Huge Victory For Free Speech: Journalist Gagged For Exposing Chinese Communist Party Interference In NZ Wins Court Case
The Free Speech Union is embarking on extensive work to thoroughly review the HDCA, analysing all decisions ever made under it, and will present this to the Minister of Justice later in the year. We cannot stand by while individuals like Portia are …
Portia Mao, a Kiwi-Chinese journalist who was gagged under the Harmful Digital Communications Act (HDCA) for exposing foreign interference in New Zealand, has won her court case with the Free Speech Union's help. This is a major victory, not just for Portia, but for all Kiwis' speech rights, says Jonathan Ayling, Chief Executive of the Free Speech Union.
'We're thrilled that Portia Mao, represented by the Free Speech Union, has won her court case and is no longer gagged by New Zealand law after calling out the Chinese Communist Party's overreach in New Zealand. This is excellent news for all Kiwis.
'CCP stooge, Morgan Zhihong Xiao, sought interim orders under the HDCA against Portia Mao, alleging online defamation and harassment. The initial orders (granted without notice!) required Portia to remove online commentary and apologise. With the FSU's representation, Portia applied to be heard and have the orders discharged. Judge McIlraith ruled in Portia's favour.
'The Court also rightly warned against weaponising legal tools to silence criticism, especially in political debate. The HDCA, while created with good intentions, has been weaponised now in a number of cases to silence dissent.
'Portia's victory is a huge step in pushing back on this flawed law. It was also essential for ensuring criticising foreign powers remains a legal right in New Zealand. If governments, foreign or not, can twist our own law to stop us from exposing them, then we are not free.
'The Free Speech Union is embarking on extensive work to thoroughly review the HDCA, analysing all decisions ever made under it, and will present this to the Minister of Justice later in the year. We cannot stand by while individuals like Portia are unjustly silenced.
'When a brave journalist is gagged for putting their neck on the line in our country, alarm bells should ring. Portia's victory was made possible by the thousands of Kiwis who support our work, and this result is the best outcome to protect all Kiwis' rights to seek, receive, and impart information.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
11 hours ago
- Scoop
NGOs Welcome Long-Awaited Reforms To New Zealand's Child Trafficking Laws
The Human Trafficking Research Coalition has welcomed the Justice Minister Hon Paul Goldsmith's announcement of reforms to New Zealand's criminal trafficking laws, calling it a vital and long-overdue step forward. The reforms will: Remove the requirement to prove coercion or deception when the trafficked victim is under 18. Make it explicit that consent is irrelevant when the victim is under 18 or when coercion or deception was present. 'This is a real win for advocacy. World Vision New Zealand, ECPAT Child Alert, Tearfund New Zealand and Hagar New Zealand have been advocating for years through the Human Trafficking Research Coalition for the definition of child trafficking to be amended. Our core message has been clear: when the victim is a child, coercion or deception should not need to be proven, and consent is irrelevant,' the Coalition said in a statement. Rebekah Armstrong, Human Trafficking Research Coalition member and Head of Advocacy and Justice at World Vision New Zealand, said the announcement was 'also a reminder of the importance of engaging in select committee processes. Survivors, academics, lawyers, and NGOs all contributed during the hearings for Greg Fleming MP's bill to increase penalties for slavery offences, which included recommendations to strengthen the wider modern slavery legal framework.' While welcoming the reforms, Eleanor Parkes, Human Trafficking Research Coalition member and National Director of ECPAT NZ, noted there is still more work to do: 'These reforms also need to include more comprehensive changes to the trafficking provisions in the Crimes Act 1961 to make sure all the current legal gaps are addressed — including the definition of 'means' and 'exploitation' so we're looking forward to seeing more of the detail over the coming weeks, and hopefully continuing to strengthen our anti-trafficking legislation.'
RNZ News
14 hours ago
- RNZ News
Cautious optimism over changes to human trafficking law
Anti human trafficking advocates are welcoming news that trafficking and people smuggling laws will soon be strengthened - with the hope it will result in more prosecutions. Since 2009, over 50 victims of trafficking have been identified in New Zealand, but only four prosecutions have been undertaken and just two of these prosecutions have led to a conviction. The Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith confirmed the changes would form part of the current reforms being made to the Crimes Act. Rebekah Armstrong is a member of the Human Trafficking Research Coalition and Head of Advocacy and Justice at World Vision New Zealand. Photo: - vimeo - Nancy Kelley
NZ Herald
17 hours ago
- NZ Herald
NZ woman detained in US may be released this week, says father
'We got messages all the way through – yes, they're at the airport, they're on the plane, they're taking off – and then she went to go back across into the US, and then I got a frantic call to say that she's being detained and they're about to take my phone off me and they're locking me up for the night.' He started to get properly concerned when he heard they had flown Shaw and Isaac to Texas, to the nearest detainment centre which accommodates families. The children on the way to Canada, excited to see their grandparents. Photo / Supplied The conditions had been difficult for them both. Her friend Victoria Besancon previously told RNZ the detention facility was 'very similar to a prison'. 'She is in a locked room with five bunk beds, she is allowed to walk around the facility from 8am to 8pm, but outside of that she is locked in a cell with other families.' But Price said among the detainees, they were the lucky ones. His daughter spoke English as a first language and had access to good lawyers – even if the logistics involved in contacting them were a little complicated. Her lawyer Minda Thorward told RNZ: 'I cannot call her, she can only call me, and then I have to be available to receive the call and press one to allow the call to come through. So communication is a little bit of an issue.' Besancon has been appointed power of attorney, making logistics a little easier. The past week had brought a big increase in media coverage and pressure from Washington state officials, and staff from the New Zealand embassy had made contact with Shaw, after learning of her case from reports in the media. Besancon said it was making a difference. 'They started really changing the way they've been speaking with her legal representation.' And Price said they were feeling optimistic. 'There's a 90% chance that she's going to be out Thursday, which is our Friday, 3pm. She's so confident that she's already booked a flight back to Seattle.' If that did not go to plan, a court date was locked in for August 29, in which Shaw would have the opportunity to fight for her release in front of a judge. Family and friends are pleading for the release of a Kiwi mother of three and her 6-year-old son after they were detained by US immigration. Photo / Supplied Meanwhile, her other two children, aged 8 and 10, were enjoying sunny Whangaparāoa, although they were anxious for their mum, Price said. 'Ah, the young fella, it's just water off a duck's back, but my granddaughter is – she won't outright say it – but you know, you can tell by their actions and their concern and questions.' He said the children would be staying with him until there was someone to meet them at the other end. - RNZ
