Minister accused of 'talking out of both sides of his mouth' with rent pressure zone plans
Housing minister James Browne has come under fire plans to overhaul rent pressure zones, with opposition TDs saying it will strip away protections for renters.
Sinn Féin, Labour, and the Social Democrats have all criticised Mr Browne for confirming that changes will be made to rent pressure zones (RPZs) — although the actual proposal is yet to be unveiled.
Mr Browne's comments came in an interview with the Irish Examiner, where he said that rent pressure zones — introduced in 2016 to stop big rent increases — are 'significantly inhibiting' the delivery of new apartments in Dublin.
'There has to be change. There's no question about that. The current system is significantly inhibiting the delivery of apartments in Dublin,' Mr Browne said.
I think all of the research is pointing to that direction, and it's just obvious from the fact that apartments are not being delivered
Mr Browne said that while rent pressure zones would be changed, he intended to introduce 'significant protections' for renters — including looking at reforms to renters rights.
The Housing Agency has provided Mr Browne with an options paper on reform, which includes the outright abolition of rent pressure zones, retention, or changing how much landlords can increase rents each year.
Sinn Féin's Eoin Ó Broin highlighted the recent Daft.ie rent report, which found the average rent in Ireland is now €2,053 per month. This is the first time the €2,000 mark has been breached.
'I have to say: The minister is gaslighting renters and he's talking out of both sides of his mouth. He's telling the industry, on the one hand, that he is going to buckle under pressure and allow them to jack up rents even further and — at the same time — he's promising to protect renters,' Mr Ó Broin said.
'You cannot do both of those things.'
'Limited tax incentive'
Conor Sheehan, Labour's housing spokesperson, said renters must not be 'thrown to the wolves to satiate investors'.
To deal with the issue of a lack of investment in Dublin, Mr Sheehan suggested a bespoke solution such as a 'limited tax incentive' for investors looking to build apartments in the capital.
Social Democrats housing spokesperson Rory Hearne said his party would 'vociferously' oppose any changes to rent pressure zones.
Some of Mr Browne's ideas have been welcomed, however, with Labour and the Social Democrats cautiously optimistic about initial talks for a State-led savings account to fund housebuilding.
The housing minister said he is currently considering the introduction of a scheme where the public could invest savings, with funds going towards the construction of homes.
'It is something we're looking at. We have to be very careful what it looks like, how it's funded,' Mr Browne said.
In a letter to Mr Browne, Mr Hearne said he had spoken in the Dáil previously about such a scheme and added that his party would be happy to engage with Government on the matter.
'Rather than chasing unreliable global institutional funds to build unaffordable rental homes, here is a mechanism to provide additional sourcing of private finance that can deliver affordable housing,' Mr Hearne wrote.
'We need new ways to fund housing to make a difference to the lives of a generation locked out of homeownership and denied affordable rental homes.'
Mr Sheehan also welcomed the proposal, saying Labour had included it as part of their general election manifesto.
Read More
Plans to form derelict restoration and vacant shop grants in motion, says minister
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Dublin Live
29 minutes ago
- Dublin Live
Housing Minister does not know when rents will drop as new RPZ measures confirmed
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Housing Minister James Browne has admitted that he does not know when his new plans for Rent Pressure Zone will result in lower rents. The Fianna Fáil TD confirmed, however, that after six years, all tenants could face massive rent increases as landlords will be allowed to "reset" rents to market rates. The Dáil heard that thousands of rents will increase annually as renters voluntarily leave their tenancies all the time. Cabinet agreed on Tuesday to extend and modify the Rent Pressure Zone (RPZ) legislation, which is due to lapse at the end of the year. This will see rent increases capped at 2 per cent annually for new tenancies. Rents in new build apartments will be linked to Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation rates. These rules will be applied nationwide. From March 1 2026, tenancies of unlimited duration will be introduced through rolling six-year tenancies. Small landlords, those with three properties or fewer, can only terminate a tenancy during the six-year period if they face hardship, such as separation, homelessness, emigration from abroad, or bankruptcy. As reported by the Irish Mirror on Tuesday, the list of family members that a landlord can expel a tenant for will be tightened to parents, children or a spouse. At the end of each six-year tenancy, a smaller landlord will have the right to terminate a tenancy if they are selling, renovating, giving it to a family member or ceasing to rent. Landlords with four or more tenancies will not be able to end a tenancy where the tenant has complied with their obligations, except in very limited circumstances. However, all landlords will have the right to reset rent where the rent is below market at the end of each six-year tenancy, unless a 'no fault eviction' occurs. This, Minister Browne suggested, means that there should not be a large increase in rents until 2032. This will not affect existing tenancies, Taoiseach Micheál Martin insisted in the Dáil. Minister Browne said that the Government was not portraying the changes as a "silver bullet" and said that the only way rents will come down is through increased supply. He argued that new apartments are being exempt from the 2% cap as international investors are "not looking at our State". When asked if rents would fall over the next 24 months, Mr Browne refused to answer the question with a yes or no. Instead, he said he "expects rents to fall over time" and he wanted them to come down as quickly as possible. He added: "What that particular length of time is, I wouldn't be able to predict." He continued: "If we get that supply moving, we will start and see rents going down. "But if we continue doing what we're doing at the moment, we're simply not going to see those rents coming down." Minister Browne also said he would like "maximum transparency" and he would like to see a rent register implemented. However, he acknowledged there was no Government agreement to do so. In the Dáil, the changes to RPZ legislation were torn to shreds by the opposition. Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald questioned the ability to increase rents to market rates once renters leave voluntarily, noting that thousands of people voluntarily leave tenancies every year. She said: "You say or claim that landlords will only be allowed to reset rent to the market rate if a tenant leaves voluntarily. "Well Taoiseach, tens of thousands of renters leave tenancies voluntarily every single year. "Under your proposals, as one renter walks out the door, they will be replaced by another whose rent will have balloons. Students will be amongst the first hit by your actions" Join our Dublin Live breaking news service on WhatsApp. Click this link to receive your daily dose of Dublin Live content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. For all the latest news from Dublin and surrounding areas visit our homepage.
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Far-right causing ‘huge concern' as counter terror detectives dedicated to probe violent political extremism
Deputy Commission Justin Kelly also told politicians this afternoon that they have put significant resources into investigating the online activities of these groups. The Deputy Commissioner for Security, Strategy and Governance was appearing before the Justice Committee on Justice, Home Affairs and Migrations this afternoon. He was joined by Garda Commissioner Drew Harris and Deputy Commissioner for Operations Shawna Coxon. During the meeting Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon questioned the senior gardaí about the threat of far-right violence and the garda response to this. Deputy Commissioner Kelly said that the force has put considerable investment into targeting groups involved in violent political extremism, including investigating their online activity. Mr Kelly added that they have gardaí in the four regions who can look at activity ahead of a protest to help identify problematic areas, as well as the garda's national security and intelligence network. 'The far-right of course is a huge concern for us,' he said, and that they have officers in the counter terror Special Detective Unit solely dedicated to investigating this. 'That's all they do,' he added. Deputy Gannon also said that while prosecutions have been brought against people involved in violence during the Dublin Riots in November 2023, he said that those who instigated the violence and have large followings online have got away 'Scot free'. Commissioner Harris said that part of these investigations includes following through on social media posts and individuals where it could meet the threshold for incitement to violence. In his opening remarks the Garda chief briefed the committee on issues around recruitment, the operating model, and roads policing. As of April 3, the organisation's strength stood at 18,194 people, including 14,221 sworn gardaí, 304 reserves, and 3,669 garda staff. Mr Harris said the rate of resignations has slowed and retirements were at their expected rate, while a small number of gardaí who resigned have since rejoined the force. In the last recruitment campaign 41pc were over the age of 30, with the force 'determined' to meet the government target of 5,000 gardaí passing through Templemore. He also said they are working out a plan to meet that target which includes looking at accommodation. The Garda Commissioner also referenced the new operating model which has shifted the organisation's focus from a local district model to a district model. Its rollout has been condemned by all garda representative bodies for gardaí, sergeants, inspectors, and superintendents. Mr Harris told the committee that An Garda Síochána's structure was unchanged since 1922 and that this 'was not sustainable' at a time of rapid and constant change in the country. He described it as the biggest organisational change the force has seen, and that it was 'done in order to enhance the service we provide to the public'. He pointed to the establishment of dedicated protective service units in each division which investigate sexual offences and domestic violence. In the last two years there have been 67 prosecutions for non-fatal strangulations, 52 for coercive control, and 12 for stalking. The Garda Commissioner said that this 'great work makes a difference to victims'. The operating model has also seen a Detective Superintendent appointed to each of the 21 divisions to oversee investigations into serious criminality. Mr Harris also said that the death of Garda Kevin Flatley on May 14 'serves as a stark reminder of the risks our gardaí face while on duty but also puts into sharp focus the danger that exists on our roads today'. So far this year 72 people have lost their lives on Irish roads, down 6 from the same time last year, though Mr Harris acknowledged that this reduction 'is no consolation for the bereaved families'. Over the last 12 months gardaí have rolled out a range of road safety measures including safety cameras, unmarked vehicles, and issuing mobile devices to gardaí to that they have access to the national driver database while on the beat. Garda Commissioner Harris also told the committee that a cadaver dog was brought in to search for missing Kerry farmer Michael Gaine before his remains were found. Mr Harris said that the canine searched Mr Gaine's land and farm in the third week of the investigation but gave no indication of anything being there. Mr Gaine was reported missing on March 20 with his remains not found until May 16. Fianna Fail TD Michael Cahill criticised the Garda response and said that 'there should have been a proper search of the slurry tanks, it seems it didn't happen in this case, and raised concerns about why a review into an active murder probe is taking place. Mr Harris said it was standard practice that a peer review is undertaken in a murder investigation. There were also calls during the committee for gardai to retain their own cadaver dog. Mr Harris yesterday said that they had only been required three times during his seven year tenure. Politicians were today told that gardai had a cadaver dog until 2012, but found its skills faded because it was not utilised enough. He said there had been considerable effort made to retrain that dog because they work best when consistently used.
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Over €400,000 allocated to Meath to provide essential modifications to social housing
The funding aims to adapt and improve local authority housing stock to support older people, those with disabilities, and families experiencing overcrowding. This funding will enable essential home modifications such as stair lifts, ramps, grab rails, and more complex adaptations including downstairs bedrooms, wet rooms, and even extensions to relieve overcrowding. Importantly, the Improvement Works in Lieu scheme will also allow for necessary upgrades to privately owned homes, if the resident has already been approved for social housing. Welcoming the announcement, Meath West Senator Linda Nelson Murray said: 'This funding will help adapt older social housing. When I was canvassing, I was working with people who were living in social housing; some of them have lived there all their lives, they've gotten older in that house and they might need a new front door, a window or a new step. So this will benefit those people. A lot of our newer social housing are more adapted.' Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage, James Browne said: 'This funding will significantly improve housing conditions for older tenants and those with disabilities. It will also help tackle overcrowding in social housing and offer an alternative for those currently living in overcrowded private accommodation.' Meanwhile Minister of State with responsibility for Older People, Kieran O'Donnell said his priority is 'to empower older individuals to remain living in the homes and communities where they have made their lives.' 'This funding announcement is a positive measure in contributing to this,' he added. The funding will be administered by Meath County Council, who will be responsible for identifying eligible properties and overseeing the improvement works. The schemes are structured so that 90pc of the cost is covered by the Department, with 10pc coming from the local authority. Funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme.
