
Unpaid community service clause unconstitutional, says Hassan Karim
HL: Unpaid community service clause unconstitutional, says Hassan Karim
Qistina Sallehuddin, Nor Ain Mohamed Radhi
KUALA LUMPUR: Government backbencher Hassan Abdul Karim has warned the government against proceeding with a clause in the proposed Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2025 that would allow unpaid community service orders to be imposed, cautioning that such provisions may amount to slavery and breach the Federal Constitution.
The Pasir Gudang member of parliament and PKR veteran said the proposed Section 104A(1), which allows a community service order to be made against individuals convicted of violating local council by-laws, contradicts Article 6 of the Constitution, which prohibits slavery and all forms of forced labour.
He also pointed out that the section defines community service as work or service that is not paid.
"This act (amendment) should not be rushed into approval. After reviewing it, I find that while the intention behind the proposed amendments is good, the method of implementation may contradict existing laws.
"From what I understand, work or service that is unpaid and must be carried out as a punishment could amount to practices resembling slavery, servitude, or forced labour.
"Referring to dictionaries, the Oxford Language Dictionary, for example, slavery is defined as a condition in which a person is forced to do hard labour without pay or recognition," he said.
Hassan also drew parallels to Section 9(5) of the Peaceful Assembly Act, which was enforced for more than a decade before being struck down by the Federal Court for being unconstitutional recently.
"This is what concerns me. As such, remove the provision for community service that resembles slavery.
"Instead, I propose that a fair and reasonable amount of wages or allowance be made mandatory for community service duties," he said.
Similarly, he also called for local government elections, which were once part of the country's system until 1965, to be revived.
This follows concerns over the legality of allowing unelected local councils to determine and enforce community service orders under the proposed amendments to existing legislation, he said.
"I wish to raise a question regarding the legitimacy or legal authority of local councils to create such by-laws, given that across the country there are 20 city councils, 40 municipal councils, and 91 district councils.
"Local authorities comprise mayors, municipal presidents, district council presidents, and appointed councillors, all of whom are not elected by the people.
"None of these positions were filled through elections, all were appointed. So is it legally valid for a local authority, such as Kuala Lumpur City Hall, to enact a by-law to determine the type of community service to be implemented?"
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Borneo Post
24 minutes ago
- Borneo Post
Wan Junaidi's significant contributions embody Sarawak Day spirit, says Lee
Wan Junaidi waves to the crowd upon his arrival at the Miri Indoor Stadium. – Ukas photo MIRI (July 23): Governor Tun Pehin Sri Dr Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar deserves to be honoured symbolically as an embodiment of the Sarawak Day spirit in recognition of his significant contributions to the state, said Dato Sri Lee Kim Shin. The Transport Minister, who is Sarawak Day celebration minister in charge, pointed out Wan Junaidi's most significant contribution was as Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Law and Parliament) when the Federal Constitution was amended to restore several of Sarawak's rights. 'Tun Pehin Sri is not only an esteemed figure in administration and legal affairs, but also a true patriot who once stood at the frontline in defending the sovereignty of our homeland,' Lee said in his welcoming speech at the Sarawak Day celebration at Miri Indoor Stadium last night. He noted that Wan Junaidi has always placed Sarawak's interests at the forefront within the framework of the Malaysian Federation, whether in his roles as lawmaker, minister, speaker, or now as Head of State. Lee pointed out that during Wan Junaidi's service with the Police Field Force, the latter had risked his life in several operations against the North Kalimantan Communist Party in areas such as Miri, Sibu, and Kapit. Wan Junaidi's bravery during those tumultuous times stands as a testament to his loyalty and the indomitable spirit of a true son of Sarawak, Lee said. 'Tun Pehin Sri is not only known as a leader of calibre and integrity, but also as a statesman dedicated to Sarawak's development, as well as the unity and prosperity of its people,' he added. He thanked Wan Junaidi and wife Toh Puan Datuk Patinggi Fauziah Mohd Sanusi for their presence at this year's Sarawak Day celebration. 'We all pray for the continued protection of His Excellency Tun and Toh Puan, and that they will remain as guiding pillars leading us towards a progressive and prosperous Sarawak,' he added. Among those present at the event were Premier Datuk Patinggi Tan Sri Abang Johari Tun Openg, Deputy Prime Minister Dato Sri Fadillah Yusof, and Deputy Premiers Datuk Amar Douglas Uggah Embas, Datuk Amar Awang Tengah Ali Hasan, and Datuk Amar Dr Sim Kui Hian. lead Lee Kim Shin Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar


Malaysiakini
28 minutes ago
- Malaysiakini
Muhyiddin's anti-Madani axis
Good morning. Here's what you should know today. Key Highlights Muhyiddin's anti-Madani axis Anwar's magnanimity Jho Low's new identity Muhyiddin's anti-Madani axis Perikatan Nasional chairperson Muhyiddin Yassin met with several opposition party leaders on Friday. Besides PN parties, those at the talks included Muda and PSM. PAS was notably absent from the meet, but was reportedly invited. The meeting sought to explore the possibility of forming a united front on national and public interest matters. HIGHLIGHTS Anwar's magnanimity PKR president Anwar Ibrahim has no intention to discipline his former deputy Rafizi Ramli and the latter's allies for going "rogue". The party's communications director said that Anwar had told members to respect differing opinions. Meanwhile, Rafizi warned that if unhappiness within PKR is not resolved, it may experience a break-up like Umno did after Anwar was sacked in 1998. HIGHLIGHTS Jho Low's new identity Fugitive businessperson Jho Low is reportedly living in Shanghai under a fake identity. Investigative journalists Bradley Hope and Tom Wright claimed that Low is using a fake Australian passport with the name Constantinos Achilles Veis. He is allegedly living in an affluent part of Shanghai and works at the city's financial centre as a "behind-the-scenes strategist" for the Chinese government. HIGHLIGHTS Views that matter In case you missed it Other news that matter

The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
LPG subsidy to stay, leakages to be probed
THE government will not withdraw the liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) subsidy, says Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Minister Datuk Armizan Mohd Ali. He said the ministry's task was to address LPG leakages through misappropriation and smuggling. 'We remain committed to providing LPG cylinder subsidies to the public. Fundamentally, this subsidy is for consumer use, a subsidy for the people's kitchens,' he told Young Syefura Othman (PH-Bentong) who sought clarification on whether the government would withdraw the subsidy. Although the subsidy is primarily for household consumers, Armizan said it also benefits micro and small businesses, particularly in the food and beverage sector. 'For this reason, the food and beverage sector must ensure that prices remain reasonable for the public,' he added. He said that the legal aspects specifically concerning the use of LPG by small traders will be detailed in amendments to the Control of Supplies Regulations (Import Prohibition) 2021. The Control of Supplies Regulations (Amendment) 2021 limits the ownership and use of subsidised LPG exceeding 42kg at any one time without a scheduled controlled goods permit.