Minister accused of 'talking out of both sides of his mouth' with rent pressure zone plans
Housing minister James Browne has come under fire plans to overhaul rent pressure zones, with opposition TDs saying it will strip away protections for renters.
Sinn Féin, Labour, and the Social Democrats have all criticised Mr Browne for confirming that changes will be made to rent pressure zones (RPZs) — although the actual proposal is yet to be unveiled.
Mr Browne's comments came in an interview with the Irish Examiner, where he said that rent pressure zones — introduced in 2016 to stop big rent increases — are 'significantly inhibiting' the delivery of new apartments in Dublin.
'There has to be change. There's no question about that. The current system is significantly inhibiting the delivery of apartments in Dublin,' Mr Browne said.
I think all of the research is pointing to that direction, and it's just obvious from the fact that apartments are not being delivered
Mr Browne said that while rent pressure zones would be changed, he intended to introduce 'significant protections' for renters — including looking at reforms to renters rights.
The Housing Agency has provided Mr Browne with an options paper on reform, which includes the outright abolition of rent pressure zones, retention, or changing how much landlords can increase rents each year.
Sinn Féin's Eoin Ó Broin highlighted the recent Daft.ie rent report, which found the average rent in Ireland is now €2,053 per month. This is the first time the €2,000 mark has been breached.
'I have to say: The minister is gaslighting renters and he's talking out of both sides of his mouth. He's telling the industry, on the one hand, that he is going to buckle under pressure and allow them to jack up rents even further and — at the same time — he's promising to protect renters,' Mr Ó Broin said.
'You cannot do both of those things.'
'Limited tax incentive'
Conor Sheehan, Labour's housing spokesperson, said renters must not be 'thrown to the wolves to satiate investors'.
To deal with the issue of a lack of investment in Dublin, Mr Sheehan suggested a bespoke solution such as a 'limited tax incentive' for investors looking to build apartments in the capital.
Social Democrats housing spokesperson Rory Hearne said his party would 'vociferously' oppose any changes to rent pressure zones.
Some of Mr Browne's ideas have been welcomed, however, with Labour and the Social Democrats cautiously optimistic about initial talks for a State-led savings account to fund housebuilding.
The housing minister said he is currently considering the introduction of a scheme where the public could invest savings, with funds going towards the construction of homes.
'It is something we're looking at. We have to be very careful what it looks like, how it's funded,' Mr Browne said.
In a letter to Mr Browne, Mr Hearne said he had spoken in the Dáil previously about such a scheme and added that his party would be happy to engage with Government on the matter.
'Rather than chasing unreliable global institutional funds to build unaffordable rental homes, here is a mechanism to provide additional sourcing of private finance that can deliver affordable housing,' Mr Hearne wrote.
'We need new ways to fund housing to make a difference to the lives of a generation locked out of homeownership and denied affordable rental homes.'
Mr Sheehan also welcomed the proposal, saying Labour had included it as part of their general election manifesto.
Read More
Plans to form derelict restoration and vacant shop grants in motion, says minister
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
34 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Fresh homeless fears as new Gov plan ‘incentivises landlords to evict tenants' & Martin accused of ‘gaslighting renters'
HARD-pressed renters face the risk of homelessness under new Government plans, it has been warned. Under the proposals, rents in newly built 2 New plans will see the rental rates of newly built properties tied to inflation Credit: Getty Images - Getty 2 Housing Minister James Browne will bring the new proposal to the Cabinet tomorrow Credit: 2025 PA Media, All Rights Reserved The plans to restructure Rent Pressure Zones will go to Cabinet tomorrow but they have led to fears tenants will face significant hikes and have increased concerns that renters may end up on the streets. Under the plans, The proposal, which Housing Minister James Browne will bring to the Cabinet, will likely state that there will be no changes for existing renters if they stay in their current tenancy. However if they move, a landlord can reset the rent for the new tenant at the market rate. READ MORE ON HOUSING CRISIS Taoiseach But He said: 'When the Taoiseach said that this was a balanced package to protect renters and encourage investment, he is deliberately misleading the public. 'He is gaslighting renters, and I'm not even sure he fully understands the extent which they're putting huge numbers of people, young people, people approaching pension age, at enormous risk with even greater financial hardship, and in many cases, at risk of Most read in Irish News Mike Allen, the Director of Advocacy at Focus Ireland, also told how the proposals could place further Allen said: 'They seem to be creating a system which creates incentives for landlords to evict tenants so they can bring in something at higher market rates. Sinn Fein housing spokesman Eoin O Broin reacts to record number of homeless people 'And secondly, they're increasing rents right across the board. What are they doing for low income people on HAP to make sure subsidies there don't force people into deeper debt and eventually into homelessness?' The Irish Property Owners Association said they were concerned that the And they stressed that the proposed six-year minimum security of tenure will have a serious negative impact on private, non-institutional landlords, and on the rental 'CHANGES ARE UNFAIR' Chairperson Mary Conway said: 'The proposed changes are unfair on the individual who – for good reason – wishes to, and needs to, rent out their home for a short period and points to a flaw on the part of the Government thinking which – by going after institutional landlords – has ignored the implications for individual, private landlords. 'We believe that in seeking to address political concerns about the role of institutional landlords (who are predominantly active in the
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Government to withhold support for motion to end Central Bank facilitation of Israeli war bonds
The Government will not be supporting a cross-party motion demanding the Central Bank end the facilitation of Israeli war bonds and will instead table its own counter motion. Four opposition parties have come together to back the motion and have called on Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael to provide the Government TDs with a free vote when it comes before the Dáil on Wednesday. The Social Democrats, Sinn Féin, Labour and People Before Profit-Solidarity have united behind the motion that demands that the Government enact emergency legislation to explicitly force the Central Bank to stop facilitating the sale of Israeli bonds. It also calls on the coalition to advise the bank that "by acting as the enabling cog in Israel's fundraising machine in the European Union it is putting the state at risk of a charge of complicity in genocide". The motion stresses that since October 2023 the bonds have been advertised as war bonds with the slogan 'stand with Israel – Israel is at war'. The website marketing the bonds contains a video by Israeli President Isaac Herzog who lauds 'the crucial role of Israel bonds during this time of conflict and war". Last month, a similar Sinn Féin bill which sought to stop the Central Bank facilitating the sale of Israeli war bonds was defeated after the Government voted against the draft legislation. Sinn Féin TD Seán Crowe said the gap between the vote on the Sinn Féin Bill and this motion has given TDs 'time to reflect'. Mr Crowe asked: Is there anyone in Ireland comfortable with the fact that we're facilitating this blood money coming into our country and being spent on weapons that are killing men, women and children? Calling on the Government leaders to allow backbench TDs a vote of conscience, Social Democrats TD Sinéad Gibney said: 'We have failed as an international community to prevent a genocide from happening so now we have to do everything in our power to make sure that we stop it.' She added: 'We are urging the Government to allow a free vote, a vote of conscience, because we believe that this is something that many TDs will support if given the opportunity. 'And we absolutely urge the Government to support this motion.' Labour TD Duncan Smith said adopting the motion would send a "clear signal" that Ireland is "morally and ethically" against Israel's bombardment of Gaza and that "Irish people do not stand for the selling of Israeli war bonds". Humanitarian aid blockade Meanwhile, Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris has made an urgent call to end the blockade and allow humanitarian aid into Gaza. "Ireland has consistently called on Israel to lift its blockade and allow unimpeded access of humanitarian aid at scale into Gaza, in accordance with international law and humanitarian principles," Mr Harris said in a statement. "The UN and humanitarian organisations must be allowed to work independently and do their job. It is a shame on the world and international community that people are starving in Gaza." Praising activists aboard the Madleen, which was blocked by Israeli forces on route to Gaza, Mr Harris said: "The question we should be asking today is not a debate about the merits or not of the flotilla but how it has come to this; that the world is turning a blind eye to starving children in Gaza." Read More Watch: Surveillance footage shows crew on Gaza aid boat putting hands up as Israeli forces seize vessel
The Journal
3 hours ago
- The Journal
Opposition calls for ‘vote of conscience' on Israeli 'war bonds' ahead of cross-party motion
OPPOSITION PARTIES HAVE requested a free 'vote of conscience' on a motion calling on the Government to stop the Central Bank from facilitating the sale of Israeli State Bonds. The Central Bank of Ireland is the designated authority in relation to the sale of Israeli Bonds in the EU. Israeli State Bonds have been advertised as supporting the country's economy, and more recently, websites promoting the securities emphasise their role in supporting Israel's military operations in Gaza, leading some to dub them 'Israeli war bonds'. The Central Bank is responsible for assessing whether a prospectus for the offer of securities is in compliance with requirements of the EU Prospectus Regulation, with the authority saying approval should not be viewed as 'an endorsement of the issuer'. Protesters have demonstrated outside the Central Bank and called for legislation that would give Ireland the power to refuse the sale of Israeli 'war bonds' over human rights concerns. Advertisement Last month, a Sinn Féin bill which sought to stop the Irish Central Bank facilitating the sale of Israeli 'war bonds' was defeated after the Government voted against the draft legislation. On Wednesday, the Dáil will vote on a motion on the matter brought by a number of opposition parties during the Social Democrats' time. The motion says the bonds are intended to fund the war in Gaza and argues Ireland ha obligations under the Genocide Convention to use all means likely to have a deterrent effect on those suspected of preparing genocide. Speaking to reporters today, Social Democrats TD Sinéad Gibney said: 'We have failed as an international community to prevent a genocide from happening so now we have to do everything in our power to make sure that we stop it.' She added: 'We are urging the Government to allow a free vote, a vote of conscience, because we believe that this is something that many TDs will support if given the opportunity. 'And we absolutely urge the Government to support this motion.' Sinn Féin TD Seán Crowe said he believes the gap between the vote on the Sinn Féin Bill and this motion will give TDs 'time to reflect'.
