Ken Hinkley's farewell tour ends with results clouding whether his reign was a success

The Guardian

a day ago

Ken Hinkley arrived at Port Adelaide as a breath of fresh air for a club on life support. The players were still to recover from a grand final humiliation five years earlier. The fans had deserted the club in droves. Tarpaulins were spread over the seats where supporters should have been at home games, which only brought more attention to the Power's woes.
'This club is in a renewal stage, there's no doubt about that,' Hinkley said during his first press conference as Power coach in late 2012. 'We know what we've got to do, and we know where we've got to go.'
In their first season under Hinkley, Port Adelaide might have been satisfied with simply earning respect. They won their first five games under their new coach, finished in the top eight for the first time in six years and stunned Collingwood in an elimination final at the MCG. The club was able to tear up the tarps as fans returned amid strong signs of progress on the field.
Port Adelaide went a step further in 2014 and reached a preliminary final. A final-term fightback fell less than a goal short as eventual premiers Hawthorn hung on in a thriller. The pain of missing out on a grand final berth could at least be dulled by results over two years suggesting that Hinkley was steering the side in the right direction, with a return to the biggest stage again on the horizon.
But the Power never did make it to the promised land under Hinkley, whose 13-year tenure will end on Friday night. They failed to even reach a decider as three more preliminary final defeats, including a crushing loss to Sydney last year, became a stain on the coach's record. The perpetual heartbreak was enough for club power brokers to decide earlier this year that it was time to move Hinkley on, only with a season-long farewell tour still to come.
Six months later, Hinkley will depart the Power holding the unwanted record for the most VFL/AFL games coached without reaching a grand final. He has also coached the fourth-most games without winning a premiership. Seven finals campaigns and four preliminary finals appearances in his first 12 seasons as Power coach, were not enough for Hinkley to save his job, and will continue to cloud whether his reign can be considered a success.
The Power had their fair share of triumphs under Hinkley as they won 173 of their 296 matches with a match against Gold Coast still to play. The winning percentage of 58.5% is better than modern-day coaching greats like Alastair Clarkson and Damien Hardwick. But that pair made their better years count for more and share seven premierships, while Hinkley and the Power remained competitive but continued to fall narrowly short. The 2020 flag is perhaps the one that got away, after Port Adelaide sat on top of the ladder for the entire home-and-away season but lost a preliminary final on home turf to Richmond by a goal.
This season has turned into the Power's worst under Hinkley, with eight wins the fewest in a single campaign. The side also suffered their four heaviest defeats across his tenure as the pressure surrounding the succession plan with Josh Carr seemed to become too much for Hinkley to bear. The usually combative coach started the year bristling at suggestions that the handover would affect him and the players, but in the past week has revealed a sense of relief that the end is near.
The Power did not achieve all that they hoped for under Hinkley and even he now concedes it is time for him to go. But the lack of silverware, or even a grand final appearance, should not mean his 13 years at the helm are considered a failure. Hinkley's legacy at Port Adelaide is as much about rebuilding a club and reminding us that – especially in a sport where there is only one winner – there can be different versions of success.
'Didn't make a grand final, didn't win one,' Hinkley said this week in his last midweek press conference as Power coach. 'That's probably what it will be. That's the reality of football. We built the footy club up, we have done really well with lots of things – ultimately we didn't quite get to the end.'
The Dockers have won 15 matches including 10 of their past 12, but could become the first side to finish ninth with 13 victories or more.
Few footballers have been more driven than Nathan Fyfe. He'd make a five-hour return road trip each week to the German osteopath who got his life back on track after a shocking concussion. When he won his second Brownlow, he singled him out, and then rattled off all his fellow midfielders by name. They'd done the heavy lifting for him. They'd been ignored by the umpires of course, but not by Fyfe. In recent years, there was the gradual modification of his game, the reduction in expectations and finally, he settled into life as a specialist sub.
At the apex of his game, he went head-to-head with a young Patrick Dangerfield. No tags, no defensive running, no zones – just two champions going hammer and tong. The late Phil Walsh could have clamped down on him, but allowed both stars to flourish. You might call me old fashioned but that's how I like footy,' he said. 'Maybe I'm a weirdo, but we have to protect the game.'
If the Suns win one of their remaining two games, they make finals. If they win both, they have a chance at the top four.
'Two years is a commitment that we need to shift the dial. He gets to look at us and we get to look at Nas. Nothing else was happening [with list management decisions] until we got Nas done.'
St Kilda coach Ross Lyon is under no illusions, while speaking with Seven, that the club needs to hold up its end of the bargain after Wanganeen-Milera turned down offers to return to his home state South Australia and signed a two-year extension.
Sign up to From the Pocket: AFL Weekly
Jonathan Horn brings expert analysis on the week's biggest AFL stories
after newsletter promotion
Any thoughts you want to share? Reply to this email or send your views to [e-mail].
Which club has won the most minor premierships during the 18-team era? Bonus point if you know how many.
a) Geelong
b) Hawthorn
c) Richmond
d) Sydney
Answers in next week's newsletter, but if you think you know it, hit reply and let me know.
Last week's answer: Which club has finished with the most wins – and draws – but missed the top eight? Collingwood finished ninth last year with 12 wins and two draws.
Congratulations to Chris Morris, who was first to reply with the right answer.
A final day of drama as Western Bulldogs meet Fremantle in an early winner-takes-all clash is just what this damp squib of a season desperately needs.
At the time of writing, Izak Rankine is still awaiting his fate as the AFL continues to deliberate over an appropriate sanction for the Adelaide star's alleged homophobic slur during last weekend's match against Collingwood. 'We are having ongoing discussions with the AFL as part of the due process,' a Crows spokesperson said on Wednesday.
The Crows had earlier handled the hype to break their Magpies hoodoo and prove they are genuine premiership contenders. But Adelaide were handed another blow when Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera rejected interest from both South Australia clubs to stay with St Kilda and become the first player to earn $2m a season.
Reply to this email and drop me a line, or email [e-mail].
Have a friend who might? Forward this to them, or tell them how to get it.