Toby Carvery criticised for felling ancient oak tree - as council reports incident to police
The remains of the trunk, surrounded by its severed branches, were discovered by council workers on 3 April in Whitewebbs Park, Enfield.
The tree was on the border of a car park for a Toby Carvery restaurant. On Tuesday, it was confirmed by the chain's parent company, Mitchells & Butlers, that specialists advised them the tree was "a potential health and safety risk" and had been "cut back".
"This was an important action to protect our employees and guests as well as the wider general public, to whom we have a duty of care," it said.
"We took necessary measures to ensure any legal requirements were met."
Image: The oak tree before it was felled in Whitewebbs Park. Pic: Woodland Trust
Sky News understands the Metropolitan Police found no evidence of criminality and has closed its investigation.
Investigators established the tree is not subject to any preservation orders.
Earlier, the local council said it held a different opinion about whether the correct permission had been sought.
Ergin Erbil, leader of Enfield Council, said: "We are treating the matter as criminal damage and have reported it to the police.
"We've now placed a legal protection (Tree Preservation Order) on the tree and are looking at ways to help it grow back."
The tree, which had a girth of 6.1m, was thought to be in the top 100 of London's 600,000 oak trees in terms of its size.
Ed Pyne, Woodland Trust senior conservation adviser for trees, said: "This is the most shocking fell I think I've ever seen in more than a decade working with ancient trees.
"In my view, and the view of many others, this is ecologically much more significant than the Sycamore Gap - and certainly a more irreplaceable tree."
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player 1:07 Seedlings could save famous sycamore tree
On Monday, the Tree Council and Forest Research published a report calling for a "robust and effective system" to protect England's most important trees following the Sycamore Gap tree felling in September 2023.
The trial of the two men, charged in connection with the felling, is due to take place later this month at Newcastle Crown Court.
Read more from Sky News:
Shoots grow from Sycamore Gap stump
King receives seedlings from felled tree
Vandals hunted after trees destroyed
Ed Allnut, Enfield resident and secretary of the Guardians of Whitewebbs group, said: "The tree belonged to Enfield and to our national heritage. I am personally devastated.
"We want answers, and we want guarantees the other trees here are being protected properly."
Oak trees are valuable for UK wildlife, supporting thousands of species as well as capturing carbon from the atmosphere.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
3 hours ago
- Sky News
The most striking pictures of the day
From scorched land damaged in wildfires and an orphaned elephant - here are the images of the day chosen by the Sky News picture editors. Workers inspect Flamingo cruise missiles at Fire Point's secret factory in Ukraine. Structures surrounded by scorched land in the aftermath of a wildfire in Unhais da Serra, Covilha area, Portugal. A scuba diver of the Italian Navy cleans the bronze statue of Jesus Christ located in the Mediterranean Sea off San Fruttuoso. Smoke rises from the Coyote Fire, as seen from Amador County, California. A display of 50-feet-long legs and 22-feet-tall ruby slippers as part of a promotion for the upcoming "Wizard of Oz at Sphere" movie in Las Vegas. A railway underpass in the northeastern Japan city of Semboku following heavy rain. More from UK Politics latest: Number of migrants in hotels rises by 8% - as asylum claims hit record high Inequalities in GCSE results stubbornly persistent - here's what the data tells us Chris Brain: Jury discharged in trial of ex-priest who ran rave-inspired 'cult' group French firefighters heading to a wildfire near Corporales, northern Spain. January Gweshe, a senior animal caregiver, feeds an orphaned elephant named Kadiki (The Little One) at Wild is Life in Harare. Kim Jong Un meets the leading commanding officers deployed to Ukraine's Kursk region. Egyptian divers work to retrieve submerged artifacts at Abu Qir Naval Port in the coastal city of Alexandria, Egypt.
Sky News
5 hours ago
- Sky News
Inequalities in GCSE results stubbornly persistent as education secretary acknowledges 'appalling' attainment gaps for white working-class children
As over one million students receive their GCSE results, Sky News has found gender and factors linked to deprivation remain troubling predictors of students' performance. Overall GCSE grades are relatively consistent with last year's results, indicating stability has returned following the end of pandemic grading. The compulsory courses, Level 2 English and Mathematics, continue to be a hurdle for many GCSE students - with Thursday's results showing the highest failure rates for the two subjects in a decade. Yet, while overall grades are stable, so too are key attainment gaps that experts say point to deprivation. Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson denounced attainment gaps for white working-class children in an article for The Telegraph. "It's appalling, and I won't stand by and watch those numbers continue to grow," Ms Phillipson wrote. "It's not just the life chances of those children that are being damaged - it's also the health of our society as a whole." While the data does not share deprivation status or ethnicity of students, other strongly correlated factors such as English region and school type show stark inequalities. Some 48.1% of GCSE exams sat at fee-paying schools in England received grades of 7 or above, compared with 18.2% at non-selective state schools. Fiona Spellman, CEO of education charity SHINE, said, "The primary difference that drives the attainment gap between those who attend independent schools and those who don't really comes from the circumstances in those children's lives." Regional inequalities across England also remain significant. In London, 28.4% of GCSE exams were awarded a grade 7 or higher compared with just 17.8% of exams in the North East of England. But even students in London were outperformed by Northern Ireland, where 31.6% of GCSE students received a 7 or above. "Deprivation is a major driver of the gap we see between the different regions and in terms of the attainment children achieve in all phases of education," said Ms Spellman. This year's cohort had both a disrupted primary and secondary school experience due to the pandemic - a factor that may be influencing some of these inequality gaps. "We know that the pandemic affected all children, but we know that it didn't affect all children equally," added Ms Spellman. "The legacy of COVID is still very much still alive today and how that had a disproportionate effect on the children who most need support is still working its way through." Gender gap stubbornly persistent One of the clearest divides in the results - and not mentioned by the education secretary - is gaps based on gender. Girls continue to receive a greater proportion of the top grades compared with boys. Among students receiving a 7/A or above, 55.8% were girls while 44.2% were boys. In England, the gap is wider when looking just at 16-year-old students taking 7 or more GCSEs. 60.7% of those in this cohort receiving top grades were girls while 39.3% were boys. But, Jill Duffy, the chair of one of the main qualifications body, the OCR, pointed out the overall gender gap this year is the narrowest since 2000. However, Claire Thomson and Cath Jadhav, both board members of the Joint Council for Qualifications alongside Ms Duffy, cautioned that the decrease in the gender gap was too small to confirm any concrete trend. "The change is relatively small, at fractions of percentage points, so there will be lots of individual factors which affect that," said Ms Jadhav. Certain subjects showed large gender imbalances between boys and girls. Girls were the most overrepresented in home economics, followed by performing/expressive arts, health & social care, hospitality, and social science subjects. In contrast, boys were disproportionately more likely to take other technology, construction, engineering, computing, and economics. Working-class boys facing hurdles So, is Ms Phillipson right to highlight white working-class children as falling behind? And should we be more concerned about white working-class boys in particular? While the data does not include sufficient detail on how these inequalities stack on each other, data published by the Department for Education (DfE) based on last year's results suggest white working-class boys are among the most disadvantaged in education. Among all children eligible for free school meals, White British boys were much less likely to receive a grade of 4 - a pass - or above on their GCSEs. Black Caribbean and mixed white/black Caribbean boys on free school meals had similarly poor pass rates. "It's not all boys. And it's not all white working-class boys," said David Spendlove, professor at the University of Manchester's Institute for Education. But, "boys top all of those key indicators: likely to be diagnosed with special needs, likely to be excluded from school." "The system is stacked against them and at every single hurdle they are going to face challenges which mount increasingly over time," said Prof Spendlove. Beyond A-levels What's next for students receiving results on Thursday? According to DfE's 2024 numbers, just over 40% of 16-year-olds started an A-level course the following year. More than 20% started other Level 3 qualifications, such as T-levels or BTECs. Around 3.5% started apprenticeships. However, 6.2% were classified as not in education, employment, or training ("NEET"). Simon Ashworth, deputy CEO and head of policy for the Association of Employment and Learning Providers (AELP), said, "The number of young people who are not in education, employment or training has got worse, not better." "We're nearly to a million young people who are NEET," he said. "That is a worry." Boys between the ages of 16 and 18 are more likely than their female counterparts to have NEET status, DfE data reveals. Furthermore, individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds "tend to be the young people who will be closest to the job market or the risk of becoming NEET once they leave education," shared Mr Ashworth. Mr Ashworth also added that some young people who pursue apprenticeships fail to complete them because they struggle to pass mandatory Level 2 Mathematics. Students who receive lower-than-desired results on Thursday, however, should stay optimistic that many doors remain open to them. This year saw a 12.1% rise in students 17 or older resitting exams this year. SHINE's Dr Helen Rafferty said that the resit rate is likely due to the pandemic as "many students have come to the end of their secondary school journey having had the most chaotic and disrupted educational journey that you can imagine." Nonetheless, Ms Rafferty said, "I do think it's encouraging that so many students are choosing to move on to an educational pathway which still provides them with that opportunity to get their English and maths results."
BBC News
2 days ago
- BBC News
Sycamore Gap tree image found under Northallerton patio
A gardener said he could not believe his eyes when he uncovered a "miraculous representation" of the now-felled Sycamore Gap tree, hidden beneath a paving Dawson made the discovery at his home near Northallerton, North 82-year-old said he lifted up a slab, which had been stacked for about a decade, and saw an image of what appeared to resemble the much-loved tree that had been formed by dirt and dust. The landmark, which grew by Hadrian's Wall in Northumberland, was illegally felled in September 2023 causing shock around the world. Daniel Graham and Adam Carruthers were each jailed for four years and three months after being convicted of criminal damage. Mr Dawson told the BBC: "It is not quite rounded at the top, it is not quite fully formed but it is a remarkable likeliness."It is a miraculous representation of the tree. I just looked at it in amazement." The grandad-of-four said the marking, which is about 23cm (9in) long, had been made up of dust and garden said it must have developed over 10 years as the paving slabs had not moved during that time."They have been in that particular part of the garden for as long as I can remember," he said."The likeness to the Sycamore Gap tree is remarkable." Mr Dawson, who lives with his wife Marilyn, has the newly found image protected from the elements by an upturned garden pot, but he said was worried how long it could be kept in its current condition."If it rains it might get washed away but my wife and friends have seen it and have all been amazed as I have," he added."It's not the sort of thing we could lift off, we could possibly put glass over it somehow and anchor it down." Mr Dawson said he had only ever seen the real tree when he was a boy 70 years ago, during a Scout trip to Hadrian's said he "couldn't bring himself" to return to the site after the tree was felled."In solitude it was in a remarkable location, and it was a magnificent tree," he tree, which was more than 100 years old and owned by the National Trust, sat near the wall, which is a Unesco World Heritage had been planted in the late 1800s and found global fame after featuring in a scene of the 1991 film Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves, starring Kevin Costner, and was popular with photographers and artists. Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
