Barring members under 5 years from polls could kill PKR, say analysts
PKR deputy president Rafizi Ramli says limiting candidacies to members who have been in the party for a certain number of years would improve party discipline and ensure loyalty.
PETALING JAYA : PKR runs the risk of losing capable new leaders if the party prohibits members of less than five years standing from contesting in its internal polls, say political analysts.
Mazlan Ali.
Mazlan Ali of Universiti Teknologi Malaysia and Universiti Malaysia Sabah's Syahruddin Awang Ahmad said PKR deputy president Rafizi Ramli's proposal would prevent younger Malaysians from using the party as a platform to bring meaningful change to the country.
They said the proposal could result in stagnation within PKR's leadership, hindering the party's ability to cultivate and advance fresh, talented leaders.
'Rafizi's idea could kill off PKR and prevent it from having a dynamic leadership in the future,' Mazlan told FMT.
Syahruddin said the proposed requirement would indirectly hinder the entry of fresh talent capable of bringing new ideas and perspectives to the party.
Syahruddin Awang Ahmad
'This risks causing a sort of 'brain drain', with talented individuals choosing to join other parties that offer a faster path (to leadership), undermining PKR's efforts to remain relevant and dynamic in the political landscape,' he said.
Rafizi had called for party rules to be amended to prevent candidates with less than five years' standing from contesting for positions, saying the move would improve party discipline and ensure loyalty.
The PKR deputy president said the current system allowed newcomers to jump straight into leadership roles, sometimes with the approval of the party president, when they should 'start from the bottom'.
Sungai Buloh MP R Ramanan, a former MIC treasurer-general, joined PKR in 2020 after quitting the Indian-based party six years earlier. Ramanan is vying for the post of vice-president at this year's party polls, scheduled to be held on Friday.
Mazlan said a two-year period would be generally sufficient to determine if a member was loyal and committed to the party, adding that there was no need to be too restrictive.
He said the requirement could vary according to the seniority of the position in the party, with a five-year prohibition proposed for those gunning to be vice-president for example.
'For posts at the grassroots level, there shouldn't be a requirement for a candidate to have been a member for five years. Maybe just a year or less to encourage the emergence of new leaders.
'But for the PKR president's post, perhaps a 10-year membership requirement followed by seven years for the deputy presidency, and so on.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
6 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Surgery on Colombian senator went well after shooting, says wife
Miguel Uribe was shot in the head during a campaign event in Bogota. (EPA Images pic) BOGOTA : Colombian senator Miguel Uribe, a potential presidential contender, survived an initial operation for his injuries after being shot in Bogota today, according to his wife and the hospital treating him, although he remains in intensive care. Uribe, 39, is a member of the opposition right-wing Democratic Center party and was shot in the head during a campaign event in a public park in the Fontibon neighbourhood. Campaigning is just beginning for the country's 2026 presidential election and Uribe, who is from a prominent political family, does not have a well-known platform so far. It was unclear why he was targeted in the attack. Though he has talked about the need to improve security and about having personally suffered in the country's conflict, many other potential candidates, including others from his party, have also said steps must be taken to tackle crime. Uribe's grandfather was president from 1978 to 1982, while his mother, journalist Diana Turbay, was kidnapped in 1990 by an armed group under the command of the late cartel leader Pablo Escobar. She was killed during a rescue operation in 1991. 'Miguel came out of surgery, he made it. Every hour is a critical hour. He fought his first battle, and it went well,' his wife Maria Claudia Tarazona told local media. 'This will take time.' The couple are parents to a young son. In a statement, the Santa Fe Foundation hospital where Uribe was treated said he had procedures on his head and his left thigh, and remained in intensive care as doctors seek to stabilise his condition. Bogota's mayor, Carlos Galan, whose own presidential candidate father was assassinated in 1989, addressed journalists outside the hospital overnight, saying he had asked for increased protection for all candidates in Bogota and for Uribe's family.
Free Malaysia Today
7 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Set up foundation to honour Double Six crash victims, says Upko No 2
On June 6, 1976, a GAF Nomad aircraft carrying then Sabah chief minister Fuad Stephens and several state leaders crashed in Sembulan, Kota Kinabalu, killing all on board. (Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives pic) PETALING JAYA : The families of the victims of the 1976 Double Six tragedy are urging the federal government to establish a foundation as a meaningful recognition of the incident, which claimed the lives of 11 people, including then Sabah chief minister Fuad Stephens. Donald Peter Mojuntin, whose father Peter Mojuntin died in the crash, said taking the matter to court would be excessive and that the families were not making any unreasonable demands, Harian Metro reported. 'We just want proper recognition,' he was quoted as saying during the 49th anniversary memorial of the tragedy at the Double Six Monument in Sembulan, Kota Kinabalu. Donald Peter Mojuntin. Donald, who was also representing the families of the other victims, said the proposed foundation could serve to honour the victims and support their descendants, particularly in education and other areas of need. 'This would be a step forward,' the Upko deputy president said. He noted that the federal government has yet to take substantive action beyond offering letters of condolence. 'The state government has done its part from the beginning and looked after the families' welfare. We hope the federal government will do the same,' he said. Donald also called for the tragedy to be acknowledged as part of national history, not just Sabah's. 'Although it was a dark chapter, it deserves a place in our national history books, just like other major events in Malaysia,' he said. Sabah youth and sports minister Ellron Alfred Angin, who represented chief minister Hajiji Noor at the memorial, said this year's commemoration featured a poetry recital competition with 132 participants. He said there are plans to involve more young people, including students, in future events commemorating the incident. 'We also propose inviting a representative from the federal government to next year's 50th anniversary ceremony so they can better understand and appreciate the historical significance of this tragedy,' he said. On June 6, 1976, a GAF Nomad aircraft carrying Fuad and several state leaders crashed in Sembulan, Kota Kinabalu, killing all on board. The victims included state ministers Salleh Sulong, Chong Thien Vun and Peter. Investigations were conducted by Malaysian authorities, the aircraft's manufacturer GAF, and the Australian department of transport. However, their findings were not made public until April 2023. The Malaysian report found no evidence of sabotage, fire or explosion. The Australian report concluded that Sabah Air, the operator of the flight, was functioning illegally at the time, with its operations manual unapproved by the then federal civil aviation department.
Free Malaysia Today
7 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Tiong orders pullout from Sibu association over ‘interference' by politician
PDP president Tiong King Sing accused the political party involved of being arrogant and stubborn, and its leaders of being obsessed with power and position. (Bernama pic) PETALING JAYA : Progressive Democratic Party president Tiong King Sing has ordered party members to withdraw from a Chinese association in Sibu, Sarawak, over an unnamed politician's interference in the association's elections. Tiong claimed to have received numerous complaints about the political party leader's actions in the election of the Sibu Chinese Community Leaders Association's committee members. He did not name the party nor the leader, but gave a hint that it might be a party associated with PDP by questioning whether the party in question would be able to win future elections on its own 'without the support of allied parties'. Tiong said the politician was trying to manipulate the association's elections using his political influence. Tiong claimed he had evidence that the political party had issued instructions about the association's elections. Tiong, who is vice-chairman of the state's ruling coalition Gabungan Parti Sarawak (GPS), warned against treating community leadership positions as political assets. 'This is my final warning. The political party in question has utterly failed to uphold the ideals of power-sharing and inclusiveness,' he said in a Facebook post. 'We do not need their so-called 'mercy' nor are we interested in being part of a body that has become another political stage for a party.' Tiong said the role of community leaders was to serve the public, and such leadership posts should never be the subject of a power struggle among political parties. He accused the other party's leaders of being obsessed with power and position. 'They bicker endlessly over trivial matters and seek to monopolise social resources and political capital,' he said. 'Their behaviour is nothing short of disgraceful.' PDP is a component of GPS, along with Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu, Parti Rakyat Sarawak, and the Sarawak United People's Party (SUPP). PDP and SUPP leaders have clashed multiple times in recent years, particularly after the former accepted Parti Sarawak Bersatu (PSB) leaders and members en bloc last year. PSB, led by Wong Soon Koh until its dissolution, is a splinter of SUPP.
