New report flags unusually high acquittal rates in Orleans Parish judge trials
NEW ORLEANS (WGNO) — A new report from the Metropolitan Crime Commission is raising questions about how justice is being served in the Orleans Parish Criminal District Court, specifically when judges, not juries, decide the verdict.
According to the report, judges Nandi Campbell and Leon Roche not only presided over more judge only trials than any other judges in the parish, they also issued not-guilty verdicts at dramatically higher rates.
Slidell man arrested following house search, drug bust
From 2021 to 2023, 123 bench trials were held in the court. Campbell and Roche handled more than half, 51% of them.
Judge Campbell acquitted defendants in 79 percent of her judge trials.
In violent felony cases, that number climbed to 91%. That's 21 acquittals out of 23 trials.
Judge Roche, in his first full year on the bench, acquitted defendants in 88 percent of his judge trials.
Judge Roche, who began serving a full term in 2023, acquitted defendants in 88% of his judge trials in his first full year on the bench.
'These cases indicate that there is a strategic advantage for defendants to waive a jury before these two judges,' said Rafael Goyeneche, president of the Metropolitan Crime Commission. 'And these two judges should not be outliers to this extent.'
Suspect wanted in connection with Algiers shooting in custody following Terrytown standoff
For comparison, Orleans Parish juries returned not guilty verdicts just 43% of the time during the same period.
Louisiana law currently gives only defendants the right to waive a jury trial, a power not shared by prosecutors. That's something the MCC wants to change. The group is proposing a legal amendment that would require both the prosecution and defense to agree to a bench trial, mirroring the approach in federal court and 31 other states.
'Most judges have two or three judge trials a year. That's a busy year for most of the court,' Goyeneche said. 'These judges are doing 15-plus judge trials per year, and their acquittal rates are well outside the norms of juries and the other 10 judges of the court.'
While the MCC isn't accusing judges Campbell or Roche of wrongdoing, the report suggests their high acquittal rates may be symptomatic of a larger issue in the judicial system, one that may warrant further oversight or reform.Brennan Stuprich could shatter several Southeastern records in Southland Tournament opener
Calloway calls UNO baseball 'probably the most dangerous' No. 8 seed ever in Southland Tournament
Shreveport's Stage Center brings 'Mean Girls Jr.' to the stage
Golf legend's private jet makes emergency landing at LAX
Sheinbaum questions why US allowed in 17 relatives of 'El Chapo'
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
St. John the Baptist Parish youth curfew back in effect for the summer
ST. JOHN THE BAPTIST PARISH, La. (WGNO) — The St. John the Baptist Parish Sheriff's Office is reminding residents of the annual youth curfew. In a post to Facebook, deputies said with students on summer break, teenagers are only allowed to be out during a certain time of day. West Nile virus detected in Orleans Parish mosquitoes Minors under the age of 17 must be off the street between the hours of 10 p.m.-5 a.m., unless supervised by a parent or legal guardian, as established by the St. John Parish's Code of Ordinances Section 28-1. 'This curfew has been in place for years, it's not new,' said Sheriff Mike Tregre. He added that during the summer, property crimes, including vandalism and burglaries, tend to increase. 'We are not trying to ruin anyone's summer, but we will enforce the law,' Sheriff Tregre said. 'Parents, please know where your minor children are and make sure they are abiding by the curfew.' Told he'd never talk, New Orleans 6-year-old now starts conversations at Xavier University Any teen in violation of the curfew 'will be dealt with in accordance with juvenile court law and procedures.' Parents in violation of the curfew rules will face a fine of up to $100, imprisonment of up to 10 days or both as decided by the Awnings Justin Baldoni countersuit against Blake Lively, Ryan Reynolds dismissed Louisiana Public Broadcasting to honor six students across the state as young heroes NeuroJust – BioJust St. John the Baptist Parish youth curfew back in effect for the summer Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Hammond man accused in child's hot car death investigation
HAMMOND, La. (WGNO) — A child is dead and a man is in police custody accused of her death. According to the St. Tammany Parish Sheriff's Office , around 12 p.m. on Sunday, June 8, deputies were alerted of a child being found unresponsive inside a vehicle. Woman struck, killed by vehicle on Laplace highway An investigation revealed, at 2:30 a.m. 35-year-old Joseph Boatman had picked up his 21-month-old daughter from a family member's home, strapped her into the car seat, went inside but did not return. STPSO detectives said the child was in the vehicle for over nine hours. They add that prior to the incident, Boatman allegedly consumed multiple alcoholic beverages. 'This is a devastating loss that no family ever wants to face,' Sheriff Randy Smith said. 'When a child is left in a vehicle, especially on a day when the heat index climbs over 100 degrees, the outcome can turn deadly in a matter of minutes. This case involved compromised judgment, and the result was heartbreaking.' New Orleans crash leaves two people dead Boatman was booked into the St. Tammany Parish Correctional Center on a charge of second-degree preparedness supplies you should have for hurricane season Communities in Schools – Gulf South WGNO to volunteer with Giving Hope NOLA for Nexstar's Founder's Day In deploying National Guard, Trump critics see 'run around' of Insurrection Act Fungi concerns spark nationwide recall of Zicam and Orajel products Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Woman struck, killed by vehicle on Laplace highway
LAPLACE, La. (WGNO) — A Laplace woman is dead following a crash in St. John the Baptist Parish. According to Louisiana State Police, around 9:30 p.m. on Saturday, June 7, troopers responded to the scene of a crash on US Highway 61 near Carrollwood Drive. Moments of heavy rain expected Monday Troopers said an investigation revealed that 71-year-old Cecilia Adams attempted to walk across the north bound lanes of the highway, outside of a designated crosswalk while wearing dark clothing. That's when a Nissan Rogue, heading south, reportedly made a U-turn on the highway, striking Adams. She was taken to a hospital where she later died from her injuries. Troopers said the driver was wearing a seatbelt at the time and was not injured. They add that there were no signs of impairment. The crash remains under investigation. Fatal crash leaves two people dead 'Practicing pedestrian safety guidelines while crossing and walking near roadways is crucial in reducing the risk of crashes. Drivers should always keep in mind that they share the road with bicyclists and pedestrians and remember to be vigilant for their presence,' said LSP Troop Protests turn violent in Los Angeles Ram CEO confirms NASCAR return in 2026 Trump vs. California is the fight the White House wants New Trump travel ban takes effect Woman struck, killed by vehicle on Laplace highway Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
