go public but no one wants this.'
Last December Whanganui District Council unanimously opposed TTR's project.
Two years ago South Taranaki District Council told Parliament economic benefits wouldn't outweigh 'environmental vandalism' off the Pātea coast and it should outlaw seabed mining.
Trans-Tasman's owners Manuka Resources told the Australian Stock Exchange they predict annual earnings of US$312 million, giving shareholders a near 40 percent rate of return on investment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
12 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Queenstown's Carlin Residence Club: What's it like staying in a $6k a night penthouse?
The Carlin is staggered over Queenstown hills. Photo / James Allan. BDO Christchurch, appointed to settle Carlin's estate, found debt of $45 million. Paynter coyly told the hiker he was an 'old property developer'. (He's actually developed several big projects across New Zealand). 'She said, 'Well, have I got a deal for you... Do you want to buy it?'' Paynter tells me over a glass of Quartz Reef Central Otago Brut in a luxury suite with an unobstructed view of Lake Wakatipu, The Remarkables and the Skyline Queenstown gondola going up and down from Bob's Peak. Paynter asked if she had heard of a co-ownership model, and The Carlin Residence Club was born. Alanah Eriksen enjoys the expansive deck of the penthouse. With the hotel's Australian owner and US fractional ownership company Elite Alliance, Paynter is bringing a concept never before seen in New Zealand. Individuals can purchase a tenth of a title of one of the former hotel's eight units. Prices start at $550,000 for a share of one of the six two-bedroom 145m2 units. The one-bedroom 172m2 penthouse is $695,000 and the three-room 236m2 presidential suite is $895,000. But the public can still benefit from the revamp - apartment owners can rent out the properties for between $3000 and $7000 a night. The penthouse The penthouse suite at Queenstown's, The Carlin. So what is a $6000-a-night penthouse like? Spacious and elegant, with the critical design feature that everything is oriented towards the mountains. I got to stay at The Carlin over a weekend in June and the first thing that strikes you is the panoramic view from the expansive deck, which runs the length of the unit. The penthouse suite, which is due to be refurbished. You could entertain 20 people on this epic deck. But you conveniently won't be obliged to house them afterwards as it's a one-bedroom pad. The technology is more advanced than anywhere I've stayed, with a heated spa with all the jets and bubble functions you could hope for. You can even play music out of it. There are several light settings, two big flat-screen TVs, a remote control fireplace, a heat pump and a marble fire pit on the deck. And one suspects there is also some sort of central heating on top of all this gadgetry because if you turn off all of these heaters, the apartment still stays warm. The massive ensuite has heated tiles and a heated toilet seat with bidet functions. But there is also a more traditional non-electronic second throne (or powder room) if you get intimidated. And for a touch of spice - the shower has no door. A deep freestanding bathtub even has a pillow for residents to rest their heads after a day of hitting the slopes, wineries or shops. In the bedroom, guests can wake up in the plush, super king bed (after booting off the dozens of pillows arranged into an elaborate pyramid) to look out on to the lake. Guests can enjoy fluffy robes with The Carlin emblem on them, and bamboo slippers. The penthouse offers a deep bathtub and a heated toilet seat. The little details are on point. Fluffy white robes carry the iconic teal-coloured Carlin emblem. In the same colour, a jewellery holder next to the bed is perfect for residents' diamond earrings, and a shoe shiner and shoehorn take pride of place in the bathroom. If you need it, there's a full chef's kitchen but guests are offered a cooked breakfast in the residents lounge, which would suit those flying in from far-flung locations. The suite offers a full kitchen. A render of The Carlin's residents lounge. Guests can also enjoy a free cocktail at happy hour and mouth-watering tapas in the lounge. My favourite pre-dinner morsels were the braised lamb shoulder croquettes with smoked aioli, chimichurri and Grana Padano. The fresh tuna and blood orange tartare taco and the overnight-cooked beef ribs with kimchi glaze and fried shallots were also a dream. Guests can enjoy complimentary tapas, including the braised lamb shoulder croquettes with smoked aioli, chimichuri and Grana Padano. Fresh tuna and blood orange tartare taco. Overnight cooked beef ribs with kimchi glaze and fried shallots. The concierge is at your beck and call, arranging a massage in a club treatment room or on your majestic deck if you prefer. Other services include a pre-arrival grocery shop, charter boat and shuttle service bookings and bespoke tours. The Carlin also has a gym, electric bikes, clothing and equipment storage and laundry services. So much to do If you can part with the room and brave the winter, I recommend getting your steps up with a 10-minute walk to the city's array of bars and restaurants. Sunfire's market fish - a creamy dish that includes clams, prawns, bacon, smoked potato and velouté was to die for. Eichardt's Bar, attached to the hotel of the same name, which has welcomed travellers through its doors since 1861, was a cool, cosy spot for a nightcap. Eichardt's Private Hotel is right on the lakefront in Queenstown. Once home to Queenstown's first building — William Rees' woolshed - the bar's fireplace and leather couches keep you comfortable and toasty and the cocktails are refreshing. At Madam Woo, which defied the odds to emerge from voluntary administration in 2023, the pork dumplings in hot broth, beef rendang and honey and soy-tossed squid are a must-try. The Ginger Mojito and Asia Classic are also worth a go. Madam Woo in Queenstown. Picture / James Allan. Coronet Peak is just a short car drive from the property, or go a bit further to Cardrona. Even if you're not a skier, the hairy drive up the mountain is worth it for the view. On the way down, warm up with a mulled wine and soup of the day (potato and leek was on offer at the time) at the iconic Cardrona Hotel. Despite its reputation as a winter wonderland, Paynter says Queenstown is much busier in the summer with people jetting in for the hiking, cycling and wineries. Alanah Eriksen at the Cardrona Hotel. Queenstown's Ayrburn. Photo / Jason Oxenham It's also worth checking out the Rifters gin tasting room in Arrowtown. The New Zealand brand has just won the World's Best Navy Gin award at the prestigious World Drinks Awards in London. Timeshare v fractional ownership With a commerce degree up his sleeve and a wife and daughter who are high-end interior designers (three homes they worked on have won the New Zealand's House of the Year Award), Paynter's Duchamp Collective is giving The Carlin a new lease on life. And he's the man for it - after university, Paynter worked for his father's construction company which built the Queen Elizabeth II Park, a multi-purpose stadium, for the 1974 Commonwealth Games in Christchurch. He went on to build Wānaka's Edgewater Resort, retirement villages and shopping complexes. Developer Richmond Paynter of DuChamp Collective. Duchamp's interior designers, Susie and Teassa Paynter. Elite's first development was a set of apartments in Utah's Deer Valley 35 years ago. Owners of The Carlin apartments can trade in their weeks for 120 properties within the Elite group dotted around the world, including in Marrakesh, Sicily, Tulum, Bali, Whistler and Dubai. So how does the concept differ to a timeshare? 'You are buying capital, not time,' says Paynter. President of Elite Rob Goodyear adds that The Carlin concept is perfect for people who 'don't want to feel anchored to one location'. 'People who have holiday homes really only use them 35 days a year... we release them from the burden of full home ownership.' CHECKLIST Getting there Four airlines fly to and from Queenstown, including Air New Zealand, Qantas, Virgin Australia, and Jetstar. The Carlin offers airport transfers. Details For more information, visit New Zealand Herald Travel visited courtsey of The Carlin.
Otago Daily Times
12 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Kmart accused of links to slave labour factories
Retail giant Kmart is facing accusations it misled customers on its ethical credentials by sourcing clothing supplies from factories in China with links to slave labour. An Australian-based Uyghur group has filed a lawsuit against the outlet in the Federal Court, seeking to gain documents so they can see whether it knowingly sourced stock from suppliers who used forced labour from those in the ethnic group. In its ethical sourcing statement, Kmart said it aimed to provide products that respected human rights according to its ethical sourcing code which committed to abiding by international standards, including guidelines set out in the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The lawsuit filed by the Australian Uyghur Tangritagh Women's Association claims Kmart included on its 2024 and 2025 factory lists two suppliers with links to the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region. It said this region in China's west has been well-documented for "systemic state-sponsored forced labour and other atrocities against Uyghur and other Turkic Muslim people". The group wants proof from Kmart that it has abided by its ethical sourcing promises regarding these suppliers and whether its public statements have been misleading or deceptive. Kmart must ensure it is not profiting off forced labour in China, association president Ramila Chanisheff said. "We're demanding answers from Kmart so we know whether its actions live up to its words about addressing forced labour risks in its supply chain," she said. The retailer risks a legal claim that it breached Australian Consumer Law by misleading and deceptive conduct if documents show it had failed to monitor the risk of it using forced labour in its supply chain. Maurice Blackburn principal lawyer Jennifer Kanis said the firm was using this first-of-its-kind case to bring real accountability to Australian retailers. "Kmart tells customers that it supports ethical sourcing and the protection of human rights – but we know there are credible links between two of its factories and suppliers and the use of Uyghur forced labour in Xinjiang," Ms Kanis said. Human Rights Law Centre associate legal director Freya Dinshaw said the case highlighted the weaknesses in Australia's laws when members of the public are left to take companies to court on suspicions of modern slavery. Unlike the United States, Australia has not banned imports of products made in the Xinjiang region, instead opting for a transparency approach which requires businesses to report annually on their actions to identify and address slavery risks. Wesfarmers, the parent company of Kmart, has been contacted for comment.
NZ Herald
15 hours ago
- NZ Herald
NZ corporate bond issuance shifts overseas, local market slows
That's partly down to banks being better positioned, so corporate treasurers are skewing their funding mix more towards bank lending, he says. The New Zealand Local Government Funding Agency (LGFA), which raises funds for councils, has recently begun issuing offshore debt, which has added another 'swing factor' away from the local market, he says. 'But it's not just LGFA. There is a kind of dynamic where treasurers are getting better pricing landed back into Kiwi dollars if they issue offshore,' he said. 'That's something we would see as being likely to persist, so it's a bit of a change.' Kāinga Ora (formerly the Housing Corporation) is absent from the corporate debt market after the Government in 2022 announced that future funding would be through New Zealand Debt Management – part of the Treasury. He said corporates are hedging funds raised overseas back into New Zealand dollars on quite favourable terms. 'In previous years, typically there is more issuance done domestically than offshore, but this year, a multiple of what's been done onshore has been done offshore. 'Borrowers probably see it as being reasonably positive, but from a fund manager's perspective, we would like to see more issuance in New Zealand,' Pannett said. 'Typically they will get a bit more tenor [longer duration] offshore, and price is a pretty significant motivator also.' But Pannett said it's too early to say if the local market risked becoming a backwater for corporate bond issuance. 'I would need to see a bit more evidence of that first, because it may just be that pricing has moved so much that that is where we are at this point. 'But to call it a real trend, you might need some more evidence.' Overseas bond issuance has been split between Australian, US, Swiss and European markets, with smaller deals done in Japan. Pannett said the trend of raising funds in overseas markets was 'strikingly different' from previous years, when domestic issuance came out on top. The trend means more fund managers, including those managing KiwiSaver funds, are looking overseas for opportunities. 'It's fair to say that they [fund managers] have been looking offshore to fill the void left by limited domestic corporate bond issuance,' Pannett said. Simon Eckhoff, director for syndicate and debt capital markets at ANZ Markets, Institutional, said hedging costs have been favourable throughout this year, which has resulted in New Zealand issuers tapping overseas markets. For corporate issuers in the year to date, ANZ estimates that for every $1 raised in New Zealand dollars, there has been the equivalent of $2 raised in overseas markets – in sharp contrast with history. 'There have been several factors touted as key drivers for the current dynamics, such as the comparative value of the likes of New Zealand government bonds to that of corporate bonds as well as prevailing hedging levels. 'These factors could be perceived as effectively shrinking the investible universe in New Zealand dollar debt,' Eckhoff said. 'While the New Zealand debt market has faced some challenges recently, markets typically normalise,' he said. 'In the interim, offshore debt offers New Zealand issuers an opportunity to enhance their funding diversification,' Eckhoff said. Jamie Gray is an Auckland-based journalist, covering the financial markets and the primary sector. He joined the Herald in 2011.
