Minister accused of 'talking out of both sides of his mouth' with rent pressure zone plans
Housing minister James Browne has come under fire plans to overhaul rent pressure zones, with opposition TDs saying it will strip away protections for renters.
Sinn Féin, Labour, and the Social Democrats have all criticised Mr Browne for confirming that changes will be made to rent pressure zones (RPZs) — although the actual proposal is yet to be unveiled.
Mr Browne's comments came in an interview with the Irish Examiner, where he said that rent pressure zones — introduced in 2016 to stop big rent increases — are 'significantly inhibiting' the delivery of new apartments in Dublin.
'There has to be change. There's no question about that. The current system is significantly inhibiting the delivery of apartments in Dublin,' Mr Browne said.
I think all of the research is pointing to that direction, and it's just obvious from the fact that apartments are not being delivered
Mr Browne said that while rent pressure zones would be changed, he intended to introduce 'significant protections' for renters — including looking at reforms to renters rights.
The Housing Agency has provided Mr Browne with an options paper on reform, which includes the outright abolition of rent pressure zones, retention, or changing how much landlords can increase rents each year.
Sinn Féin's Eoin Ó Broin highlighted the recent Daft.ie rent report, which found the average rent in Ireland is now €2,053 per month. This is the first time the €2,000 mark has been breached.
'I have to say: The minister is gaslighting renters and he's talking out of both sides of his mouth. He's telling the industry, on the one hand, that he is going to buckle under pressure and allow them to jack up rents even further and — at the same time — he's promising to protect renters,' Mr Ó Broin said.
'You cannot do both of those things.'
'Limited tax incentive'
Conor Sheehan, Labour's housing spokesperson, said renters must not be 'thrown to the wolves to satiate investors'.
To deal with the issue of a lack of investment in Dublin, Mr Sheehan suggested a bespoke solution such as a 'limited tax incentive' for investors looking to build apartments in the capital.
Social Democrats housing spokesperson Rory Hearne said his party would 'vociferously' oppose any changes to rent pressure zones.
Some of Mr Browne's ideas have been welcomed, however, with Labour and the Social Democrats cautiously optimistic about initial talks for a State-led savings account to fund housebuilding.
The housing minister said he is currently considering the introduction of a scheme where the public could invest savings, with funds going towards the construction of homes.
'It is something we're looking at. We have to be very careful what it looks like, how it's funded,' Mr Browne said.
In a letter to Mr Browne, Mr Hearne said he had spoken in the Dáil previously about such a scheme and added that his party would be happy to engage with Government on the matter.
'Rather than chasing unreliable global institutional funds to build unaffordable rental homes, here is a mechanism to provide additional sourcing of private finance that can deliver affordable housing,' Mr Hearne wrote.
'We need new ways to fund housing to make a difference to the lives of a generation locked out of homeownership and denied affordable rental homes.'
Mr Sheehan also welcomed the proposal, saying Labour had included it as part of their general election manifesto.
Read More
Plans to form derelict restoration and vacant shop grants in motion, says minister
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
3 hours ago
- The Journal
70-year-old Irish woman deported from Israel after being denied legal representation in court
AN IRISH WOMAN has been deported from Israel this afternoon, ten days after she was arrested by Israeli forces for 'entering an active military zone' in the West Bank. 70-year-old great-grandmother Máire Ní Mhurchú, originally from Douglas, Co Cork, was detained by Israeli forces in the village of Khallet al-Dabaa in the Masafer Yatta region of southern West Bank on 1 June. Murphy was arrested shortly after Israeli forces declared the village a 'closed military zone.' According to Palestinian sources, residents and international solidarity activists were forcibly removed from the area. The International Solidarity Movement (ISM), a Palestinian-led organisation that supports nonviolent resistance in the West Bank and Gaza, said Murphy had been complying with Israeli orders to leave when she was harassed by Israeli settlers. Murphy was initially held at Ben Gurion Airport, before being transferred to Givon Prison in Ramla on Tuesday. She appeared before court in Israel this week to appeal the deportation order given to her by Israeli authorities – though the ISM claim she was denied legal representation and was unable to contact her lawyer , despite her requests for them and multiple attempts by her lawyer to get in touch through the prison service. Murphy was deported to the UK this afternoon. Advertisement Her son, Dale Ryan, said that her family 'are all very relieved' to have her home. 'The past 10 days have been intense and we have had to trust that the Israeli authorities would treat my mother fairly and ensure her basic needs were met,' Ryan said. 'From their treatment of the Palestinians over the past several decades, this was not something we had the most confidence in. He added that his mother wanted to remain in the West Bank 'helping them in any way she could', but conceded that Murphy 'would have been pleased that her situation helped to draw some more eyes to the appalling treatment of Palestinians in the West Bank'. 'I know after a day's rest my mother will be back gathering support for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza and for the fair treatment of all Palestinians, after me and all her family give her a massive hug.' According to the ISM, Israeli forces are now demolishing the houses and water systems left in Khalet Al-Dabaa, together with makeshift tents. 'These communities face an ongoing and escalating campaign of ethnic cleansing and forcible displacement being carried out by Israeli settlers with the full support of the Israeli state,' an ISM spokesperson said. They added that they were disappointed in the 'shy response' from both the Irish and British governments. 'Murphy's case has served to remind us that the international community not only has an obligation to stop trade and relationships with Israel, but also to take decisive steps to bring the genocide and occupation of Palestine to an end,' the spokesperson added. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
The Journal
3 hours ago
- The Journal
The UK has finally struck a deal with the EU on managing its land border with Spain
THE EU AND UK have finally struck a post-Brexit deal on the status of the territory of Gibraltar, which is located on the Iberian peninsula south of Spain but is controlled by the UK. The deal, which has taken five years since UK left the EU, should ease the flow of people and goods over the Gibraltar-Spain border. When the UK left the EU in 2020, the relationship between Gibraltar – historically an important military base for Britain due to its position at the mouth of the Mediterranean Sea — and the EU remained unresolved. Talks between the UK, Spain, EU and Gibraltar on a deal had made halting progress during several rounds of negotiations under the UK's previous Conservative government but the arrival of Labour last summer gave new impetus. EU trade chief Maros Sefcovic said it was 'a truly historic milestone for the European Union, including Spain, as well as for the United Kingdom and Gibraltar'. 'This agreement benefits everyone and will bring legal certainty and confidence to the people and businesses across the region,' he said during a news conference in Brussels. He said he was 'absolutely convinced' it would be ratified by the parties because 'it's a good agreement'. A truly historic milestone: an EU-UK political agreement on the future relationship concerning Gibraltar. This benefits everyone and reinforces a new chapter in the 🇪🇺🇬🇧 relationship. Our joint statement with @jmalbares @DavidLammy @FabianPicardo 👉📝 . — Maroš Šefčovič🇪🇺 (@MarosSefcovic) June 11, 2025 In a statement, the four parties said the agreement would create a fluid border between Gibraltar and Spain, with no physical barriers or checks between the territory and the border town of La Linea. Advertisement People arriving in the territory by air or sea would undergo dual border checks at Gibraltar port and airport, to be carried out by Gibraltar and Spanish officials. 'Spanish officials will be responsible for ensuring the integrity of the Schengen Area,' said a UK statement, which likened the arrangement to the system at London's St Pancras station, where French police carry out border checks for passengers bound for the EU. 'Immigration and law and order in Gibraltar will remain the exclusive responsibility of Gibraltar's authorities,' said the statement from Britain's foreign office. 'Today's breakthrough delivers a practical solution after years of uncertainty,' British Foreign Minister David Lammy said in a statement. The agreement 'protects British sovereignty, supports Gibraltar's economy and allows businesses to plan for the long-term once again', he said. Chief Minister of Gibraltar Fabian Picardo said he was 'delighted' about the agreement that will bring 'legal certainty to the people of Gibraltar, its businesses and to those across the region who rely on stability at the frontier'. The deal, he said, 'will protect future generations of British Gibraltarians and does not in any way affect our British sovereignty'. Today, with @DavidLammy and @SDoughtyMP we held a Cabinet meeting in No6 Convent Place to agree final parameters for negotiation. We will now travel to Brussels to meet @MarosSefcovic and @jmalbares . It's time to try to finalise arrangements for lasting, stable relationship… — Fabian Picardo (@FabianPicardo) June 11, 2025 Around 15,000 people — over half of Gibraltar's workforce, according to the UK — cross the land border between Spain and Gibraltar every day. Britain and Spain have disputed control of the tiny territory since it was ceded to Britain in the 1713 Treaty of Utrecht. © AFP 2025
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Opposition accuses Government of making 'sacrificial lambs' of renters
The Taoiseach has been accused of turning renters into "sacrificial lambs" under the Government's new rent rules. The Government announced sweeping changes to the rent system on Tuesday that will cap rent increases at the rate of inflation. However, in times of high inflation, hikes for most tenancies will be limited to a maximum of 2%. The changes will also end 'no-fault evictions' for larger landlords — those with four or more tenancies — who will no longer be able to terminate a tenancy where the tenant has met their obligations, except in very limited circumstances. However, speaking during Wednesday's leaders' questions, Social Democrats deputy leader Cian O'Callaghan said the Government was "gambling" with the changes. Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald branded them "a shambles". Mr O'Callaghan said the reality of the rental market was "dystopian". "Instead of protecting renters, [the Government's] big plan is to use them as sacrificial lambs and to bleed them dry. Incredibly, yesterday the minister for housing, James Browne, claimed that rents would eventually come down but he could not tell us when this was going to happen. Before being put in charge of housing, the minister was responsible for gambling. It now seems he is gambling with renters' future and betting against them. Taoiseach Micheál Martin rejected the criticisms, saying renters would not be affected in the short-term. 'The bottom line is, I repeat again, all existing tenants will not have their rents increase beyond 2% and no attempts by you to sow confusion will change that reality,' he said. Meanwhile, the minister for further and higher education has been accused of agreeing a decision that will deepen the accommodation crisis for students. People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy criticised James Lawless as he attended the Oireachtas committee on further and higher education and research. Mr Murphy said he noted how in the minister's opening statement to the committee he referred to the lack of affordable accommodation is a 'big barrier' for students attending tertiary education. 'Yet, you are part of the Government that yesterday signed off on a plan that is going to make that crisis for students a lot worse. 'Students are arguably the group that is hit hardest, so students who are in rental accommodation will effectively not have any rental protection whatsoever.' 'When asked about it, you say that you'll be meeting with Minister Brown to trash out how this will work,' Mr Brown said. I don't understand; You're there at the Cabinet. Student accommodation is one of the biggest issues in higher education. How have you not already thought this through? Mr Lawless rejected the criticism in an — at times — tense exchange with Mr Murphy. The plans will come into effect next March, he said. 'There's a lot of water under the bridge between now next March." He plans to sit down with James Browne and 'delve into the detail about how it affected student accommodation sector', he added. Committee chair Erin McGreehan said she did not think it was fair to interrogate the minister on plans that have not yet been finalized. 'Respectfully, I think your job as chair is not to defend [or] to protect the minister from questioning,' Mr Murphy said.
