Third cookbook author named in Brooke Bellamy, Nagi Maehashi recipe dispute
RecipeTin Eats founder Nagi Maehashi revealed a third cookbook author has been 'blantantly' plagiarised by baker Brooke Bellamy.
Brisbane bakery owner and author of $4.6m selling cookbook Bellamy has been accused of copying recipes, which she strenuously denies and has described the backlash she has faced since accusations first emerged as 'deeply distressing'.
Fellow author and cook Maehashi first accused Bellamy of plagiarising two recipes in her best-selling book, Bake with Brooki, as well as from 'other authors' — which the RecipeTin Eats founder initially did not name.
After the allegations were shared publicly on April 29, famed US baker, Sally McKenney, then also claimed that a vanilla cake recipe from a book she had published in 2019 was used in Bellamy's 2024 cookbook.
Now, Maehashi has confirmed to Good Food, for which she is a columnist, that the late Bill Granger is another author she believes has been plagiarised.
'It is so blatant to me that the wording in the method part of the recipe is copied almost exactly. To me, it is the biggest and strongest example of plagiarism that I have seen by this author,' Maehashi says.
The article — Maehashi's first interview since the allegations — included Granger's Portuguese tarts recipe from his 2006 cookbook Every Day, alongside the Portuguese tarts recipe in Bake with Brooki.
Maehashi claimed the wording for the method is nearly identical to the text used in the original.
'I was so shocked when I saw it. Bill is an icon of the Australian food scene. When I became aware of it, I knew that including it in my statement would make it stronger but I left it out at the request of Bill's family,' Maehashi told Good Food.
Granger died in December 2023 and Good Food reported that his widow Natalie Elliott declined to comment, but Murdoch Books publishing director Jane Morrow said they were aware of the allegations and were 'currently reviewing the concerns raised'.
news.com.au has contacted Murdoch Books for comment. Bellamy's lawyer said she had nothing to add to an earlier statement that said: 'I do not copy other people's recipes'.
'Please stop': Nagi Maehashi addresses backlash
Maehashi told social media trolls to stop personal attacks towards Bellamy in an Instagram video on Thursday night.
'Now I know I've made serious allegations. But this does not justify the personal attacks that I've seen online against Brooke Bellamy. I do not support it and I'm asking you to stop,' she said.
'I know that this is just a very, very small percentage of people online and I know the majority of people are good, fun, normal people. You know, share your opinions, have heated debates, support Brooki, support me, disagree with both of us, think we're pathetic, whatever you want. But just keep it respectful. No trolling, no hateful comments. Fundamentally, at the end of the day, we're talking recipes and this is a business dispute. You know, these are legal allegations that I have made against Penguin, a corporate, allegations made by my company. So we've got to be respectful about this.'
Maehashi told Good Food she was also being trolled by people trying to find examples of plagiarism on her own website.
'I am not a martyr. I am not pretending I am pure, but this is of a magnitude that I felt I had to speak up,' she was quoted to say.
Bellamy had shared a statement with news.com.au on Wednesday night, saying the backlash she had faced since the accusations first emerged had been 'deeply distressing' both for her and her family.
'The past 24 hours have been extremely overwhelming,' said the star in a statement, saying that she has faced 'attacks' on social media as a result. 'I have had media outside my home and business, and have been attacked online. It has been deeply distressing for my colleagues and my young family.'
Bellamy went on to insist that she has never copied another baker's recipe, and instead has only ever 'drawn inspiration' for her own creations.
'I do not copy other people's recipes. Like many bakers, I draw inspiration from the classics, but the creations you see at Brooki Bakehouse reflect my own experience, taste, and passion for baking, born of countless hours of my childhood spent in my home kitchen with Mum.'
She continued: 'While baking has leeway for creativity, much of it is a precise science and is necessarily formulaic. Many recipes are bound to share common steps and measures: if they don't, they simply don't work.
'My priority right now is to ensure the welfare of the fantastic team at Brooki Bakehouse and that of my family.'
Penguin has also denied the claims in a statement sent by their lawyers to Maehashi's lawyer, which read: 'Our client respectfully rejects your clients' allegations and confirms that the recipes in the BWB Book were written by Brooke Bellamy.'
It was revealed on Thursday that Bellamy had been dropped from working as ambassador for the Academy for Enterprising Girls, an Australian Government-funded entrepreneurship program to help young women aged between 10 and 18 learn new skills.
'Brooke Bellamy was recently engaged to conduct a small number of promotional activities for the Academy for Enterprising Girls program over the coming months,' an academy spokesman said in a statement.
'While we make no legal assessment on the allegations aired in the media, we have informed Bellamy that we will not move forward with the engagement at this time.'
Nagi Maehashi's copycat allegations
Maehashi accused Bellamy of plagiarising her caramel slice and baklava recipes from her site RecipeTin Eats.
Additionally, she claimed that other authors had their recipes copied by Bellamy. Bellamy vigorously denied these claims as well.
'I'm no stranger to seeing my recipes copied online,' Maehashi wrote in a post on Instagram and on her website. 'But seeing what I believe to be my recipes and my words printed in a multimillion-dollar book launched with a huge publicity campaign from one of Australia's biggest publishers was shocking.'
'There are also recipes from other authors, including from a very well known, beloved cookbook author where the similarities are so extensive, dismissing it as coincidence would be absurd (in my opinion),' Maehashi wrote in her post addressed to Bellamy and her publisher Penguin Books.
'Out of respect for and at the request of authors, I cannot share further details.'
Later on, McKenney, who blogs under @sallysbakeblog and boasts 1 million followers on Instagram, claimed that her vanilla cake recipe was used by Bellamy.
News.com.au reached out to Maehashi for further comment on the allegations. We also reached out to McKenney, who politely declined to comment.
In a statement posted on her Instagram Story on Thursday, Maehashi claimed she went 'back and forth with Penguin/Brooki' for 'almost 6 months' before going public with the allegations this week.
She also denied her goal was for compensation.
'I have nothing to gain out of speaking up except that I believe it's the right thing to do. I do not want their money. I didn't even ask for reimbursement of legal fees,' the statement said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
The stark numbers that spell grim news for Aussie musos
Aussie music lovers feel a sense of pride when they hear Australian music, but their playlists are actually dominated by pop from the US and Britain. While 71 per cent of listeners love to hear Australian tunes, and two thirds want to hear more, only one in three music fans make an effort to seek out new Australian music. It's a big contradiction revealed in landmark research by Music Australia, the federal government's music development and funding body. A massive 98 per cent of local listeners discover musicians via streaming, but more than half (51 per cent) don't think about whether an artist is Australian when they are looking for new tunes. Of the top 10,000 artists streamed in Australia during 2024, just eight per cent were Australian, while more than half were from the US, according to entertainment analytics firm Luminate. It seems the sheer convenience of personalised playlists delivered via an algorithm might be stopping music fans discovering Australian artists - and that's a problem for musicians like Sara Storer. The ARIA-award winning country musician is releasing her eighth solo album titled Worth Your Love, and says the music industry has completely transformed since her first release back in 2001. "For a young person, especially a young Aussie artist trying to get out there, I'd be terrified. Where do you start?" she said. Despite building an inter-generational audience over decades, the Darwin-based musician can no longer rely on album sales, and even solid streaming figures don't add up to a viable income. "There's no income from streaming. It looks good on paper and you think, well, I should be making a few bucks, but you don't see anything," said Storer. "All my money is made through live performance. I rely heavily on ticket sales, which is like a roller coaster." The contradiction between listener sentiment and behaviour could be the basis of a campaign for actively discovering local music - a bit like the 'Life. Be in it' health campaign of the 1980s - suggested Music Australia director Millie Millgate. "We can remind Australian audiences what these bands are doing overseas and encourage them not to miss out - like, don't miss out on your own party," said Millgate. "There's no one single bullet, but if audiences can be mobilised to do their part and really seek out Australian new music, it would go an incredible way." And the Music Australia research suggests we could potentially Aussify Spotify: listeners like the idea of a dedicated Australian music streamer, with 42 per cent saying it's something they would pay for. Melbourne rock band Amyl and the Sniffers are one act making it big on the global stage, and when the band appeared on The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon recently, singer Amy Taylor's top was made from two classic Aussie thongs. It's a big effort to demonstrate a sense of national pride - but it seems many Aussie musos are actually getting more love overseas, with more than 80 per cent of royalties for local musicians coming from international listeners in 2024, according to figures from Spotify. The research also found radio still plays a role. A quarter of music fans still tune in to discover new music, with ABC station triple j a popular source. An economic snapshot of the local sector showing a direct contribution of almost $3 billion to the national economy was part of three industry research reports released on Thursday.
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
The stark numbers that spell grim news for Aussie musos
Aussie music lovers feel a sense of pride when they hear Australian music, but their playlists are actually dominated by pop from the US and Britain. While 71 per cent of listeners love to hear Australian tunes, and two thirds want to hear more, only one in three music fans make an effort to seek out new Australian music. It's a big contradiction revealed in landmark research by Music Australia, the federal government's music development and funding body. A massive 98 per cent of local listeners discover musicians via streaming, but more than half (51 per cent) don't think about whether an artist is Australian when they are looking for new tunes. Of the top 10,000 artists streamed in Australia during 2024, just eight per cent were Australian, while more than half were from the US, according to entertainment analytics firm Luminate. It seems the sheer convenience of personalised playlists delivered via an algorithm might be stopping music fans discovering Australian artists - and that's a problem for musicians like Sara Storer. The ARIA-award winning country musician is releasing her eighth solo album titled Worth Your Love, and says the music industry has completely transformed since her first release back in 2001. "For a young person, especially a young Aussie artist trying to get out there, I'd be terrified. Where do you start?" she said. Despite building an inter-generational audience over decades, the Darwin-based musician can no longer rely on album sales, and even solid streaming figures don't add up to a viable income. "There's no income from streaming. It looks good on paper and you think, well, I should be making a few bucks, but you don't see anything," said Storer. "All my money is made through live performance. I rely heavily on ticket sales, which is like a roller coaster." The contradiction between listener sentiment and behaviour could be the basis of a campaign for actively discovering local music - a bit like the 'Life. Be in it' health campaign of the 1980s - suggested Music Australia director Millie Millgate. "We can remind Australian audiences what these bands are doing overseas and encourage them not to miss out - like, don't miss out on your own party," said Millgate. "There's no one single bullet, but if audiences can be mobilised to do their part and really seek out Australian new music, it would go an incredible way." And the Music Australia research suggests we could potentially Aussify Spotify: listeners like the idea of a dedicated Australian music streamer, with 42 per cent saying it's something they would pay for. Melbourne rock band Amyl and the Sniffers are one act making it big on the global stage, and when the band appeared on The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon recently, singer Amy Taylor's top was made from two classic Aussie thongs. It's a big effort to demonstrate a sense of national pride - but it seems many Aussie musos are actually getting more love overseas, with more than 80 per cent of royalties for local musicians coming from international listeners in 2024, according to figures from Spotify. The research also found radio still plays a role. A quarter of music fans still tune in to discover new music, with ABC station triple j a popular source. An economic snapshot of the local sector showing a direct contribution of almost $3 billion to the national economy was part of three industry research reports released on Thursday.
The Age
an hour ago
- The Age
From unimpressed mums to Peter Garrett's butt: The Spicks and Specks stories you haven't heard
Over its 20-year history, and 308 episodes, Spicks and Specks (named after the 1966 Bee Gees song) has become one of Australian television's enduring success stories: a family-friendly quiz show that celebrated music and comedy, revelled in nostalgia and sparkled with the chemistry of its three stars, Adam Hills, Myf Warhurst and Alan Brough. It turned a generation of musicians and comedians into household names and still remains one of the few outlets for live music on TV. For the show's 20th anniversary season, Hills, Warhurst and Brough share their memories of the iconic music quiz show, with an assist from frequent guest stars Dave O'Neil, Hamish Blake, Denise Scott and Brian Mannix. Adam Hills, host: It was pitched to me as a music quiz show that also celebrated Australian music and showed new music. But the thing that really got me was when I sent an outline of games for the show and I remember sitting on a plane back from London reading the outline for Substitute, and it was where you sing a well-known song using the words of an unrelated book. And I used the Qantas magazine, and thought of some songs, and went through it, and went, 'Oh, wow. I could see this could be a thing.' It was like a cross between a trivia quiz and Countdown. Myf Warhurst, team captain: I got a call at Triple J, where I was working, and they said, 'Can you come for an audition?' I thought it sounded like a bit of fun and I said yes to everything back in those days! I turned up for the audition, and I literally got a call within a day. I hadn't met you [Adam]. I knew Alan. And then I was like, 'Oh, what's the show?' Alan Brough, team captain: Well, approached is a big word for how it happened. I think [TV producer] Anthony Watt called me and said, 'I'm involved in a show about music. Do you want to do it?' And I went, 'Yeah.' And that was all I knew. Do you remember watching the first episode go to air? Myf Warhurst: It was a very strange experience because I'd not had any mainstream television experience prior to this, and it was like a dream of mine, growing up in the country, [to be on ABC TV] because we only had the ABC. It was like, 'Oh, I've made it.' But then I spoke to mum on the phone and she said, 'Yes, it's very good, but I hope you recorded that on VHS, just for your files.' She thought it was so bad! Mum loves the show, by the way. Nance is the biggest fan. Alan Brough: My mum, when she came over to Australia [from New Zealand], she said, 'I saw that show you're on.' And I said, 'Oh.' And she said, 'Thank god all the useless stuff you know, it's come in handy.' Myf Warhurst: It's often been compared to overseas shows like Never Mind the Buzzcocks, which was much more competitive. They take the mickey out of some artists, but we never did that. We were very supportive and played very nicely with everybody. What was it like being a guest on the show? Denise Scott, comedian: I know f--- all about music. Every time, including an episode I just did recently, I feel sick because of my complete lack of knowledge of music. I keep thinking, 'What am I doing here?' But it did give me confidence about telling what I thought were pretty boring stories, they made everyone laugh. Hamish Blake, TV presenter: [On my first episode] I knew – and know – very little about music trivia, a deficiency I was assured wouldn't be a problem. But the fact it's a show that's 100 per cent about music made me nervous of that assurance. Dave O'Neil, comedian, who has appeared more than 60 times, more than any other guest: It was a perfect show for me because I don't have that much knowledge about sport or current affairs, but music, I'm going to be up for it. Brian Mannix, lead singer of the Uncanny X-Men: The first time I went on, I had a couple of beers. I think I was on about six times before I was ever on the winning team. Hamish Blake: I was almost exclusively on Myf's team and have a lot of fond memories of celebratory high-fives after looking in each other's panicked eyes and pulling answers out of thin air that somehow were correct. Also, being on Myf's team gave me a front-row seat to appreciate Alan doing his thing and being able to name the cab driver who dropped Freddie Mercury to Live Aid or some other wild fact. Denise Scott: They always put a question in that they assume you might know. For me, it'll be about Julie Andrews. But otherwise, I must admit, I do try and give a bit of time to looking at YouTube clips of various artists. I don't even know what to Google. I don't even know what name to search for. And then I think, 'Who am I kidding?' Brian Mannix: The show has been really good to me. I talked to [musician] Wilbur Wilde about this the other day, because our mothers have passed away, and I said the good thing is we get to see our mothers every Mother's Day because me and Wilbur had our mums on the show for the Mother's Day episode and we get to see it in repeats. Were you ever starstruck? Adam Hills: My favourite was Weird Al Yankovic because I was a comedy nerd. I was losing my mind. And he's one of the few people that have been on the show that I've kept in touch with. I've caught up with him. He's met my kids, and he still sends me a birthday email every year. Alan Brough: Lloyd Cole from Lloyd Cole and the Commotions. [Producer] Anthony Watt knew I loved him, so he didn't tell me he was coming on. I walked into the green room [and saw him] and I went, 'F---' and then walked out, had a few breaths, came back in, and I said, 'I'm really sorry.' And he said, 'It's happened before.' Myf Warhurst: For me, growing up, Countdown on the ABC was all we had. We didn't have much and no internet, obviously, because I'm ancient. So when all these Australian pop stars that I grew up adoring came on the show, it was wild. I did shows with Sharon O'Neill from New Zealand, and Jane Clifton from Jo Jo Zep and the Falcons and Renee Geyer. Dave O'Neil: I met Peter Garrett from Midnight Oil, which was great because I showed him my Year 10 folder, which had his butt on the front. It freaked him out a little bit. And because I was a big fan of Oz rock, they started putting me with difficult people, like Chris Bailey from the Saints. He was really grumpy. I remember Jim Keays, from the Masters Apprentices, said to me once, 'Adam's a busy person, he hosts this and The Gruen Transfer.' And I said, 'That's Wil Anderson.' He thought Wil Anderson and Adam Hills were the same person. At that point he'd been on the show four or five times. Denise Scott: I had an interesting – oh, I can't say who it was because it was an American performer, a quite well-known musician – and he talked to himself the whole show so quietly and no one else knew except me. It was a mental health issue. OK, who was the worst at Substitute? Alan Brough: It was Hamish [Blake] doing Eye of the Tiger. He did all of the song and then he stopped, and I think Adam said, 'Hamish, can you tell us what it is?' And he said, ' Eye of the Tiger.' And you may have said, 'Are you sure?' And then he did it again, and we still didn't know what it was. Hamish Blake: Now that I think about it, that segment is literally for professional singers so, of course, I was the No. 1 worst. Denise Scott: I did have to do Substitute, but interestingly, I only ever got asked to do it once… Brian Mannix: The last time I did the show, I was dressed up in a Taylor Swift ballerina outfit. I don't often get to do that. In 2011, Hills, Warhurst and Brough decided it was time to leave the show. It was briefly rebooted for one season in 2014, with a new host and team captains, but it didn't last. Do they ever regret calling it quits in 2011? Myf Warhurst: I thought it was perfect timing because we'd done it for seven years and told all our stories. It meant people got to miss us, and we got to step away and realise how much joy the show had given us. It's one of the sweetest gigs for Alan and I, because we just turned up, basically. We sit back, knowing that we get to talk about what we love, meet people we love and hang out with our friends that we love. Adam Hills: You don't realise what you've got until you finish it. My manager had a really good phrase for it, he said, 'It's important to go off and do other things and realise that you're not magic.' Alan Brough: He's wrong because you got even more famous after we stopped. So you are magic. Dave O'Neil: My mum would watch [the repeats] in the nursing home and then ring me up and say, 'Did you dye your hair? I saw you on TV last night.' And I was like, 'Mum, that episode was 15 years old!' Who made the first move to get the band back together in 2018? Alan Brough: I made the first move once. It didn't work out and I didn't do it ever again… Adam Hills: It was the ABC wanting a one-off Aus music special. As soon as we all walked into the make-up room, it was like we'd never been away from each other. And I think, probably, at the end of that episode, there was talk of maybe we could do a couple of specials, and then, we could do a small series… Do you have another 20 years in you? Alan Brough: I don't think I've got 20 years of life. Myf Warhurst: We were talking about it today. We might do one in the nursing home. A reality show, maybe. Adam Hills: Music is constantly refreshing itself, and especially now with Spotify and the internet and all that kind of stuff. So as long as there's more music to talk about, then I think we could probably still talk about it. Alan Brough: There's a picture of the three of us, just as you go into the make-up room, and when we first came back, my daughter, who was born in 2011, walked past that at the age of 10 or something, and went, 'Oh, Myf and Adam look good, but you have got much older.' Adam Hills: We're like a three-part harmony. If you look at it in a musical sense, we each bring something different. And when you have all those three voices on their own, the voices are fantastic, but all those three voices together, it's bigger than the sum of the parts.
