Divergence emerges between human traders and computer-driven investors
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
Chasing Momentum
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
CTA Risk
The thing about trading stocks is everyone has an opinion. And right now there's an unusual divergence in the market that's as stark as man versus machine.Computer-guided traders haven't been this bullish on stocks compared to their human counterparts since early 2020, before the depths of the Covid pandemic, according to Parag Thatte, a strategist at Deutsche Bank AG The two groups look at different cues to form their opinions, so it's not a shock that they see the market differently. While computer-driven fast-money quants use systematic strategies based on momentum and volatility signals, discretionary money managers are individuals looking at economic and earnings trends to guide their moves.Still, this degree of disagreement is rare — and historically, it doesn't last long, Thatte said.'Discretionary investors are waiting for something to give, whether that's slowing growth or a spike in inflation in the second half of the year from tariffs,' he said. 'As the data trickles in, their concerns will either be proven right if the market sells off on growth fears, or the economy will remain resilient, in which case discretionary managers would likely begin to lift their stock exposure on economic optimism.'Wall Street offers a lot of confident predictions, but the reality is nobody knows what will happen with President Donald Trump's trade agenda or the Federal Reserve's interest-rate policy.With the S&P 500 Index repeatedly hitting all-time highs, professional investors aren't sticking around to find out. As of the week ended Aug. 1, they'd cut their equity exposure from neutral to modestly underweight on lingering uncertainty surrounding global trade, corporate earnings and economic growth, according to data compiled by Deutsche Bank.'No one wants to buy pricier stocks already at records so some are praying for any selloff as an excuse to buy,' said Frank Monkam, head of macro trading at Buffalo Bayou Commodities.Trend-following algorithmic funds, however, are chasing that momentum. They've been lured into a buying spree after cut-to-the-bone positioning in the spring cleared the path to return in recent months as the S&P 500 rallied almost 30% from its April low. Through the week ended Aug. 1, long equity positions for systematic strategies were the highest since January 2020, Deutsche Bank's data show.This divergence underpins the tug-of-war between technical and fundamental forces, with the S&P 500 stuck in a tight range after posting its longest streak of tranquility in two years in July.The Cboe Volatility Index — or VIX — which measures implied volatility of the benchmark US equity futures via out-of-the-money options, closed at 15.15 on Friday, near the lowest level since February.The VVIX, which measures the volatility of volatility, dropped for the third time in four weeks.'The rubber band can only stretch so far before it snaps,' said Colton Loder, managing principal of the alternative investment firm Cohalo. 'So the potential for a mean-reversion selloff is higher when there's systematic crowding, like now.'This kind of collective piling into a trade periodically happens with computer-driven strategies. In early 2023, for instance, quants loaded up on US stocks on the heels of the S&P 500's 19% drop in 2022, until volatility spiked in March of that year during the regional banking tumult. And in late 2019, fast-money traders powered stocks to records after a breakthrough in trade talks between Washington and Beijing.This time around, however, Thatte expects this split between man and machine to last weeks, not months. If discretionary traders start selling in response to weaker growth or softening corporate earnings trends, pushing volatility higher, computer-based strategies are likely to begin to unwind their positions as well, he said.In addition, fast-money investors will likely reach full exposure to US equities by September, which could prompt them to sell stocks as they become vulnerable to downside market shocks, according to Scott Rubner of Citadel Securities.Given how systematic funds operate, selling may start with commodity trading advisors, or CTAs, unwinding extreme positioning, Loder said. That would increase the risk of sharp reversals in the stock market, although there would need to be a substantial selloff for a spike in volatility to last, he added.CTAs, who have been persistent stock buyers, are long $50 billion of US stocks, putting them in the 92nd percentile of historical exposure, according to Goldman Sachs Group Inc. However, the S&P 500 would need to breach 6,100, a decline of roughly 4.5% from where the index closed on Friday, for CTAs to begin dumping stocks, said Maxwell Grinacoff, head of equity derivatives research at UBS Group AG.So the question is, with quant positioning this stretched to the bullish side and pressure building in the stock market due to extreme levels of uncertainty, can any rally from here really last?'Things are starting to feel toppy,' said Grinacoff, adding that the upside for stocks 'is likely exhausted' in the short run given that CTA positioning is near max long. 'This is a bit worrisome, but it's not raising alarm bells yet.'What's more, any pullback from systematic selling would likely create an opportunity for discretionary asset managers who missed out on this year's gains to re-enter the market as buyers, warding off a more severe plunge, according to Cohalo's Loder.'Whatever triggers the next drawdown is a mystery,' he said. 'But when that eventually happens, asset-manager exposure and discretionary positioning is so light that it will add fuel to a 'buy the dip' mentality and prevent an even bigger selloff.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
12 minutes ago
- Economic Times
In 2019, Rs 50K was gold and now it can't pay rent: CA explains why most are struggling, not 'surviving' in urban cities
Synopsis Chartered Accountant Nitin Kaushik has warned that in 2025, earning less than Rs 50,000 a month in metros like Bengaluru, Mumbai, or Pune means barely covering basic expenses. He says rent alone swallows 40-60% of income, with essentials and lifestyle costs doubling in three years. Bengaluru's prime-area rents have surged up to 100% since 2022. Kaushik estimates singles need Rs 20-30 lakh annually for comfort, families Rs 40-50 lakh. Even Rs 1 lakh earners struggle, prompting his call for upskilling, smart budgeting, and early investment. TIL Creatives Representative AI Image Living in India's largest cities has become a battle to stay afloat. Chartered Accountant Nitin Kaushik says that in 2025, a monthly income below Rs 50,000 in Bengaluru, Mumbai, or Pune means 'barely breaking even' rather than on X, he warned that rents alone consume 40-60% of many urban salaries. Add transport, food, and utilities, and there is little left over. 'Living in a metro today without a strong salary equals financial pressure 24x7,' Kaushik wrote. — Finance_Bareek (@Finance_Bareek) Bengaluru, long considered India's tech capital, has seen one of the sharpest rent hikes. Kaushik pointed out that in prime neighbourhoods, one-bedroom flats that cost around Rs 18,000 a month in early 2022 now exceed Rs 30,000. That is an increase of 70-100%.He linked the rise to several factors — the return to office after COVID, a wave of job relocations, and growing real estate demand from NRIs and investors. Kaushik also highlighted that the price of essentials such as food, energy, and transport has stayed high. Combined with lifestyle spending, this has made metro living nearly twice as expensive as it was just three years ago. For those hoping to live comfortably, Kaushik estimates that in 2025, a single person in Bengaluru would need a CTC of Rs 20-30 lakh a year. For a family with one child, that figure rises to Rs 40-50 lakh, which he says would cover good housing, schooling, leisure, and savings. Kaushik warned that even households earning Rs 1 lakh a month are often stuck living paycheck to paycheck due to lifestyle expenses. His advice is direct: upskill to increase income, manage rent and commuting costs, start investing early, and look beyond headline salaries to focus on take-home pay after adjusting for living summed up the shift bluntly: 'Your Rs 50K/month in 2019 was gold. In 2025, it barely pays rent.'
Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
Over half of US industries are cutting jobs, and history says a recession could be next
The U.S. economy is sending increasingly alarming signals as more than half of key industries cut jobs in July 2025, fueling growing concerns among economists and investors about an impending recession. After years of steady growth, the sudden spike in layoffs across manufacturing, retail, and construction sectors marks a sharp reversal — one that experts say could be a leading indicator of broader economic trouble ahead. Why are job losses climbing sharply in major U.S. industries? July's labor reports reveal a widespread contraction: manufacturing shed 11,000 jobs following losses in prior months, retail job cuts skyrocketed by 249% year-over-year, and construction layoffs intensified amid cooling demand. Healthcare stands out as the lone sector still adding workers, but its growth is not enough to offset the broader decline. Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass Batch-1 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 2 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 3 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Artificial Intelligence AI For Business Professionals By Vaibhav Sisinity View Program Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 4 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Artificial Intelligence AI For Business Professionals Batch 2 By Ansh Mehra View Program Economist Mark Zandi of Moody's Analytics highlights the significance: 'Payroll employment growth has stalled, and downward revisions to previous months' data confirm weakening momentum beneath the surface.' He stresses that employment trends often presage economic shifts — and these recent layoffs are sending a clear warning. How could rising job cuts affect the U.S. economic outlook? Despite a robust 3% GDP gain in the second quarter, the labor market slowdown threatens to undercut consumer spending, which drives nearly 70% of the U.S. economy. As layoffs rise, households may tighten their belts, dampening demand and slowing growth further. Labor force participation rates are also slipping, as uncertainty pushes some workers to leave the job market altogether. The Federal Reserve is reportedly eyeing interest rate cuts to cushion the blow, but monetary policy typically takes months to ripple through the economy. Live Events Are policymakers ready to tackle a looming recession risk? Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has underscored the central role of a healthy job market in sustaining economic expansion. The Fed's anticipated rate cuts aim to encourage borrowing and investment, but experts caution these moves may not fully take effect soon enough to prevent a downturn. Meanwhile, businesses are increasingly cautious, pausing hiring and scaling back expansion plans amid uncertainty over future demand. This collective retrenchment risks deepening the slowdown if not addressed promptly. What do experts predict about the timing and likelihood of a recession? Views among economists vary, but caution prevails. Mark Zandi warns a recession is 'increasingly probable,' though pinning down an exact timeline remains difficult. Others point to pockets of resilience, particularly in technology and services, that might soften the blow or delay a full downturn. Ultimately, the U.S. economy's trajectory will hinge on consumer confidence, global trade dynamics, and the Federal Reserve's policy effectiveness. But rising layoffs and flat payroll growth are unmistakable red flags signaling that more challenging times may lie ahead. How should Americans prepare as recession fears grow? With job losses spreading and hiring stalls becoming more common, workers and households should brace for tighter budgets and shifting job markets. Policymakers and businesses alike face pressure to act decisively to stabilize growth and protect the economy's recovery. The coming months will reveal whether the Federal Reserve's policy shifts and fiscal measures can steer the nation away from recession — or if the U.S. is entering a tougher economic chapter. FAQs: What are the key recession warning signs in the U.S. right now? Stalled payroll growth , increasing layoffs in manufacturing, retail, and construction, along with declining labor force participation, are core signals economists watch closely. How do job losses in critical sectors impact the economy? Layoffs in industries tied to consumer demand, like retail and construction, often signal slowing spending, which can trigger broader economic contractions.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Affordable housing lenders stare at defaults as MSME workers set to take the biggest hit of Trump's tariffs
Housing finance companies (HFCs) lending for affordable homes are expected to see headwinds and defaults as a large segment of borrowers working in SMEs and MSMEs, as a collateral damage, are likely to take the sharpest blow from the tariff imposed by U.S. President Donald Trump on India's imports. According to Central Government estimates MSMEs alone contribute nearly 30% to the country's GDP and over 45% of exports. Over 260 million people formally and informally employed in labour-intensive textiles, engineering, auto components, gems and jewellery, food processing industries which will take the biggest hit from the trade war, feel analysts. 'India's affordable housing segment is mainly driven by demand coming from the country's MSMEs and SMEs which, despite their relatively modest scale, are deeply integrated into India's export ecosystem. Their workforces are the primary clientele for affordable housing,' said Prashant Thakur, Executive Director - Research & Advisory, Anarock Group. 'Housing finance institutions that cater to this segment's home loans will look at a growing risk – of defaults at worst, and dampened disbursements on account of lower demand at best,' he said. He said post-pandemic, the demand for affordable homes, which cater to about 17.76% of India's population, declined, clearly reflecting in a drop in supply of affordable housing. Its share of the total launches plummeted from 40% in 2019 to just 12% in H1 2025, he said. Now, with affordable housing sales in crosshairs, the HFCs catering to this buyer segment may see more loan defaults, he added. 'This category of homes priced Rs 45 lakh or less was already gravely hit by the COVID-19 pandemic and is still struggling to find any semblance of firm ground. Trump's mercenary tariffs will snuff out even the dimmest ray of hope for this segment,' Dr. Thakur cautioned. According to Anarock data, as of H1 2025, the sales share of affordable housing has dropped to a mere 18%, or about 34,565 units of a total of 1.90 lakh units sold in the top 7 key cities. 'The fact that affordable housing had an overall sales share of more than 38% in 2019 shows how badly its momentum has faltered,' he said. He said when the SME/MSME workers would find the going tough and will be in not position to contribute to the growth of affordable housing, this segment may collapse. 'So far, the global economy presented a major opportunity to Indian MSMEs to seize new export markets, build global supply chains, and diversify revenue streams. The new tariff imposition, if it takes hold, puts a roadblock on what should be a no-limits speedway – and a chakka jam on the affordable housing vehicle that drives the homeownership dreams of the largest lower quadrant of the Indian population,' Dr. Thakur said. 'Because of the disruption in this large workforce's future income thanks to the tariffs, affordable housing demand may very possibly derail and further impact sales in this highly income-sensitive segment,' he cautioned. 'Concurrently, such a drop in demand will curtail launches by developers, who will have to contend with tighter working capital due to lower sales. As it is, they have been grappling with serious input cost inflation since the pandemic,' he added. In short, the fate of India's affordable housing segment hangs in the balance. How the government addresses the issue through coordinated policy, fiscal safeguards, and buyer-focused support measures would be pivotal, Dr. Thakur concluded.
