
Why the Colts have to prioritise Colston Loveland in the draft
When the spotlight turns on the Indianapolis Colts with the 14th pick on draft day it's expected that General Manager Chris Ballard will target a tight end, especially as Mo Alie-Cox remains an unrestricted free agent and Kylen Granson is now with the reigning Super Bowl champion Philadelphia Eagles.
Advertisement
The Colts finished the 2024 season with an 8-9 record and narrowly missed out on a playoff berth. If they are to end their four-year postseason drought in 2025, they will need to land another pass-catcher.
On the latest episode of 'The Athletic Football Show', the third in our 'On the Clock' series, Robert Mays was joined by ESPN's Ben Solak to discuss why Michigan tight end Colston Loveland would be a better fit for Indianapolis than Penn State's Tyler Warren. Watch the full discussion below.
A partial transcript has been edited for clarity and length. The full episode is available on YouTube below or in 'The Athletic Football Show' feed on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Robert: Let's get to the Indianapolis Colts at 14. You have three options; first, tight end Colston Loveland from Michigan…
Ben: I don't need to hear the next two (laughs)…
Robert: That's it, you're done? (Laughs) The other one was an interior offensive lineman, so Kelvin Banks Jr. if he's available, or Tyler Booker. The third option was Jihaad Campbell from Alabama. But you don't need to hear the options, Colston Loveland is the answer?
Ben: Jihaad Campbell was interesting for a second. I like Campbell a lot, and the film is good. But the torn labrum seems like it's really impacting the draft process, and there might be a fall there. I can't speak to his medicals, but that's something that's been spoken about post-combine. I have Loveland as tight end one. I like him a hair better than Tyler Warren. It is splitting hairs legitimately because they're both very good tight ends and both bring value as blockers and as receivers. They're just used a little bit differently. So much of Warren's production at Penn State was the goofy stuff like screens, throwbacks, the wheels on the fake screens and everything, which is totally fine.
Advertisement
Robert: Playing center and catching jump balls in the end zone…
Ben: Right. It doesn't take anything away from the fact he's clearly got height, power, some strength and movement skills to him. But if you want Warren to have a round one impact on your passing game, you've got to design stuff for him. You have to make plays for his skill set to shine.
With Loveland, you just put him out there because he has the speed, the change of direction, and he catches everything. He's got wonderful hands away from his frame through contact, and he can line up on the outside for you if you want to use him that way as your tight end. When you look at the Colts and you say, 'Anthony Richardson, the run game and the multiple backfield stuff,' Warren would be a great fit for them. But there's nothing that Loveland can't do. And if you're taking a run-heavy approach there with Richardson in the trenches, and tied up next to the offensive tackle, Loveland is a better blocker than Warren even though Warren gets the tough guy moniker. People assume he's a better blocker… and he is tough as nails. But he's got short arms and he doesn't displace and uproot people the way you might expect him to. He's very high cut, and he doesn't have that lower-body leverage.
Robert: Why do you think that moniker has been attached to Warren more than it's been attached to Loveland?
Ben: Because he plays for Penn State and he kind of has a mullet (laughs)… and he's very physical with the ball in his hands, so it just makes sense. Our brains just naturally fill in the gap of the evaluation. But it's the length thing. Warren has a 10th percentile arm length for tight ends. It's 31 and a half inches, which is very light. He goes into contact good and keeps his hips and pads low. But when he goes to up route, he doesn't have the lockout you would expect a guy to have because he's a little bit lacking in length.
Advertisement
Loveland is a bit more linear and thinner. He's not a 260-pound guy rolling people off the line of scrimmage. He's a Michigan tight end… to fall into the new stereotype now. But he understands how to get into his blocks, he knows how to seal guys off and steal an extra half second with a hold, and he gets the job done. So to me, Loveland would fit very nicely with what the Colts need at tight end.
Robert: That was my next question here. You like Loveland as a prospect, but how does he fit with what the Colts already have? Looking at their pass-catching group here, if they draft a tight end at 14 they've got a really good tight end, hopefully in Loveland. They've got Michael Pittman Jr., Josh Downs, Adonai Mitchell, who they drafted in the second round last year and Alec Pierce. We don't know who's going to be the quarterback yet, but they'll probably feel pretty good about their pass-catching options if Colston Loveland turns into the player you want him to be at 14.
Ben: I do think that one of the issues the Colts ran into last season was they looked at Pittman Jr., Downs and Pierce, and they said, 'Okay, obviously Pierce plays way deep down the field for us, but he's this 50-50 jump ball guy. Pittman we more so use underneath, and Downs can play downfield a little bit, but he's smaller so we'll use him in the slot. And we'll get Mitchell and have some real speed and field stretching abilities.' But with Mitchell, it just never crystallized with Anthony Richardson at quarterback and the chemistry was never great. Mitchell made his mental errors and Richardson had his accuracy issues, and it was just no good.
In Loveland, I'm introducing a player who, from the seam, can put a lot of vertical stress on you right away. Loveland eats up ground off the line of scrimmage, he's got big strides and he goes. It's not a traditional field stretching thought — but if you're thinking about that play-action-heavy approach and that ability to sucker some linebackers down to then get your one-on-one opportunities down the field, I like Loveland in that sort of role because of how quickly he gets down field. He's also so good at catching above the rim, and he's awesome at catching the ball when it's above his face mask. So I like verticality with Loveland. He's good on the break, and he's got good yards after the catch, so I do like the ability to get him moving up the seam in this exact offense.
You can listen to full episodes of 'The Athletic Football Show' for free on Apple Podcasts and Spotify, and watch on YouTube.
(Top Photo: Michael Miller/)
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


USA Today
18 minutes ago
- USA Today
7 Things to watch for during Eagles' mandatory minicamp
7 Things to watch for during Eagles' mandatory minicamp Philadelphia is holding one mandatory minicamp practice on Tuesday, and we're looking at seven things to watch as the Eagles take the field for one final time before training camp in July Unlike most of the teams around the NFL, Philadelphia will hold one mandatory minicamp practice on Tuesday before taking a five-week break until training camp. The mandatory minicamp is part of Phase 3 of the NFL offseason. During mandatory minicamp, teams can participate in 7 on 7, 9 on 7, and 11 on 11 drills, provided no live contact takes place. Like in OTAs, players cannot wear pads except protective knee and elbow pads, though helmets are permitted. With Tuesday's session about to begin, we're looking at seven things to watch as the Eagles take the field for one final time before training camp in July. New personnel on defense The Eagles saw cornerbacks Darius Slay Jr., Isaiah Rodgers, James Bradberry, Avonte Maddox, edge rushers Brandon Graham and Josh Sweat, safety C.J. Gardner-Johnson, and defensive tackle Milton Williams all exit this off-season. Starting linebacker Nakobe Dean is still rehabbing from a torn patellar tendon and "won't be back for a while," according to defensive coordinator Vic Fangio. The Eagles will add cornerback Kelee Ringo, safety Sydney Brown, and defensive lineman Moro Ojomo to the rotation. At the same time, new additions in cornerback Adoree' Jackson, edge rusher Azeez Ojulari, and rookies Ty Robinson and Andrew Mukuba are expected to compete for those spots. First-round pick, linebacker Jihaad Campbell (shoulder), will eventually be in the mix, but won't be on the field until sometime in August, per Vic Fangio. Will there be any surprise no-shows? DeVonta Smith, Lane Johnson, Avery Williams, Reed Blankenship, and Cam Jurgens were among the Eagles who missed OTA sessions. Tuesday is mandatory, and with no lingering contract issues, Tuesday should see the team have perfect attendance. Rookies take the field The 2025 NFL draft is over, and Eagles GM Howie Roseman deserves to be commended for acquiring ten athletic and versatile football players. In this draft, Philadelphia focused again on big-game experience and leadership. Every player drafted had spent three years in school or had served as a captain. Jihaad Campbell could still be weeks away from a clean bill of health, but we will still be watching Drew Mukuba, Ty Brown, and Smael Mondon, among others. Toughness must be maintained despite Super Bowl win When Nick Sirianni was initially hired, team leaders convinced the first-year head coach to eliminate the mandatory Minicamp and focus on keeping players healthy. Philadelphia had the lightest OTA workload of any team in the league, but that changed after the 2023 collapse. After winning the Super Bowl, the Eagles will balance maintaining that toughness while lessening the load slightly. Pace and competition It'll be year No. 5 for Nick Sirianni with a slightly retooled coaching staff. Sirianni has preached competition since the beginning, and things will be intense with a new offensive coordinator, a new quarterbacks coach, and several new faces on the defensive side of the football. There's continuity with Jalen Hurts, and the entire offensive personnel will be needed during an offseason of change. Re-tooling the Tush Push The Tush Push or Brotherly Shove remains for the 2025 season as the NFL owners rejected a proposal from the Green Bay Packers during a vote at the league's Spring Meeting to ban the play. The Packers' proposal was rejected. The proposal needed 24 of the 32 votes to pass. Philadelphia had already taken steps to enhance the short-yardage scenarios with the signing of A.J. Dillon and linebacker Ben VanSumeren, making the permanent switch to the fullback position. The Eagles have encountered a lot of hate, and the next few months are about adding wrinkles to a play that most of the NFL will spend the summer working to stop. Position battles A.J. Dillon against Will Shipley, Tyler Steen against Kenyon Green, and Kelee Ringo against the field are among the looming training camp battles that'll officially begin on Tuesday. Today's session could provide insight into potential depth charts for July.


Newsweek
22 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Steelers See Tom Brady Comparison With Aaron Rodgers
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. The Pittsburgh Steelers and Aaron Rodgers have officially agreed to terms on a one-year contract for the 2025 NFL season. It was a move that had long been expected, but took a long time to work out. Rodgers was dealing with some personal issues throughout the offseason. He openly stated that he wanted to get those issues taken care of before committing to a team. Now, he's all-in with the Steelers. Following the move to officially sign with Pittsburgh, there are a lot of questions surrounding what to expect from the team. Some expect a good year from Rodgers, while others don't think the future Hall of Fame quarterback will be able to make the kind of impact the team hopes. Aaron Rodgers #8 of the New York Jets looks to throw a pass during pregame warmups prior to an NFL football game against the Buffalo Bills at MetLife Stadium on September 11, 2023 in East... Aaron Rodgers #8 of the New York Jets looks to throw a pass during pregame warmups prior to an NFL football game against the Buffalo Bills at MetLife Stadium on September 11, 2023 in East Rutherford, New Jersey. More Photo bySpeaking of what the team is hoping for, an intriguing take has been shared from ESPN analyst Booger McFarland. Read more: Steelers Could Make Huge Splash With Former Aaron Rodgers Teammate He shared that the Steelers are hoping to see a Tom Brady like impact from Rodgers. When Brady signed with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers following an illustrious tenure with the New England Patriots, he brought a Super Bowl to his new team. Can Rodgers do the same? "Make no mistake about this: they're not bringing in Aaron Rodgers here to go 9-8," McFarland said. "They're not bringing Aaron Rodgers in there to win one playoff game. When you have Minkah Fitzpatrick and Cam Heyward and T.J. Watt, you're going to geet a 41-year-old quarterback, who's a Hall of Fame quarterback, to see if he can have some similar effect that Tom Brady had in Tampa when he took them to a Super Bowl." McFarland did share later that he doesn't think Pittsburgh has enough, even after signing Rodgers, to win a Super Bowl. However, that is their goal with the move. This is the Steelers going all-in on trying to contend. They're doing everything they can to give themselves a chance to win it all. Read more: Steelers' Aaron Rodgers Has Chance at Massive NFL Milestone Last season with the New York Jets, Rodgers played well. The team as a whole did not, but Rodgers completed 63 percent of his pass attempts for 3,897 yards, 28 touchdowns, and 11 interceptions. It will be interesting to see what kind of impact Rodgers has on Pittsburgh this season. More than likely, it will be his farewell tour to the NFL before riding off into the sunset of retirement. Hopefully, he can put together a strong season and help lead the Steelers on a deep run in the postseason. For more Pittsburgh Steelers and NFL news, head over to Newsweek Sports.


USA Today
43 minutes ago
- USA Today
Big Ten coach calls out anti-West Coast bias in College Football Playoff system
Big Ten coach calls out anti-West Coast bias in College Football Playoff system The first season of the 12-team College Football Playoff certainly created plenty of controversy. While ultimately, most people felt as though the selection committee took the correct 12 teams, the process of getting there was anything but smooth. This week, a Big Ten head coach called out the committee for alleged bias against West Coast schools. Interestingly, however, the coach in question is not in charge of a West Coast program himself. Rather, the man behind the comments, was, of all people, Penn State head coach James Franklin. "There's a lot of challenges," Franklin said, via CBS Sports. "You've got East Coast people voting on this, and they haven't watched enough of the West Coast games based on the time. All the different rankings that are out there. In my mind, a formula makes the most sense because it takes the bias out that we all have." Franklin's proposed solution to the matter was going back to a BCS-style formula to determine the rankings. "It's funny, because I think there's all these complaints about the BCS, but then we go to this, and I think it goes back to really, my answer is, the problem is, everybody voting and everybody involved in the process—whether you want to be biased or not, we all are biased. I think in a lot of ways, you could make the argument a formula could be better. But we didn't love the formula. So we went to this other system." USC fans know all too well, however, that leaving the rankings to the computers does not always work out. After all, back in 2003, the Trojans infamously got screwed out of the BCS Championship Game despite being ranked No. 1 in both the AP and Coaches Polls. However, Franklin's point about the current system having major issues is certainly a valid one. Perhaps one day, college football will be able to come up with a method of selecting a postseason field that will not inevitably make people mad. Right now, however, that day feels like a long way in the distance. As for Franklin, his comment was not entirely altruistic. Given that Penn State plays in the same conference as four West Coast schools, USC, Oregon, Washington, and UCLA getting more national respect could certainly help the Nittany Lions' resume in seasons to come.