Canada conservative leader mounts comeback after Trump-linked defeat
But even if the Conservative Party leader wins Monday's by-election in one of the country's most right-wing districts, experts say he may struggle to regain momentum in a political arena still heavily shaped by the U.S. president.
Poilievre's Conservatives blew a massive polling lead in the run-up to Canada's April general election, as voters backed the new Liberal leader, Prime Minister Mark Carney, to confront Trump.
In a stinging humiliation, Poilievre lost to a Liberal in his own constituency, an Ottawa-area district he had represented for two decades.
But the Conservatives performed solidly overall and deprived the Liberals of a majority, allowing Poilievre to suppress calls for him to go as party leader.
To return as opposition leader, Poilievre needed to get back into parliament.
The MP for Battle River-Crowfoot — a rural district in the western province of Alberta where Conservatives dominate — offered to step down so Poilievre could run for his seat.
Poilievre is the favorite but faces an uncertain path should he rejoin parliament, in part because some voters continue to see him as "a little Trump," said Frederic Boily, a University of Alberta political scientist.
In Canada, that is not a good brand.
New Gallup data puts Canadian attitudes towards U.S. political leadership at record lows.
While the president's threats to make Canada the 51st U.S. state have subsided, his trade war is hurting crucial industries.
The Gallup survey shows only 15% of Canadians approve of Washington, the lowest level on record in data going back to 2008. The next lowest approval rate -- 16% — was recorded in 2018, during Trump's first term.
Seventy-nine percent of Canadians disapprove of U.S. political leadership, a figure only three points better than attitudes towards Vladimir Putin's Russia.
Canadian faith in their own leadership has also jumped to 59%, a rise of 19 points since Carney replaced former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.
Poilievre has sought to make clear that he sees Trump as a rival, but one that Carney is failing to confront.
"President Trump is the one putting these tariffs on Canadians, but Mark Carney is the one who promised Canadians he could 'handle him' and 'win,'" Poilievre said this month.
For Donald Abelson, an expert on U.S.-Canada relations at McMaster University, Poilievre is trying to "feed off the frustration and disillusionment in Canada about the imposition of tariffs and the bullying (while saying) that he, unlike Carney, is prepared to stand up to Trump."
The strategy is limited, Abelson argued, as Canadians want a long-term plan to realign the country away from the United States — a central Carney talking point.
"If Poilievre overplays the Trump card, he's making a mistake," Abelson said.
Boily, the political scientist, said Poilievre faces an additional problem — an enduring attachment within his base to issues Trump has elevated.
"It's tough for any conservative leader not to talk about the fight against globalists and wokism because it's the new conservative reality," Boily said, arguing Poilievre's "DNA" is more aligned with traditional conservatism, not Trump-inspired populism.
If Poilievre loses Monday's election, voter confusion will be the likely cause.
There are 214 candidates on the ballot, a record number caused by the Longest Ballot Committee protest group, which wants electoral law reform.
Poilievre was targeted by the same group in April, but organizers claim they are not motivated by partisan ideology.
Voters on Monday will have to write the name of their preferred candidate on their ballot, not tick a box, an exceptional measure designed to spare people finding the correct name on a 214-candidate list.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Japan Times
2 hours ago
- Japan Times
European leaders to join Zelenskyy for key meeting with Trump
European leaders will join Volodymyr Zelenskyy at his high-stakes meeting with U.S. President Donald Trump on Monday in Washington as they seek to pin down security guarantees for Ukraine to ensure that any peace deal reached with Russia holds. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte, Finnish President Alexander Stubb, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and French President Emmanuel Macron have confirmed their participation in the delegation. The move comes as European nations shift their focus toward providing Ukraine with robust security guarantees as Trump pushes for a quick peace deal between Moscow and Kyiv. Officials from the so-called coalition-of-the-willing countries were set to hold a video call on Sunday afternoon to work on their plan. They're skeptical that a peace agreement can be rapidly reached, and that Russian President Vladimir Putin even wants one. Von der Leyen said in a post on X that she'll host Zelenskyy in Brussels on Sunday afternoon before joining him, Trump and other European leaders at the White House meeting. The talks will include, among other things, security guarantees, territorial issues, and continued support for Ukraine in its defense against Russian aggression, according to a German statement. It will be Zelenskyy's first visit in the White House since February, when his Oval Office encounter with Trump turned into a public shouting match and led to U.S. briefly pausing military aid to Ukraine. U.S. President Donald Trump berates Ukrainian leader Volodymyr Zelenskyy in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington in February. | Doug Mills / The New York Times While the two leaders patched up their relationship since then, the show of support from European leaders aims to help the Ukrainian president as he comes under growing pressure to cede some of the land in return for a vague promise of peace. Trump told European leaders on a call Saturday, following his talks with Putin in Alaska, that he was prepared to contribute to security guarantees with Europe so long as it didn't involve NATO. The U.S. president suggested Putin would be OK with such an arrangement, people familiar with the matter said. He also indicated he could be looking to organize a meeting between the Russian and Ukrainian leaders as early as within a week, the people said. Zelenskyy has said repeatedly that he's willing to meet Putin. The Kremlin has yet to provide a similar commitment, and many European officials doubt he wants to end Russia's invasion of Ukraine, which is halfway through its fourth year. The topic of a trilateral summit wasn't raised during the meetings in Alaska, Russia's state TV channel Vesti reported on Saturday, citing Russian presidential aide Yuri Ushakov. The specifics of a U.S. contribution to any security guarantees for Ukraine are unclear. The discussions have touched upon the possibility of granting Kyiv assurances from some allies — similar to those of NATO's Article 5 collective defense clause — which commits members to defend each other if attacked, said the people. The people spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss private deliberations, and cautioned that a NATO-like mechanism would be difficult. An alternative would be bolstering, through U.S. commitments, earlier plans coordinated by the U.K. and France, which included reassurance forces, monitoring and air-cover, the people said. Ahead of his meeting with Putin, the U.S. president told allies that a ceasefire would be his key demand. He also threatened to walk out of the talks and impose tough new punitive measures on Moscow and countries buying its oil if it wasn't met. Yet Trump signaled on Friday that he wasn't in a rush to implement fresh penalties on Russia's trading partners. Russian leader Vladimir Putin and U.S. President Donald Trump pose on a podium on the tarmac after they arrived to attend a meeting at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson in Anchorage, Alaska, on Friday. | Sputnik / Pool / via REUTERS Following his calls with Zelenskyy and European leaders early Saturday, Trump said in a Truth Social post that "it was determined by all' that the best way to end the war was to achieve a peace agreement and "not a mere Ceasefire Agreement.' Most statements issued by European leaders on Saturday made no mention of a ceasefire. Trump told Zelenskyy and European leaders that Putin wants Ukraine to cede control of the entire Donbas region in Ukraine's east, renewing earlier demands. Zelenskyy has repeatedly ruled out giving up all of Donetsk and Luhansk provinces, which comprise Donbas. Moscow's forces only partially control the region and have failed to take it militarily after more than a decade of fighting. Russia would also halt advancing its claims over the parts of Zaporizhzhia and Kherson regions it doesn't now control, effectively freezing the battle lines there. The Kremlin could also potentially withdraw troops from other regions such as Sumy and Kharkiv in Ukraine's northeast, areas near the Russian border where Kremlin forces control only small pockets of land. According to an assessment by the U.K. Defense Ministry, it would take Russia more than four years to fully occupy the four Ukrainian regions it laid claim to in 2022. That would come at a cost of nearly 2 million additional Russian casualties based on current battlefield advances, the ministry said on X. While maintaining that any territorial decisions are for Zelenskyy to make, Trump has repeatedly signaled that a peace agreement would include land swaps, and has urged the Ukrainian president to make a deal. Many European officials are skeptical that a detailed agreement can be reached quickly. Russia's rejection of repeated calls for a ceasefire "complicates the situation,' Zelenskyy said in a social media post late Saturday. "If they lack the will to carry out a simple order to stop the strikes, it may take a lot of effort to get Russia to have the will to implement far greater — peaceful coexistence with its neighbors for decades.'
Japan Times
8 hours ago
- Japan Times
Internal battle pits LDP's conservatives against liberals
Some lawmakers in the ruling Liberal Democratic Party — mainly onetime members of the now-defunct faction once led by the late former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe — are calling for the party to more actively advertise conservative policies. These lawmakers are increasingly concerned about the situation within the LDP, blaming the party's major setback in last month's Upper House election on a poor showing among its base supporters, who apparently turned their back on the party. The moves come as other party lawmakers have grown wary of an acceleration in any LDP tilt to the right. "The LDP, as a conservative party, was not able to appeal its policies to the public, so we lost to other parties," Shoji Nishida, an Upper House lawmaker and former member of the Abe faction, told reporters on Aug. 5 after a hearing related to the party's review of the Upper House election results. Abe, a pivotal conservative figure in the LDP, was assassinated in July 2022. Nishida is a senior member of an intraparty group of conservatives that backs former LDP policy chief Sanae Takaichi, a key conservative politician who has taken up the mantle once held by Abe. In an apparent bid to highlight the party's conservative chops, Takaichi and her colleagues opposed the proposed introduction of a selective dual surname system for married couples during this year's ordinary parliamentary session, which ended in June. In the run-up to the Upper House election, they also called for a cut in the consumption tax, despite a cautious stance shown by senior party officials. One conservative lawmaker said the LDP is believed to have started to take a more liberal stance under former Prime Minister Fumio Kishida, who was in office between October 2021 and October last year. Kishida promoted legislation for increasing understanding for sexual minorities, which was enacted in 2023. Kishida's now-defunct LDP faction had been known for its liberal stance for a long period. In last year's LDP presidential election, Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba did not rule out the idea of allowing Japan to have female-line emperors while sounding positive about a selective dual surname system. These stances by Ishiba are viewed with suspicion by former Abe faction members and others, who say he is betraying the party's base, and have prompted them to boost attempts to remove the prime minister. Still, this is not to say that all conservative LDP members are on the same page. "True conservatives aim for economic growth while maintaining fiscal discipline," one midcareer LDP lawmaker said. The same lawmaker also called for a realistic approach toward China and South Korea. "We need to get along well with the two nations because they are neighbors." Another LDP lawmaker, who has also served as a Cabinet minister, voiced a positive view of Japan introducing a selective dual surname system to support people in need. The LDP was created in November 1955 through the merger of the then-Liberal Party and the then-Japan Democratic Party, and will soon mark the 70th anniversary of its formation. Despite a widespread view of the party as right-leaning, the LDP has had many prominent lawmakers with liberal stances, including former Prime Minister Kiichi Miyazawa and former Chief Cabinet Secretary Yohei Kono. "I thought I was a conservative, but before I knew it, I have become a liberal," a veteran LDP lawmaker who claims to be a moderate conservative said, warning the party not to go too far to the right.
Nikkei Asia
9 hours ago
- Nikkei Asia
US-South Korea drills, Lee visits Japan, Taiwan nuclear power vote
Welcome to Your Week in Asia. Fresh off calling for a "redefining" of ties with Japan in an independence day speech, South Korean President Lee Jae Myung heads to Tokyo for talks as the two countries wrestle with the impact of U.S. President Donald Trump's tariffs. Also in Japan, relations between Asia and Africa will be in focus during the Tokyo International Conference on African Development (TICAD). Japan is expected to announce an investment push in the continent in tandem with countries such as India. Get the best of our coverage of Asia and much more by following us on X, where our handle is @NikkeiAsia. We are also now on Bluesky, with the handle @ MONDAY U.S.-South Korea military drills The U.S. and South Korea will hold their annual military drills, known as Ulchi Freedom Shield. About 18,000 South Korean soldiers will take part in the live-fire exercises amid North Korea's warnings of reprisals for what it says is a "direct military provocation." Data: Thailand gross domestic product TUESDAY Data: Malaysia trade WEDNESDAY Africa conference in Japan TICAD, an international conference focusing on African development, will be held in Yokohama, south of Tokyo, for three days until Friday. The ninth edition of the event features over 200 seminars and symposiums, as well as approximately 300 booths and panel displays. Thailand electronics trade show The Thailand Electronics Circuit Asia 2025 trade show kicks off in Bangkok. The three-day event will bring together hundreds of companies from across the tech supply chain, with a major focus on printed circuit boards, a key component used in all types of electronic devices. Taiwan robot show The Taiwan Automation Intelligence and Robot Show opens in Taipei. Exhibitors at the four-day fair will show off the latest advances in smart manufacturing, robotics, artificial intelligence and more. Earnings: Baidu THURSDAY Data: India purchasing managers index FRIDAY Ruling in Thaksin lese majeste case Thailand's Criminal Court is due to hand down its verdict on former Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra in a lese majeste case. The 75-year-old Thaksin is accused of insulting the monarchy during an interview with the South Korean newspaper Chosun Ilbo in May 2015. South Korea's opposition People Power Party elects new leader Data: Malaysia consumer price index Earnings: China Vanke SATURDAY Lee visits Japan for summit South Korea's President Lee will make his first overseas trip for a bilateral summit when he travels to Tokyo to meet with Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba. While the neighboring nations are historical rivals and Lee has a track record of criticizing Japan, both are export-led economies seeking solutions to the steep tariffs imposed by America. After his Japan trip, Lee will head to Washington for a summit with U.S. President Donald Trump. Taiwan nuclear power referendum Taiwan holds a referendum on whether to restart its Maanshan nuclear power plant, the shutdown of which marked the end of the island's atomic energy era in May. The opposition Taiwan People's Party pushed for the vote on the grounds that reactivation is necessary for energy stability and security. President Lai Ching-te of the ruling Democratic Progressive Party has said he will vote "no." The referendum coincides with a handful of districts voting in recall elections against opposition Kuomintang lawmakers, after a larger first set of recall attempts all failed.
