Doubt cast over suggestions incestuous ‘god-kings' ruled Newgrange during Neolithic Ireland
A paper, written by researchers at University College Dublin (UCD), has questioned the belief that burial within the 'mega' passage tomb of Newgrange was the preserve of kings and other dignitaries who represented a dynasty that practised incest.
Such claims followed a study in 2020 that suggested evidence of incestuous unions at the site.
A study of the DNA of an adult male buried there revealed he had been born of an incestuous union. His parents were either siblings or parent and child.
The finding led the research team at the time, headed by Trinity College Dublin, to speculate that the elite associated with the monument practised incest as a way of maintaining a dynastic bloodline.
This implied he was among a ruling social elite akin to the similarly inbred Inca god-kings and Egyptian pharaohs.
But now, in findings published in the journal Antiquity, researchers say that the ancient genome of the adult male revealed a 'rare case of incest, which led to claims in 2020 that the individual was a high-status ruler, with press coverage dubbing them a 'god-king''.
Associate professors Jessica Smyth and Neil Carlin at UCD School of Archaeology point out that no other incestuous unions have been identified in Neolithic Ireland and Britain, and say there is a lack of evidence for inbreeding across prehistoric Europe.
They also say the evidence found at the site does not support the existence of a 'king' of Newgrange or any hereditary power or dynasty with a shared ancestry.
'People were definitely being selected for burial in passage tombs – the whole community does not end up in these monuments. However, we don't know the reasons behind this selection,' Professor Smyth said.
'Unlike today, bodies don't tend to be buried 'whole' or 'intact' in this time period. Before they end up in megalithic monuments, bodies are broken down, sometimes cremated and even circulated around their communities
ADVERTISEMENT
Learn more
.'
Professors Smyth and Carlin argue that these conclusions relied heavily on unsuitable comparisons with hierarchical societies where incest was limited to ruling families, such as in ancient Egypt, while ignoring examples of incest in non-elite or egalitarian communities.
'A one-off example of incest is a shaky foundation on which to reconstruct an elite, let alone a specific social [hierarchy],' the authors said.
Newgrange is believed to have been built by a farming community that prospered in the Boyne Valley, Co Meath, about 5,000 years ago.
It is far more likely, they argue, that rather than being reserved for elite rulers or a ruling dynasty, the tombs at Newgrange were places where people made their kin through a range of practices, including living, working and burying their dead together.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
Scanning the air for life
We are a step closer to the legendary Star Trek tricorder, a fictional device that enabled the intrepid crew of the Starship Enterprise to scan an alien planet for signs of life. A recent paper by Nousias and colleagues shows how the instructions of life, contained in DNA , can be detected and analysed in greater detail than ever before from air samples. While environmental DNA has been collected before from water, soil, sand and even air, the team combined air samples with deep sequencing methods that recover much more detailed information on the genetic code of animals, plants, humans and microbes in the environment. This paper has a fascinating Irish connection. Some of the tiny air pumps used to collect samples were located at the zoology building in Trinity College Dublin , the Boyne estuary in Meath and Croghan mountain in Wicklow. READ MORE These samples were contrasted with air samples from Florida coastal and forest locations. Notable species detections in Dublin city centre included dust mites, high bacterial diversity and a substantial amount of bumblebee DNA – perhaps related to the success of Trinity's recent campuswide actions for pollinators. DNA was also detected from plants that may be largely consumed rather than grown in the area, including peanuts, cannabis, opium poppy and the fungus psilocybe – 'magic mushrooms'. [ What do changing rainfall patterns mean for the world's nourishing grasslands? Opens in new window ] Organisms in the environment, including humans, shed DNA into the air through the flaking of skin, production of pollen or saliva and all manner of other materials that are produced as they go about their daily lives. The materials we use and consume also shed DNA. The air is therefore a veritable genetic soup which can be sampled and the DNA sequenced. Modern genetic sequencing called 'shotgun sequencing' enables sequences of DNA to be produced without an initial template, so genetic surprises may be found by comparing the sequences with databases of known species. Methods such as 'genetic barcoding' require that you fish in the genetic soup with a specific set of organisms in mind, and your detections are therefore limited by what you are looking for. 'Shotgun sequencing' also enables you to quantify how much DNA of a particular genetic sequence is in the air sample, which means you can compare sites for the relative abundance of a particular animal, plant or microbe. Of course human DNA is also detectable. An astonishing level of detail on the genetics of human populations can be retrieved from sampling the air alone. DNA from Dublin was characteristic of a diverse international city, whereas there were much fewer genetic types in the rural samples. While individual humans were not identified in this study, the technology now undoubtedly exists to enable individual human genomes to be analysed and identified from non-invasive samples, such as the air you have recently walked through. As with many technological leaps there are risks and opportunities for the deployment of deep sequenced environmental DNA analysis from air samples. Rapid biodiversity assessment is urgently needed to identify, monitor and manage the health of our environment. Difficult to study and detect species such as nocturnal bats and moths, low-density predators and microscopic species can be sampled using these methods. Environmental monitoring for detection of harmful pathogens is possible, with the potential for early-warning signals of disease outbreaks. In one week of sampling in Dublin city, 221 species with disease potential for humans were detected. Air can be scanned for the presence of allergens such as peanuts or for illegal narcotics. It will also be possible to deploy this technology for harmful purposes, including military use, monitoring and targeting of particular human populations or individuals and the illicit sampling of natural resources in the search for new medicinal drugs. There are profound ethical consequences of large-scale genomic analysis of human populations and individuals that need to be urgently addressed and regulated. While the lure of the tricorder is strong, there is still a lot of work to be done to ensure that the methods are robust and representative of the abundance and presence of particular species in the sample area. International and national-level policy and regulation needs to be developed to ensure that the benefits of rapid biodiversity assessment can be achieved with guardrails in place to prevent potentially damaging uses. Yvonne Buckley is co-director of the Co-Centre for Climate + Biodiversity + Water and professor of zoology at Trinity College Dublin
Irish Independent
4 days ago
- Irish Independent
Doubt cast over suggestions incestuous ‘god-kings' ruled Newgrange during Neolithic Ireland
A paper, written by researchers at University College Dublin (UCD), has questioned the belief that burial within the 'mega' passage tomb of Newgrange was the preserve of kings and other dignitaries who represented a dynasty that practised incest. Such claims followed a study in 2020 that suggested evidence of incestuous unions at the site. A study of the DNA of an adult male buried there revealed he had been born of an incestuous union. His parents were either siblings or parent and child. The finding led the research team at the time, headed by Trinity College Dublin, to speculate that the elite associated with the monument practised incest as a way of maintaining a dynastic bloodline. This implied he was among a ruling social elite akin to the similarly inbred Inca god-kings and Egyptian pharaohs. But now, in findings published in the journal Antiquity, researchers say that the ancient genome of the adult male revealed a 'rare case of incest, which led to claims in 2020 that the individual was a high-status ruler, with press coverage dubbing them a 'god-king''. Associate professors Jessica Smyth and Neil Carlin at UCD School of Archaeology point out that no other incestuous unions have been identified in Neolithic Ireland and Britain, and say there is a lack of evidence for inbreeding across prehistoric Europe. They also say the evidence found at the site does not support the existence of a 'king' of Newgrange or any hereditary power or dynasty with a shared ancestry. 'People were definitely being selected for burial in passage tombs – the whole community does not end up in these monuments. However, we don't know the reasons behind this selection,' Professor Smyth said. 'Unlike today, bodies don't tend to be buried 'whole' or 'intact' in this time period. Before they end up in megalithic monuments, bodies are broken down, sometimes cremated and even circulated around their communities ADVERTISEMENT Learn more .' Professors Smyth and Carlin argue that these conclusions relied heavily on unsuitable comparisons with hierarchical societies where incest was limited to ruling families, such as in ancient Egypt, while ignoring examples of incest in non-elite or egalitarian communities. 'A one-off example of incest is a shaky foundation on which to reconstruct an elite, let alone a specific social [hierarchy],' the authors said. Newgrange is believed to have been built by a farming community that prospered in the Boyne Valley, Co Meath, about 5,000 years ago. It is far more likely, they argue, that rather than being reserved for elite rulers or a ruling dynasty, the tombs at Newgrange were places where people made their kin through a range of practices, including living, working and burying their dead together.
Irish Independent
19-06-2025
- Irish Independent
Ireland's universities among most improved in the world as Trinity retains top place in country's rankings
Trinity College Dublin (TCD) retained its place as Ireland's top institution in the QS World University Rankings for 2026, improving its overall ranking from 87th last year to 75th. University College Dublin (UCD) was ranked 118th, up from 126th a year ago, followed by University College Cork (UCC), up to 246th from 273rd, and the University of Galway, which fell to 284th from 273rd. The University of Limerick, Dublin City University (DCU), the University of Maynooth and the Technological University of Dublin (TUD) made up the rest of the eight Irish universities included in the rankings. Seven of the eight improved on their ranking from a year ago, making Ireland the most-improved country in Europe and the second-most improved in the world, trailing Azerbaijan. This edition of the QS rankings also marks the first time every ranked Irish university has been included in the world's top 800. Further and Higher Education Minister James Lawless said third-level institutions 'play a vital role in delivering education and research' in Ireland. 'This work has been and continues to be pivotal to the success of our country as a knowledge-driven economy,' he said. Their achievements reflect the strength of our higher education system 'I congratulate the institutions that have improved their standing in this year's QS university rankings. 'Their achievements reflect the strength of our higher education system and reinforce Ireland's global reputation for academic excellence and cutting-edge research. 'This progress also reflects the significant investment this Government has made in higher education in recent years, supporting our ambition to build a world-class, innovative and inclusive system that delivers for all.' TCD ranked in the top 100 globally in three indicators: academic reputation, international faculty and graduate outcomes. UCD landed in the top 100 for graduate outcomes and in the top 50 for sustainability, where it was ranked 49th. After rising into the global top 250, UCC also improved in academic reputation, employer reputation and citations per faculty. The University of Oxford was in fourth place, down from third At the top of the rankings, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) retained the number one spot it has held since 2012. In second place was Imperial College London, the same spot it earned last year. The University of Oxford was in fourth place, down from third, and Harvard University was in fifth, down from fourth. QS senior vice-president Ben Sowter said: 'Ireland's outstanding results in the 2026 QS World University Rankings are testament to the dedication of academics, administrators and students across the eight universities from the country included in the ranking. 'The Government has been clear in its ambitions to make Ireland a first-choice destination for international learners in its Global Citizens 2030 Talent and Innovation Strategy and, with every university improving in the international student indicator, the country's campuses are increasingly open and diverse.'
