
Tensions continue to mount in Coalition over potential student fee changes
Both the Taoiseach and Tánaiste have stressed the coalition is committed to reducing the cost of third level education over the lifetime of the government, after differences of opinion emerged in recent days over whether student fees should be restored to €3,000 from this term.
However privately, senior members of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael have moved to blame the other party for the disagreement which has sparked a backlash from students and families in recent days.
One senior Fianna Fáil minister described as "unfortunate" the fact that the parties have become embroiled in a row before proper budget talks have even started, and suggested that Mr Harris was raising expectations at a time when it will be challenging to meet the level of spending which people may be anticipating.
However, another Fine Gael minister laid the blame for tensions squarely at higher education minister James Lawless who said student fees, that were reduced by €1,000 over the past three years, will return to €3,000 as Budget 2026 will not contain a cost-of-living package which enabled the cut.
The source hit out a "naivety on his part" of Fianna Fáil's Mr Lawless, stating that he "certainly doesn't have an understanding of how the process works".
Mr Harris insisted that the Government is united on the issue of student fees, which he indicated will be reduced from early next year.
Asked about differences of opinion between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael on third level fees, Mr Harris stressed that a programme for government had been sign off on by both parties.
"This idea that a bill is going to fall due of €3,000 in September isn't actually what happens. Most people don't have three grand under the mattress, or six grand if the two kids come to college, people pay in instalments, often two or three instalments, one before Christmas, maybe one in the new year, one after. So actually, the time that any reduction comes in at isn't the most pertinent point."
Speaking in Japan, Taoiseach Micheál Martin said the Government wants to introduce reforms to be sustained across their five year term.
'The Tánaiste and I, and Minister Paschal Donohoe and Minister Jack Chambers have agreed that there won't be a cost of living package this year,' Mr Martin said.
What we're going to try and do is mainstream reforms and commitments in the Programme for Government into the Budget, that will be sustained then over a period of time.
"But that will create challenges for us in the first year.'
Mr Martin said there are other commitments within higher education the Government needs to examine, including the expansion of the SUSI grant and increasing accessibility to third-level for students with disabilities.
'There's a broad range of priorities there. So it'll all go forward to negotiations,' he said.
With student fees typically paid in instalments, Mr Martin was asked if it would be possible to cut the second instalment fee for students.
He said it 'might be possible', but it was early days ahead of the October budget and it would depend on the funding agreed by the public expenditure minister.
Read More
Tánaiste insists student fees will be reduced despite coalition tension
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Reduction in college fees to be sought by Minister for Higher Education in budget
Minister for Higher Education James Lawless has sought to defuse the controversy over third-level fees by insisting he will be seeking resources in the budget process to continue reductions to the €3,000 fee next year. After days of division between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil on the issue, Mr Lawless said he would try to achieve the 'best possible deal' for students and their parents. He stressed it was not possible at this stage to say how much of a reduction, if any, would be in the budget. However, he said he wanted to see if changes could be made to offer more support to those with more than one child in college. [ Coalition sharply divided over third-level fees Opens in new window ] 'I'm being very straight,' Mr Lawless told the Kildare Today programme on Kildare FM, his local radio station. 'At this time of year we don't have a budget yet so no minister before me either has been able to say in July what the budget will be in October,' he said. 'Everything is up in the air, everything is to play for.' He insisted that any changes would have to be permanent, rather than once-off. [ Chambers of Commerce offers no clarity over third-level fees Opens in new window ] If people pay the full amount of fees up front in September, they may 'well be entitled to a rebate', he said, but added that it was not possible to say at this stage what that might be. Meanwhile on Wednesday, two Government Ministers, including Mr Lawless, failed to clarify in the Dáil whether a proposed €1,000 increase in the fees would come into effect in September. For the second day in a row under sustained questioning and Opposition accusations of 'complete disarray and open revolt ' in Government, Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers stressed any changes would be in the context of Budget 2026. He said 'the changes we make will be done in a sustained and permanent way'. Mr Lawless told Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald the budgetary process takes place in October and 'not in June, July or August'. Controversy over the fees erupted after Mr Lawless said at the weekend on RTÉ that an additional €1,000 would have to be paid this year 'as things stand', provoking a sharp divide with their Fine Gael Coalition partners. Ms McDonald said the Ministers should 'have the decency to be clear with students and their families'. She said parents and students needed to know what level of fees they will have to pay in September. 'It is a very straightforward question'. She asked 'will their fees be set at €2,000 or €3,000'. Mr Lawless told her he was 'fighting within the resources available for students and their families for the best possible outcome across the board'with measures such as Susi grants, fee thresholds and student contributions. The fee, known as an 'annual student contribution', had been €3,000 but it was reduced to €2,000 as a temporary cost-of-living measure and rolled over for two more years. The Government has said that in Budget 2026 it will introduce permanent and sustainable measures to alleviate the cost burden for students and their families, which would likely include fees. Mr Chambers insisted the Government had to be cautious because of economic uncertainty and said Mr Lawless would engage with students and other stakeholders. 'That will form the basis of the options paper on the cost of education', for the budgetary process, he said. Acting Social Democrats leader Cian O'Callaghan called on the Government to 'stop the pretence that what is going on is part of the normal budgetary process'. He said 'nobody is buying that spin' and claimed there was 'complete disarray' and 'open revolt' in Government over student fees.


Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Tánaiste Simon Harris defends not permanently cutting college fees as Further and Higher Education Minister
James Lawless, the Fianna Fáil Minister who currently holds that portfolio, is under fire this week after suggesting last weekend college fees of €3,000 would not be cut in this year's Budget. Previous budgets saw the fees cut by as high as €1,000 as a once off measure as part of the cost of living package designed. However, the cuts were not put on a permanent reduction and Minister Lawless suggested that as there would be no cost of living measures this year, student fees would go back up to €3,000. His comments sparked a row with Fine Gael, with Tánaiste Simon Harris telling party members the commitment to cut fees remains. Minister Harris served as Further and Higher Education for four years in the last Government and moved to cut fees on a temporary basis in previous Budgets. He said how during the general election, Fine Gael campaigned to abolish college fees during the lifetime of the Government. He said the party campaigned on permanently cutting costs for education, childcare and VAT for hospitality. Minister Harris defended his record as Further and Higher Education Minister, saying he used the funds available to make the temporary reductions. 'What I used was every euro that was available to students to try and drive down their bills during the cost of living crisis. 'We had the money to do it on a once off basis and we took that in the cost of living package, as we did in many areas. But we made it crystal clear, crystal clear, I said this when I was Taoiseach and I said it during the election campaign, I want to permanently decrease the fees,' he said. 'That's the commitment I made to students and I want to deliver on it.' Speaking in the Dáil after being asked for clarity by Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald, Minister Lawless said 'no figure has ever been produced' by the Government in advance of a decision being made during Budgetary negotiations. Ms McDonald asked if students will be paying €2,000 or €3,000 in fees. 'The Budgetary process is underway. I am fighting within the resources available for students and their families with best possible outcome across the board,' said Minister Lawless. He said he is looking at many costs students have, including fees, Susi grants and the cost of accommodation. Fine Gael TD Catherine Callaghan told the Dáil her phone has been 'hopping' since Minister Lawless' comments over the weekend. Fianna Fáil Minister Jack Chambers said the measures will be considered as part of Budget 2026 and said the Government wants to make 'permanent changes' to some of the costs 'that exist for students'. Minister Lawless is expected to publish a report on the cost of education shortly.


Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Harris says he's not convinced there's a need for a ‘significant rise in the dole'
Fine Gael leader Simon Harris said that he was not convinced there was a need for a 'significant rise in the dole', when the country is at near full employment, compared with pension rises. He said he was keeping an 'open mind' in relation to Budgetary measures, saying there is 'only so much money in the pot'. He was speaking amid a Government row over student fee changes. Speaking to reporters today, Mr Harris said: 'I do always think there's merit in not looking at social welfare payments with a uniformity across the board because, you know, we've been talking a lot about college fees in the last couple of days, unexpectedly perhaps. 'But roughly speaking, the equivalent of €1.20/€1.25 on every social welfare payment is roughly the equivalent of reducing the college fees by €1,000. 'So budgets are all about choices, they're all about balance, and there's only so much money in the pot.' He added: 'I'm not convinced that you need to see as significant a rise in the dole as you do in the pension, for example, at a time when our country is in full employment, when there's lots of supports out there for people getting into work, when there's other supports out there for people who can't work for very many good reasons. 'That's my view. We'll thrash all this out in the Budget.'