Former Edinburgh police chief says murderers 'must reveal where bodies are to get parole'
David Swindle told the Daily Record podcast, Criminal Record, that he backs Suzanne's Law. This demands that killers must disclose their victim's whereabouts if they are to be considered for parole.
The Scottish Government has included a proposal for Suzanne's Law in the Witnesses, and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill which is going through parliament.
READ MORE: Edinburgh gangsters go on six-day rampage armed with 'gun', machetes and knife
READ MORE: Edinburgh man rushed to hospital after being 'stabbed' in tenement flat terror
Suzanne's Law is named after office worker Suzanne Pilley, who was murdered by colleague and ex David Gilroy in 2010. He was sentenced to life in 2012 but has never revealed what he did with her body, which is believed to be buried in Argyll.
Other high-profile cases include Arlene Fraser, Margaret Fleming and Lynda Spence. Swindle, who probed more than 100 murders in a 34-year police career, said: 'We need to have something like a Suzanne's Law to stop people getting out if they don't reveal what they did with the body.
'With Suzanne Pilley her body has never been found and there is a person convicted of that, the same as Arlene Fraser, Margaret Fleming and Lynda Spence.
Sign up for Edinburgh Live newsletters for more headlines straight to your inbox
'These people have never revealed what they did with the bodies. If they don't reveal what they did they should not then be eligible for parole. If your loved one is murdered by someone who is in prison and has never revealed what they did with the body you would not want them to get out."
Swindle, who retired in 2011, says a murder without a body leaves victims' families in limbo. He added: 'People think by destroying the body that there is no evidence but you will still be caught."
England and Wales already have a similar measure – Helen's Law.
Suzanne's dad Rob died in 2019 without knowing where she was buried. Detectives believe Gilroy killed her in the building where they worked in Edinburgh after he confronted her over ending their affair.
Arlene, from Elgin, Moray, vanished from her home in 1998 after her children went to school. Her husband Nat Fraser, who is serving life for her murder, has refused to say what became of his wife.
Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
Avril Jones and Edward Cairney were jailed for life in 2019 for killing Margaret, 19, at their home in Inverkip. They refused to say where they put her.
Financial adviser Lynda was abducted, tortured and killed in 2011. Colin Coats and Philip Wade were convicted of killing the 27-year-old Glaswegian in 2013. Her body has never been found.
Swindle led the probe into Tobin's murder of Polish student Angelika Kluk in Glasgow in 2006 for which he got life. He set up Operation Anagram which led to Tobin being convicted of the murders of Vicky Hamilton, 15, and Dinah McNicol, 18.
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: "The Justice Secretary supported an amendment at Stage 2 in May which requires the Parole Board to take account of whether the prisoner has information about the disposal of the victim's remains but has not disclosed it.
"If the Bill is passed then this will become law."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
18 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Teen arrested on suspicion of rape and murder after death of 13-year-old girl
Police say the passing of a 13-year-old girl in Huddersfield is being treated as 'unexplained'. The force was called to a flat on Sheepridge Road, in the West Yorkshire town, on Monday night following a report a girl was unresponsive. She died later in hospital, West Yorkshire Police confirmed. A 16-year-old boy was arrested on suspicion of murder and rape and remains in custody. West Yorkshire Police said in a statement: 'Police were called by the ambulance service to an address on Sheepridge Road, Huddersfield at 11.36pm on Monday August 11 to a report that the teenage girl was unresponsive. The 13-year-old was taken to hospital where she sadly died in the early hours of Tuesday morning. READ MORE: Toddler, 1, airlifted to hospital from Stoke-on-Trent estate READ MORE: Man hospitalised as police and paramedics shut Hanley ring-road 'A 16-year-old boy, from Huddersfield, was arrested on suspicion of murder and rape, remains in police custody. A post-mortem examination was conducted yesterday (Wednesday) which concluded the girl's death was unexplained pending further investigation.' Detective Chief Inspector Stacey Atkinson said 'We are continuing to conduct a number of inquiries today following the death of a 13-year-old girl following an incident at a flat on Sheepridge Road. A post mortem was not able to determine how she died, and we continue to treat her death as unexplained at this time, pending more inquiries. 'Those inquiries are complex and are likely to be lengthy as we work to fully understand the circumstances of the girl's death. 'Specially trained officers are supporting her family at this time.' The force confirmed the 16-year-old boy was arrested on suspicion of another offence of rape relating to a 16-year-old girl from a separate incident, elsewhere in the Kirklees district. Get daily headlines and breaking news emailed to you - it's FREE
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Police will not endorse activities of volunteer ‘force' launching patrols
A police force said it will not endorse the activities of volunteers in Bournemouth who have set up a uniformed 'force' to patrol the streets, adding a review of their vetting processes highlighted 'areas of significant concern'. Safeguard Force, whose volunteers will wear branded bibs, said it aims to create 'safer, more supportive communities by providing visible, compassionate and non-confrontational patrols' which were set to start on August 11. The move follows two high-profile murder cases in the town as well as the local police force having to introduce dispersal powers on the seafront after a disturbance involving a 'large group of people' on June 30 which left a teenage girl and two officers injured. Dorset Police said a multi-agency meeting was held with Safeguard Force on Friday and 'a review of their vetting processes has highlighted areas of significant concern'. Assistant Chief Constable Mark Callaghan, of Dorset Police, said: 'Following a multi-agency meeting on Friday 15 August 2025, which involved Dorset Police, other emergency services, the local authority and representatives of Safeguard Force, we will not be endorsing their activities. 'We have engaged with the group extensively and a review of their vetting processes has highlighted areas of significant concern. The organisers have been unable to provide reassurance that this group has sufficient safeguards in place to ensure volunteers are adequately vetted, trained, and equipped to undertake high-visibility patrols in the community. 'Safeguard Force's policies provided to police contain insufficient details in relation to the use of body-worn cameras, publishing of photographs of members of the public, administration and recording of any force used or first aid provided and limited evidence of any training provided. 'We welcome the responsible use of volunteers, who wish to carry out public service and there are many ways in which this can be facilitated in a safe way, including becoming a Special Constable, joining the street pastor programme, or via established Watch schemes. 'All these initiatives have appropriate policies and processes in place, particularly around the vetting of individuals and safeguarding of vulnerable people. 'Dorset Police continues to carry out high-visibility patrols, with 289 foot patrols taking place in the past seven days throughout Bournemouth town centre, gardens and seafront. 'This resulted in arrests being made and dispersal notices being issued, stop searches for drugs or weapons, anti-social behaviour incidents attended, intelligence gathered and almost 1,200 conversations with members of the public and 131 businesses and local premises visited. 'We would encourage members of the public to speak to our officers and report incidents and crimes directly to us so we're able to effectively respond and investigate.' In March, Nasen Saadi was jailed for life to serve a minimum of 39 years at Winchester Crown Court for the murder of Amie Gray and attempted murder of Leanne Miles on Bournemouth beach on May 24 2024. And in January 2023, Afghan asylum seeker Lawangeen Abdulrahimzai was jailed for life to serve a minimum of 29 years at Salisbury Crown Court for the murder of 21-year-old Thomas Roberts outside a Subway takeaway shop in Bournemouth in March 2022.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Missing Hairstylist's Ex Believed to Be on Video Lifting Heavy Object — With Possible Arm Sticking Out — Into Dumpster
Ashley Elkins' ex-boyfriend Deandre Booker has been charged in connection with her January killing NEED TO KNOW Ashley Elkins, 30, disappeared from her Michigan home after running out for errands on Jan. 2 Her ex-boyfriend Deandre Booker has been charged with murder, among other offenses, in connection with her death Elkins' body was never found The ex-boyfriend of Michigan mom Ashley Elkins, who disappeared in January, is believed to be the man seen in security camera footage pushing a cart that appeared to have an arm hanging from it, per local police. Deandre Booker, 33, was charged with first-degree murder in connection with Elkins' disappearance from her Warren, Mich., home where she was last seen on Jan. 2, PEOPLE previously reported. Her disappearance came to light after her family carried out an extensive campaign to have police investigate it. Authorities initially arrested Booker in nearby Roseville, Mich., on charge of lying to an officer, before he was charged with murder in late January, the Macomb County Prosecutor's Office previously confirmed to PEOPLE. While searching Booker's home during their investigation, Roseville police claim to have recovered items from the residence indicating Elkins was the victim of a "crime of violence," Warren Police Department Lt. John Gajewski told PEOPLE at the time. Her disappearance led to an extensive search, but no trace of Elkins was never found. During a preliminary examination that began last week, Roseville Detective Chris Moran testified in court that they recovered security footage showing a man, believed to be Booker, pushing a cart towards a dumpster, WDIV Local 4 and The Detroit News reported. Moran testified the cart contained something covered in a white sheet, which the man appeared to be struggling to lift into the dumpster. He further testified that he saw what seemed to be an arm hanging off from the cart, per The Detroit News. When questioned by Booker's lawyer, Roseville Police Detective Patrick Taylor testified that while it was not clear in the video who the man was, he appeared to have similarities with Booker's clothing from earlier that day: a dark coat with a fur hood, black pants with holes in them, a black hat and black shoes with white bottoms, the outlet reported. Taylor also testified, according to The Detroit News, that during their search of Booker's home, they found clothes similar to those worn by the man in the video. The dark fur coat in the home including a faded area that appeared to show dried blood. Authorities began investigating Booker in January after Elkins' family tracked her phone to Booker's home, her family previously told PEOPLE. Days before Elkins disappeared, on New Years Eve, Booker allegedly showed up to Elkins' home salon under a fake name, her sister said at the time. Elkins hid from Booker until he left. Two days later, she disappeared, leaving behind two young was charged with first-degree murder, tampering with evidence, disinterment and mutilation and concealing a death. He has pleaded not guilty to the charges. If you are experiencing domestic violence, call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233, or go to All calls are toll-free and confidential. The hotline is available 24/7 in more than 170 languages. Read the original article on People
