‘This is not a rehearsal for trial' — magistrate in Evans case
These were the words of magistrate Deidre Dickson in the Humansdorp Regional Court on Wednesday morning.
Dickson said for the past three weeks she had cleared her criminal and civil rolls, often sat through lunch and tea breaks, and sometimes ended court late to accommodate murder accused Rob Evans' application for bail.
Evans is accused of murdering his girlfriend, Vanessa van Rensburg, 36, at his Oyster Bay holiday home over the Easter weekend.
And while Dickson stood firm in her views from Tuesday that 'speculation will not assist the court to decide on bail', for the sake of not wasting any more time, she gave defence attorney Paul Roelofse the floor to continue with his line of questioning.
Roelofse had been busy with his cross-examination of investigating officer Warrant Officer Xolile Kato on Tuesday when Dickson interjected.
After Roelofse raised questions about possible alternative suspects, or how someone else could have entered the house where Van Rensburg's body was ultimately found, Dickson said speculation would not assist her in deciding if Evans should be granted bail.
A visibly frustrated Roelofse had then asked for an adjournment to consider his position.
Later in the day, he returned to the courtroom with a fresh application to formally challenge the magistrate's ruling.
Roelofse argued that questions about locked doors and potential entry without force were crucial to ensuring a fair bail application for his client.
Delivering her ruling on Wednesday, Dickson said: 'A bail application is not a criminal trial, it is also not a rehearsal for trial.
'Speculation will not assist the court to decide on bail. If this were a trial and bail had been finalised, then this would have been a different [scenario].'
She said the bail application was already in its third week.
'This court will not unreasonably cut short or restrict cross-examination.
'The test here is the prima facie evidence. The court doesn't want to prolong the matter unnecessarily even further.
'Be that is it may, Mr Roelofse, I don't want to waste any more time, I have stated what the situation is.
'If you want to put more scenarios in front of the court then so be it, but let's finalise this matter.
'Everyone in this court needs this application to come to an end now.'
The matter was postponed to Friday.
The Herald
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
5 hours ago
- The Herald
Severed hands, 'tongue' found outside Verulam primary school
A newspaper delivery person made a gruesome discovery outside a primary school in Verulam, north of Durban, on Wednesday: two human hands severed at the forearm and wrapped in a bloody white cloth. Reaction Unit South Africa (Rusa) responded to the call from the employee, who reported seeing either animal or human limbs. Rusa's owner Prem Balram said officers made the grisly find along with an organ, thought to be an animal tongue lying on a shattered piece of Perspex or glass. 'We cannot say with certainty whether the hands are from the same person, even though one is darker than the other, or whether they were male or female,' he said. 'Also with regard to the organ — it looks like an animal tongue but sometimes human organs can swell. The forensic team will have to make that determination.' Balram said it seemed as if the items were dumped on the side of the road, outside the school Trenance Park. Officers were conducting a search in the area for a body. TimesLIVE
The Herald
5 hours ago
- The Herald
Police searching for five after robbery at Metlife Mall
Gqeberha police are on the hunt for a group of five who robbed a sports shop at the Metlife Mall on Wednesday morning. The incident happened at the Sportscene store on the corner of Samantha Way and Kabega Road at about 11am. Police spokesperson Captain Sandra Janse van Rensburg said the investigation was being conducted by the provincial serious and violent crimes unit in Gqeberha. Janse van Rensburg said that, according to preliminary information, the store manager had been with two shop assistants at the time of the incident. 'One female suspect entered the shop, followed by two male suspects. 'One of the men threatened the manager and his assistants with a firearm,' Janse van Rensburg said. One of the men and the female accomplice had started taking items of clothing from the rails and placing them into bags. 'Two more suspects entered the shop and also took clothing and walked out of the shop. 'The five suspects fled in a white Kia Picanto.' Janse van Rensburg urged anyone with information that could assist the police in their investigation to contact detective Lieutenant-Colonel Mondi Sitole on 082-457-2812, Crime Stop on 08600 1011, or the nearest police station. Anonymous tip-offs can also be communicated via the MySAPS App. All information is confidential, and callers may remain anonymous. The Herald
The Herald
5 hours ago
- The Herald
AKA murder trial set down for July next year after judge scolds lawyers
The state and defence have agreed on a follow-up date for a pre-trial conference in June next year, with a murder trial for rapper Kiernan "AKA" Forbes and his celebrity chef friend Tebello "Tibz" Motsoane scheduled to sit the following month. This comes after a morning of high drama at the Durban high court on Wednesday where judge Jacqueline Henriques lambasted the parties for the slow pace of pre-trial conference proceedings. 'I am not signing the matter trial ready. This is in discussion with the office of the judge president,' said an irate Henriques. Forbes and Motsoane were gunned down at the now defunct Wish restaurant in Florida Road in February 2023. Thabani Mkhwanazi, 30 Lindani Zenzele Ndimande, 35, Siyanda Eddie Myeza, 21, Mziwethemba Harvey Gwabeni, 36, and Lindokuhle Mhlaliseni Ndimande, 29, were arrested in February last year in connection with the deaths. Deputy director of public prosecutions Lawrence Gcaba said the state was withholding statements of additional witnesses for safety reasons.
