Social media and U-16s
The Senate is considering a groundbreaking bill to ban social media access for children under 16, citing mental health risks, cyberbullying and predatory content. The bill would impose fines up to Rs5 million on non-compliant platforms and even jail time for adults aiding minors in setting up or using social media. But while safeguarding youth is a laudable goal, this proposal suffers from fatal flaws in enforcement and overreach, risking privacy and digital rights.
Proponents rightly argue that social media exposes children to several harms, including anxiety and depression, vulnerability to exploitation and distraction from studies. The bill also aligns with global steps such as Australia's recent under-16 ban and the EU's General Data Protection Regulation, which mandates parental consent for minors to use several types of online services and products, including social media.
The problem, however, is that the mechanics of age verification pose severe practical and ethical challenges. Requiring platforms like TikTok or Instagram to authenticate ages could force 16-year-olds to submit government IDs or biometric data. As seen in EU trials, such systems create honeypots for hackers and normalise surveillance. Meanwhile, Pakistan's own history of internet bans has made almost everyone familiar with VPNs.
Tech-savvy teens will almost certainly find ways to circumvent age gates whenever they want. At the same time, PTA would need to audit millions of accounts — a herculean task for an agency already struggling with enforcing politicised censorship under PECA and related laws. The bill also overlooks nuances such as parental autonomy. Many argue that monitoring children's online activity should rest with families, not the state.
Instead of unenforceable prohibitions, the government should invest in digital literacy programmes for schools and parents, including encouraging family rules for responsible social media use, and work with platforms and international partners to encourage platform accountability via transparent content moderation.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
7 minutes ago
- Business Recorder
India slams ‘unjustified' action by US, EU over its Russian oil purchases
NEW DELHI: India's foreign ministry said Monday that the United States and European Union were 'targeting' it due to its buying of Russian oil, adding that the moves were 'unjustified' and that it would protect its interests. 'The targeting of India is unjustified and unreasonable,' India Foreign Ministry spokesman Randhir Jaiswal said in a statement, after US President Donald Trump vowed to raise tariffs on the country over its oil purchases from Russia. 'Like any major economy, India will take all necessary measures to safeguard its national interests and economic security.' It did not provide further details on the measures. India became a major buyer of Russian oil, providing a much-needed export market for Moscow after it was cut off from traditional buyers in Europe because of the Ukraine war. New Delhi saved itself billions of dollars while bolstering Moscow's coffers. But India on Monday argued it 'began importing from Russia because traditional supplies were diverted to Europe after the outbreak of the conflict'. It also noted that Washington at that time had 'actively encouraged such imports by India for strengthening global energy markets stability.' Trump says will 'substantially' raise tariffs on goods from India over Russian oil purchases It pointed to what it suggested were double standards of EU and US trade with Moscow. 'It is revealing that the very nations criticising India are themselves indulging in trade with Russia,' Jaiswal added. 'Unlike our case, such trade is not even a vital national compulsion.' Jaiswal singled out examples of where deals were being done with Moscow. 'Europe-Russia trade includes not just energy, but also fertilisers, mining products, chemicals, iron and steel and machinery and transport equipment,' the statement added. 'Where the United States is concerned, it continues to import from Russia uranium hexafluoride for its nuclear industry, palladium for its EV industry, fertilisers as well as chemicals.' India, the world's most populous country, was one of the first major economies to engage the Trump administration in broader trade talks. The United States is India's largest trading partner, with New Delhi shipping goods worth $87.4 billion in 2024. India's protectionist trade policies, however, saw it run up a surplus of nearly $46 billion the same year. On Monday, Trump said in a post to his Truth Social platform that India was 'buying massive amounts of Russian Oil' and selling it for 'big profits.' 'Because of this, I will be substantially raising the Tariff paid by India to the USA,' he wrote. But he did not provide details on what tariff level he had in mind. For now, an existing 10 percent US tariff on Indian products is expected to rise to 25 percent come Thursday. Last month, the EU and Britain sought to ramp up economic pressure on Russia to halt the war in Ukraine by slashing a price cap meant to choke off revenues from key oil exports.
Express Tribune
9 minutes ago
- Express Tribune
Donald Trump drags in Taylor Swift while praising Sydney Sweeney's controversial American Eagle ad
President Donald Trump reignited his public criticism of Taylor Swift in a recent post on Truth Social, while expressing strong support for actress Sydney Sweeney and her controversial American Eagle ad campaign. The remarks, made on Monday (Aug. 4), included a claim that Swift is 'no longer hot' and a broader commentary on political affiliations and cultural appeal. Trump praised Sweeney, describing her American Eagle advertisement as the 'hottest ad out there,' and attributing the campaign's success to her status as a registered Republican. 'Go get 'em, Sydney!' he wrote, referencing reports that Sweeney registered as a Republican in 2024. The ad has stirred controversy due to its messaging, with critics drawing comparisons between Sweeney's statement about having 'great genes' and past fascist propaganda. President Trump speaks on Sydney Sweeney being a registered Republican 'Sydney Sweeney is a registered Republican? Now I love her ad. If she is a registered Republican, I think her ad is fantastic' — FearBuck (@FearedBuck) August 4, 2025 Despite the backlash, Trump celebrated the campaign's performance, claiming American Eagle jeans are 'flying off the shelves.' The fashion brand responded to criticism by emphasizing that the campaign is focused solely on the jeans, not political ideology. 'Great jeans look good on everyone,' American Eagle stated on Instagram. In contrast, Trump targeted Swift, labeling her a 'woke singer' and repeating his earlier claims that her popularity has declined since he publicly expressed dislike for her. He reiterated past assertions that she was 'booed out of the Super Bowl,' a claim contradicted by eyewitness accounts, which indicate Swift attended the entire game and was cheered by fans. Trump has long criticized Swift, particularly following her political endorsements of Democratic candidates such as Phil Bredesen in 2018 and Kamala Harris in 2024. In May, Trump questioned whether Swift's popularity had declined since he said he 'hated' her, again suggesting that being 'woke' is detrimental to cultural relevance.
Express Tribune
17 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Poland extends checks on border with Germany
Poland has extended temporary controls on the border with its EU neighbours Germany and Lithuania, Poland's Interior Minister Marcin Kierwinski said on Sunday, as the government cracks down on irregular migrants. "The relevant regulation was issued and sent to the European Commission for notification on Friday," Kierwinski said at a meeting with regional governors. He said the checks, which were introduced last month after Germany imposed similar ones to stop undocumented migrants, would be extended until October 4. Kierwinski said increased checks and barriers on Poland's border with Russia and Belarus had stopped irregular migrants transiting through those countries. He added it was now "fundamental" to close the route being used by migrants through the Baltic states of Latvia and Lithuania and then across Poland to Germany. Polish officials estimate that hundreds of migrants, mainly from the Middle East, are crossing into the Baltic states every month from ex-Soviet Belarus. EU countries within the free-movement Schengen area are allowed to impose border controls if they feel there is a threat to public order or internal security. "There is full understanding on the part of our European partners, because... these decisions are intended to close the migration route that has now re-emerged through Lithuania and Latvia," Kierwinski said. Border guard chief Robert Bagan said at the same meeting that border guards had checked more than 493,000 people crossing the borders with Germany and Lithuania between July 7 and August 2. He said that during that time border guards had refused entry into Poland to 124 foreigners at the border with Germany and 61 people at the border with Lithuania.
