Ontario police may have secretly used controversial Israeli spyware, report finds
Researchers say Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) may have secretly used controversial Israeli spyware technology, raising concerns about potential spying on citizens.
Citizen Lab, which investigates digital espionage against civil society, released a report Wednesday identifying "possible links" between the OPP and Paragon Solutions, a company that sells military-grade spyware called Graphite to government clients.
Graphite can be used to hack into phones, and was recently found to have been used against an Italian journalist and activists who supported migrants, after Meta-owned messaging app WhatsApp reported to nearly 100 users in January that their cellphones may have been compromised.
Human rights group Amnesty International called the discovery out of Italy "alarming" and said it underscored worsening digital surveillance across Europe.
Based on a tip from a collaborator, Citizen Lab mapped out servers connected to Paragon's Graphite tool and found suspected deployments at five IP addresses in Ontario. One of those IP addresses was traced to OPP headquarters in Orillia, Ont.
OPP did not confirm or deny the use of Paragon spyware. Acting Staff Sgt. Jeffrey Del Guidice said in an email to CBC News that the "interception of private communications" requires judicial authorization and is only used in serious criminal investigations.
"The OPP uses investigative tools and techniques in full compliance with the laws of Canada, including the Charter of Rights and Freedoms," Del Guidice said. "Releasing information about specific investigative techniques and technology could jeopardize active investigations and threaten public and officer safety."
Paragon was founded in Israel in 2019 and is now U.S.-owned. Its founders include former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak, as well as Ehud Schneorson, the former commander of Israel's Unit 8200, a secretive cyber warfare unit that was tied to last year's pager attacks in Lebanon that killed more than 30 people and wounded thousands.
The company's minimal website says it provides clients with "cyber and forensic capabilities to locate and analyze digital data, cyber workforce training, and critical infrastructure analysis and threat mitigation."
Law enforcement use of spyware growing, researchers say
Kate Robertson, a senior researcher at Citizen Lab, says the findings underscore the need for governments and privacy regulators to raise questions about the use of spyware against citizens, and for law enforcement agencies to be transparent about the tools they're using.
"When governments themselves become buyers in this proliferating hack-for-hire industry, they're actually investing in the insecurity and vulnerability of our everyday devices that we depend heavily on to be safe for all of our daily needs," Robertson told CBC News.
"It's really turning cybersecurity on its head, to have governments themselves help actors to harbour and exploit vulnerabilities, as opposed to patching them."
Citizen Lab also reported in 2020 that the OPP developed a technology to scrape communications from private, password-protected online chatrooms without obtaining judicial authorization.
WATCH | RCMP deputy commissioner discusses controversial usage of spyware technology:
The group's Wednesday report also detailed evidence of "a growing ecosystem of spyware capability" among both the RCMP and Ontario-based police services.
In 2022, the RCMP admitted it had used spyware that it called an "On-Device Investigative Tool" (ODIT) from an unnamed vendor to collect data and infiltrate mobile devices in more than 30 investigations dating back to 2017, without consulting the public or the Privacy Commissioner of Canada.
Citizen Lab researchers obtained public court records showing OPP had also used the RCMP's ODITs in a 2019 investigation, and that the Toronto Police Service (TPS) independently obtained ODIT software from an unknown source.
They say they also learned of other cases that have been before Ontario courts, or are currently before them, involving other police services that possess ODITS or have sought authorization to deploy them, including York Regional Police Service, Hamilton Police Service and Peel Regional Police Service, in addition to OPP and TPS.
"The apparent expansion of spyware capabilities to potentially multiple police services across Ontario reflects a widening gap in public awareness surrounding the extent to which mercenary spyware is being deployed in Canada," the report states.
CBC News reached out to both the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario and the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, but did not hear back in time for publication.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Miami Herald
29 minutes ago
- Miami Herald
‘This is choking Haiti': Haitians blast Trump administration's travel ban
Even before President Donald Trump told Haitians this week they will no longer be welcome in the United States, travel from the crisis-wracked Caribbean nation was already difficult. It's been restricted by deadly gang violence, repeated airport shutdowns and years-long visa delays at the U.S. Embassy in Port-au-Prince. Now, with the newly instated travel ban, Haitian families are facing prolonged separation and the country risks being further isolated, according to Haitians and heads of U.S.-based organizations who see the move as unfair and discriminatory — and likely to have devastating consequences. 'This is choking Haiti, choking Haitians,' said Clarel Cyriaque, a Miami immigration attorney and longtime Haitian rights advocate. 'The impact on Haiti and Haitians is astronomical.' Haiti is the midst of a spiraling crisis marked by years-long political instability, escalating gang violence, economic collapse and deepening hunger. On Wednesday, Trump made it the only country in the hemisphere whose nationals are banned from entering the U.S. The list of 12 nations with full bans also includes seven African countries. Cuba and Venezuela were added to a list of seven nations with partial bans. The measures are set to take effect on Monday and have left many Haitians confused. While the White House proclamation made clear that the issuance of all new non-immigrant visas for Haitians will be suspended, both State Department and Homeland Security officials have refused to say whether those with current, valid B1/B2 tourist visas will be allowed entry. If those with current visas are banned, it will mean that many children will be unable to see their parents. Due to the ongoing gang violence and kidnappings, many children emigrated to the U.S. with one parent, leaving the other behind. A former Haitian lawmaker who travels frequently to the U.S. to see his own kids, and who is currently in Haiti, said countless families will be split. 'The biggest winner are the gangs, holding the country hostage and instilling terror, which has led the U.S. not to take action to help Haiti to eliminate the gangs but rather to consider all law-abiding Haitian citizens as gangsters and pariahs,' said the lawmaker, who asked not to be named because he fears the ire of U.S. authorities. The ban stands to affect not just all aspects of Haitian life but also South Florida's economy, which offers the only U.S. gateway into the country aboard a Haitian-owned airline. Sunrise Airways became the sole carrier into and out of Haiti after gangs opened fire on three U.S. commercial airlines flying over Port-au-Prince's Toussaint Louverture International Airport in November, prompting an ongoing Federal Aviation Administration ban on U.S. airlines. ''Why are they doing this now?' said Nathan Letang, a Haitian businessman. 'Why are they doing this to Haiti in 2015?' Letang, attending a Boston Foundation Haiti Funders Conference in Boston this week, blasted the ban as an effort to 'humiliate Haitians.... If they want to isolate Haiti, they should just say they want to isolate Haiti.' The Caribbean nation is already isolated from the neighbor with which it shares the island of Hispaniola. Since April 2024, the Dominican Republic has had its airspace closed to Haiti, and since January has deported more than 139,000 Haitians back to their country. Terrorist designation, travel ban Last month, Secretary of State Marco Rubio designated some of Haiti's most powerful gangs as global and foreign terrorists, a label that was welcomed by some Haitians, though others now see as having devastating consequences after President's Trump travel ban. The ban, and the terrorist designation, are likely meant to deal with the problem of illegal arms trafficking to Haitian gangs, which have used South Florida ports to smuggle weapons to Haiti, said Kim Lamberty, executive director of the Washington-based Quixote Center, a nonprofit social justice organization that advocates on behalf of Haiti. Administration officials, she said, are afraid of taking on the U.S. gun lobby to curtail the illegal arms and have instead turned to measures like the terrorist designation and the travel ban. 'This visa thing now punishes regular people,' Lamberty said, 'because they [U.S. authorities] don't think they can deal with the real issue because of the gun lobby.' In justifying Haiti's ban, Trump's proclamation cites the Haitian government's inability to provide the 'information necessary to ensure its nationals do not undermine the national security of the United States.' The administration also cites high so-called overstays — over 31% for B1/B2 tourist visa holders, and 25% for individuals with student visas. 'Additionally, hundreds of thousands of illegal Haitian aliens flooded into the United States during the Biden Administration,' the proclamation said, in reference to the more than 200,000 Haitians who legally entered the U.S. under a humanitarian parole program that required them to have a financial sponsor in the U.S., undergo government background checks and buy airline tickets. 'This influx harms American communities by creating acute risks of increased overstay rates, establishment of criminal networks, and other national security threats,' the proclamation added. The Congressional Black Caucus on Friday issued a statement blasting the travel ban, noting that the majority of the nations involved have predominanly Black and brown populations. In the case of Haiti, the CBC met with the country's new ambassador to the U.S., Lionel Delatour. 'This proclamation has nothing to do with national security. Rather, it represents a continuation of the Trump Administration's long standing pattern of bigoted attacks against Black and brown nations,' Rep. Yvette Clarke, a New York Democrat, said. 'His aim is to create fear, sow division, and demonize the vulnerable—many of whom are struggling to recover from catastrophic circumstances, seeking life-saving medical attention, or have waited decades to be reunited with family members.' U.S.-based organizations that rely on visas to bring employees to the United States for training and conferences warn of the ripple effects and say the new policy is akin to keeping people 'inside a burning house.' 'They're actually blaming the people, as if they twisted the Biden administration's arms to create these programs through a planned invasion, and now they must pay the consequences,' said Cyriaque. The narrative being pushed by the Trump administration is that beneficiaries of the Biden-era humanitarian parole program known as CHNV, the initials of the four countries affected — Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua and Venezuela — have assaulted the immigration system. Haitians haven't had access to normal visa services at the U.S. Embassy in Port-au-Prince since before the COVID-19 pandemic, which created huge backlogs in the processing of applications. The gang violence that escalated after the July 2021 assassination of the president, Jovenel Moïse, only exacerbated the situation. The embassy's next appointment to process requests for non-immigrant visas to the U.S. is in 2026. In the meantime, the country has continued to plunge deeper into chaos. The main international airport in Port-au-Prince remains close to U.S. commercial traffic. Roads in and out of the capital, already in imminent danger of collapse, are controlled by armed groups, leaving those with means and connections to resort to helicopter flights to escape the violence out of the only airport connecting them to the outside world in Cap-Haïtien. Longtime U.S. visa holder and Haitian development professional Ronel says this is what led him and his wife to leave the country under the humanitarian parole program in 2023, after spending a year in limbo unable to get his U.S. visa renewed. 'I was stuck,' he said. 'There was no more hope.' After arriving in the U.S., Ronel, who asked that his last name not be used to avoid being targeted by U.S. immigration authorities, applied for political asylum, citing threats against him as a youth organizer and international project coordinator in Haiti. Despite his fear of persecution in Haiti, he's says he's now considering abandoning his asylum application. 'Even though I was actually persecuted in Haiti... the thing with asylum is you cannot travel, and I am a global traveler,' he said. 'I am part of different networks in the world, volunteer networks; there are conferences happening everywhere in the world, and you're stuck.' He is also concerned about the Trump administration's targeting of Haitians and other immigrants, especially the half-million in the Biden-era parole program who are now being targeted for deportation after the U.S. Supreme Court gave Trump the green light last week. 'I don't want to stay in the U.S. with this situation. I don't like living in distress,' said Ronel, 38. 'That's why we are really actively exploring the alternatives, before it's too late.' While he and his wife are exploring several countries to move to, there is one that is off the table: Haiti. 'I don't want to be stuck in Haiti,' he said. 'It's hard for you to get out of the country and almost everywhere you go, requires you to transit through the United States.... This is very bad news for Haitian professionals who want to be connected with the world.'
Hamilton Spectator
33 minutes ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Residents speak out about homeless encampment at town hall organized by MLA
Calls for amending the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and imposing long jail terms on drug dealers were among several proposed solutions from residents at a packed community forum on homelessness in Penticton Thursday evening. Between 150 and 200 people gathered at the Penticton Seniors' Drop-in Centre for the town hall, which was organized by Penticton-Summerland MLA and former city councillor Amelia Boultbee. Penticton Mayor Julius Bloomfield also attended. After opening remarks from the two officials, the meeting shifted to a town hall format, allowing residents to share concerns and ask questions directly. The focus of the event was the growing homeless encampment located along the Penticton Channel Parkway near Fairview Road, where as many as 70 individuals are now believed to be living in tents. The site lacks basic sanitation, including running water or washrooms, and lies close to environmentally sensitive areas such as Ellis Creek and Skaha Lake, heightening public health and ecological concerns. A wide range of opinions were voiced during the forum, reflecting the deep divide and frustration among residents about how the issue has been handled. One of the first speakers estimated that about half of those living in the encampment are physically able to work but choose not to. 'There shouldn't be any enabling for these people to sit around and get free stuff,' he said. 'If there was a test that said, 'You're able to work, buddy,' you'd get a year and a half to find a job or be cut off. Food is free, medical is free, shelter is free. There's no logic – just come and go as you please.' He also criticized the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, introduced in 1982 under Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau, blaming it for what he sees as a culture of entitlement and lack of accountability. 'I call it the Charter of Wrongs and Foibles,' he said. 'What this has done is given people the right and the freedom—mainly by lefty lawyers—to do whatever the hell they want.' He acknowledged that changing the Charter would be a monumental task requiring approval from seven provinces and at least 51% of the voting population, but insisted it's necessary. 'Unless that happens, someone's going to fight a Charter challenge and we'll be stuck here forever.' Boultbee responded by acknowledging the frustration in the room, but emphasized that most people living in these conditions aren't simply freeloaders. 'The data doesn't support that a large number of unhoused people just don't want to work,' she said. 'Most are dealing with mental health issues, trauma, or complex personal challenges. I understand the anger, but we also have to look at the facts.' A senior man took a broader view, blaming capitalism and systemic greed for the social breakdown that has led to widespread homelessness. He called on the federal government to take responsibility and help municipalities shoulder the cost of addressing the crisis. 'We keep shoving these people all over the place. We want to shut down this encampment, but there's nowhere else for them to go,' he said. 'Too many bureaucracies are involved, and they're not working together.' He added that some individuals may never re-integrate into society and acknowledged the need for ongoing support systems. However, he was adamant that drug dealers must be held accountable. 'More than 50,000 Canadians have died of overdoses in the past eight years. There has been a complete failure in our judicial system. We're babying the criminals who are killing these people.' Another resident described how crime has affected his personal life. Living in a well-kept neighborhood in the south end of Penticton, he recounted how his daughter's $3,000 electric bike was stolen from their backyard shed at 6 a.m. one morning. 'We caught the guy on camera—he was nicely dressed, didn't look like a drug addict or a thief,' he said. Relying on a hunch, he drove to the homeless encampment and spotted the stolen bike within minutes. After calling police, the bike was returned the same day. 'That's a happy ending to an ugly story,' he said. 'But these incidents are happening across our city. It's affecting all of us.' He added that earlier in the year, two windows of his truck were smashed and several items stolen in broad daylight. The repair process took three months and cost him significantly, even after insurance. Boultbee acknowledged a shift in provincial policy under Premier David Eby's NDP government. 'We're starting to see less emphasis on free drugs for addicts and more support for involuntary care for those who are severely unwell. That's encouraging. These individuals are not okay. They need help.' A business owner spoke next, sharing her frustration with how nearby businesses have been affected by the encampment. 'It's not illegal to be homeless, but a lot of what's happening there is illegal,' she said, noting a rise in vandalism and theft that has forced many businesses to invest heavily in security measures. Boultbee agreed, saying that small businesses are bearing the brunt of the crisis. 'It's beyond frustrating. Our private business owners, entrepreneurs, everyday folks—they're the ones experiencing loss. The word 'inconvenience' doesn't begin to cover it.' Another speaker referenced well-known local volunteer Allan Garland, a senior who has spent the past decade picking up trash and removing invasive weeds along the Channel. Garland was allegedly assaulted by homeless campers during one of his regular cleanups. 'He's a dedicated citizen who deserves a medal, not to be attacked and beaten up by thugs,' the speaker said. Bloomfield responded that funding has historically favored larger centres, where governments believe they get 'more bang for their buck.' But he said the tide is turning. 'The province now realizes this is not just a big city problem—it's everywhere.' He also shared that the Okanagan Correctional Centre has been operating at less than 30% capacity due to staffing shortages. Bloomfield said he had recently asked whether a portion of the jail could be used for addiction rehab, only to learn that no such feasibility study has ever been done. 'But I can tell you that conversation is finally happening,' he said. 'Two years ago, the provincial government wasn't interested. Now they're actively exploring all options, including mandatory rehabilitation. That's a big shift.' As the evening wrapped up, residents were united by a shared sense of urgency—even if they didn't agree on the solutions. One common sentiment: the status quo is no longer acceptable. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Enfinity Global sells minority stakes in two BESS projects
Enfinity Global has divested 49% of its interest in two significant battery energy storage system (BESS) projects, with a combined capacity of 380MW, to Daiwa Energy & Infrastructure. The projects, located in the US and Italy, will enhance grid resilience and meet increasing power demands. The US-based project is situated in the Houston zone of the Electric Reliability Council of Texas area and has a 250MW BESS with a two-hour duration and 500 megawatt hours (MWh) capacity. Located in the Veneto region, the Italian project comprises a 130MW BESS with a four-hour duration and 520MWh capacity. Operations for both projects will commence by 2027. Enfinity Global maintains a controlling stake of 51% and is tasked with overseeing the development, construction and long-term asset management of both projects. Enfinity Global CEO Carlos Domenech stated: 'We are honoured to partner with Daiwa Energy & Infrastructure, one of Japan's leading financial institutions, to bring new investments to the USA and Italy. 'This is a win-win outcome and creates a demonstrable case study, strengthening the grid capabilities, accelerating powering of reliable competitive clean energy for customers, cross-border capital investments at attractive returns, and bringing the best global solutions by long-term responsible sponsors.' The partnership with Daiwa will bolster infrastructure to support data centres, AI and industrial electrification in both regions. Legal aspects of the transaction were managed by Winston & Strawn and DLA Piper for Enfinity Global, while Daiwa Energy & Infrastructure sought counsel from Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe, Ensight Energy Consulting and Ernst & Young. Enfinity's global head of capital and general manager for the Americas Ricardo Diaz stated: 'We are pleased to be able to bring in Daiwa Energy & Infrastructure as a capital partner to our BESS projects in the US and Italy. Bringing long-term, like-minded investors as shareholders in our global portfolios is central to our capital formation strategy to accelerate growth and optimise returns.' In a related development, Enfinity Global secured a €100m ($112.2m) bond facility from Eiffel Investment Group to propel the deployment of energy storage and solar photovoltaic projects across Europe. "Enfinity Global sells minority stakes in two BESS projects" was originally created and published by Power Technology, a GlobalData owned brand. The information on this site has been included in good faith for general informational purposes only. It is not intended to amount to advice on which you should rely, and we give no representation, warranty or guarantee, whether express or implied as to its accuracy or completeness. You must obtain professional or specialist advice before taking, or refraining from, any action on the basis of the content on our site.
