New Study Shows Smartwatch Stress Sensors Have No Idea What They're Doing
Researchers studied 800 young adults using the same Garmin Vivosmart 4 smartwatch model. They compared the data the smartwatches produced with the reports that the users created four times per day about how sleepy or stressed they were feeling. Lead author and associate professor Eiko Fried said the correlation between the wearable data and the user-created data was, "basically zero."
A representative for Garmin did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Stressed or sex? Your watch doesn't know
So why do wearables like fitness smartwatches get it so wrong? Their sensors are fairly limited in what they can do. Watches like these need to be worn correctly at all times (a loose or tight watch may give poor readings, for example), and they typically use basic information like pulse rate and movement to make guesses about health.
Those guesses don't always reflect real-world scenarios. A wearable may identify high stress when the real cause of the change was a workout, excitement over good news, or sex. There are so many potential alternatives to stress or fatigue that the watches in the study never really got it right -- and the devices sometimes guessed the complete opposite emotional state from what users recorded.
The Dutch study did note that Garmin's Body Battery readings, which specifically measure physical fatigue, were more reliable than stress indicators, but still inaccurate. And sleep sensing performed the best of them all, with Garmin watches showing a two-thirds chance of noting the differences between a good night's sleep and a bad one.
It's also worth noting that smartwatch sensors can become more accurate as technology improves. It would be interesting to run a similar study with the much newer Garmin Vivosmart 5 to see if anything has improved, as well as see if other models like the latest versions of the Apple Watch have similar accuracy results.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wall Street Journal
18 minutes ago
- Wall Street Journal
Eli Lilly to Raise U.K. Price of Mounjaro for Out-of-Pocket Patients
Pharma giant Eli Lilly said it is negotiating to raise drug prices in Europe, starting in the U.K. with the weight-loss drug Mounjaro, so that it can comply with the Trump administration's goal of bringing down prices in the U.S. Lilly said Thursday that it has an agreement with the U.K. government to raise the list price of Mounjaro for patients who pay for it out-of-pocket. Lilly will more than double the list price of Mounjaro's highest dose from about $165 to about $446. The new price is in line with the prices paid in the rest of Europe and other developed countries, Lilly said.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Sapiens International (SPNS) Skyrockets 44% on $2.5-Billion Merger With Advent
We recently published . Sapiens International Corp. N.V. (NASDAQ:SPNS) is one of the best-performing stocks on Wednesday. Sapiens International skyrocketed by 44.27 percent on Wednesday, a fourth day, to close at $42.56 apiece following news that it was set to be acquired by private equity firm Advent for $2.5 billion. In a statement, Sapiens International Corp. N.V. (NASDAQ:SPNS) said it entered into an agreement with Advent for the sale of more than 57.47 million common shares at a price of $43.5 apiece. The transaction, which will be entirely paid in cash, represents a 64-percent premium over Sapiens International Corp. N.V.'s (NASDAQ:SPNS) closing price of $26.52 last August 8, as well as a premium of approximately 51 percent to both the 30- and 60-day volume-weighted average price from the same period. Pixabay/Public Domain Meanwhile, minority shareholder Formula Systems (1985) Ltd. will retain its ownership in the company. Sapiens International Corp. N.V. (NASDAQ:SPNS) expects the transaction to close either in the fourth quarter of the year or in the first quarter of 2026, subject to closing conditions, including shareholder approval. While we acknowledge the potential of SPNS as an investment, our conviction lies in the belief that some AI stocks hold greater promise for delivering higher returns and have limited downside risk. If you are looking for an extremely cheap AI stock that is also a major beneficiary of Trump tariffs and onshoring, see our free report on the . Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
7 Sleep Behaviors That May Actually Be Sneaky Signs Of ADHD
Late-night scrolling, restless tossing and groggy mornings aren't always the result of too much caffeine or poor sleep hygiene, but could also be signs of something deeper. As ADHD diagnoses rise among adults, experts shed light on how the condition can impact sleep behaviors in ways that often go unrecognized. And if you're experiencing any of these challenges, here are expert-backed strategies to help improve your sleep. 1. Sleeping And Waking At Atypical Times Though often seen as simply being a night owl, there's actually a strong neurological overlap between ADHD and circadian rhythm disruptions like delayed sleep phase syndrome (DSPS). 'People with ADHD often experience a delayed release of melatonin, making it harder to feel sleepy at conventional times,' said Dr. Chelsea Sarai, clinical psychologist and founder of the Brentwood Therapy Collective. 'Combined with difficulty transitioning between tasks and regulating internal cues, their sleep-wake cycles naturally shift later and later, often without them realizing it.' The brain of someone with DSPS is wired to come alive at night, which makes it challenging to match typical daily routines. A way to gradually shift one's sleep schedule earlier is by getting exposure to natural light in the morning to help reset the body's internal clock. 'In the evening, reducing blue light exposure and maintaining a consistent wind-down routine can reinforce those shifts,' Sarai said. Related: 2. Difficulty 'Shutting Off' The Brain At Night Feeling physically tired but mentally alert can lead to long nights awake, and growing sleep debt. 'A hallmark of ADHD is difficulty regulating attention, not just focusing when needed, but also knowing how to mentally disengage,' Sarai said. 'At night, when external distractions fade, the brain suddenly has space to process everything that's been pushed aside during the day. This often leads to a surge of racing thoughts or mental 'noise' that makes it hard to wind down and fall asleep.' These thoughts can resemble anxiety, but Sarai notes they're not always anxious — they might be creative ideas or hyperfixations. Be realistic about how long it takes to fall asleep and create a wind-down routine to support it. 'It could look like writing down all the thoughts in one's head before bed as a way to honor those creative thoughts and trust that you will get back to them at a more appropriate time,' Sarai said. 3. Trouble Waking Up Despite Adequate Sleep Trouble waking up despite getting enough sleep is often brushed off as laziness, poor self-discipline or even a sign of depression. But in many cases, it can be attributed to having a delayed circadian rhythm and the ADHD brain struggling to shift from sleep to wakefulness, said Dr. Zishan Khan, a child and adolescent psychiatrist and regional medical director at Mindpath Health. 'Low dopamine and norepinephrine levels in the morning can also lead to grogginess, poor motivation and difficulty activating for the day,' he added. He suggests regulating the sleep-wake cycle by implementing consistent bedtimes and wake times, even on weekends, and using visual cues or alarms that gradually increase in volume or light. Related: 4. Using Screens To Fall Asleep Those with ADHD often turn to screens to calm a restless mind. 'The sensory stimulation — visual, auditory or narrative — can help distract from intrusive thoughts or anxiety, making it easier to drift off,' Khan said. For some, screens even mirror the level of internal alertness they're used to, which paradoxically helps them settle. But because screens suppress melatonin and delay sleep onset, even if someone falls asleep while using one, their sleep quality may still suffer from continued stimulation or disrupted sleep cycles. To support better sleep, try gradually replacing screen time with low-stimulation options like audiobooks, white noise or guided meditations. 'Establishing a 30- to 60-minute wind-down period before bed is crucial, ideally involving non-screen activities that still provide sensory regulation, such as dim lighting, gentle music or tactile tools like weighted blankets,' Khan said. 5. Bedtime Procrastination Delaying bedtime despite knowing it's time to sleep is often tied to poor time perception and difficulty shifting away from preferred activities. 'People with ADHD may hyperfocus on an enjoyable task late into the evening or delay sleep because it represents the end of their 'free time' after a demanding day,' Khan said. Related: In kids and teens, this can be mistaken for defiance. A consistent, rewarding bedtime routine with built-in cues and transitions can help. 'Visual timers, reminders and positive reinforcement can help signal the winding-down process,' Khan said. 'For those with ADHD, it's key to build in extra time for this process, as it often takes longer than expected to shift gears.' 6. Frequent Middle-Of-The-Night Wakeups People with ADHD often experience fragmented sleep due to arousal dysregulation and heightened sensitivity to environmental stimuli like noise or light. 'When they wake, which is normal even for good sleepers, they may struggle to fall back asleep due to intrusive thoughts or urges to engage in stimulating activities,' said Dr. Nicole Moshfegh, a licensed clinical psychologist and director of We Rise Psychology, Inc. These disruptions can prevent the brain from cycling through all the important stages of sleep, especially deep and REM sleep, leading to grogginess, reduced focus and memory, and less impulse control the next day. If you wake up at night, avoid checking the clock or using screens, which can increase alertness. Instead, Moshfegh suggests practicing stimulus control: if you're awake for 15 to 20 minutes, get out of bed and do a quiet, dim-light activity like reading or stretching until you feel sleepy. 'This helps recondition the brain to associate the bed with sleep, not wakefulness.' Related: 7. Oversleeping On Days Off Sleeping in on days off often reflects an attempt to make up for late or inconsistent bedtimes during the week. 'Without external structure, they revert to their intrinsic rhythm of going to bed and sleeping in later,' Moshfegh said of those with ADHD. 'Oversleeping on weekends leads to social jet lag, a mismatch between biological and social clocks.' This can make it harder to fall asleep Sunday night and leave you tired at the start of the week. To keep your sleep on track, stick to consistent wake-up times and get morning light, either by going outside or using a light therapy box, within 30 to 60 minutes of waking. 'This light acts as a strong cue to anchor your internal clock and reduce daytime sleepiness,' Moshfegh said. Here's When To Consider An ADHD Assessment If you consistently struggle to fall asleep, stay asleep or wake up feeling unrefreshed despite practicing good sleep hygiene, and these issues coexist with difficulties in focus, organization, time management or emotional regulation, it may be worth seeking an evaluation for ADHD. 'This is especially true if sleep difficulties have been lifelong or began in childhood, and if they interfere with daytime functioning at school, work or in relationships,' Khan said. 'It's important to view sleep problems not in isolation, but in the context of other symptoms that may point toward a broader neurodevelopmental condition.' Related... Is This ADHD Symptom Messing With Your Sex Life? 7 Relationship Habits That Secretly May Be Signs Of ADHD 7 Relationship Habits That Secretly May Be Signs Of ADHD
